THE THE THE RESTLESS RIVER RESTLESS RESTLESS RIVER RIVER YARLUNG TSANGPO-SIANG-BRAHMAPUTRA-JAMUNA “This book tells a fascinating story of one of the world’s longest and diverse river systems. It combines beautiful illustrations and a narrative based on good science and the ability to tell a complex story which should be of interest to a wide public”. Julia Marton Lefevre Former DG, IUCN, Chair of the Board of Alliance of Bioversity International and the International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) d “This truly exceptional book has taken the dry, technical data that feeds water diplomacy and turned it into an adventure down this EDITORS: GANESH PANGARE BUSHRA NISHAT XIAWEI LIAO HALLA MAHER QADDUMI beguiling river of many names and many voices. Anyone fascinated by how water shapes cultures, nature and well-being will treasure the book’s diverse narratives and rich visuals and how, layer by layer, they reveal the river’s personal stories and geopolitical calculus; its management alongside its spiritual heart; its ecology and engineering; and despite the river’s timelessness, the urgency of cooperation to secure its future.” l Mark Smith Director General, International Water Management Institute d l “This book is an extraordinarily successful attempt to narrate the natural characteristics, history, and present-day challenges of one of the most diverse transboundary rivers of the world. Based on science and accurate research, and written in a compelling way, it is l an example to follow when setting the foundations for cooperation in transboundary rivers basins”. Michela Miletto YARLUNG TSANGPO-SIANG-BRAHMAPUTRA-JAMUNA Coordinator, UNESCO World Water Assessment Programme (WWAP) and Director, UNESCO Programme Office on Global Water Assessment © 2021 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank YARLUNG TSANGPO-SIANG-BRAHMAPUTRA-JAMUNA 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000; Internet: www.worldbank.org THE This work is a product of the staff of The World Bank with external contributions. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this work do not necessarily reflect the views of The World Bank, its Board of Executive Directors, or the governments they represent. RESTLESS The World Bank does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this work. The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in this work do not imply any judgment on the part of The World Bank concerning the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. RIVER Rights and Permissions The material in this work is subject to copyright. Because The World Bank encourages dissemination of its knowledge, this work may be reproduced, in whole or in part, for noncommercial purposes as long as full attribution to this work is given. Please cite the work as follows: Ganesh Pangare, Bushra Nishat, Xiawei Liao, Halla Maher Qaddumi “The Restless River”. 2021. World Bank, Washington, DC. Any queries on rights and licenses, including subsidiary rights, should be addressed to World Bank Publications, The World Bank Group, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USA; fax: 202-522-2625; e-mail: pubrights@ worldbank.org. EDITORS Cover design and layout: Rustam Vania, Bee Buzz Media Ganesh Pangare Cover photo: © Ganesh Pangare Bushra Nishat All photos: © Ganesh Pangare or otherwise individually credited Xiawei Liao Halla Maher Qaddumi Photographs by Ganesh Pangare THE RESTLESS RIVER THE BEGINNING: STORY OF A RIVER YARLUNG TSANGPO-SIANG-BRAHMAPUTRA-JAMUNA RIVER Pg 10 1. THE BEGINNING The story of a river Pg 20 2. FLOW The river’s journey Pg 98 3. LIFE Biodiversity of the region Pg 166 4. GROW Living off the land Pg 238 5. PEOPLE One river, many cultures Pg 290 6. HARNESS Tapping the river Pg 334 7. GOVERN Framework for co-operation Pg 378 8. VOICE Perspectives 2 3 THE RESTLESS RIVER Foreword TRANSBOUNDARY COOPERATION amongst riparian countries is crucial to managing the sustainable development and utilization of transboundary water resources and key to optimizing the mutual benefits that river basins provide. This fact is widely recognized. For example, the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 6 Target 5 calls on the world community to implement integrated water resources management at all levels, “including through transboundary cooperation as appropriate.” The World Bank is committed to supporting its client countries to better manage transboundary water resources and plays a global leading role in promoting cooperation in transboundary river basins world-wide. Amongst its many engagements, the South Asia Water Initiative (SAWI) is a multi-donor trust fund supported by the United Kingdom, Australia, and Norway, and administered by the World Bank, which supports a rich portfolio of activities to increase regional cooperation in major transboundary Himalayan river systems. The Brahmaputra Basin focus area under SAWI has aimed to promote shared understanding and management of the Brahmaputra Basin to deliver sustainable, fair, and inclusive development and climate resilience. From 2016, SAWI has supported the Brahmaputra Dialogue, an informal multi-lateral and multi-track dialogue process, which has provided an important platform for the four riparian countries to find common avenues for coordinated management of the river basin. Over the years, the Brahmaputra Dialogue process has led to broader agreement on the need for cooperation amongst basin stakeholders and identified the lack of common understanding as one of the key barriers. This report aims to break down that critical barrier. It is the first of its kind to look holistically at the entire Yarlung Tsangpo – Siang – Brahmaputra – Jamuna River Basin. It is novel in that it examines this majestic system from the perspectives of the riparians themselves through contributions from top academics, researchers, diplomats, journalists, politicians, and policy makers from across the basin. As such, the report adds immense value to the comprehensive understanding of the basin and the importance of transboundary cooperation. I would like to thank the many contributors, who generously gave of their time and knowledge and without whom this rich report would not have been produced, in addition to the many others who supported the preparation of the report. May all who have the pleasure of reading this stunning report be awed by the magnificence of the Yarlung Tsangpo – Siang – Brahmaputra – Jamuna River Basin. Cecile Fruman Director Regional Integration and Engagement, South Asia, The World Bank 4 5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Acknowledgements This book would not have been possible without the generous contributions of all of the authors who together produced a unique piece of work. We are grateful for their To H.E. Tshering Tobgay, Gongsar Karma Choppel, Kinlay Tshering, Tenzin Khorlo, time, effort and commitment in sharing the knowledge of and insights on this incredible Lam Dorji, Dasho Sonam Wangdi, Dasho Rinjin Dorji, Dechen Dorji from Bhutan river basin. To He Daming, Feng Yan, Wang Wenling , Yu Hongyuan, Jianjun Cao, Lei Dai, Xinlei Li, Sincere thanks to Nagaraja Rao Harshadeep and his team member Aminul Islam for Zongyi Liu, Jian Yang, Gancheng Zhao, Jiahan Cao from China producing the maps for the book. Thanks also to Malik Fida A. Khan, Executive Director, CEGIS and Md. Firoz Alam for the maps and GIS work for the FLOW chapter. To A B Pandya, Vinay Sahasrabudhhe, Kazu Ahmed, Sanjoy Hajarika, Rita Banerjee, Nitin Desai, Shiv Mukherjee, Ashok Khosla, Ravi Narayanan, Nalong Mize, Group Captain We would like to thank SAWI donors: UK Aid, Australian Aid and Norwegian Ministry of M Panging Pao, Sushmita Mandal, Neelesh Kulkarni, Lalit Mohan, Anil Sharma from India Foreign Affairs. To Kabir Bin Anwar, C M Shafi Sami, Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad, Runa Khan, We would like to thank the following internal World Bank and external peer reviewers Sadik, Manohar Islam, A J M Zobaidur Rahman, M. A. Quassem, Nazra Mahjabin Sabet, for their critical review and helpful feedback that greatly enriched the report: Anders Md Monowar Hossain, Md. Sadiqul Islam from Bangladesh Jagerskog, Xiaokai Li, Md Istiak Sobhan, and Nagaraja Rao Harshadeep (from the World Bank), and Ainun Nishat, Ger Bergkamp and James Dalton (external reviewers). We would also like to thank Mark Smith, John Dore, David Molden, Eklabya Sharma, Philippus Wester, Mohammed Mainuddin and Jonathan Quebbeman for their support A very special thanks to Taylor Henshaw, Marcus Wishart and Jai Mansukhani for their to us during the preparation of this report unfailing support. Finally, we appreciate the support from Shivani Sharma who helped with the web based A special appreciation goes to Anamika Barua and her team Arundhati Deka and others literature review, Nachiket Pangare and Kartik Pangare who helped with editing for being a partner in the Brahmaputra Dialogue over the past several years under SAWI. photographs taken over the last 20 years and were also companions during previous expeditions to the basin and Shimul Roy for support at various stages. We would like to extend our sincerest thanks to all of those whose support has been critical to the long and fascinating journey that has culminated in this report: d From the World Bank: Cecile Fruman, Michael Haney, Junaid Kamal Ahmad, William Young, Janet Minatelli, Jennifer J. Sara, John A. Roome, Feriha Mugisha, Benoit Bosquet, Martin Raiser, Mercy Miyang Tembon, Takuya Kamata, Sudipto Sarkar, Yoonhee Kim, Sumila Gulyani, Gayatri Acharya, Yinan Zhang, Eileen Burke, Sona Thakur, Tiziana Smith, Genevieve Connors, Christina Leb, Julie Ann Vorman, Robert J. Saum, Meike Van Ginneken, Elena Karaban, Lucson Pierre Charles, Tapas Paul, Anil Das, Praveen Badoni, Anju Gaur, Satya Priya, Chabungbam Rajagopal Singh, Debbie Menezes, Sanjay Gupta, Priyanka Chaturvedi, Bekele Debele, Harold Bedoya, Anqi Li, Abedalrazq F. Khalil, Mohammed Dalil Essakali, Lucy Lytton, A T M Khaleduzzaman, Sarwat Batool, Varun Bhardwaj, Ankan De, Santhakumar Sundaram. 6 7 THE RESTLESS RIVER Preface “THE RESTLESS RIVER” Perspectives on the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra- Jamuna River Basin, is a first attempt at documenting the Brahmaputra as a one river system and presenting a multi-layered, holistic perspective of the entire river basin from the perspectives of the four riparian countries. The genesis of the report is the stakeholders from the riparian countries themselves, who highlighted the need for one comprehensive, fact-based document that provides information on the various aspects of the entire river basin and that comprehensively captures the viewpoints of those from all riparian countries. It was felt that a document of this type would be important for supporting the dialogue process and policy discussions on cooperative river basin management. It is natural to expect that such a document should be co-written by various stakeholders across the basin, along with other international experts. We are pleased that the report includes contributions from over 90 authors, which is a powerful expression of cooperation in and of itself. The report consolidates the existing wealth of knowledge and information on the river system. At its heart, however, are the riparian’s perspectives and insights that reflect how the river is deeply embedded in the cultures and the lives of the people living within it. The report portrays the inextricable interlinkages between those living in the countries that share the river system: even though they are divided by international borders, they are tightly connected through the basin’s water resources. It is our sincere hope the report will contribute to enhanced knowledge exchange, catalyze interaction and knowledge sharing amongst basin stakeholders, and ultimately foster a spirit of cooperation to manage and develop the basin optimally, holistically, sustainably, and for the benefit of all. Ganesh Pangare Bushra Nishat Xiawei Liao Halla Maher Qaddumi 8 9 THE RESTLESS RIVER THE BEGINNING: STORY OF A RIVER 1. THE BEGINNING Story of a river Ganesh Pangare Bushra Nishat Xiawei Liao Halla Maher Qaddumi 10 11 THE RESTLESS RIVER THE BEGINNING: STORY OF A RIVER Yarlung Tsangpo Siang Brahmaputra A river with many names... Jamuna RIVER BASINS have been the cradles of civilizations and people have flourished along riverbanks over the ages. Every river has its own unique ecosystem harboring within it a diverse flora and fauna and humans have adapted to live within this complex web of life. THE BRAHMAPUTRA as it is commonly referred to, is actually known by this name only in about 40 percent of its length when it flows through Assam in India. Revered as the Yarlung Tsangpo where it originates in Tibet, known as the Siang, after it plunges down the Grand Tsangpo Canyon, celebrated as the Brahmaputra in the flat terrains of Assam, and flowing as the remarkable Jamuna as it crosses the floodplains of Bangladesh, where it meets the Padma (Ganges) and the Meghna to form the largest delta in the world. This is the 12 13 THE RESTLESS RIVER THE BEGINNING: STORY OF A RIVER mighty river system of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River, one of the biggest river systems in the world. On its way towards the sea many tributaries, each a unique river in its own right, merge into the main channel which flows through three countries, China, India and Bangladesh. The basin, however, also includes Bhutan, from where the largest number of tributaries originate. Hereafter we refer to this river system as the River. One river, many names; representing a continuum of change, and diversity, from upstream to downstream, as the River flows through borders and geographical regions. Each name has a story, giving it an identity that is more than a physical entity, imbibing it with history, culture and religion. The cultural and historical thread flows through the river system as it interacts with the people and communities that live and survive on its banks. Civilisations and kingdoms have come and gone, yet the river flows on, changing course over time, ebbing and flooding each year. Recent estimates show that about 130 million people live in the basin, of which about 86 percent live in rural areas. The River remains largely unharnessed and with a few areas still uncharted, the basin remains one of the most intriguing regions of the world. Only recently, as documented later in the book, the origin of the river has been recharted, and the basin delineated. Based on this recent discovery the length of the River has been estimated at 3,350 kilometers from the source until it meets the iconic Ganges in Bangladesh, and 3,848 kilometers till it reaches the sea. The basin of around 712,035 square kilometers, encompasses a huge network of water courses formed by the numerous tributaries of the River. A River of many superlatives, the Yarlung Tsangpo section of the river flows through the highest of landscapes, plunges 4,000 meters before it is known as the Siang, rushes through flat lands as the Brahmaputra, while as the Jamuna, the elevation of riverbed level falls well below mean sea level. The diversity and complexity in the physiology, ecology and even ethnology makes the basin unique and enchanting. Shrouded in mythology, the River and its tributaries have been of great interest to researchers, scholars, as well as writers, journalists, artists and photographers not only from the region but from around the world. The literature is abundant, covering various aspects including hydro-morphology, biodiversity, cultural history, social development, livelihoods, resource utilization and management of the basin. But the literature has focused on only one or the other segment of the River or basin, and usually from one perspective, and not of the entire River system. This book is one of the first attempts at documenting the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna as a one river system creating multi layered narratives of the basin. The book is divided into 8 chapters exploring the physical characteristics like geomorphology, climate and hydrology, biodiversity, as well as socio-economic and cultural aspects of the basin. The book compiles and collates 91 contributions from global, regional and national experts from the four riparian countries. 14 15 Giving the river its due place as one of the 20 longest rivers in the world IF ONE LOOKS at any list of 20 or 25 longest rivers in the world there is sadly no mention of the Yarlung Tsangpo – Brahmaputra river. This needs to be corrected. The length of the Yarlung Tsangpo- Brahmaputra river is 3,350 kilometers from its source in Tibet till it meets the Ganges river in Bangladesh. After this the Ganges – Brahmaputra together meet the river Meghna and together they are known as the Lower Meghna which flows to the sea of Bay of Bengal. If one includes this length, from the confluence with Ganges till the sea, the total length of the river becomes 3,848 Kilometers. The Yarlung Tsangpo – Brahmaputra river should be ranked amongst the 20 longest rivers in the world. We hope that the River gets this recognition and China, India, Bangladesh and Bhutan can proudly say that one of the 20 longest rivers of the world flows through their lands. We hope that this book is able to bring notice to one of the most fascinating river systems in the world and give the River its due recognition. THE RESTLESS RIVER THE BEGINNING: STORY OF A RIVER The Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna River Deepest and longest canyon: The Yarlung Tsangpo Grand Canyon in Tibet, with Largest riverine island: Majuli, the largest riverine island in the world is located depth upto 6,009 meters, is regarded as the deepest canyon in the world. in the Brahmaputra in Assam. Highest navigable river: Originating at an altitude of 5,300 meters above sea level Biodiversity Hotspots of the world: Listed as one of the 36 Biodiversity and flowing at an elevation of 3,500 meters above sea level through Tibet, China, the Hotspots in the world. Yarlung Tsangpo is considered as the highest navigable river in the world. One of the oldest human migration routes: Major crossroad of movements One of the highest sediments carrying rivers: One of the most heavily of pre-historic ancestors from Africa to the Far East. sediment-laden large rivers of the world, exceeded only by the Amazon and Yellow River. Largest riverine National Park in the world: With a total area of 340 square Joins the largest delta in the world: Over thousands of years, sediments carried kilometers, Dibru Saikhowa National Park is the largest riverine island national park by the Brahmaputra-Jamuna are being deposited in the Bengal Delta, the largest delta in and one of the 19 biodiversity hotspots in the world. the world. The Bengal delta slopes into the spectacular Bengal Deep Sea Fan, the largest submarine fan in the world. Pride of China, India, Bangladesh and Bhutan 18 19 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 2. FLOW The River's Journey Bushra Nishat Malik Fida A. Khan Harish Kapadia Fanyu Zhao S. S. Nandargi Fuqiang Tian Arun B Shrestha Imtiaz Ahmed Neera Shrestha Pradhan Md Monowar-ul-Haq Ahmmed Zulfiqar Rahaman Eklavya Prasad Xiawei Liao Sudipta Kumar Hore 20 21 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y FLOW throughout its basin. Although the main channel does not flow through Bhutan a large number of tributaries originate from the Bhutanese Himalayas, thus Bhutan The river’s journey is also a part of the basin. In Bangladesh, the River joins the Ganges (Padma) and together they converge with Meghna, from where on the river is called the Lower THE YARLUNG TSANGPO-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system is truly one of Meghna, which eventually drains into the Bay of Bengal (shown in the Basin Map). the most intriguing, vigorous and imposing fluvial systems in the world. The River originates in Tibet, China from a glacier over 5,300 meters above sea level and flows Each year, especially in the monsoon, the River carries not only a huge amount as the Yarlung-Tsangpo then as Siang and Brahmaputra in India and the Jamuna in of water but also sediment towards the sea. The River is one of the most heavily Bangladesh. The basin is spread across 712,035 square kilometers1 in four countries. sediment-laden large rivers of the world. As the ultimate carrier of freshwater and On its 3,350 kilometers journey, the River flows through China, India and Bangladesh sediment in the region, the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna drives the and is joined by numerous tributaries creating a huge network of water courses hydrometeorological interactions, dynamics, and processes of the entire region. 