Publication: Predictors of Informal Health Payments: The Example from Turkey
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2010
ISSN
0148-5598
Published
2010
Author(s)
Editor(s)
Abstract
Little is known about the factors that can affect informal health payments in Turkey, which is pertinent given that Turkey has been undergoing and considering a series of reforms in the health sector. This paper aims to examine the predictors of informal payments in Turkey. The study surveyed a random sample of 3,727 people in a medium-sized city, of whom 706 received medical care for illness and/or non-illness related reasons, using a Turkey-specific version of a model questionnaire focused exclusively on informal out-of-pocket payments. Using multivariable logistic model, household health expenditure, health insurance, service type and provider ownership were found to be statistically significant predictors of informal payment. The findings suggest the supply side factors as the main drivers of informal payments and thus a need for radical changes in the supply side as well as actions to rebuild lost confidence in the health care system of Turkey.
Link to Data Set
Associated URLs
Associated content
Other publications in this report series
Journal
Journal Volume
Journal Issue
Citations
- Cited 39 times in Scopus (view citations)
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by metadata.
Publication Institutional Issues in Informal Health Payments in Poland : Report on the Qualitative Part of the Study(World Bank, Washington, DC, 2001-02)A growing pattern within the ECA (East Europe and Central Asia) region is informal payments to doctors, hospital administrators, nurses and others connected with health service delivery. These payments have implications for governance of health systems and for equity and access, as well as for incentives for both health providers and managers. According to the research findings, informal payments are widespread in the Polish health sector. They include both cash and in-kind contributions. The study reinforces the existing anecdotal evidence as well as evidence from studies in other countries of the ECA Region and shows that the phenomenon has, if anything, become more widespread over the last few years. Informal payments are both paid voluntarily and coerced by providers in one way or another. As this paper shows, the main reasons for paying for medical services are to ensure quality care, to buy future care, and to jump queues. Providers are also paid to show gratitude and appreciation. In addition, users contribute in-kind for ancillary services. For instance, they bring their own sheets, food, or even medicines to the hospital because the hospital is not providing them. Building on the existing literature, this research is aimed at: (1) identifying the nature, extent, and economic dynamics (mechanisms of collection and revenue distribution among different actors) of informal payments; (2) understanding the leading causes of informal payments; (3) identifying the consequences of informal payments on accessibility and quality of care, and (4) articulating policy options to reduce the size and negative impact of such payments.Publication Qualitative Study on Informal Payments for Health Services in Georgia(World Bank, Washington, DC, 2002-11)This paper focuses on the specific dimension of informal payments by health users in Georgia, a growing pattern within many ECA (East Europe and Central Asia) countries. Using newly collected data from in-depth interviews and focus groups in rural and urban areas of the country, it investigates the determinants of out-of-pocket payments for health services that are supposed to be delivered free of charge under the Georgian Basic Benefit Package (BBP). The study finds that the demarcation between formal and informal components of these Out-of-Pocket payments is extremely imprecise because of: (a) the spread of "health rights unawareness" around the country and, (b) the prices outside the BBP differ from provider to provider. The study also found that some informal payments are based on cultural/social patterns ingrained in the Georgian tradition. Georgian now about the low health sector salaries and compensate the doctors with small payments. Finally, some recommendations to help the Georgian government to break the vicious cycle (excess capacity, decreasing demand of health services, lack of accountability) are proposed in this study, including greater role of the government in leading reforms, and the wider participation of the private sector in designing new governance arrangements in the future.Publication How to Attract Health Workers to Rural Areas? Findings from a Discrete Choice Experiment from India(World Bank, Washington, DC, 2012-08)India faces significant challenges in attracting qualified health workers to rural areas. In 2010 the authors conducted a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) in the Indian states of Uttarakhand and Andhra Pradesh to understand what health departments in India could do to make rural service more attractive for doctors and nurses. Specifically, we wanted to do the following: (a) examine the effect of monetary and nonmonetary job attributes on health worker job choices; and (b) develop incentive 'packages' with a focus on jobs in rural areas. The study sample included medical students, nursing students, in-service doctors and nurses at primary health centers. An initial qualitative study identified eight job attributes health center type, area, health facility infrastructure, staff and workload, salary, guaranteed transfer to city or town after some years of service, professional development, and job in native area. Respondents were required to choose between a series of hypothetical job pairs that were characterized by different attribute-level combinations. Bivariate probit and mixed logit regression was used for the statistical analysis of the choice responses. The findings suggest that the supply of medical graduates for rural jobs remained inelastic in the presence of individual monetary and nonmonetary incentives. In contrast, the supply of nursing students for rural jobs was elastic. Further, medical and