22 23 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y The Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna Basin 24 25 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y THE PHYSICAL SETTING OF THE BASIN Depending on topography and morphology, the basin of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna is a mosaic of five different zones, the cold dry plateau of Tibet, the rain-drenched Himalayan slopes, the landlocked Brahmaputra Valley, the distinctive Lower Assam mountainous region and the vast deltaic floodplains. THE TIBETAN PLATEAU covers around 50.5 percent of the basin, with elevations of 3,500 meters and above in the northern most part of the basin2. THE HIMALAYA BELT covers around 23 percent of the basin with elevations ranging between 100 meters to 3,500 meters above mean sea level and is sandwiched between the Tibetan Plateau and Brahmaputra Valley3. THE LOWER ASSAM MOUNTAINOUS REGION covers only 6.4 percent of the basin and includes the Shillong Plateau and Mikir Hills with elevation between 600 meters and 1,800 meters above sea level4. The River basin THE BRAHMAPUTRA VALLEY is long and narrow with elevations below 155 and adjoining meters above sea level and takes up 9.7 percent of the basin. mountain ranges are tectonically THE DELTAIC FLOODPLAINS of Jamuna, situated in Bangladesh and West Bengal, active, and a large India cover the remaining part of the basin. This region is extremely flat, and elevations part of the basin is vary from less than 10 meters above sea level to just under 90 meters above sea level5. geologically young The River basin and adjoining mountain ranges are tectonically active, and a large part of the basin is geologically young. Yet, the rivers in this region are antecedent6, older than the mountains they flow through. Major morphological evolutions started to take place in Early Eocene7, when the Indian plate collided with the Asian mainland and the rise of the Himalaya was initiated between 40 and 50 million years ago8 (some scientists suggest this to be 55 million years ago9). The Yarlung Tsangpo currently flows through the suture zone that separates the Indian plate from the Asian Plate situated in the Tibetan Plateau. With vast expanses of pristine flatness at high elevations, this is the world’s highest and widest plateau, and the geological history is closely linked to that of the Himalayas. East of this Plateau is the geologic wonder, the narrow deep Yarlung Tsangpo Grand Canyon entrenched between the Namcha Barwa and Gyala Peri mountains10. The Siang-Brahmaputra valley is bounded by the Himalayan ranges of northeastern India and Bhutan in the north; and the Shillong Plateau in the south. Huge amounts of sediment carried down from the Himalayas and deposited at the foothills, have created and shaped the valley. In the last leg of the journey, the River enters the Bengal Basin, one of the largest reservoirs of fluvial sediments in the world and represents the lower floodplain and delta plain deposits of the Brahmaputra, Ganges and Meghna rivers. 26 27 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Sediments from the eroding Himalayas create huge alluvial fans in the plains11. The India. We could see the mouth of the Nugong Asi nala flowing from the snow-capped Bengal Basin slopes into the spectacular Bengal Deep Sea Fan, the largest submarine Dapang peak (5,570 meters) in Tibet merging with the Siang. We had reached a point fan in the world and the ultimate destination of the waters and sediments carried by that explorers had been trying to reach for decades. It was a historical moment—the the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River system. last piece of an almost century-old puzzle. That the Yarlung-Tsangpo and Brahmaputra were one river! d It took almost a century of exploration to solve this question. One school of thought Expedition to the Tsangpo bend believed that the river traversed further east till it merged with the Salween river and turned south into Burma. Another school believed that it took a turn to the south Harish Kapadia much sooner and flowed towards India, either into the Siang valley or the Subansiri valley. Several exploratory trips were made, and many different results were obtained. WE WERE standing at a bend in the river. Flowing fast from the Tibetan plateau, it made a large “S" turn and came rushing towards us. It is a river known by many names: The Survey of India deputed the first of its pundit explorers, Nain Singh Rawat, to in Tibet, it is the Yarlung Tsangpo, followed by Siang, and Brahmaputra as it enters trace the route of the Tsangpo. These native explorers were trained to survey the area The Great Bend Liu Rui/China Plus 28 29 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y while travelling in disguise. By this time, Tibet was closed to outsiders, but in two epic journeys in 1865 and 1873, Singh followed the course of the river to Lhasa and beyond. Reaching Chetang, east of Lhasa, he was forced to turn south after his subterfuge was revealed. In 1874, the Assam survey was placed under Lieutenant Henry Harman. He measured the flow of various rivers and found that the flow of the Siang was greater than that of the others, proving that the river was most likely the Tsangpo. He dispatched another pundit explorer, Nem Singh, to Tibet in 1878-79, accompanied by Kinthup, a tailor from Darjeeling. They followed the Tsangpo from Chetang onwards, between the gorge of Namcha Barwa and Gyala Peri, and turned south to reach Gyala Sindong before returning. They made a major contribution, taking the exploration further upstream by 460 kilometers. Harman, then posted in Darjeeling, again deputed Kinthup to travel to Tibet in 1880. Kinthup was instructed to cut 500 logs, make a marking on them and throw them into the Tsangpo river. If the logs emerged in the plains of Assam it would conclusively prove that the river turned south to enter Assam. As Kinthup was illiterate, a Chinese lama accompanied him. From Darjeeling, they went to Lhasa and followed the course of the Tsangpo to Chetang and Gyala Sindong. Around 24 kilometers later, they reached Lieutenant Henry Pemakochung village, where the Tsangpo fell 150 feet in a waterfall which came to be Harman measured known as the “rainbow falls". the flow of various rivers and found Unfortunately, Kinthup was sold into slavery at a monastery, from where he escaped that the flow of the two years later, but was captured again at Marpung, 56 kilometers downstream of the Siang was greater river. He was, however, allowed to go on a pilgrimage. He crossed the Tsangpo to the than that of the opposite bank, cut and marked 500 logs with special markings and threw them into After the journey of Kinthup, no further physical explorations were undertaken, but View of Siang others, proving the river. the journey of the river was known through technology. In the year 2003 a party of as it leaves the that the river was Indian explorers including myself, trekked from the south, coming from the plains mountains and most likely the Kinthup sent a letter to Harman about this, unaware that the Englishman had already of Assam to reach the entry point of the river into India and named it, the “S” bend, hits the plains for Tsangpo left India, the letter remained unopened, and there was no one to check on those logs completing the physical exploration of the Tsangpo. Standing there and completing a the first time even if they reached Assam. He followed the Tsangpo downstream as far as Onlet, a historic exploration was the elixir of my trekking life. small village near the Indian border. He could see the haze of the Assam plains; he was about 64 kilometers in a straight line from the border. He concluded that the Tsangpo The Tsangpo bend expedition from 16 November to 5 December 2004 was organised did indeed flow into the Brahmaputra. with two main objectives: firstly, to see and photograph the bend where Tsangpo enters India and secondly to see if Namcha Barwa, the massif, around which the Kinthup returned to Darjeeling in 1884 and resumed tailoring. Two years later, he river takes a right angle southwards to reach Guyor La could be visualised from was debriefed by the Survey of India, but no one believed him. It was only in 1913, the Upper Siang valley. The expedition comprised of Motup Chewang (adventure following a report by Bailey, that Kinthup’s description was acknowledged as remarkably tour professional, Ladakh), Wing Commander V K Sashindran (Assistant Professor, accurate. Aerial photography and satellite imagery have now confirmed beyond doubt Armed Forces Medical College, Pune), with Lt. Rippon Bora (17 Kumaon, Indian that the Tsangpo enters India, is called the Siang, and forms a major tributary of the Army) and myself. Brahmaputra. d 30 31 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y data of the Chemayungdung Glacier from 1974 to 2010 and concluded that the glacier area has decreased THE ORIGIN OF THE YARLUNG TSANGPO RIVER by 5.02% and the glacier terminal has retreated 768 meters at a rate of 21 meters per year. The terminal lake area has increased by 63.7 percent, from 0.7 square kilometers to 1.14 square kilometers. The volume Xiawei Liao of the lake has increased by about 9.8 million cubic meters. From 2007 to 2010, Chinese Academy of Sciences and the National Geomatics Center of China under the This may be surprising and counterintuitive. The headwater region of the Yarlung-Tsangpo River actually National Administration of Surveying, Mapping and Geo-information formed joint expedition teams to suffers from serious desertification issues due to the high altitude, dry climate and wind disasters (Figure 4). conduct field investigations in the headwater areas of the Yarlung-Tsangpo River in Tibet Autonomous Desertification has also resulted in serious grassland retreat and conflicts between grassland conservation Region of China. The field investigations showed that the Yarlung-Tsangpo River originates from the Angsi and animal grazing46. Glacier (82°03’20’’E, 30°22’06’’N), located on the northern side of the Himalayas and southeast of Mount Kailash and Lake Manasarovar in the Burang County in Tibet. The altitude of the origin is 5319.7 meters45. (Below) Desertification in the headwater region of the Yarlung-Tsangpo River Based on the identification of the origin the river length is 3,848 kilometers and the drainage area is 712,035 square kilometers. (Left) The headwater region of the Yarlung- Lake Mansarovar Tsangpo River Before the expedition, the origin of the Yarlung-Tsangpo River was thought to be the Tamlung tso lake Chemayungdung Glacier (Figure 2), according Angs to what was proposed by the Indian geographer i Glac ier Swami Pranavananda in the 1930s based on traditional Tibetan information. Chemayungdung stream Che ma yun (Below) The upstream of the Yarlung-Tsangpo gdu River ng Gla cie r Ma you stre am The Chemayungdung Stream converges with the Mayou Stream from the north and Kubi stream from the south (Figure 3) and becomes Maquan River (meaning the horse Chemayungdung stream Ma river in Tibetan), the upper stream of the am qu tre an Yarlung Tsangpo. bi s Riv Ku er Against the global context of climate change, glacier retreating has raised growing concerns. Liu and Xiao (2011) analyzed topographic 32 33 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Tributaries of the River north bank tributaries originate in high precipation intensity catchments, have very steep channel gradient, carry a lot of sediment and cause choking of river beds resulting IN THE course of its 3,350 kilometers journey, the River receives as many as 22 major in channel shifting or change in drainage pattern; the tributaries from the south have tributaries in Tibet, 33 in India12 (another estimate indicates 50 tributaries in India, 30 comparatively lower gradient with deep meandering channels, a lower sediment yield, of these coming from the north and 20 from the south13), and 5 in Bangladesh. Like and are more stable than their northern counterparts. The major tributaries that join the main channel, many of the tributaries take on different names at their origin and as the northern bank from east to west are Subansiri, Jia Bareli, Dhansiri and Manas; the they cross the borders or meet with another tributary. In this narrative, the local names tributaries that meet the river on its southern bank are Buridihing, Dhansiri (south), of the tributaries as they join the main channel have been used (shown in the Basin Kopili, Krishnai and Jinjiram15. The flow contributions of these tributaries are shown Map and Figure 1). in Table 1. The table shows that Subansiri contributes the highest flow to the main channel. The tributaries of the Yarlung Tsangpo are mostly snow fed, as they originate in snow covered high mountains. As mentioned earlier, in this region the major tributaries Table 1: Tributary flow contributions to the Brahmaputra are Doxung Zangbo, Nianchu, Lhasa, Nyang, Parlung Zangbo and Yigong Zangbo. (Source: based on 1995 data, Mahanta et al, 2014 ) Average flow in Tributary million cubic meter (MCM)/yr Subansiri 52,705 Lohit 46,964 The Dhansiri, Dibang 37,818 Manas, Dudhkumar and Jia Bharali 28,844 Dharla originate in the mountains Burhi Dihing 11,906 of Bhutan and Kapili Kalang 9,023 contribute substantially to Other tributaries above Pandu 121,938 the discharge of the Brahmaputra- Brahmaputra at Pandu 494,300 Jamuna Although the Yarlung Tsangpo flows west to east, the tributaries flow in the opposite The Jamuna, on its southbound course towards the Ganges, is joined by the Dudhkumar, direction that is in a westerly direction before joining the main channel, assuming a Dharla, Teesta, Ghagot and Karatoya-Atrai rivers on its right bank and the Jinjiram on barbed drainage pattern14. The longest tributary is the Lhasa, which joins the River its left bank. Twenty kilometers south of its entrance, the Old Brahmaputra flows out from the north near the city of Lhasa. Another tributary, the Parlung Tsangpo rises from the left bank of the Jamuna. Another left bank distributary is the Dhalesawri. in mountain glaciers situated at the eastern margin of the Tibetan Plateau and flows The Dhansiri, Manas, Dudhkumar and Dharla originate in the mountains of Bhutan from east to west to join the Yarlung Tsangpo, before it plunges into the Yarlung and contribute substantially to the discharge of the Brahmaputra-Jamuna. Many of Tsangpo Grand Canyon. The Siang is joined by Dibang and Lohit about 30 kilometers these tributaries are large rivers in their own right, draining out large catchments while downstream of Pasighat in north-east India. Both these tributaries originate from the receiving higher-order discharges along their banks. However, only the transboundary extreme eastern flank of the Himalayas. The Brahmaputra gradually gains in size and tributaries of the River, Lohit, Subansiri, Manas, Dudhkumar, Dharla and Teesta will becomes more silt laden, as it collects water from scores of tributaries flowing from be detailed in this section. the Himalayas in the north and from the Patkai hills, North Cachar hills and Shillong plateau to its south. The tributaries of the Brahmaputra valley are of two categories. The d 34 35 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y In the course of its journey, the River receives more than 75 major tributaries. Like the main channel, many of the tributaries take on different names at their origin and as they cross the borders. 36 37 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y N Figure 1: Schematic diagram of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna T I B E TA N P L AT E AU CHINA River System (not to scale) Doxung Zangbo Parlung Zangbo Yigong Zangbo Lhasa Nyang Zhongba Xigaze Lhasa YARLUNG TSANGPO YARLUNG TSANGPO Nian SIKKIM H I M A L AYA S Chamkhar Chu B H U TA N Wang Chu Raidak Dudhkumar Dangme Chu Gangtok Mangde Chu Amo Chu Thimphu Kuri Chu Kameng SIANG Pho Chu Mo Chu Torsa Subansiri Jia Bareli Dibang Dhansiri Pasighat Sankosh Jaldhaka Manas ASSAM Tista WEST BENGAL BRAHMAPUTRA Guwahati Lohit Chayu Dharla Jorhat Dhansin Jinjiram Kopili Dikhow Buri Dihing Dudhnoi Krishnai Tista MEGHALAYA Ghagat Jamalpur JAMUNA O ld INDIA Atrai Bra hm ap utr a a hn Dhaka eg rM NAGALAND pe Up Ganga Padma MANIPUR TRIPURA BANGLADESH Lower Meghna MIZORAM Main Channel Tributary M AYA N M A R Distributary BAY OF B E N G A L 38 39 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 95∞0'0"E 96∞0'0"E 97∞0'0"E 0'0"N 0'0"N 30∞ 30∞ China 0'0"N 0'0"N 29∞ 29∞ India Lohit 0'0"N 0'0"N 28∞ 28∞ Pasighat u tra ap m Myanmar Tributary: Lohit River (Zayul River) Br ah Assam Bushra Nishat LITERALLY MEANING river of blood, the turbulent Lohit is the eastern most tributary of the Brahmaputra. In ancient times, the Lohit was considered as the main channel of the Brahmaputra. According to folklore, the Brahmaputra originated from 0'0"N 0'0"N the Brahmakunda or Parshuram Kunda, a holy site currently nestled on the lower 27∞ 27∞ reaches of Lohit, at the foothills of the Mishimi Hills. The river originates from the Kangri Garpo mountain range of Eastern Tibet as the Zayul and then enters India 95∞0'0"E 96∞0'0"E 97∞0'0"E through the northeastern tip of the country, flows through the Mishmi Hills and / Brahmaputra Index Map Legend 0 10 20 40 km descends to join the Siang and Dibang at the head of the Brahmaputra valley. On its Basin Lohit Catchment travels, the Lohit is joined by numerous tributaries; all these streams are perennially Yarlung Tsangpo Data source: Ganges River CEGIS model output snowfed rivers17. A very small part (less than 1 percent) of the Lohit catchment falls Basin Brah mapu tr a SRTM DEM in Myanmar. Ja m u n a Meghna Elevation (meter) Map prepared by: Basin Center for Lohit Environmental and Geographic Catchment Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 40 41 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 92∞0'0"E 93∞0'0"E 94∞0'0"E Tributary: Subansiri River Bushra Nishat THE SUBANSIRI is the largest, longest and most important tributary of the Brahmaputra, China and contributes around 12 percent of the annual flow of the Brahmaputra. The Subansiri is 442 kilometers long, with a drainage basin covering 32,640 square kilometers in 0'0"N 0'0"N China and India. The Subansiri River originates in the Himalayas, in China at an 29∞ 29∞ elevation of 5,591 meters above sea level. It flows east and southeast into India, then south to the Assam Valley, where it joins the Brahmaputra on its northern bank. Many tributaries such as Kamala, Kurung and Ranga join the Subansiri as it descends into the Brahmaputra valley18. Subansiri meaning the flow of gold in Assamese was a potential site for the valuable mineral. Religious Epics record that, the Kings of Brahmaputra valley offered Yudhistira, son of the Hindu God of justice and death, a gift of gold shipped on elephant back. Legends claim, this gold was carried by the water and washed since ancient times by the local tribes called Sonowals19. 0'0"N 0'0"N 28∞ 28∞ Suban siri Assam 0'0"N 0'0"N Bhutan 27∞ 27∞ Tezpur Assam a u tr ap India a hm Br Guahati 0'0"N 0'0"N 26∞ 26∞ 92∞0'0"E 93∞0'0"E 94∞0'0"E Index Map Legend / Brahmaputra 0 10 20 40 km Basin Subansiri Catchment Yarlung Tsangpo Data source: Ganges Basin River CEGIS model output Brah map utra SRTM DEM Subansiri Ja m u n a Catchment Map prepared by: Meghna Elevation (meter) Center for Basin Environmental and Geographic Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 42 43 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 90∞0'0"E 91∞0'0"E 92∞0'0"E Tributary: Manas River 0'0"N 0'0"N 29∞ 29∞ Md Monowar-ul-Haq China THE MANAS is the largest river system of Bhutan, which drains almost all the catchments of the central and eastern regions of the country. It comprises of four major sub-basins, namely Mangde Chhu and Chamkhar Chhu; Kuri Chhu, which originates from Tibet; and Dangmechhu, formed by joining two main tributaries Kholongchhu that originates from the northeastern part of the country and Gongri that originates from Tibet and flows into India before entering Bhutan. Mangde Chhu and Chamkhar Chhu both originate close to Gangkhar Puensum which has a height of 7,570 meters above sea level, is the highest peak of Bhutan and one of the highest unclimbed mountains in the 0'0"N 0'0"N world. The Manas basin covers 8,457 square kilometeres, which represents 22 percent 28∞ 28∞ of the total area of Bhutan20. The catchment is mostly covered by steep mountainous terrain, rising within a space of 140 kilometers from an elevation of about 100 meters near the Indian border to the great Himalayan peaks at over 7,500 meters along the main Himalayan range bordering Bhutan and Tibet. The huge elevation range and Bhutan varied climatic conditions are reflected in the great ecological diversity and rich fauna Manas and flora in the river catchment21. The climate is extremely varied, ranging from hot and humid subtropical conditions in the south to cold and dry alpine conditions in the north. From May to October, the  southwest monsoon  brings heavy rainfall, more than 6,000 millimeters to the 0'0"N 0'0"N southern part and there is a pronounced dry season in winter22. The difference between 27∞ 27∞ maximum and minimum river flow in monsoon and the dry months is said to be as much as 20 times. The Manas merges with the Brahmaputra in Duars23 of India, has a recorded maximum discharge of 7,641 cubic meters and contributes 5.48 percent Tezpur of the total flows of the Brahmaputra24. a Assam u tr ap m ah Br Assam Sanko Guahati Dhubri sh 0'0"N 0'0"N 26∞ 26∞ India Shillong 90∞0'0"E 91∞0'0"E 92∞0'0"E Index Map Legend / Brahmaputra 0 10 20 40 km Basin Manas Catchment Data source: Yarlung Tsangpo Ganges River CEGIS model output Basin SRTM DEM map utra Brah Manas Ja m u n a Catchment Map prepared by: Meghna Elevation (meter) Center for Basin Environmental and Geographic Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 44 45 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E Tributary: Dudhkumar River/ Torsa-Raidak River system China 0'0"N 0'0"N Md Monowar-ul-Haq 28∞ 28∞ THE TWIN streams of Torsa and Raidak draw their source-waters from high glacial valleys that fringe western Bhutan and the Tibetan plateau and merge in West Te e Bengal, India as the Dudhkumar, which flows through northeastern Bangladesh as sta a major tributary to join the Jamuna. In Bhutan the Torsa and Raidak are known as Thimphu Bhutan Sikkim the Amuchhu and Wang Chhu respectively. Just before the Torsa-Raidak confluence, one Raidak distributary combines with Sankosh, another Indian tributary to flow into Gangtok D the Brahmaputra near the Assam-Bengal border. The Raidak thus contributes to the ud Brahmaputra through two river systems, one branch of which is gaining prominence Sankosh hk as the other shrinks. However, till the downstream flows of the Torsa and Raidak unite, um Darjeeling 0'0"N 0'0"N they are widely seen as separate rivers in their upper, middle and lower segments. Nepal ar 27∞ 27∞ Therefore, a real sense of their regional importance is better gained if they are viewed initially as distinct systems25. West Bengal Assam Dh ar la Cooch Behar Kishanganj a Dhubri u tr 0'0"N 0'0"N ap hm 26∞ 26∞ a Te Br Kurigram e st Dinajpur a Rangpur Meghalaya India Bangladesh India Atrai-Korotoa Jamuna G a ng e s Malda 0'0"N 0'0"N 25∞ 25∞ Bogura 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E Index Map / 0 10 20 40 km Brahmaputra Basin Legend Yarlung Tsangpo Dudhkumar Catchment Data source: Ganges CEGIS model output Basin utra River SRTM DEM map Brah Dudhkumar Ja m u n a Catchment Meghna Elevation (meter) Map prepared by: Basin Center for Environmental and Geographic Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 46 47 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E Tributary: Dharla River/Jaldhaka River China 0'0"N 0'0"N 28∞ 28∞ Bushra Nishat FROM ITS source and most part of its upstream, this tributary emerges as Jaldhaka Te e from the eastern part of Sikkim, the southwestern highlands of Bhutan and the sta Darjeeling hills of West Bengal in India. Flowing east of Teesta, it gathers waters Thimphu Bhutan from several mountain streams as it descends on the low lying Duars of northern Sikkim Bengal. As it flows downstream, the Jaldhaka, also known as Mansai in some areas Gangtok of Jalpaiguri, assumes a new name Dharla as it crosses the international border and joins the Jamuna north of the Teesta-Jamuna confluence. The Dharla is completely Nepal rainfed. With a large and well-developed higher-order catchment, it receives major Darjeeling 0'0"N 0'0"N tributary rivers along both its banks. These include the Jaldhaka that separates India 27∞ 27∞ from Bhutan, as well as the various segments, Mansai, Jaldhaka, Singimari, that feed into the Jaldhaka downstream. This variety of names also identifies the Jaldhaka as West another transboundary river that has swung widely over its floodplains in the past26. Bengal Assam Dh ar la Cooch Behar Du Sanko a tr dh Kishanganj u ku Dhubri ap m sh 0'0"N 0'0"N hm ar 26∞ 26∞ a Br Te Kurigram e st Dinajpur a Rangpur Meghalaya India Bangladesh India Atrai-Korotoa na Jamu Malda Ga 0'0"N 0'0"N ng es 25∞ 25∞ Bogura 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E / Brahmaputra Index Map Legend 0 10 20 40 km Basin Dharla Catchment Yarlung Tsangpo Data source: Ganges Basin River CEGIS model output a Brah mapu tr SRTM DEM Dharla Ja m u n a Catchment Map prepared by: Meghna Elevation (meter) Center for Basin Environmental and Geographic Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 48 49 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E China 0'0"N 0'0"N 28∞ 28∞ Te e s t a Thimphu Sikkim Gangtok Bhutan Nepal Darjeeling 0'0"N 0'0"N 27∞ 27∞ West Assam Bengal Cooch Behar Du Sanko dh Tributary: Teesta River Kishanganj ra Dh ku Dhubri t pu ar ma sh 0'0"N 0'0"N la a r 26∞ 26∞ m Malik Fida Abdullah Khan r ah Te Kurigram B es Dinajpur Rangpur ta THE TEESTA originates high in the Himalaya at an elevation of 5,330 meters above Meghalaya sea level from the Cholamo Lake and crosses Sikkim and West Bengal states of India before joining the Jamuna in Bangladesh. This river is the main tributary of the Jamuna India India Atrai-Korotoa and a river of high importance in Sikkim, northern part of West Bengal and northwest Bangladesh Bangladesh. In the northern state of Sikkim of India, the emerald green waters of the Ga ng es Jamuna Teesta dominate the landscape of the mountains and valleys. As the river winds its way through the Himalayan temperate and tropical valleys it is fed by smaller rivers which arise from Thangu, Yumthang and Donkia-La ranges. The main tributaries being the 0'0"N 0'0"N snow and rainfed – Lachen and Lachung, Rangeet and the Rongni-chu rivers27. 25∞ 25∞ Historians believe the name Teesta comes from the Bengali word Trisrota (having three torrents) as once this river split up into three distributaries, the Punarbhaba, the Karatoya and the Atrai. This tendency to shift course is displayed by most mountain- sourced rivers of this region, the Teesta is the largest among these to have periodically 88∞0'0"E 89∞0'0"E 90∞0'0"E undergone such shifts. Each swing of the river has irretrievably transformed the Index Map Legend / Brahmaputra 0 10 20 40 km economic life and activities of the eco-region through which the Teesta flows28. Basin Yarlung Tsangpo Teesta Catchment Data source: Ganges CEGIS model output The rain and snow fed river is perennial but flow in the dry season goes down drastically. Basin map utra River SRTM DEM Brah The average annual rainfall varies from 1,200 millimeters to 2,500 millimeters in the Teesta Ja m u n a Catchment Map prepared by: Meghna Elevation (meter) Teesta basin29. Basin Center for Environmental and Geographic Information Services 0 8,790 A Public Trust under the Ministry of Water Resources June 2020 50 51 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y CLIMATE OF THE BASIN Fanyu Zhao and Di Long THE LOCATION, complex topography and tremendous height of the Himalayas impedes the passage of cold continental air from the north into the Brahmaputra valley and Jamuna floodplains in winter and also forces the rain-bearing summer monsoon from the Bay of Bengal to limit moisture content before crossing the range northward. The result is heavy rain in lowlands and snow at higher elevations on the southern part of the basin but arid conditions in the Tibetan Plateau30. The Himalayas thus divides the entire basin into two distinct climatic zones: (1) the mountain climate, characterized as cold and dry, dominates the northern part of the basin; and (2) the tropical monsoon climate, characterized as warm and humid, dominates the southern part. However, based on climate and topography there are three distinctive physiographic zones, the Tibetan Plateau, the Himalayan Belt and the lowlying flood plains31. Temperatures in the three physiographic zones Average temperature and precipitation in the basin vary in the three physiographic zones. Typically, December and January are the coldest months, and May to August are the warmest months of each year. The mean annual precipitation in the basin is about 1,350 millimeters32, of which 60 to 70 percent occurs during the summer monsoon The Himalayas months (June to September)33, 20 to 25 percent in the pre-monsoon months from thus divides March through May. the entire basin into two distinct The Tibetan Plateau is coldest with average temperatures ranging from −10 °C in climatic zones: the winter to 7 °C in summer. Winter temperatures in the Himalayan Belt fluctuate around mountain climate 2 °C, whereas summer temperatures are approximately 15 °C on average. The low-lying and the tropical flood plains are the warmest among the three zones, with mean winter temperatures monsoon climate around 17 °C and mean summer temperatures about 27 °C. For all zones the seasonal reduces this thermal gradient36. temperature variation is largest in winter but smallest in summer34. The Himalayan Belt is situated in the periphery of the extra-tropical circulation and Precipitation in the three physiographic zones tropical monsoon circulation in the north and south respectively. Southwesterly The dry Tibetan Plateau has a mean annual precipitation of 734 millimeters, however, monsoon currents channel moist air toward the eastern Himalayas, where the around the Yarlung Tsangpo Grand Canyon, channels of moisture and precipitation moisture rising over the steep terrain cools and condenses to fall as rain or snow. extend northwards, which translates into significant rainfall, around 2,000 millimeters Annual average precipitation varies between 1,000 millimeters and 1,600 millimeters or less per year north of the Himalayan front in the syntax region35. Snowpack of the in the north to higher than 4,000 millimeters in the south at the lower reaches of the Tibetan Plateau also plays a crucial role in the variation in inter-annual precipitation. mountain ranges37. Upper-tropospheric air temperatures above the Plateau are amongst the warmest on the planet as a result of the heating of the elevated land with altitudes of over 3,500 The Brahmaputra floodplains are the wettest part of the basin with an average meters above sea level. The tropospheric temperature gradient between the Tibetan precipitation of 3,500 to 4,000 millimeters. Within Bangladesh, the annual Plateau and the Indian Ocean is essential for the occurrence of the Indian monsoon. rainfall within the Jamuna floodplains varies between 1,500 millimeters and 3,000 The snow depth on the Tibetan Plateau affects the land surface thermodynamics and millimeters38. 52 53 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Glaciers of the Basin Due to the high altitude and low temperature, glaciers are widely distributed in the basin, with an area of about 9,513 square kilometers39. These glaciers are mainly distributed in the high altitude areas of the Himalayan mountain ranges. In the eastern Nyainqentanglha range, the glaciers are extremely developed, mainly affected by the Indian monsoon, with a low elevation (minimum 2,400 meters), and glacier tongues generally extend into forests. The impact of climate change on glaciers is becoming apparent with the majority of glaciers shrinking. Rising temperatures is one of the major causes of snow-melting in the Yarlung Tsangpo catchment. The increased rates of snow and glacial melt are likely to increase summer flows for a few decades and accelerate glacial lake expansion40. Climate change in the Basin Over the past decades and across the basin, temperatures are changing over time and showing mixed trends across seasons and in different areas of the basin. Overall, mean Glacial reserves winter minimum temperatures show increasing trends, and nighttime temperature combined with shows a highly significant warming trend for winter as well as summer. There has been the extremely a significant rise of 0.5 °C in mean minimum winter temperature across the basin. dynamic monsoon As for precipitation, no specific trend of change in the amount of rainfall has been regime interacting observed between the baseline period of 1951–1980 and 1981–2007. Extreme rainfall in a unique appears to be decreasing in the north but increasing over eastern portions of the basin. physiographic Rainfall intensity has increased slightly over eastern portions of the basin41. Therefore, setting and active there could be more disastrous problems like flood frequency and lake outburst. seismo-tectonic geological base have moulded the HYDROLOGY river into one of the world's most Glacial reserves combined with the extremely dynamic monsoon regime interacting massive fluvial in a unique physiographic setting and active seismo-tectonic geological base have systems moulded the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna into one of the world's most massive fluvial systems. The inter annual discharge and repetitive patterns of rise and fall of flow correspond to the seasonal variation of monsoon precipitation and freeze-thaw cycle of the glaciers and snowpack in the basin. The seasonal variation in flow is thus highly skewed with around 70 to 80 percent of the flow occurring during monsoon and very small flow during dry season42. Floods inundate the landscape during the summer monsoon every year as rainfall and snowmelt from the mountains cause the rivers to spill over their banks. These inundations frequently develop into devastating floods, especially in India and Bangladesh. The average annual runoff of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River at Majuli and Pandu in India is 278 and 509 billion cubic meters43 respectively, and at Bahadurabad in Bangladesh the flow becomes 660 billion cubic meters44. This section describes the network of the main channel, tributaries and drainage outlets, the hydrology and floods of the River. 54 55 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Hydrology of the River System Figure 5: Sub-catchment flow contributions for Yarlung Tsangpo-Brahmaputra- Jamuna Basin Md Monowar-ul-Haq, Malik Fida Abdullah Khan, Tanvir Ahmed Source: Analysis by Center for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) based on Shuttle Radar Topographic Mission (SRTM) 90 meter Digital Elevation Data of 2016 (resampled to 900 THE WATER yield of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna basin is one meter from 90 meter) and the Bangladesh National 300 meter resolution (resampled to 200 meter) of the highest in the world; the drainage area is the fourteenth largest in the world, Digital Elevation Model50 yet, in terms of flow the River carries the fifth largest discharge47. It should be noted that the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna catchment is largely ungauged; The water yield of moreover, topography, accessibility and to a large extent, economic considerations the river basin is restrict the routine data collection which can consequently limit the accuracy of the one of the highest data owing to the fact that the river through its course, traverses some of the steepest in the world; the jagged ravines and dense temperate and tropical forest landscapes48. drainage area is the fourteenth Figure 5 illustrates the catchment-wise flow contributions for the River system. The largest in the estimations of flow are based on basin level hydrological modelling using the ArcSWAT world, yet, in terms model tool based on the Soil & Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) with precipitation of flow the River data for the period 1981 to 201249. River, tributaries and sub-basin delineation has carries the fifth been principally based on georeferenced Digital Elevation Models. The delineated largest discharge Brahmaputra Basin was sub-divided into 223 watersheds for flow calculations. For weather data (precipitation, temperature, relative humidity etc.), a combination of both local (Bangladesh portion of GBM) and global (transboundary portion of GBM) sourced data have been used. The model has been calibrated and validated against monthly discharge data at Bahadurabad inside Bangladesh and simulated for a period between 1981 and 2012 and annual average flow was estimated for each catchment to assess the percentage of catchment contribution. Figure 5 shows the Yarlung Tsangpo is the largest of the catchments which covers nearly half of the entire basin of the River system, but with less than one-fifth (17.7 percent) of the annual flow indicating relatively less precipitation from within the upper catchment bounds51. The Figure shows that the Yarlung Tsangpo has been further subdivided into three sub-basins for easier calibration. The Brahmaputra sub-catchments which are mainly within India and Bhutan contribute substantially to the flow as these regions see some of the highest rainfall in the world. The six sub-catchments totaling to roughly one-third (34 percent) of the entire basin contribute almost half (47.7 percent) of the total basin flow. The combined flows of Siang, Dibang and Lohit contribute 20.2 percent of the total Brahmaputra flow52. By the time the River enters Bangladesh, it already carries almost the entirety of its total flow (93.7 percent). Only 9 percent of the basin is situated in Bangladesh, and this portion experiences relatively low rainfall, so contribution to Jamuna flow from Bangladesh is also compartitively low. 56 57 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Figure 6 illustrates flow river reach-wise distribution as displayed as proportionate width. It Table 2: Length of channel and area of basin of the six major tributaries of depicts the gradual increase in river discharge as it gains flow via tributary sub-catchments. Yarlung Tsangpo Name Length (km) Area (km2) Figure 6: Reach-wise flow distribution proportion to flow width for Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna System Doxung Zangbo 303 19697 Nianchu 217 11130 Lhasa 551 32471 Nyang 286 17535 Parlung Zangbo 266 28631 Yigong Zangbo 295 13533 In terms of climate, due to the barrier effect of the high Himalayas and the high altitude of the Tibetan Plateau, the upper and middle sections of the basin, classified as semi- arid climate and cold temperate zone, are extremely cold with little precipitation. The downstream section is humid, rainy and warm and can be classified as mountainous subtropical and tropical climates. Precipitation in the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin The mean annual precipitation of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin is 470 millimeters (data from China Meteorological Forcing Data, CMFD). The precipitation shows an increasing trend from the upstream Lazi station to the downstream Nuxia station (Figure 7). The precipitation at Lazi, Nugesha, Yangcun, and Nuxia stations are 410 millimeters, 404 millimeters, 428 millimeters and 470 millimeters, respectively. Figure 7. Mean annual precipitation in Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin 1 Lazi Nugesha Yangcun Nuxia Hydrology of Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin 0 -1 Fuqiang Tian, Ran Xu, Yi Nan Precipitation (mm) -2 THE YARLUNG Tsangpo is one of the largest rivers originating from the Tibetan Plateau in Southwest China. The mean annual discharge is approximately 20,000 cumec53. The -3 climate of the basin is monsoon-driven with an obvious wet season from June to September, -4 which accounts for 60–70 percent of the total annual rainfall. Yarlung Tsangpo basin covers Lhasa, Shannan, Shigatse, Nyingchi and Nagqu, and southern Tibet regions. There -5 are four main hydrological stations located along the main stream, i.e., from upstream to -6 downstream, Lazi, Nugesha, Yangcun and Nuxia hydrological stations. Yarlung Tsangpo 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 River has several tributaries. Information of the six main tributaries is listed in Table 2. 58 59 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Temperature of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin Table 3: Spatial variation of hydrometeorological elements in Yarlung The mean annual temperature of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin is -1.01°C (data Tsangpo River Basin from CMFD). As shown in Figure 8, the temperature gradually increases as the altitude Name Mean Annual Mean Annual Potential Mean Runoff decreases from upstream to downstream. Mean annual temperature at Lazi, Nugesha, Precipitation Temperature Evapotranspiration Annual Actual Depth Yangcun, and Nuxiazhan are -3.15°C, -1.59°C, -1.18°C, and -1.01°C, respectively. In (mm) (°C) (mm) Evapotranspiration (mm) terms of temporal pattern, the graph shows a slow increasing trend, which is consistent (mm) with global warming. Nuxia 470 -1.01 2043 195 292 Yangcun 428 -1.18 2104 223 184 Figure 8. Mean annual temperature in Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin Nugesha 404 -1.59 2129 253 152 1 Lazi Nugesha Yangcun Nuxia Lazi 410 -3.15 2012 225 106 0 -1 Figure 9: Average seasonal cycles of streamflow at Nuxia station from 1980 to 2012 Temperature (°C) -2 25.00% 22.89% -3 20.00% 19.11% -4 18.02% -5 15.00% Average (%) 11.32% -6 10.00% 8.30% 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 4.89% 4.22% 5.00% 2.23% 1.78% 2.37% 2.90% 1.97% Hydrology of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin 0.00% The mean annual runoff depth or water level of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin at Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Nuxia is about 300 millimeters. In terms of spatial pattern, similar to precipitation, the runoff depth increases from upstream to downstream, and the average runoff depth at Lazi, Nugesha, Yangcun, and Nuxia stations are 106 millimeters, 152 millimeters, Hydrometeorology of Siang-Brahmaputra River Basin 184 millimeters, and 292 millimeters, respectively (see Table 3). Due to the effect of monsoon, there is an obvious wet season from June to September, which accounts for Bushra Nishat more than 70 percent of the runoff (Figure 9). THE SIANG and Brahmaputra along with their network of tributaries dominates the The runoff of Yarlung Tsangpo River is a mixture of various components. In dry landscape and controls the geomorphic regime of the entire region, especially the season from October to April of the next year, baseflow dominates the hydrograph. Brahmaputra Valley. This is the middle reach and the strongest segment in terms of With the increasing temperature, from April to June, snowmelt contributes to the discharge for the entire River system. Almost 80 percent of this flow occurs in the runoff. During the wet season from June to September, the runoff is a mixture of monsoon season between June and September which corresponds to high monsoon precipitation, snowmelt, glacier melt and baseflow, resulting in a comparatively large rainfall, especially in the upper reaches of the tributaries. The tributaries have been discharge54. detailed in a separate section, so in this section the hydro-meteorological conditions of the main channel of the Siang and Brahmaputra is being described. 60 61 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Climate in the Siang-Brahmaputra River Basin The climate of this part of the basin is humid sub-tropical characterized by high rainfall and humidity. The physiographic configuration, enormous water bodies and upper air circulation has shaped the climate of this region. The valley is bounded by high mountainous formations and table land in the north, northeast and south; and is wide open in the southwest. The valley thus predominantly receives southwest tropical monsoons during April through October through two inlets, through the southwest and also through hill gaps in the eastern boundary55. The monsoon rain accounts for 70 to 80 percent of the annual rainfall with an average between 2,500 and 3,200 millimeters. However, spatial distribution of monsoon rainfall is influenced by orography and varies from 1,200 millimeters in the eastern part to over 6,000 millimeters in the southern slopes of the Himalayas56. The higher mountain areas in the north experience snowfall in the winter. The smaller The region experiences four distinct seasons, the relatively dry, cool tributaries are winter from December through February; the dry, hot pre-monsoon mostly fed by season from March through May; the southwest monsoon from June rain and spring through September when the predominating southwest maritime water, but the winds bring rains; and the retreating monsoon of October and major tributaries November57. Post winter, a wide thermal gap is created between the orginate from valley and surrounding mountains, this thermal fluctuation and the high precipitation moisture from the Brahmaputra and its tributaries creates dense areas and in fogs, especially in the morning hours58. The pre-monsoon season is combination with characterized by a gradual rise in temperature, disappearance of fog, snow and glacier occasional thunderstorms, cool mornings and hot afternoon winds. melt contribute The hottest month for most of the basin is May when temperatures can large flows to the rise as high as 40°C, and winter becomes extremely cold as freezing main channel winds from the north depress temperatures in the valley. Hydrology of the Siang-Brahmaputra River Basin The Siang-Brahmaputra and their major tributaries show a seasonal variation in discharge pattern, which corresponds to a tropical monsoon climate. The smaller tributaries are mostly fed by rain and spring water, but the major tributaries orginate from high precipitation areas and in combination with snow and glacier melt contribute large flows to the main channel. Since peaking characteristics of flood flows are different in different tributaries, due to catchment physiography and time lag in rainfall, there is a time lag in tributary floods draining into the river. As a result, the flood hydrograph for the Brahmaputra often shows multiple peaks as can be seen from Figure 10. 