nursing students from rural areas had a greater inclination to take up rural jobs. The supply of in-service doctors and nurses for rural posts was elastic. Higher salary and easier enrolment in higher education programs in lieu of some years of rural service emerged as the most powerful driver of job choice. Overall, better salary, good facility infrastructure, and easier enrolment in higher education programs appear to be the most effective drivers of uptake of rural posts for students and in-service workers. Combining these incentives can substantially increase rural recruitment. Incentivizing medical graduates to take up rural service appears to be challenging in India's context. This can be improved to some extent by offering easier admission to specialist training and recruiting students from rural backgrounds. In contrast, nursing students and in-services nurses are much more receptive to incentives for uptake of rural service. This suggests that cadres such as nurse practitioners can play an important role in delivering primary care services in rural India.Publication Protecting Pro-Poor Health Services During Financial Crises : Lessons from Experience(2009)OBJECTIVE: This chapter assesses the extent to which previous economic and financial crises had a negative impact on health outcomes and health financing. In addition, we review evidence related to the effectiveness of different policy measures undertaken in past crises to protect access to health services, especially for the poor and vulnerable. The current global crisis is unique both in terms of its scale and origins. Unlike most previous instances, the current crisis has its origins in developed countries, initially the United States, before it spread to middle- and lower-income countries. The current crisis is now affecting almost all countries at all levels of income. This chapter addresses several key questions aimed at helping inform possible policy responses to the current crisis from the perspective of the health sector: What is the nature of the current crisis and in what ways does it differ from previous experiences? What are some of the key. lessons from previous crises? How have governments responded previously to protect health from such macroeconomic shocks? How can we improve the likelihood of positive action today? METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: The chapter reviews the literature on the impact of financial crises on health outcomes and health expenditures and on the effectiveness of past policy efforts to protect human development during periods of economic downturn. It also presents analysis of household surveys and health expenditure data to track health seeking behavior and out-of-pocket expenditures by households during times of financial crisis. FINDINGS: Evidence from previous crises indicates that health-related impacts during economic downturns can occur through various channels. The impact in households experiencing reductions in employment and income could be manifest in terms of poorer nutritional outcomes and lower levels of utilization of health care when needed. Households may become impoverished, reduce needed health services, and experience reductions in consumption as a result of health shocks occurring during a time when their economic vulnerability has increased. Women, children, the poor, and informal sector workers are likely to be most at risk of experiencing negative health-related consequences in a crisis. Real government spending per capita on health care could decline due to reduced revenues, currency devaluations, and potential reductions in external aid flows. Low-income countries with weak fiscal positions are likely to be the most vulnerable. IMPLICATIONS FOR POLICY: Past crises can inform policy-making aimed at protecting health outcomes and reducing financial risk from health shocks. Evidence from previous crises indicates that broad-brush strategies that maintained overall levels of government health spending tended not to be successful, failing to protect access to quality health services especially for the poor. It is particularly vital to ensure access to essential health commodities, which in many low-income countries are imported, in the face of weakening exchange rates. Focused efforts to sustain the supply of lower-level basic services, combined with targeted demand-side approaches like conditional cash transfers may be more effective than broader sectoral approaches. Low-income countries may need specific short-term measures to ensure that health outcomes do not suffer.Publication Health Worker Attitudes toward Rural Service in India : Results from Qualitative Research(World Bank, Washington, DC, 2010-11)The paucity of qualified health workers in rural areas is a critical challenge for India's health sector. Although state governments have instituted several mechanisms, salary and non-salary, to attract health workers to rural areas, individually these mechanisms typically focus on single issues (e.g. salary). This qualitative study explores the career preferences of under-training and in-service doctors and nurses and identifies factors important to them to take up rural service. It then develops a framework for clustering these complex attributes into potential ?incentive packages for better rural recruitment and retention. The study was carried out in two geographically diverse Indian states, Uttarakhand and Andhra Pradesh. A total of 80 in-depth interviews were conducted with a variety of participants: medical students (undergraduate, postgraduate, and Indian system of medicine), nursing students, and doctors and nurses in primary health centers. The information collected was clustered by constructing several hierarchical displays, and collated into job-attribute matrixes. The findings indicate that, while financial and educational incentives attract doctors and nurses to rural postings, they do not make effective retention strategies. Frustration among rural health workers often stems from the lack of infrastructure, support staff, and drugs, a feeling exasperated by local political interference and lack of security.
Users also downloaded
Showing related downloaded files
No results found.