62 63 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Figure 10. Hydrograph of Brahmaputra Figure 11. Average seasonal cycles of streamflow at Pandu (Source: Mahanta et al 201459) (Based on Mahanta et al 201462) 70 70 14000000 60 60 12000000 10000000 50 50 Discharge (MCM/month) Discharge in thousand (CUMEC) 8000000 40 40 6000000 30 30 4000000 Guwahati 20 20 Pasighat 2000000 Tsela Dzong Chushul Dzong 10 Shigatse 10 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 0 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec The Brahmaputra channel is governed by the peak and dry period discharge With a catchment during which the channel bed undergoes tremendous adjustment, which in turn area of 47,000 affects the flow regime of the river. While the Siang-Brahmaputra is considered a square kilometers, Table 4 shows the different flows of the Siang-Brahmaputra at different locations of water abundant basin and the main channel and tributaries are perennial in nature, the four river the basin at Pasighat, Majuli, Pandu and Pancharatna. It shows that the flow of the flows reduce considerably between October and May (shown in Figure 11). Since basins of Bhutan main channel increases substantially and almost doubles by the time the River reaches all tributaries pass through alluvial plains, underground seepage is quite high, cover around 9% Bangladesh. As seen from Figures 10 and 11, this increase is more prominent in the especially during flood events, providing a substantial base flow for the rivers of Brahmaputra monsoon60. during dry season63. basin Table 4: Mean annual flows at various locations on the Brahmaputra d (Source: Mahanta et al 201461) Location Mean Flow (MCM/yr) Hydrometeorology of tributaries flowing through Bhutan Bechamara, Majuli 278,447 Ahmmed Zulfiqar Rahaman Bhurbandha, Bhurgaon 365,550 BHUTAN HAS four64 major river basins viz Amohchu, Wangchhu, Punatsangchhu, and Pancharatna, Goalpara 509,435 Manas with a catchment area of around 47,000 square kilometers, which covers around 9 percent of Brahmaputra basin65. The Manas is the largest river basin with the highest Pandu, Guwahati 526,092 flow, which drains almost all the catchments of central and eastern Bhutan. The basin is around 15,83766 square kilometers inside Bhutan and covers around 41 percent of the country’s territory. 64 65 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Hydrology of Jamuna River Basin Md Monowar-ul-Haq and Malik Fida Abdullah Khan THE BRAHMAPUTRA enters Bangladesh east of Bhabanipur (Assam, India) and northeast of Kurigram district and the river is now called the Jamuna. The Jamuna has an annual average discharge of around 667 billion cubic meters as measured at Bahadurabad Water and Discharge Guaging Station. Over 75 percent of the discharge of the Jamuna river is generated from rainfall and snowmelt from upstream countries, as a result, the flow pattern is not strongly related to local precipitation. Climate The Jamuna basin lies in the northwest part of Bangladesh where the climate is sub- tropical in nature with three seasons namely summer/pre-monsoon from March to May, monsoon between June to September, and winter season from October to February. Lower rainfall makes this area atmospherically drier than the rest of the Figure 12: Mean annual flow of rivers of Bhutan country. The rainy season is hot and humid with about 70 percent to 80 percent of the (Source: National Environment Commission (NEC), 2016)67 annual rainfall. The winter is predominately cool and dry. 25,000 20,000 Manas Mean annual ow (MCM) 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 Amochhu Wang chhu Punatsang Drangme Mangde Aiechhu Nyera Amari chhu chhu chhu These rivers are mostly fed by rainfall and supplemented by glaciers (2 percent to 12 percent)68 and snowmelt, which attributes an estimated 70,576 million cubic meters flow from Bhutan into the Brahmaputra-Jamuna river and corresponds to around 12 percent of the flow of Jamuna at Bahadurabad Water and Discharge Guaging Station69. The rivers of Bhutan generally have steep gradients in the scale of 1:114070 on an average, and narrow steep-sided valleys, which occasionally open up to give small areas of flat land for human settlement and cultivation71. They carry large volumes of flow and sediment during the monsoon season and significant snowmelt at the end of the dry season. Average annual suspended load of the Manas River is 2,1660 tonnes and the annual sediment yield is 1,581 tonnes per square kilometer per year72. 66 67 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Maximum temperature occurs in the month of April and minimum temperature Figure 14: Flood Hydrograph for Jamuna River at Bahadurabad in January. Monthly maximum temperature varies from 25°C to 35°C.The average (Data source: National Water Resources Database, Bangladesh. Analysis by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) temperature during monsoon is about 34°C73. Figure 13 presents a temperature trend analysis for the Jamuna Basin within Bangladesh. Plots are generated for both maximum 60,000 0 and minimum temperature values using data for the years 1981-2017. Trends indicate 200 an increase for both maximum and minimum temperatures. Average monthly rainfall in mm Average daily discharge in cumec 50,000 400 600 Figure 13: Temperature trend analysis for Jamuna Basin 40,000 800 (Data source: National Water Resources Database, Bangladesh. Analysis by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS)) 30,000 1000 1200 20,000 1400 32 24 1600 10,000 23 1800 31 y = 0.0166x – 2.6178 R = 0.2393 23 0 2000 February March April May June July August September October November 31 Month 22 Minimum temperatire (°C) Maximum temperatire (°C) 30 As mentioned earlier, around 55 percent of the discharge at Lower Meghna is contributed by the 22 30 21 Jamuna. Dry season contribution of Jamuna to the Bay of Bengal is even more significant as this y = 0.0271x – 33.624 R = 0.4587 21 river alone discharges around 70 percent of the average Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna flow for the 29 month of December, January and February to the Bay of Bengal. During monsoon, the freshwater Maximum Maximum 20 boundary lies close to the coast, but as the rains die down after monsoon and the flows decline, the 29 Linear (Maximum) 20 saline front advances, penetrating further and further landward over the dry months. The flows of Linear (Minimum) the Jamuna strongly affect the salinity of the Meghna estuary and neighbouring coastal areas by 28 19 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 pushing back the coastal salinity line. Year d Average annual rainfall in this region is around 1,900 millimeters which is below the average of Bangladesh, which is around 2,300 mm74. Trend analysis of precipitation in the Jamuna basin is shown in Figure 13. Rainfall data for the plot was prepared Historical and Future Climate and Hydrology Between 1953 using the average data for the years 1948-2017 and is compared with the discharge and 2016 the for Jamuna river at Bahadurabad. Arun B Shrestha and Nisha Wagle Brahmaputra valley experienced Hydrology Precipitation: Historical and Projected major floods The Jamuna usually peaks in July when the average maximum discharge is about The average annual precipitation in the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna basin on thirty-nine 60,000 cumec and flow reduces in the dry season with average lowest in February at is just over 1,100 mm, 70 percent of which is received in the monsoon (June-October). The occasions, affecting 4,700 cumec75. Around 70 percent of total average annual flow is discharged during lower basin receives almost three times more rainfall than the upper basin76. Majority of the over a million monsoon. studies do not report significant trends in the rainfall in the basin. For example, Shrestha et al. people found no significant trends in the past rainfall records (1951-1980 and 1981-2007) but found Figure 14 presents the flood hydrograph for Jamuna at Bahadurabad with data slight increase in average and extreme rainfall in the eastern basin77. Immerzeel also reported between 1999 to 2019 with monthly average values. The flow hydrograph represents no clear trend from 100 year (1900-2002) monthly precipitation data and suggested that the typical bi-modal nature as observed for Brahmaputra with back-to-back peaks annual precipitation was determined by the monsoon78. Flügel et al., reported slight increase occurring in between July-August and August-September. Onset of these peaks are in annual and seasonal precipitation from 1961-2005, but with no statistical significance79. In from the beginning of the monsoon season. contrast, Apurv et al. report increasing trend in summer monsoon during 1990-200080. 68 69 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Unlike in the past, precipitation is projected to increase in the future, including the extremes to August in comparison with 1988-2010. Wijngaard et al.,85 projected increase in annual but with strong spatial and seasonal differences. Shrestha et al.81 suggest an increase (upto 56 percent) and extremes (P99 upto 104 percent) towards the end of 21st century as of about 10 percent (from both RCP 4.582 and RCP 8.583) in the monsoon season in the compared to 1981-2010. Lutz et al.,86 also projected increase in both annual and extreme mid-century (2050) when compared with 1961-1990, while winter precipitation in the precipitation when compared with 1981-2010 with small decrease in monsoon precipitation southwest and central northern part are projected to decrease (Figure 15). Likewise, Pervez in the eastern part for 1.5°C global temperature scenario. Lutz et al.,87 projected increases in & Henebey84 reported seasonal variation in future precipitation with increase in monsoon, precipitation in 2050 when compared with 1998-2007, in a range between 12 percent and post-monsoon and decrease in pre-monsoon, and also suggested monsoon shift from July 18 percent under two emission scenarios (RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5). Figure 15: Change in future precipitation (2021-2050), when compared with the base period (1961-1990) (Source: Shrestha et al., 2015)88 The basin has experienced a general warming trend in the past, but with seasonal and spatial differences with higher warming observed in winter season Temperature: Historical and Projected The basin has experienced a general warming trend in the past, but with seasonal and spatial differences with higher warming observed in winter season. Overall, winter minimum (+0.5°C), pre and post monsoon (+0.3°C and +0.4°C), and night-time temperature (both winter and summer) are seen to increase between 1951-1980 and 1981-2007, while the change in summer temperature is not significant. Moreover, extremes (highest maximum) are increasing over the northern parts (Tibetan Plateau), but decreasing east and southwards, and extreme minimum temperatures are decreasing in the center of the basin89. Immerzeel90, reported warming at an average rate of 0.6°C per decade between 1900 and 2002, with 10 percent of the warmest years occurring between 1995 and 2002. Increase in both average annual (+0.28°C per decade) and seasonal temperature (highest in winter: 0.37°C per decade) during the period 1961-2005 with 95 percent significant level was reported by Flügel et al.91. 70 71 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y The warming is projected to continue and intensify in the future with some indications Hydrology of elevation dependent warming and more prominent warming in the Tibetan Plateau. The basin is rainfall dominated with glacier and snow contribution of about 25 percent100. Annual temperature is projected to increase in the range of 1-3°C by mid-century (2050) Under changing climatic condition, the snow and glacier melt water will reduce, while under RCP4.5 and RCP 8.5, with the northern part of the basin projected to warm more the rainfall-runoff will increase101. The climate change will have significant impact on prominently. Higher increases are projected for winter temperatures over a major portion the hydrological cycle102, and likely lead to more severe and extreme flooding events103. of the basin with some areas projected to warm more than by 3°C for RCP8.5 as compared Shrestha et al.,104 projected an increase in runoff in the range of 0-13 percent up to 2050, to 1961-1990 (Figure 16; Shrestha et al.,92). Immerzeel93 also projected increase in average with no significant seasonal shift. Lutz et al., 105also projected year-round increase in temperature from 2000-2100 by up to 3.5°C under B2 scenario (SRES94 scenarios)95 as flow for 2041-2050 under RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5. compared to 1961-1990, with highest increase in the Tibetan Plateau. Similar result was obtained by Dobler et al.96, where increase in annual temperature by 5°C (A1B Gaini et al., 106analyzed both extreme low and high flows and indicated that extreme scenario) and 4°C (B1 scenario) until 2100 as compared to 1971-2000 was projected, low flow conditions are less likely to occur, while projected strong increase in and also reported more warming in higher altitude and highest increase in maximum peak flow, which is in line with steep increase in monsoon precipitation. Likewise, temperature. Wijngaard et al.,97 also projected increase in average annual temperature Immerzeel, 107also projected increase in average monthly discharge in the range of towards the end of 21st century in the range of 0.7°C to 5°C for both RCP4.5 and RCP8.5, 20-30 percent under A2 and B2 scenario as compared to 1956-1993, with seasonal when compared with 1981-2010. Likewise, recently Lutz et al.,98 also projected increase variation. The winter discharge showed slight positive change, autumn and spring in average temperature, higher in the Tibetan Plateau under 1.5°C and 2°C global average showed intermediate increase, and monsoon discharge showed the highest increase warming scenario, when compared with 1981-2010. from 2005 to 2100. Lutz et al.,108 also projected consistent increase in runoff at least Under changing up to 2050, primarily due to increased precipitation and melt runoff, and will likely climatic condition, Figure 16: Change in future average temperature (2021-2050), when compared increase the extremes as compared to 1998-2007. The recent study conducted by the snow and with the base period (1961-1990)99 Lutz et al.,109 is consistent with the findings reporting increase in precipitation, and glacier melt water (Source: Shrestha et al., 2015) extreme events. Ghosh & Dutta110, projected increase in peak discharge for all the will reduce, while major tributaries and monsoon and pre-monsoon flood-waves under A2 scenario, the rainfall-runoff which is more pronounced in the downstream area. Wijngaard et al.,111, also will increase. The projected increase in mean discharge in both near future (2035-2064) and far future climate change will (2075-2100), up to 49 percent at the end of century, along with increase in high flow have significant condition, as compared with 1981-2100. impact on the hydrological cycle On the other hand, Immerzeel et al., 112projected decrease in mean water supply in the upstream by 19.6 percent for 2046-2065 as compared with 2000-2007, which is partly compensated by increase in mean rainfall. Prasch et al. 113predicted reduction in water availability from 2011 to 2080, due to decrease in glacier melt after 2040. The hydrology of Brahmaputra basin is a complex interplay between temperature and precipitation. Increased temperature, particularly in the high elevation and Tibetan Plateau and resulting melting of cryosphere is likely to cause decrease in the water availability in the upstream part. In the downstream, the meltwater reduction is compensated by precipitation. Therefore, overall, studies show increase in future discharge, due to increased precipitation together with increased occurrences of the extreme flows114. There is still uncertainty in future projections of climatic parameters and its impact on the hydrology115, but a no regret strategy for basin planners would be to prepare for reduced water availability in the upstream and increased floods in the downstream. d 72 73 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y UNDERSTANDING FLOODS The Brahmaputra and Jamuna sections of the River system are prone to heavy annual flooding during the monsoon season. The Brahmaputra flows through the state of Assam in the northeastern part of India which is a high rainfall area. Currently, 5,000 kilometers of embankments stand along the Brahmaputra river and its tributaries to manage floods but often fail to withstand the increased pressure during heavy rainfall leading to breaches and flooding in the adjoining lowlands. In Bangladesh, the hydrology and inundation cycles of almost 40 percent of the flood plains are influenced by the Jamuna. Floods in the Brahmaputra river116 S.S. Nandargi FLOODS IN the Brahmaputra Valley of Assam are caused by a combination of several natural and anthropogenic factors such as unique geographic features of the region, highly potent monsoon rainfall region, easily erodible geological formations in the upper catchments, recurrent and high seismic activities, numerous landslides in the hilly areas of the Valley, accelerated rates of basin erosion, massive deforestation, intense land use practices, increasing population growth especially in the flood plain areas and temporary measures of flood controls. The two heaviest In India, the southwest monsoon occuring between mid-May and mid-October is rainfall stations responsible for causing 65 percent of the annual rainfall over the Brahmaputra basin, of India, viz. generating 70 percent flow of the Brahmaputra river. The other cause of heavy rainfall Cherrapunji and is the ‘Break monsoon’ which occurs when the monsoon trough moves towards the Mawsynram, are foothills of the Himalayas. In addition, cyclonic circulations like low pressure areas, located just to depressions and storms when they move in a northerly or northeasterly direction, the south of the cause very heavy rainfall over Assam region. The two heaviest rainfall stations of India, Brahmaputra viz. Cherrapunji and Mawsynram, are located just to the south of the Brahmaputra basin basin. One-day extreme point rainfall over the basin varies from about 40 centimeters to 90 centimeters. Most of the runoff of this river is contributed by heavy rainfall of 510 centimeters to 640 centimeters in the Abor and Mishmi hills in Siang basin and 250 to 510 centimeters in the Brahmaputra plains. Eklavya Prasad According to the Rashtriya Badh Ayog (RBA), or National Flood Commission, the total flood-prone area in Assam is about 32 lakh hectares which comprises nearly 9.4 percent Flood analysis shows that thirteen sites on eleven tributaries and three sites on the of the country’s total area. Therefore, the Brahmaputra Valley in Assam represents an main Brahmaputra river experienced flood deviation more than 2.0 meters above their acutely flood-prone region of the country causing devastating floods almost every year respective danger levels in a period of 33 years. The highest flood deviation recorded by with tremendous loss and damage to public property, infrastructure and environment. different measurement sites above their respective danger levels (D. Ls) at these rivers The annual loss due to flooding in Brahmaputra basin is also observed to be increasing (Table 6) showed that northern tributaries, Jaibareilly and Manas recorded highest since 1953. flood deviation of more than 10.0 meters in the last 25 years. 74 75 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Table 6: Most severe floods in the Brahmaputra basin in northeast India when (approximately 40 million USD) whereas 25.351 million hectares of agricultural land flood levels were 5 m and more above their respective Danger Levels D.Ls. was damaged. The cost of total damages (crops, houses, and public utilities) during this (updated up to 2019) period is estimated at Rs 78.97 billion (approximately 1 billion USD). River Gauge/ State Deviation of Date & year of Assam's proneness to high, extreme precipitation, frequent earthquakes, landslide Discharge Site Highest flood from occurrence hazards, and sediments from the upper catchments increases the possibility and DL (m) intensity of floods in the region. Apart from the geo-climatic setting, human activities like deforestation, accelerated change in land use, filling up of low lying areas for the Kushiyara Karimganj 5.37 24.09.2010 construction of buildings, urban development and temporary flood control measures are Barak Lakhipur 6.05 12.09.1979 some changes which contribute to the overall vulnerability of the Brahmaputra valley to Assam and floods. Sudden and excessive release of water from dams also lead to flooding, a mega- Manas N.H. Crossing neighbouring 11.03 13.07.1984 disaster because of the huge loss of life and property associated with it. The reliability states and effectiveness of the embankments from the Brahmaputra flooding are generally Kopili Kampur 8.30 13.08.2002 insufficient because of structural deterioration and ongoing riverbank erosion.118 Jaibareilly N.T.Rd. Crossing 12.22 22.09.2010 However, detailed flood frequency analysis at individual gauge/discharge sites of the main Brahmaputra river, its northern and southern tributaries of recent past indicate that there is decrease in frequency of floods in the main river and its northern tributaries as compared to its southern tributaries but there is increase in the intensity of floods in the Assam valley and surrounding region. This is mostly because of man- made interventions or obstructions made to the free flow of water such as bridges, or for agriculture purposes, to meet the increasing population demands. d Brahmaputra, floods and people Eklavya Prasad Between 1953 THE BRAHMAPUTRA Valley, home to 85 percent of Assam’s population, is one of the and 2016 the most hazard-prone regions of the country, with more than 40 percent of its land (3.2 Brahmaputra million hectares) susceptible to flood damage. This is 9.4 percent of the country’s total valley experienced flood-prone area. About seven per cent of land in the state’s 17 riverine districts has Eklavya Prasad major floods been lost because of river erosion over the past years.117 Between 1953 and 2016 the on thirty-nine Brahmaputra valley experienced major floods on thirty-nine occasions when more The eighteen districts along the main Brahmaputra stem encounter different kinds occasions when than one million people were affected. of floods with multi-layered complexities involving social, cultural, and economic more than one dimensions which lead to differential impacts. Therefore, typologizing floods in the million people were A total of 51.564 million hectares land area was affected by cumulative flood damage Brahmaputra valley on the basis of spatial location and character of flood hazard, will affected induced by the Brahmaputra and its tributaries between 1953 and 2016, of which help define the area specific vulnerabilities which will further help in preparedness the maximum was 3.820 million hectares during the 1988 floods. As per the figures, and minimization of losses through addressing area specific prerequisites, rather than the value of damaged crops from 1953 till 2016 is approximately Rs 24.07 billion adopting a generalist approach. 76 77 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y In Brahmaputra valley there are multiple flood typologies, but the one that is widespread and impacts the poorest are: riverine flood with riverbank erosion on the river side, between the embankments of the same river; riverine flood with riverbank erosion adjacent to the river without the embankments; riverine flood with riverbank erosion adjacent to the embankments on the riverside; flash floods with riverbank erosion on the riverside between the embankments of the same river and flash floods with riverbank erosion adjacent to the river without embankments. Riverbank erosion is a natural phenomenon that results in the removal of material from the banks of a river. Most of the rivers in the Ganga-Brahmaputra basin are essentially braided alluvial channels that cause erosion through a combination of three different processes. The pre-weakening process involves repeated cycles of wetting and drying of the bank, which prepares it for erosion. While the phenomenon is natural, the impact it has is disastrous on the life and livelihoods of the riparian community Floods are who are settled on or close to the unstable banks of these channels. The resettlement is diverse, multi- often an involuntary decision as the land gets eroded. Given the impoverished state of layered and must the riparian population, the resettlement happens close to the river, since land prices be attended to as increase as one moves farther away from the river.119 per its location, reason, severity Development induced displacements tend to displace people once, the families affected and diversity by bank erosion are subjected to multiple displacement. It is estimated that annually nearly 8,000 hectares of land is lost to erosion. The intensity of the problem can be gauged from the fact that the total land lost due to bank erosion caused by the Brahmaputra River in Assam alone has ranged between 72.5 square kilometers per year and 80 square kilometers per year between 1997 and 2007-2008.120 Hazards like riverbank erosion that continuously affect the poorest and the most impoverished sections of the community residing in the Brahmaputra flood plains, has to be considered as a typology of floods, to demystify floods as homogenous entity. Floods are diverse, multi-layered and must be attended to as per its location, reason, severity and diversity. Therefore, there is a need to re-examine the flood management plans and strategies in the changing times. d Floods of the Jamuna Basin Malik Fida Abdullah Khan EACH YEAR in Bangladesh about 26,000 square kilometers, that is around 18 percent of the country is flooded121. During severe floods, the affected area may exceed to 55 percent of the total area of the country. In the event of catastrophic floods, it has been anticipated that about two-thirds of the country can get affected122. 78 79 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y The hydrology and inundation cycles of almost 40 percent of the flood plains in The floods of 2007 and 2017 mostly affected the northern districts due to high water level Bangladesh are influenced by the Jamuna. Major extreme flood events contributed by and discharge in the Brahmaputra. In 2007, many countries in South Asia experienced Jamuna inundates between 18,000 square kilometers 23,000 square kilometers area in floods, thus all the rivers, especially the Brahmaputra and Ganges peaked at the same the surrounding flood plains on an average, which is equivalent to 12 percent to 16 time. In 2017, the northern districts faced severe floods in July and August (there were percent of the total country area. However, impacts of those floods are even higher also flash floods in the northeast part of the country in March-April). These floods when combined with peak discharge of Ganges and Meghna. Table 7 summarizes impacted standing crops. Prices of rice, the country’s main staple, reached record high extent of flooding during major flood years for the Jamuna and corresponding impacts levels in September, mostly reflecting flood-induced crop losses in 2017. on the entire country when combined with Ganges and Meghna flows. d Table 7: Notable flood disasters in Jamuna floodplains and their impacts (Source: Analysis by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) based on satellite images, Hossain, 2006124 and Reliefweb, 2017125 Plethora of Pains: Living with floods and erosion Flooded area (sq km) in Countrywide impacts due to floods Year Imtiaz Ahmed Jamuna floodplains123 (from Jamuna, Ganges and Meghna) 1954 23,132 (16% of the country area) Affected 55% of the country. EVERY YEAR during the monsoon season, floods arrive in the Jamuna river basin. Riverbank erosion is also an annual phenomenon. Flooding and erosion have become Inundated 61% of country, estimated damage a part of the lives of the people living on the banks and the chars126 or riverine islands 1988 23,200 (16% of the country area) US$ 1.2 billion, more than 45 million homeless, of the Jamuna. In Bangladesh, flooding begins from the middle of July and continues between 2000-6500 deaths. till September. 1100 deaths inundated nearly 100000 km2, 1998 21,232 (14% of the country area) rendered 30 million people homeless, damaged The Bengali language distinguishes between the normal floods of the rainy season, 500000 homes, heavy loss to infrastructure, which are locally known as barsha, and the more harmful floods of abnormal depth estimated damage US$ 2.8 billion. and timing, which are termed bonna. The barsha, which occurs more frequently than 2000 10,601 (7% of the country area) Estimation unavailable bonna, is often deemed a necessity for survival, especially to farmers127. 2002 16,395 (11% of the country area) Estimation unavailable Huge tracts of paddy and other crops, ponds and fish enclosures go under water, livestock Flooding and is also damaged, crippling already poor rural communities. Stranded in waterlogged erosion have 2003 13,027 (9% of the country area) Estimation unavailable areas, people lose their livelihoods, with little access to food and drinking water. In become a part of Inundation 38%, damage US$ 6.6 billion, deaths the wake of floods, outbreak of water-borne diseases such as diarrhoea, skin diseases, the lives of the 2004 17,477 (12% of the country area) dysentery and cholera cause immense suffering and even loss of lives. Roads, railways people living on 700, affected people nearly 3.8 million. and key infrastructures are damaged, communication system is disrupted, homesteads, the banks and the 8 million people displaced; 2000 people died schools, hospitals are also submerged in flood waters. In the period between 10 July chars or riverine 2007 14,068 (10% of the country area) from drowning and water borne diseases. and 24 July 2019 alone, torrential rains damaged more than 580,000 houses forcing an islands of the Estimated damage US$1billion, Dhaka was estimated 307,000 people from their homes across Bangladesh. Public health officials Jamuna badly affected. confirmed 14,781 flood induced medical cases in northern Bangladesh128. July floods affected about 1.6 million people, damaged over 100000 houses and 40000 Although in Bangladesh, more than 10,000 kilometers of embankments have been hectares of cropped lands were inundated. constructed throughout the country129, embankments are often overtopped or 2017 Estimation unavailable breached. The people living in the region, having suffered from the bonna or ‘big August floods affected 31 districts, and about 16000 ha were fully lost and 560000 ha of floods’ in their own lifetime more than once, have learned to ‘live with floods’. This is standing crops were partially damaged. manifested not only in the coping mechanisms, for instance, in containing diarrhoea and other water-borne diseases, but also in agricultural practices and the construction of secured infrastructures in flood prone areas. The people residing in the vicinity of 80 81 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y these rivers have learned to grow flood-tolerant crops, live in portable houses, store food, household items and crops on a platform in the main living room and plant flood tolerant vegetation such as bamboo and banana. Flood resistant houses constructed on a two-foot-high concrete plinth with walls made from jute panels helps to reduce loss from damage to property130. People in this Erosion caused from the flooding and receding of the waters of the Jamuna results region are in huge loss of land and property every year. Embankments collapse from erosion, resilient, and causing flood inundation in previously flood protected lands. Huge number of people over the years become homeless for uncertain periods due to erosion131. People in this region are have adapted resilient, and over the years have adapted with coping mechanisms. People in char with coping areas (riverine islands), where erosion occurs the most, live in portable houses; the mechanisms house and assets can be easily relocated to safer places. Many people have to eventually leave their lands and migrate to nearby districts and urban areas132. d Community based flood early warning system Neera Shrestha Pradhan and Partha J Das “That one hour of early flood warning makes all the difference to ensure that my investments are safe, and livelihood ensured”- Osman Ali, Barsola 2 village, Assam, India DEVASTATING FLOODS inundate large areas of the Brahmaputra River Basin every year crossing national and inter-state borders resulting in loss of lives and livelihoods, and displacing millions of people in India. Though early warning systems have been developed in many parts of the world to provide flood information, there are gaps – identified by the Hyogo Protocol and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) Special Report on Extreme Events and Disasters (SREX 2012) – in getting this information to communities that are most vulnerable. In the The first version of CBFEWS was tested and used during 2010-2012 on the Jiadhal absence of reliable and timely early warning of flooding, damage and loss to private river of Dhemaji District in Assam. In 2013, five units of an advanced version of the and public property, economy, lives and livelihoods have increased, making people CBFEWS were installed in the Jiadhal (Dhimaji district) and Singora (Lakhimpur more vulnerable worldwide. district) rivers in Assam with active involvement and ownership of local people and DDMA reaching out to 45 vulnerable communities downstream to provide flood A community-based flood early warning system (CBFEWS) was envisioned and early warning. With an investment of approximately USD 1,000 per instrument, the executed by ICIMOD jointly with the District Disaster Management Authority information disseminated by CBFEWS was able to save assets worth USD 3,300 in the (DDMA) in Dhemaji and Lakhimpur, and Aaranyak- an NGO partner in Assam, India, flood of 5 September 2013 in the Dihiri village of Dhemaji. Dhemaji DDMA officer to provide near real time flood information to prepare the vulnerable communities for explained, “After receiving a warning, we deployed the National Disaster Response the upcoming flood risk during 2010-2016. CBFEWS is an integrated system of tools Force to the affected downstream areas of the Jiadhal River, which helped the district and plans in which upstream communities, upon detecting flood risk, disseminate administration prevent a disaster situation”. The communities, who had to stay awake the information to vulnerable downstream communities through mobile phones for all through the night to monitor rivers and floods earlier, expressed their happiness preparedness and response using local resources and capacities. as they were able to have “sound sleep at night” after the installation of CBFEWS. 82 83 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Providing the life-saving information to the villagers, a woman caretaker of the system stated, “I feel empowered and important because even the Gaon-Burha (Village Head Man) of the village comes to me to ask about the flood situation”. The project’s impact was acknowledged by the UNFCCC by awarding it the Momentum for Change 2014 Lighthouse Activity Award as a shining example of innovative use of Information and Communication Technology for Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation. Encouraged by the impact on the ground, the DDMA of Lakhimpur District replicated the CBFEWS in Ranganadi river in 2016. The Government of Assam, Flood and River Erosion Management Agency of Assam discussed the upscaling of CBFEWS in Assam and mentioned, “We have been informed that the only Early Warning System (EWS) established in Assam has proved to be successful in generating and disseminating flood signals that not only helped people to save their assets but also supported District Disaster Management Authorities to deploy flood rescue teams to the vulnerable sites”. The river Inspired by the success achieved in Assam, CBFEWS instrument was improved from To the south across the flood plains major channel avulsion135 has taken place within displays a wireless to telemetry based EWS and scaled up in different tributaries in Nepal, India, the last 250 years. Historical maps and tell-tale palaeo-channel markers show that the variety of channel Pakistan and Afghanistan in the Hindu Kush Himalayan region. From 2020 onwards, Teesta, the largest tributary of the Jamuna shifted course several times in the past. British patterns on its CBFEWS is also out scaled in 33 tributaries in Malawi, South Africa jointly with the geographer Major James Rennel’s136 maps of 1764 and 1777 show Teesta flowing into journey towards relevant government line agencies and local partner organization. three branches while travelling through North Bengal and ultimately discharging into the the sea, at times Ganges at several places. Devastating floods and neo-tectonic activities led to a change meandering, d of direction and the Teesta swung eastward flowing towards the Jamuna around 1787137. Historical maps but mostly in This sudden eastward shifting combined with the tectonic tilting of the Madhupur Tract and tell-tale braided form triggered avulsion of the Brahmaputra channel. Historical mapping of the last 250 years palaeo-channel MORPHOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE RIVER indicates that the main active channel of the river used to flow through the east of the markers show Madhupur tract and join the Meghna River directly at Bhairab Bazaar in Bangladesh. that the Teesta, The Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna displays a variety of channel patterns In the late eighteenth century, the Brahmaputra began to diverge towards a small spill the largest on its journey towards the sea, at times meandering, but mostly in braided form. The channel known as the Konai-Jenai, shifting gradually southwards to join the Ganges and tributary of the Yarlung Tsangpo consists of alternating sections of wide valleys with braided channels by 1810, emerged as the Jamuna, leaving the eastward channel which is now known as Jamuna shifted and narrow gorges with single deeply incised channels amid shallow layers of boulders Old Brahmaputra138. course several that cover bedrocks. In the Brahmaputra valley and flood plains of Jamuna the River times in the past is highly braided, marked by the presence of numerous alluvial channels with lateral The middle reach of the river has also experienced channel migration in more recent bars and islands between meeting and dividing again133. This section briefly describes times. The Assam earthquake of 1950 and more contemporary processes of erosion and the historical development, planform134 characteristics and morpho-dynamics of the aggradation through bar formation caused bankline migration of the Subansiri, a major main channel. tributary of the Brahmaputra. Additionally, abnormal high flood level in 1988, and difference in gradient due to topographic elevations led to avulsion of the Lohit River, a south bank tributary of the Siang. A small channel of the Lohit captured the Dangori river of the Dibru Geological history Saikhowa region, and gradually by 1995, the main flows of the Lohit began flowing through the captured channel. This transference in combination with the southward adjustment Bushra Nishat of the Brahmaputra caused significant shifting of the Lohit-Siang confluence point. But the most noticeable response to this avulsion has been its effect on the Dibru Saikhowa THE YARLUNG-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna and its tributaries are morphologically National Park. As can be seen from Figure 17, previously the park area was a part of the dynamic, and the fluvial patterns have continuously been reshaped by continental left (south) bank of the Brahmaputra river, but in response to the migration of the river, the tectonics, surface processes and climate feedbacks. area has become a char or river island in the main channel of the Siang139. 84 85 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Figure 17: Landsat image over Dibru Saikhowa. A 15 November 1973; B, 28 GEOMORPHOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS November 2000 (Source: Borgohain et al 2016)140 Yarlung Tsangpo Sun Jian and Lin Binliang THE GEOMORPHOLOGICAL characteristics of the Yarlung Tsangpo river is significantly affected by the uplift of the Tibetan Plateau and the movement of geological structures, with a hydrographic network developed on a rock-based gravel bed. Its slope goes steeper, and its undercut goes deeper at the edge of the Tibetan Plateau. In recent decades, the runoff and sediment transport of the river are strongly affected by climate change and the potentially ever-increasing human activities. Local geological structure and lithology, as well as the temperature difference and water erosion, lead to the variety of spatial scales and plane view of the fluvial network. Geology background Longitudinal profile of riverbed The staggered width of the Yarlung Tsangpo river looks like the shape of a lotus. The In the upper reaches in Tibet, the river channel displays mild gradient in the wide canyon sections of the lotus roots are mainly dominated by granite and significant uplift valleys and large gradient in narrower sections. The gradient of the basin and River by a lateral fracture in a nearly north-south direction. The glacier-mantled mountains, channel is as steep as 4.3 meters per kilometer to 16.8 meters per kilometer in the gorge with an elevation higher than 5,500 meters, is steep along the canyon, and the river section and the slope decreases suddenly in the Brahamputra valley after the Siang- mainly has straight or slightly bending patterns. The riverbed here is deeply cut down In recent Lohit confluence. Near Guwahati in Assam, the Brahmaputra is as flat as 0.1 meters per into the bedrock with little sediment on the riverbed, because of the high riverbed decades, the kilometer as can be seen in Figure 18141. The low gradient results in high width to depth slope and flow velocity. The branches drained into the mainstream also takes the form runoff and ratios causing high deposition of sediment and development of a braided channel. of deep-cut canyons. Wide valley sections are mainly developed in the large fault zone, sediment where sandstone and mudstone widely distribute. The mountains along both sides of transport of Figure 18: Longitudinal profile of the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra- the wide valley have elevations less than 5,500 meters and have gentle slopes. The river’s the river are Jamuna River (Based on SRTM 90m DEM) longitudinal slope and flow velocity are small in these reaches, with thick sediment strongly affected Yarlung Tsangpo Siang Brahmaputra Jamuna Padma & deposition and widely distributed braided rivers. In addition, the shape of the branch by climate 6000 Lower Meghna estuary in the wide valley sections is mostly trumpet-shaped. In the middle reaches, change and canyon valleys are restricted by narrow gorges, while the width of the valleys is between the potentially 5000 2 and 8 kilometers. Multiple bars in the channel constitute unique complex braided ever-increasing channels of the Yarlung Tsangpo river. human activities 4000 The uneven elevation of the Tibetan Plateau in the east-west direction and the Elevation (msl) 3000 sediment deposition over thousands of years have formed lotus-shaped river valleys Manasarovar Lake of the Yarlung Tsangpo River. The river alternately distributes with large-width and Bay of Bengal 2000 shallow-depth lakes. The river reach is characterized by slow flow velocity contributed by a relatively static water environment. 1000 Impacts of climate change and human activities on river geomorphology 0 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 Because of the high elevation, the hydro-sediment dynamics, river pattern, the Distance (km) sediment erosion/ deposition of the Yarlung Tsangpo river are basically in a natural state. However, climate change has accelerated the glaciers melting and changed the d plateau monsoon over the past few decades. Given the long-term impact of climate 86 87 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y change on hydrological elements, it will gradually change the water and sediment flux, river channel and bring a series of issues on sediment engineering as well as water- the sediment transport capacity, the riverbed morphology and promote river pattern sediment conservation. transformation. The high-elevation terrain and neotectonic movement of the Tibet Plateau play a The ever-increasing human activities in the river basin will also have potential impacts fundamental role in the geomorphic diversity of the Yarlung Tsangpo river. The plateau on the river evolution. For example, over-grazing will lead to grassland degradation and uplift is the long-term and large-scale geological background of the Yarlung Tsangpo river's even desertification, which may decrease the flow discharge and increase the sediment evolvement, especially for the bedrock undercut, headward erosion, and landslide or debris flux. The road networks constructions and the mineral resources exploitations produce in the riverbank slopes. It is notable that, as a sensitive area for climate change in the Tibetan numerous soil and slag accumulation and expose the bare surface of mountains, which Plateau, Yarlung Tsangpo river is gradually suffering the water and sediment changes as will also increase the sediment flux. Besides, reservoir constructions are the most well as the complex river evolution against the background of global warming. Meanwhile, direct and strongest human activity that influences the evolution of natural rivers. It the human activities such as the hydropower development, road constructions, mineral works in intercepting coarse sediment in the upstream, decreasing the riverbed slope. exploitations and grazing expansion have been increasingly enhanced on the plateau. The As a result, sediment in the downstream river reach is reduced and the riverbed is changes will break the balance between sediment erosion and deposition in local river likely scoured by the clean water with lower sediment concentration. These human reaches, sharply change the alluvial river patterns and accelerate the deep cut of the riverbed, activities are likely to partially change the flow and sediment transport process of the result in the changes in the evolutionary process of the Yarlung Tsangpo River. 88 89 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Siang-Brahmaputra occasionally splits up into multiple smaller primary and secondary channels and they are part of the main channel having average width of approximately 1 kilometer147. Malik Fida Abdullah Khan Erosion-Accretion SIANG RIVER meanders along its southbound path until it reaches the confluence with Erosion and accretion have been identified as a major challenge in the northeast Dihang and Lohit Rivers. After the confluence, the main channel of the Brahmaputra region of India148. The combined effects of large and highly variable discharge, high becomes braided. The number of major channels in the braided Brahmaputra varies silt content, heavy rainfall, and unstable geology have resulted in a very unsteady river across the segment, with the planform being dominated by a range of vegetated and channel of Siang-Brahmaputra causing heavy lateral erosion149. The river shows a non-vegetated bars that divide the channel into a hierarchy of channel sizes142. tendency to migrate south as the south bank faces active bank erosion. Erosion is more prominent during recession stages of floods when the water level drops very quickly. Planform characteristics The Brahmaputra in the reach from Dibrugarh to Dhubri (near Bangladesh border), Planform characteristics of the Brahmaputra River has significant spatial and between 1990 and 2008, around 1,464 square kilometers land was lost due to riverbank temporal variability from upstream to downstream reaches, which is caused by erosion, compared to accretion of 214 square kilometers. Erosion was higher in the tectonic zonation of the river, channel slope and sediment load. Further, the tributaries south bank (920 square kilometers) compared to north bank (544 square kilometers) Between 1990 joining the northern and southern banks of the Brahmaputra vary in terms of river while it is vice-versa for accretion. This high amount of erosion along both banks of the and 2008, around dynamics and sediment load resulting in differences in tectonic regimes. From the river resulted in the deterioration of living standard of people by affecting the people 1,464 square recent studies, the average widening over the last 90 years has been estimated at 44 living near the bank as well as loss of infrastructures. The highest erosion occurred in kilometers land percent; from the average width of 9.74 kilometers in 1915, the channel has widened the segment upstream of Dibrugarh until the confluence of Siang-Lohit Rivers150. was lost due The River is one to the average width of 14.03 kilometers in 2005 and in certain reaches the average to riverbank of the widest widening is as high as 250 percent while the shifting of bankline is not uniform Sediment Transport erosion, rivers in the towards both banks143. The Brahmaputra flows with a huge load of sediment acquired from the rain-soaked compared to world. In the Himalayan tributaries. Estimates of the sediment load of the Brahmaputra River are accretion of 214 plains of Assam, The great Assam earthquake of 1950 with an epicenter within the Brahmaputra highly variable, ranging from 270 to 720 million tonnes per year151. Similar to discharge, square kilometers the average basin has triggered multiple transformations in planform in the main channel and sediment load varies throughout the year, and is highest during monsoon season. width is almost tributaries of the Siang-Brahmaputra and downstream reaches. This earthquake 10 kilometers induced large-scale landslides in the Himalayas, and the loose debris and barren The source of this sediment is the Himalayan region, the distribution of erosion and some places slopes together resulted in 45 billion m3 of sediment into the river system choking contributing to the sediment flux in the mountain range is heterogeneous. Recent the width is and raising the bed of the Brahmaputra, which was as high as 3 meters in Dibrugarh. studies show, the eastern syntaxis including the Namche Barwa mountains is a major as high as As the river became shallower, it became wider to accommodate its regular flow source of sediments and supplies about 50 percent of the bulk sediment inflow to the 18.6 kilometers subsequent to 1950144. Brahmaputra system152. Even in average conditions, the River is one of the widest rivers in the world. The d narrowest part of the Yarlung Tsangpo is when it passes through the big bend within the Great Canyon entrenched between the Namcha Barwa and Gyala Peri mountains, which stand only 21 kilometers apart145. In the plains of Assam, the average width is Jamuna almost 10 kilometers and some places the width is as high as 18.6 kilometers, although rock outcrops at several places confine the river width. At Saraighat, a place near Sudipta Kumar Hore Guwahati, Assam the bank-to-bank width narrows down to 1 kilometer146. JAMUNA IS a large sand bed braided river. As discussed earlier, the main channel and In certain reaches the braiding intensity, which measures the channel multiplicity tributaries of the River have changed courses rerouting drainage patterns frequently has also increased. The Brahmaputra River consists of large, deep and active primary in historic and prehistoric times. Geomorphologically this segment of the river is in channels in combination with smaller and shallower secondary channels. The width and dynamic equilibrium and migration of channels, shifting of banklines and widening depth of the primary channels as well as the bed profiles vary significantly from place of watercourse are a frequent phenomenon. However, within the last decade the to place with time. During low flow period, the primary channel of the Brahmaputra morphological instability of the Jamuna has slowed down. 90 91 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y Planform Characteristics The Jamuna has multiple channels separated by small bars and chars, typically showing two to three channels per cross-section. Migration of channels and shifting of banklines are very frequent. The high variability of discharge, averaging 60,000 cumec during flood and 4,250 cumec during dry period leads to erosion and accretion in the channel respectively. In Bangladesh the average width of the first order Figure 19: Erosion-Accretion of the channel increases to almost 12 kilometers and in Brahmaputra-Jamuna River in the last 46 some places, width can be up to 16 kilometers, years (Analysis based on satellite images) especially during monsoon period. Similar to the Brahmaputra, the Assam Earthquake of 1950 has had a massive impact in the planform changes of the Jamuna. Mainly coarse sediment (sand portion) from the earthquake induced landslides played a significant role to alter the morphology in the last 70 years which propagated gradually as sand wave to the Bay of Bengal. This additional input of sediment made the river more dynamic, and energy was dissipated by the process of the erosion and river widening153. In most places there is a tendency of the Jamuna to migrate westward. Migration from the center line of the Jamuna took place at about 45 meters per year between 1973 and 2010 as a result of channel shifting and widening154. Erosion-Accretion The instability of the Jamuna river coupled with erodible alluvial banks causes heavy bank erosion. Erosion is not similar to a meandering river where erosion takes place in the outer bend at one bank and deposition in the inner bend at the other bank. Erosion occurs in both banks in the Jamuna. It is very difficult to predict the erosion as vulnerable channels shift within one season. Historical analysis shows that erosion has been dominating in the past six decades compared to accretion in the Jamuna. In the Jamuna in the past 46 years (from 1973) total erosion was 928 square kilometers and net accretion was 148 square kilometers (shown in Figure 19). This erosion often takes place in populated areas and erosion is responsible for land loss causing damage to agricultural land and physical infrastructure such as homesteads, embankments and roads. On the other hand, newly accreted area needs time to mature and become productive or create opportunities for inhabitation and economic activities. 92 93 THE RESTLESS RIVER F LO W: T H E R I V E R ' S J O U R N E Y The chars of the Brahmaputra-Jamuna 76 percent of the chars in the Jamuna were less than nine years old while only 7.2 Created from sedimentation or avulsion of river channel, river islands or shoals, locally percent chars were mature having existed for 21 years or higher155. But there are also known as chars in India and Bangladesh are an important feature of braided rivers. Char very old chars such as Majuli, the world’s largest riverine island which was formed dynamics are interrelated with the bank erosion processes, widening and narrowing of around 1750. rivers. While there are river islands of various sizes and shapes in the braided portion of the Yarlung Tsangpo channel, these remain mostly uninhabited and unexploited. In Analysis of satellite images show that the char area in the Brahmaputra channel India and Bangladesh, development of chars provides opportunities for settlement of was 1,460 square kilometers in 2018156 and in the Jamuna the area was 760 square people and crop cultivation and for decades, many chars, especially mature chars have kilometers in 2016. Widening of the river caused increasing trend of the char area. established rural areas including schools, hospitals and other infrastructure. Typically, However, the widening process has slowed down recently. This does not mean the a new char land continuously emerges and submerges and requires at least 10 years of formation of chars will stop. Rather loss of char in one area may compensate in continuous survival before it becomes fit for human habitation. In 2000, approximately another area within the riverbank. 94 95 THE RESTLESS RIVER The Ganga- Brahmaputra- Meghna delta is the largest in the world. Sediment Transport from the river. The remaining sediment is circulated in the bay and acts as a source Although estimates vary, on average the Brahmaputra-Jamuna carries an amount of of alluvial delta development across the Bay of Bengal. This process is important for about 607 million tons of sediment every year which is the third highest sediment land building in the coastal region of Bangladesh and East India. transport river in the world after Amazon and Huang Ho Rivers157. However, the combined suspended sediment load of the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna (GBM) Sediment transported through Brahmaputra-Jamuna and deposited to the Bay of region is around 1,050 million tons per year, the second largest sediment load in Bengal over thousands of years had a significant role in the development of the Bengal the world. Almost 60 percent of this sediment load originates in the Brahmaputra Delta160. More recently, a large amount of accretion due to the Assam earthquake basin. The sediment carried by the Jamuna originates in the Himalayas with nominal resulted in the delta progradation in the 1950s and 1960s and accelerated the delta contribution by the tributaries in Bangladesh and the Jamuna158. shifting process161. Even though there is influx of high sediment, the shoreline remains mostly unchanged, as most of the sediment brought to the rivers bypasses Around 55 percent of this load is deposited in the rivers, floodplains and deltas, the estuary and is deposited into deeper waters by way of the Swatch of No Ground, accretion is most rapid in the river braid belt and adjacent floodplain159. Annual a shelf canyon that deeply incises the Bay of Bengal near the Meghna Estuary162. precipitation and associated runoff rework accumulated sediments in adjacent floodplain surfaces and transport remobilized deposits to local catchments distant d 96 97 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION 3. LIFE Biodiversity of the region Ganesh Pangare Ravindra Kumar Sinha S. P. Biswas Marc Foggin Liu Jiang Sanchita Boruah Bibhab Kumar Talukdar M. Monirul H. Khan Utpal Singha Roy Karma Chopel Ghongsar M Niamul Naser S M Sadik Tanveer Xiawei Liao D. B. Gurung Sayam U. Chowdhury M Firoz Ahmed Rekha Chetry Dilip Chetry Indra P Acharja Girish Jathar S.M.A. Rashid Partha Sarathi Ghose Bishal Thakuri 98 99 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION THE CONVENTION on Biological Diversity 1992 defined biological diversity or “The life of a river in many ways rests on the flowers, insects, animals, fish biodiversity as: ‘the variability among living organisms from all sources including, inter alia, terrestrial, marine and other aquatic ecosystems and the ecological complexes and fisheries found not only in the waters but also in and around the region. of which they are part; this includes diversity within species, between species and of ecosystems”. The true value of the river lies in its aesthetic manifestation, much of which The Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system comprises unique arises from the flowers, insects, animals, fish and fisheries that come to abound and diverse ecosystems and habitats for a large variety of flora and fauna including many endangered species. The biodiversity of living habitats and species brings beauty the river and its surroundings”. Imtiaz Ahmed and vibrancy to the river system making it one of the most fascinating river systems of the world. The aquatic and terrestrial habitats of the river system are dynamic in themselves and also change in character over short and long distances due to the changes in altitude and geographical and climatic conditions in each basin and sub- basin of the river system. From the high altitude Tibetan plateau with its drought-resistant shrubs and grasses which is home to the yak, to the forests at lower altitudes with unique plant diversity, and the tall reed jungles, grasslands, and wetlands of the floodplains, home to three of Asia’s largest herbivores-the greater one-horned rhino, the wild water buffalo and the Asian elephant, and the largest carnivore, the Bengal tiger, this river system showcases diverse environments and ecosystems. Blue pitta This chapter provides an overview of the biodiversity of the Yarlung Tangpo-Siang- (Hydrornis cyaneus) Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system. YARLUNG TSANGPO BASIN Biodiversity Marc Foggin THE YARLUNG TSANGPO is an international river that flows more than 2,000 kilometers from west to east across the southern part of the Tibetan plateau, just north of the Himalayan range, at an average elevation over 4,600 metres above sea level. In total, its watershed encompasses approximately 242,000 square kilometers and it is divided in three main sub-basins (see Map 1 and Table 1). Based on the physical geography, including average altitude, topography, precipitation, and main land cover types, each of the sub-basins has relatively unique ecological characteristics, both in terms of biodiversity and of their socio-ecological features (traditional livelihoods) based on the areas’ long-term environmental constraints and opportunities, including human-nature interactions and pressures. 100 101 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Map 1: The Yarlung Tsangpo and its sub-basins, including visualisation of altitude as well as spatial (including a suite of snow finches, e.g. Montifringilla species, as well as Hume’s ground- distribution of meteorological and hydrological stations in Tibet Autonomous Region, China1 tit, Pseudopodoces humilis) and lizards (Phrynocephalus erythrurus) that co-utilize the pikas’ burrows, and a unique and rich plant diversity enabled by the pikas’ burrowing activities. The middle section of the Yarlung Tsangpo watershed is its most populated sub-basin. This region of southern Tibet is agriculturally the most productive, often referred to as the ‘bread-basket’ of Tibet due to its long history of crop production. Even here, however, cultivation is limited due to the cold and semiarid environment and is dependent on cropping systems characterised by relatively heavy tillage, frequent irrigation, high seeding rates and fertiliser applications4 and there remain land use conflicts for production of food for human consumption versus forage5. Yet, along all the waterways and in lakes and wetlands of south-central Tibet, there is also a rich biodiversity. In the Lhasa urban area, the Lalu wetlands are recognized internationally under the Ramsar Convention for their global significance, providing critical habitat for endemic, rare and/or representative Tibetan avifauna including ruddy shelduck Around two- (Tadorna ferruginea), bar-headed goose (Anser indicus), brown-headed gull (Larus thirds of all Table 1. Basic information about the Yarlung Tsangpo and its sub-basins2 brunnicephalus), white stork (Ciconia ciconia), common redshank (Tringa totanus) vascular plants, and many other local and migratory species. In these wetlands as elsewhere across half of the Yarlung Area Length Precipitation Average Main types Population the middle stretch of the Yarlung Tsangpo, the black-necked crane (Grus nigricollis) is mammals and Tsangpo (km2) (km) (mm) annual of land cover particularly noteworthy, being of great cultural significance to Tibetan people. four-fifths of the temp. (oC) insects that are Upper sub-basin 26,000 268 < 300 - 0.3 Alpine steppe, alpine 153,400 Moving further eastward and downstream along this world river, finally the most known in Tibet (arid area) meadow, alpine extraordinary of sections in this unique and diverse watershed is encountered: the are found in this bushes Yarlung Tsangpo Grand Canyon. Wrapping around Namche Barwa mountain (7,782 unique land, Middle sub-basin 166,000 1,293 300 – 600 5.2 Semi-arid herbs, broad 1,297,000 meters) in eastern Tibet Autonomous Region, China, the river makes its “great one of China’s (semi-arid area) leaf shrubs bend”, cutting through the Eastern Himalayas, in the process dropping from around most exceptional 2,900 meters on the Tibetan plateau to around 600 meters when it flows into India, biodiversity Lower sub-basin 50,000 500 > 4,000 7.0 Alpine forest, tropical 82,000 where it is then known as the Brahmaputra River. Flowing around 250 kilometers hotspots (humid area) forest between Namche Barwa and Gyala Peri mountain (7,294 meters), with an average depth of 5,000 meters, this is indisputably the deepest canyon in the world. At its extreme, a single slope rises from the river all the way to the snow-capped peak Within the Yarlung Tsangpo’s vast watershed, its westernmost headwaters, the upper with an elevational difference over 6,000 meters – thus presenting a multitude of basin, are most similar to the Tibetan Plateau as a whole. As high altitude arid and ecosystems across all altitude zones, with climatic conditions ranging from sub- semiarid rangelands, this ecological region is particularly noteworthy for its unique tropical to Artic in just a few kilometres. Around two-thirds of all vascular plants, suite of large ungulate (hoofed mammal) species including the migratory Tibetan half of the mammals and four-fifths of the insects that are known in Tibet are found antelope (or chiru; Pantholops hodgsonii), Tibetan gazelle (Procapra picticaudata), blue in this unique land, one of China’s most exceptional biodiversity hotspots. Though sheep (or bharal; Pseudois nayaur), argali (Ovis ammon), and wild yak (Bos grunniens); largely unexplored (with no permanent road access until 2014), recent camera trap large carnivores such as Tibetan wolf (Canis lupus chanco), Eurasian lynx (Lynx lynx), surveys in subtropical Metog county have confirmed the presence of 23 medium snow leopard (Panthera uncia) and Pallas’ cat (Otocolobus manul); and other native and large terrestrial mammal species and six pheasant species, including the very wildlife including Tibetan bear (Ursus arctos) as well as the black-lipped or plateau rare Bengal tiger (Panthera tigris tigris) as well as the dhole (Cuon alpinus), golden pika (Ochotona curzoniae). Plateau pika is itself a keystone species3, that is, a species cat (Catopuma temminckii), marbled cat (Pardofelis marmorata) and clouded that enables the survival of many others including many mid-size terrestrial and aerial leopard (Neofelis nebulosa)6, highlighting the exceptional conservation value of this predators that depend on the plateau pika as prey in winter, a wide range of birds spectacular lower sub-basin of the Yarlung Tsangpo river. 102 103 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION 104 105 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Plant diversity plants distribution. Often in this region tropical and temperate plants meet to form a floristic junction and a strange geographical distribution in a small area at the same Liu Jiang time, presenting a significant flora transition from tropical to temperate zones. Overview of the vegetation and species diversity7 According to a survey on middle reaches of the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin10, almost The vertical distribution of vegetation in the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin shows 60 percent species belong to the families of Compositae, Rosaceae, Ranunculaceae, significant zonal characteristics, including coniferous forests, broad-leaved forests, Papilionaceae, Labiatae, Liliaceae, Scrophulariaceae, Polygonaceae, Umbelliferae, thickets, deserts, grasslands, grasses, and meadows. From the perspective of a diversity Gramineae, Cruciferae and Saxifragaceae. Families with tropical flora and temperate index, its value gradually increased as the elevation declined from the upper reaches to flora account for 50 percent respectively, indicating the seed flora in the middle reaches the lower reaches of the Yarlung Tsangpo River. of the Yarlung Tsangpo River is the transitional type from tropical to temperate zone. In the riparian zone of the Yarlung Tsangpo River, the top three families are Compositae, Gramineae and Leguminosae 11. Species of high occurrence include Heteropappus gouldii, Artemisia wellbyi, Sophor moorcroftiana, Astragalus strictus, Oxytropis sericopetala, Eragrostis mino, Pennisetum flaccidum, Orinus thoroldii, and Microula sikkimensis. The downstream On the basis of the different climatic and geographic conditions, the Yarlung Tsangpo region of the River Basin can be divided into three main regions based on the typical vegetation in Yarlung Tsangpo upstream, middle and downstream basin areas. River Basin is the most complete Headwater and upstream region vertical mountain Headwater region is located at an altitude of 4,000 meters to 6,000 meters. The river ecosystem in in the upper valley is composed of many bays, center bar, swamps and lakes, under the world the climate of arid and semi-arid zone. The landforms on both sides of the river are dominated by barchan dunes. This region has Alpine grassland, Alpine meadow, Alpine shrub, Alpine cushion vegetation, Alpine scree vegetation. Middle reach The middle reaches of the river are like a string of beads, wide or narrow, with broad valley, providing the main farming areas in Tibet. Altitude of this region is from 3,000 meters to 4,000 meters. This reach has Subalpine dark coniferous forest which includes There are more than 3,700 species of vascular plants in the Yarlung Tsangpo River tree moss and lichen in abundance, in addition to Alpine pine forest and sand dune valley belonging to 210 families and 1,106 genera8, ranging from vines and epiphytes in vegetation. tropical forests to alpine cushion vegetation in alpine subnival belt. There are 11 cover types and 21 cover types in alpine vegetation9. More than 150 species are endemic to Downstream region Tibet. Some dominant species, such as Ericaceae in alpine shrubs, has a total number The downstream, flowing in the grand mountain valley, is the area with abundant of 154, accounting for 26 percent of the global population. Also, there are more than vegetation types and plant species. It is the most complete vertical mountain 50 genera and 150 species of orchids, and some of them are almost impossible to find ecosystem in the world. The reach has Alpine shrub meadow with a good quality grass elsewhere in China. layer which is suitable for grazing cattle, sheep and other herds in the summer season. The Alpine shrub meadow, Alpine and Subalpine coniferous forest, is the forest group The water-vapor passageway along the Yarlung Tsangpo River has resulted in a with widest distribution, largest area, strongest stability and highest productivity. In complete vertical distribution of natural zones in the Yarlung Tsangpo canyon. Due to the vertical zone with an elevation from 2,700 meters to 4,300 meters, mountain semi- the special landform and climate conditions, the canyon has become the high and north evergreen broad-leaved forest, evergreen broad-leaved forest and the valley monsoon limitation for tropical plants and also the low and the south limitation for temperate rainforest can be found. 106 107 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION 108 109 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Black-necked cranes Xiawei Liao THE BLACK-NECKED crane (Grus nigricollis) belongs to the Grus genus, Gruidae family and Gruiformes order. It is the latest crane discovered among the 15 kinds of cranes worldwide by the Russian naturalist, Przhewalski, near the Qinghai Lake in 1876. It is also the only kind that inhabits high-altitude plateau areas between 2,500 and 5,000 meters above the sea level. There are estimated 10,000 to 10,200 black-necked cranes in the world and Tibet is home to 7,000 to 8,000, making up about 70 to 80 percent of the global population12. The black-necked cranes are featured with red head, black neck and white body. An adult crane is around 110 to 120 centimeters tall and weighs 4 to 6 kilograms. The breeding areas of black-necked cranes in China are located in the rivers and wetlands in the northern and There are western parts of the Qinghai-Tibet plateau, and scattered in the swamps in the southwest estimated 10,000 of the Qinghai-Tibet plateau as well as in Gansu and Northern Sichuan. They arrive at to 10,200 black- the breeding areas in March and build their nets that are about 10 centimeters tall and necked cranes in 90 centimeters in diameter in swamps or wetlands which cannot be easily accessed by the world and humans and other animals. From early May, female and male black-necked cranes start Tibet is home to to mate. They are known to usually mate in the mornings. They begin laying eggs in late 7,000 to 8,000, May. Nestlings start to hatch after 30 to 33 days. making up about 70 to 80 percent Attracted by the warmer climate and abundant food, including barley, wheat and of the global grassroots, black-necked cranes migrate to the middle reach of the Yarlung Tsangpo population River and its two tributaries, Lhasa River and Nyang Chu River from middle-October to March to spend the winter13. The black-necked crane is endangered because of habitat losses and illegal hunting. Due to the development of lakes and construction of infrastructure, such as fishing ponds and roads, the habitats of black-necked cranes are being gradually threatened. In southern Tibet, black-necked cranes are also affected by the changing farming practices. Due to technology improvement, many farmers started to grow winter wheat. When the black-necked cranes arrive, the winter wheat has not yet started to germinate and therefore cranes cannot find food. Black-necked cranes are now on China’s first-class protection list, along with other 90 endangered species including the giant panda and golden monkeys. The National Black-necked Crane Natural Reserve in the middle reach of the Yarlung Tsangpo River (28o39’-30o00’N, 87o34’-91o54’E) was established in 1993 and elevated to a National Natural Reserve in 2003 with a total area of 6,143.5 square kilometers. Frescoe in a monastry in Tibet (left) 110 111 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Fish diversity Lalu wetlands, Lhasa Town Xiawei Liao THERE IS a long history of fishery in Tibet. Fish bones and fishing gears were found in the Qugong ancestor village ruins in Lhasa that date back to four to five thousand years. Fishery in Tibet took off from the early nineteen eighties, with the total catches tripling from 450 to 1,291 tons in ten years from 1985 to 1995. There are 71 species14 or subspecies of fish in Tibet, many of which are unique to the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, including Schizothoracinae, Triplophysa, and Sisoridae. In the downstream, besides the species mentioned above, there are also other typical oriental region fish species, including Barbodes hexagonlepis, Sinilabeo dero, Garra Kempi, Nemacheilus subfuscus, and Aborichthys kempi. There are 13 alien species found in Tibetan water bodies, including rivers, wetlands and reservoirs. Cyprinus carpio and Carassius auratus are the most widely seen. According to the Chinese Fishery Statistics, in 2017, fishery GDP amounted to RMB 32.7 million (approximately USD 4.7 million), making up 0.2 percent of the provincial agricultural GDP. The total fishery output in Tibet in 2017 was 454 tons, including 383 tons of catches from the rivers and 71 tons of aquaculture production. In recent years, the total aquaculture production in Tibet ranges from 60 to 100 tons. The main aquaculture species include Hypophthalmichthys molitrix, Oreochromis spp, and Silurus asotus. 112 113 THE RESTLESS RIVER Red Pandas are members of Ailuridae family and are endemic to the Himalayan and Hengduan mountain ranges. Red panda population has probably declined by 50 percent over the last three generations and is likely to continue to decline in future Red pandas essentially indicate the health of temperate forests that ranges from 1,500 to Fire cat: red panda 4,800 meters above sea level. The species shows high preference for mixed temperate and conifer forests in different landscapes across its range. Red pandas prefer dense forest Partha Sarathi Ghose, Shalini Thapa, Megha Moktan with healthy bamboo understory and proximity to water sources. Potential red panda and Abhishek V. Shukla habitats across the range countries range between 47,100 and 134,975 square kilometers. Red panda is a member of the Order Carnivora. However, its principal food is bamboo. RED PANDAS are members of Ailuridae family and are endemic to the Himalayan The species of bamboo preferred by red pandas vary considerably across its range. Across and Hengduan mountain ranges. They occur in the mountainous regions of Nepal, the Himalayan range countries red pandas prefer Yushania maling and Thamnocalamus India, Bhutan, Myanmar and China. Red pandas have recently been classified into two aristatus for food. Red panda population has probably declined by 50 percent over the last distinct species, the Himalayan red panda (Ailurus fulgens), distributed across Nepal, three generations and is likely to continue to decline in future. Negative impact of human India, Bhutan, parts of southern China and northern Myanmar, and the Chinese red related causes on red panda population and its habitat are undeniable. International Union panda (Ailurus styani), which is endemic to China. The A. fulgens is distributed across for Conservation of Nature has categorised the red panda as an Endangered species and the Yarlung Tsangpo and the Siang-Brahmaputra basin. receives protection as a critically threatened species across all the range countries. 114 115 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION the Brahmaputra floodplains of Assam. It is the richest diversity of rotifer recorded from any part of the Indian sub-region and one of the richest known globally. The Brahmaputra also has the richest diversity of Cladocera in India as well as South and Southeast Asia. Deepor beel, a Ramsar designated wetland in the Brahmaputra valley is recognized globally as a rich rotifer ecosystem with its 171 species of rotifer and 58 species of Cladocera. Majuli, the largest riverine island which is located in the floodplains has a rich micro-metazoan diversity with 131 species of rotifer and 55 species of Cladocera. The beels, streams and rivers provide ideal habitats for turtles and amphibians. Out of 24 species of Changeable hawk eagle (Nisaetus cirrhatus) freshwater turtles in India, 21 are present in the Brahmaputra river. More than 250 species of birds have been recorded in the river basin. The  floodplains also harbor a total of 76 species of macrophytes or  aquatic plants  belonging to 36 families and 55 genera. A detailed checklist of Angiosperms and Gymnosperms of Assam state prepared in 2014, lists 3,854 taxa (including infra-specific taxa) under 1,394 genera and 236 families. Out of these, 2,752 taxa are dicotyledons, SIANG BRAHMAPUTRA BASIN 1,080 taxa are monocotyledons, and 22 taxa are gymnosperms. Biodiversity The flora of Assam represents 18 percent of Ravindra Kumar Sinha the total species of flora in India. However, the figures are provisional as many areas of the state THE RIVER Brahmaputra is the abode of rich biological diversity with over 300 species are still unexplored or underexplored. The flora Bar-headed geese (Anser indicus) of fish and other megafauna, including the endangered Gangetic Dolphin, Platanista of Umananda island (having an area of only 4.7 gangetica gangetica. The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has hectares) on the Brahmaputra near Guwahati includes 146 species of plants belonging found four species of fish to be critically endangered, 11 endangered and 25 vulnerable to Macro-Fungi, Bryophytes, Pteridophytes, Gymnosperms and Angiosperms. Macro- in the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna basin. There is not enough data available for 27 fungi are represented by 4 species belonging to 4 genera and 3 families; Bryophytes percent of the species, some of which might turn out to be in the “threatened” category are represented by 4 species belonging to 3 genera and 3 families; Pteridophytes are as well, after obtaining more data. represented by 11 species belonging to 8 genera and 6 families; Gymnosperms are represented by 2 species belonging to 2 genera and 2 families; Dicots are represented Among zooplankton 220 rotifer species (21 families and 46 genera), and Cladocera, by 100 species belonging to 88 genera and 42 families and, finally, Monocots are termed as “water fleas” (74 species belonging to 41 genera) have been recorded from represented by 25 species belonging to 22 genera and 11 families. 116 117 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Linked Ecosystems of the Siang-Brahmaputra River Basin Wetlands (Floodplain lakes) The Brahmaputra basin is blessed with innumerable wetlands variously named as Sanchita Boruah and S.P. Biswas beel, anua and haor depending on the size and origin of the wetland in question. The marshes and swamps are locally known by different names such as jalah, doloni, pitoni, THE NORTHEASTERN region of India is blessed with high endemism due to its doba. These water bodies with diverse aquatic macrophytes are home to many aquatic highly assorted and complex habitat which includes the numerous floodplain lakes faunas and a major source of capture fisheries which provide livelihood support to the scattered throughout the valley covering an estimated area of 0.1 million hectares15. local population. Deepor beel, Maguri beel, Mer beel, Chatla haor, Bakri haor, Sone beel The Brahmaputra, aptly considered as the ‘lifeline’ of Assam, boasts some unique flora are among the prominent wetlands in Assam. The beels and anuas are repositories of a and fauna, which makes it a paradise for nature and wildlife lovers. The diverse types of wide array of riverine species including Indian Major Carps while hoars are abode of aquatic habitat scattered throughout the river basin are the abode of a variety of edible food as well as ornamental fish species. Over 100 species of commercially important and ornamental fish species as well. fish have so far been recorded from the wetlands of Assam. Fishing is conducted in the wetlands almost round the year except in the season when fishing is banned. Fish The five critical components of the flow regime which regulate river ecosystems are: production from these wetlands is far below their potential production of about 1,000 magnitude, frequency, duration, timing and rate of change of hydrologic conditions16. kilograms per hectare per year. Siltation of wetlands, wanton killing of brood and In maintaining river health, the water quality and quantity is the master variable, which juveniles and lack of management plans are identified as major contributory factors for includes natural flow regimes, physio-chemical properties, sediment transport and the poor fish production in the wetlands. However, proper management can turn these drainage basin runoff. These collectively give rise to diverse habitats which comprise wetlands into fish granaries of the region. “linked ecosystems” within a particular river ecosystem. The Brahmaputra river system comprises such linked ecosystems. Man-made tanks The upper Brahmaputra basin has large excavated tanks which are centuries old and Lesser whistling teal (Dendrocygna javanica) 118 119 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION fed by both snowmelt and rainwater alternatively during summer and monsoon seasons respectively. However, a special type of lotic system known as ephemeral or seasonal streams emerge during monsoon. Ephemeral streams represent a semi-arid existence which harbour fish diversity uniquely adapted to survive in those adverse micro habitats. These are locally known as Jiadhal and create havoc due to flooding particularly in Dhemaji and Lakhimpur districts of upper Assam. The small sized fish like Danionella, Pseudolaguvia, and other biota living in this type of biome have specific adaptive capability to cope with harsh and fluctuating abiotic parameters of seasonal streams. Threats/Issues Aquatic biodiversity especially is in critical crisis due to human exploitation, pollution and developmental activities19. The depletion of biodiversity is accelerated by various anthropogenic activities such as (a) release of toxic waste elements from the factories/ industries and agricultural fields into open water sources; (b) felling of trees in White-winged are perennial tanks being fed by underground streams. The tanks provide shelter for a catchment areas for setting up of industries and large scale construction works which Local ecological wood duck variety of flora and fauna and provide drinking water to thousands of people residing also have an adverse impact on aquatic life; (c) leakage of crude oil into water sources knowledge (Asarconis scutulata) in their periphery. During the Ahom rule in Assam, many large tanks were constructed from the nearby oil reservoir; (d) injudicious fishing, high rate of siltation in river bed constitutes a Highly endangered, which are still in their full splendor. The Ahoms adopted a special technique to construct and above all, non- implementation of the existing fishing policies which are the root potentially only about 800 these tanks. One such tank is the Joysagar tank which is one of the largest man-made causes of declining aquatic diversity in the basin; (e) climate change is inevitably a useful source of survive in the wild tanks in south Asia having an area of 4,50,000 square meters. The tank holds about 22, major challenge for fishermen and riparian communities. information for 02, 240 cubic meters of water during winter. Maximum depth of the tank ranges from conservation of about 8.85 meters in winter to about 9.67 meters in the monsoon season. Twenty-three Eco restoration, Sustainable development, Livelihood & Flood ephemeral fish, species of aquatic macrophytes belonging to 18 families have been recorded from the mitigation plan some of which tank. The faunal composition comprises of insects (19 genera), fish (21 species), and Local ecological knowledge constitutes a potentially useful source of information for are very rare birds (22 species) including many migratory forms. Between December and February, conservation of ephemeral fish, some of which are very rare and endemic. Although and endemic thousands of migratory birds throng into Joysagar and other historical tanks of upper there are limitations and biases of this type of untested traditional knowledge, the local Assam which could be developed as ecotourism destinations. information from fishing communities is likely to help in monitoring the population status of target species. Paddy fields In the eastern and southern states of India, paddy fields are often flooded with small The following suggestions have been put forward for maintaining a balance between wild fishes during monsoon months which are retained within for varying periods of economic activities and ecological resilience. time; but production is low as many of the traditional systems of rearing are inefficient17.  » Minimize environmental stresses such as pollution, habitat alteration, and exotic In Assam, people trap varieties of wild fish, mostly murrel and other air-breathing species introduction in the aquatic system forms in seasonal water bodies like ditches, road-side canals, and deeper areas of paddy » Retain riparian forests that shade streams and rivers for maintenance of existing fields by making  ‘shelter’ or traps for the fishes during the rainy season. The fishes are habitat quality harvested during post-monsoon/winter months. However, the method of trapping fish » Reduce nutrient loading to rivers and wetlands by maintaining natural flow is still ‘primitive’ and therefore the yield is very erratic and usually low. In the Siang » Maintain flow of water and sediments critical to riverine ecosystems Basin, composite rice-fish culture has been adopted by the Apatani tribe in their paddy » Restore aquatic and wetland ecosystems to the maximum extent possible to promote fields, mostly for common carps18. In agriculture dominated areas, expansion of paddy ecosystem resilience to climate change and other stressors cum fish culture may be an alternative livelihood option for the farmers. » Use groundwater judiciously for irrigation and human consumption in the rain shadow areas of the region Ephemeral streams » Conduct a comprehensive study on impacts, mitigation and adaptation in the In the northeastern Himalayan region, most of the rivers are perennial, as these are vulnerable areas, combined with practical actions involving resource users. 120 121 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION In most of the non-protected areas, various anthropogenic activities and natural events Brahmaputra Grasslands have changed the habitats leading to their degradation and transformation. Land use has changed due to expansion of agriculture, human settlements, developmental projects, Girish Jathar and breaking up of the grasslands into smaller and patchy fragments. Over the last 45 years, the mosaic of grasslands, wetlands, agriculture patches have been converted to THE GRASSLANDS of the Brahmaputra floodplains are a suitable habitat for many either tea gardens or contiguous agriculture areas in most of the districts of Assam. threatened species such as the Indian rhinoceros Rhinoceros unicornis, Bengal tiger Panthera tigris tigris, Asian elephant Elephus maximus, wild water buffalo Bubalus These grassland floodplains are of great importance to both wildlife and human The ecosystem arnee, hog deer Axis porcinus and the swamp deer Rucervus duvaucelii. Most of beings. The ecosystem services they provide are invaluable in terms of water recycling, services they the important grassland bird species of the Indian subcontinent20 are found in the arresting soil erosion, controlling floods, providing habitats for threatened wildlife, provide are Brahmaputra floodplains. The Assam Plains Endemic Bird Area which includes the carbon storage, and most importantly livelihood to local communities. Conservation invaluable in floodplains, has three restricted range species namely Manipur bush-quail Perdicula of these grasslands are of great importance in view of the changing climate and needs terms of water manipurensis, black-breasted parrotbill Paradoxornis flavirostris and marsh babbler to be integrated into the policy and action plans of the government. recycling, arresting Pellorneum palustre21. Other threatened bird species found in the grasslands of the soil erosion, Brahmaputra are listed in Table 222. d controlling floods, providing habitats Table 2: Threatened grassland birds found in the Brahmaputra Floodplains for threatened Avifaunal diversity wildlife, carbon S.No Common Name Scientific Name IUCN Status storage, and Utpal Singha Roy most importantly 1 Bengal Florican Houbaropsis bengalensis CR livelihood to local 2 Swamp Grass Babbler Laticilla cinerascens EN MORE THAN 900 different bird species including birds of global conservation concern communities and restricted-range bird species have been recorded from North-east India the 3 Swamp Francolin Francolinus gularis VU majority of which are found in the Brahmaputra valley ecoregion25. Wide geographic areas under this region have been designated as Important Bird Areas (IBAs). These 4 White-throated Bushchat Saxicola insignis VU include National Parks such Dibru-Saikhowa, Kaziranga and Orang; Sanctuaries such as D’Ering, Panidihing and Chakrashila; and Reserved/Protected Areas such as Dibang 5 Jerdon’s Babbler Chrysomma altirostre VU and Majuli island. On the basis of the large number of endemic birds found in these 6 Slender-billed Babbler Turdoides longirostris VU areas, two Endemic Bird Areas have been designated from this region; the Eastern Himalayas (EBA 130) and the Assam Plains (EBA 131)26. 7 Marsh Babbler Pellorneum palustre VU Several important studies on avifaunal diversity of Brahmaputra valley have been 8 Black-breasted Parrotbill Paradoxornis flavirostris VU conducted. However, most of the studies have been limited to areas with easier access. Studies from remote areas covering different seasons throughout the year are likely to 9 Bristled Grassbird Chaetornis striata VU result in newer interesting findings. 10 Yellow-breasted Bunting Emberiza aureola VU Among the numerous residential and migratory birds recorded from the Brahmaputra 11 Finn’s Weaver Ploceus megarhynchus VU Valley, many belong to the threatened category. Most notable among these threatened birds are the critically endangered Bengal florican (Houbaropsis bengalensis), white- bellied heron (Ardea insignis), Baer’s pochard (Aythya baeri), spoon-billed sandpiper Encroachment is one of the major threats to the Brahmaputra floodplains23. Grasslands (Eurynorhynchus pygmeus), Indian vulture (Gyps indicus), slender-billed vulture (Gyps outside protected areas are currently under great threat owing to rise in human tenuirostris) and white-rumped vulture (Gyps bengalensis). Among the Endangered population throughout the Brahmaputra floodplains. Protected areas such as Dibru- category most notable are white-winged duck (Asarcornis scutulata), oriental white Saikhowa National Park are heavily disturbed by humans and overgrazing by livestock24. stork (Ciconia boyciana), greater adjutant-stork (Leptoptilos dubius) and masked 122 123 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION From left to right: Long-tailed broadbill (Psarisomus dalhousiae); Crimson sunbird (Aethopyga siparaja); Red-billed leiothrix (Leiothrix lutea) finfoot (Heliopais personatus). Vulnerable birds from this region include Dalmatian Fisheries and aquatic biodiversity pelican (Pelecanus crispus), lesser adjutant stork (Leptoptilos javanicus) and great knot (Calidris tenuirostris). Apart from these, black-bellied tern (Sterna acuticauda), black- S.P. Biswas headed ibis (Threskiornis melanocephalus), black-necked stork (Ephippiorhynchus asiaticus), Blyth’s kingfisher (Alcedo Hercules) and ferruginous pochard (Aythya nyroca) Riverine Biota all belong to the Near Threatened category. Brahmaputra basin is made up of alluvial soil, with high percentages of sand and silt. The riverbank is almost perpendicular in most of the 640 kilometer stretches Deforestation in the Brahmaputra watershed has resulted in higher siltation and soil and highly prone to erosion. Based on the topography of the Brahmaputra river erosion often leading to flash floods in downstream habitats causing huge loss to biota basin, fish habitats and their faunal types are as follows: - (I) Bedrock reaches (fast (including birds) thriving therein. Hunting and poisoning of birds are other major flowing river): Rapid streams having relatively steep gradient and rocky bed that threats for both migratory and resident avifauna of this area. Thus, habitat loss, habitat harbour small fish genera like Amblyceps, Barilius, Danio, Garra, Glyptothorax alteration, restricted geographic range, pollution, climate change, hunting and various and Hara; (II) Step-pool (upstream pools): Sluggish and deeper parts of upland diseases are affecting the birds of this region negatively27. streams. Fishes like Bangana dero, Labeo pangusia, Neolissocheilus hexagonolepis, Raiamas bola, Tor spp., are dominant here. (III) Regime reaches (river meandering The Wild Life (Protection) Act 1972 of India prohibits hunting of water-birds under & confluence): The eddy counter-current system at the junction of two rivers is Schedule IV. Also, birds like white-bellied heron, oriental white stork, pink-headed an ideal place for fish assemblages. The confluences are also the passageways duck, white-winged wood duck are protected under Schedule I under the same act that for upstream fish migration. Similarly, the channel meanderings offer suitable prohibits killing or capturing them. However, these laws need to be enforced without home for a large variety of fish species; (IV) Braided reaches (adjoining prejudice to save the bird population. Habitat protection is another excellent approach floodplain lakes): Beels are weed infested shallow water bodies temporarily or to conserve wildlife and the Brahmaputra valley semi-evergreen forests ecoregion has permanently connected with the main river. (V) Plane-bed reaches (open river): been included in the 200 global priority ecoregions identified by WWF in the year Large sized species such as Sperata, Bagarius, Chitala, Pangasius, Silonia and 2000. To conserve the rich biodiversity of this region a number of protected areas other giant aquatic fauna like Platanista and Nilssonia (Trionix ) are mainly have been designated of which Kaziranga National Park is also a ‘World Heritage Site’. encountered in the open river; (VI) Ephemeral streams: These streams are ‘alive’ Brahmaputra valley with its enormous avian diversity can be easily considered a birds during rainy months. Varieties of small and medium sized fish are encountered; paradise, however, it is obvious that this region needs proper scientific management (VII) Seasonal water bodies: Low lying paddy fields, derelict ponds, swamps and strategies including conservation education and awareness for long-term sustenance. road-side nallahs (depressions) are also ‘temporary homes’ for a variety of small 124 125 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION fish species. The Brahmaputra system shares its fish resources with the Indo- Maguri beel is one of the largest floodplain lakes in upper Brahmaputra basin located Gangetic plain gene pool and to a lesser extent with the Myanmar and south in the periphery of Dibru-Saikhowa National Park in Tinsukia district, Assam. Chinese fauna. Maguri, an important source of capture fisheries, covers an area of 167.4 hectares at full storage level. The ecology and faunal assemblage of the wetland is almost entirely Biota of Riparian Ecotones regulated by rainfall and combined discharge of rivers Dibru and Lohit. Altogether Over 3,500 floodplain lakes or beels, including both tectonic (closed type) and ox- 110 fish species, mostly dominated by air breathing forms and also a good number bow lakes (open type) scattered throughout the Brahmaputra valley receive regular of ornamental and endemic species like Badis assamensis, Channa aurantimaculata, flood pulses during monsoon. Almost all types of riverine fish including Indian major C. barca, C. bleheri, C. stewartii and Mystus dibrugarensis have been recorded from carps depend on riparian ecotones for spawning. This lateral migration of spawning this wetland. It is also a rich habitat for chelonians and avian fauna. Over 500 avian fish alters the species composition of floodplain lakes during rainy months. Trophic species including a large number of migratory birds in the locality attracts a large structure is typically present from surface dwelling to typical substrate dwelling species number of tourists every year. The beels constitute like Glossogobius giuris to mud-dwellers like Monopterus cuchia or burrower like Wetlands are also rich in benthic fauna found attached with aquatic macrophytes a major fishery Channa barca. Fish species may be grouped into five habitat guilds, such as surface or sediments as nymphs or larvae. Two insect species (Cybistertri punctatus and resource of Assam water guilds, column dwellers, bottom dwellers, marginal dwellers and mud dwellers. Lethocerus indicus) and several ubiquitous mollusc species like Lamellidens corrianus, and have provided Further, wetland fish may also be categorized as: (a) food fish; (b) ornamental; (c) L. marginalis, Corbicula assamensis, C. striatal, Brotia costula, Bellamya bengalensis, livelihood support larvicidal and (d) medicinal. Flood water rejuvenates the beel by providing fresh water Tarebia lineate are used as non-conventional food as well as for medicinal purposes to thousands of and nutrients, auto stocking of fish as well as flushing out of floating macrophytes by indigenous people. Further, rare and endemic mollusc species such as Solenaia riparian fisher mainly water hyacinth. The common fish biota of beels and seasonal water bodies soleniformis, Parreysia spp. and Pseudodon spp., have also been recorded from wetlands folks for centuries are Amblypharyngodon, Botia, Esomus, Channa, Crossocheilus, Danio, Glossogobius, and slow moving streams of upper Brahmaputra basin. Leiodon, Macrognathus, Pethia, Puntius, Rasbora, Salmophasia, Trichogaster and Xenentodon. The beels constitute a major fishery resource of Assam and have provided Conclusion livelihood support to thousands of riparian fisher folks for centuries. About 200 fish species reported in the mid-twentieth century from the Brahmaputra 126 127 THE RESTLESS RIVER valley have now disappeared especially between Saikhowaghat and Dhansirimukh. High fishing pressure and wanton killing of gravid and juveniles by using explosives and chemicals as well as the jeng fishing (a local destructive fishing technique) have been identified as major threats to the fish biodiversity. Deforestation in the catchment area, construction of roads and embankments and blockade of feeder channels of floodplain lakes have contributed to the reduction of habitat complexity. Excessive boulder and sand excavation from the riverbed also alter the micro-habitats of many hill-stream fish species. A comprehensive study on the entire Brahmaputra basin must be carried out to assess anthropogenic and environmental stresses on instream and also riparian biota so that effective policies for river management can be formulated to maintain environmental flow for sustenance of existing riverine biota as well as dependent economy and livelihoods of riparian people. d Gangetic dolphin Sanjay Das S.P. Biswas OUT OF the four freshwater dolphins found around the globe, the one which is found The dolphin is the keystone species in a riverine ecosystem. It maintains the ecosystem The Gangetic in the Ganga-Brahmaputra-Meghna system is known by a plethora of names: Sus, equilibrium by controlling the population of secondary consumers. In fact, the dolphin is the Shushuk, Xihu in Hindi, Bengali and Assamese respectively. To the scientific community presence of dolphins is a clear indication of the ‘good health’ of a river. Dolphins were national aquatic this rare cetacean mammal is- Platanista gangetica gangetica. once abundant in the Brahmaputra river but the population came down drastically animal of India. in the eighties primarily due to intentional killing of dolphins for their oil which The presence The Gangetic dolphin is the national aquatic animal of India. It has a robust fish-like is believed to be a master drug against various ailments. Dolphin oil was also used of dolphins is a body and may attain 2 meters length and weigh about 100 kilograms or more. Calves for catching cat fishes especially Clupisoma garua. People were ignorant about the clear indication and young dolphins are dark colored but as they grow, the body colour changes importance of dolphins in a riverine ecosystem. In one particular instance, more than of the ‘good and the adults are mostly slate grey. Gangetic dolphins are virtually blind but are 50 dolphins were killed, and their body oil extracted by some professional killers at health’ of a river champion swimmers and movement even in highly turbid water is possible with the Narain Dahr, upstream of the Barak (Meghna river system) in 1985-86. This led to a help of a sonar system (echolocation) located on the forehead (melon). Gangetic virtual extinction of dolphins from the Barak River in southern Assam. At present only dolphins prefer sandy riverbeds, moderate water currents, and are often encountered ‘fragmented populations’ of dolphins can be sighted in certain pockets in protected in small groups of 3 or 4 in relatively deeper portions of the river (depth of more than areas like Dibru-Saikhowa National Park, river Subansiri, Kaziranga National Park and 3 meters), usually at a river confluence and also at river meanders during dry months. River Kulsi in the Brahmaputra valley. The long, pointed rostrum bears a series of homodont teeth meant for grasping the prey, mostly fish. Continuous widening and aggradations of the river due to bank erosion, high rate of siltation and loss of prey base in the habitat are major threats for the survival of Dolphins perform all their metabolic activities under water, except breathing. The dolphins. High rate of siltation has reduced the depth of the river especially ‘deep pools’ mean time between two surfacing has been recorded as 38 to 45 seconds for adults. by 30 percent in the last four decades and this is the prime reason for the shrinkage They roll over rather quietly exposing the forehead and part of the back for a second or of dolphin habitats in the upper reaches of the Brahmaputra. Fortunately, the number so. The infants are very playful, surface more frequently (15 to 20 seconds between two of Gangetic dolphins in the central and lower reaches of the Brahmaputra has shown intervals) and often jump over the water. an increasing trend due to continuous efforts by conservation groups in the last two decades. 128 129 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION black in colour with white eyebrows and adult females are copper tanned in colour. Hoolock gibbon Neonates are milky white in colour. Juveniles of both the sexes are black with white eyebrows. Females turn gray to tan colour in sub-adult stage, but males retain the black Dilip Chetry colour till adulthood. There is no marked size variation between males and females. Some morphological differences are there between the two species. Females attain WESTERN HOOLOCK gibbon (Hoolock hoolock) and Eastern Hoolock gibbon (Hoolock sexual maturity at the age of 6 to 8 years and the age for sexual maturity in males is leuconedys) are two charismatic primates that represent the ape group in India. Their 7 years. Estimated gestation period is 183 to 225 days and inter-birth interval is 2 to distribution in India is restricted to the southern bank of the Dibang–Brahmaputra 3 years. The gibbon is our close living relative and wild gibbons share 95 percent of river system in the northeastern states of India excluding Sikkim. The Eastern their genetic material with us. Gibbons play a vital role in the regeneration of forests as Hoolock gibbon occurs only in the Siang basin and in Assam. Extremely elusive, active seed dispersers. the gibbons inhabit tropical wet evergreen, tropical semi-evergreen and sub-tropical moist deciduous forests. Being exclusively arboreal, Hoolock gibbons depend on the The principal threats to gibbons in Assam are massive habitat loss, intensive habitat high canopy coverage in their habitats. They are diurnal and exhibit extreme form of fragmentation, jhum cultivation and hunting. Loss of habitat is a result of wanton brachiating skill. Fruit is the staple food of frugivore Hoolock gibbons. They live in destruction of forests, encroachment, agro-expansion, and development projects. monogamous families and an ideal Hoolock gibbon family has one adult male, one Along with habitat loss, fragmentation of habitats is becoming another major threat to adult female and one to four offspring. The average group size is three. Each gibbon gibbons. Reducing cycles of traditional jhum cultivation has also threatened gibbons Hunting of family maintains its own territory through their trademark duet song. Adult males are by creating secondary forests. Hunting of gibbons as food, for traditional medicine, gibbons as food, sports, and ornaments is also a common custom among many tribes. for traditional medicine, sports, In the Indian Wildlife Protection Act, 1972, both species of Hoolock gibbons are and ornaments listed as Schedule I species. According to the IUCN red list of 2019, Western Hoolock is also a common gibbon is endangered and Eastern Hoolock gibbon is vulnerable. The Gibbon Wildlife custom among Sanctuary in Jorhat district of Assam is the only protected habitat in the country to many tribes be named after a primate species. Thirteen protected habitats in Assam support the Western Hoolock gibbon. Only three reserve forests in Sadiya harbour protect the eastern Hoolock gibbon in Assam. Implementation of the slogan “Save Forest, Save Gibbon” in its true sense can only ensure long-term conservation of gibbons and their habitats in Assam. d Golden langur Gibbons play a vital Rekha Chetry role in the regeneration THE GOLDEN langur (Trachypithecus geei) is a highly attractive arboreal primate of forests as discovered in 1953. It is endemic to northwest Assam in India and neighbouring active seed Bhutan. In India, its distribution is limited to an area bounded by the river Manas Illustration by Tania Zakir dispersers in the east, Sankosh in the west and the Brahmaputra in the south. In India they are primarily inhabitants of wet evergreen forests and semi-evergreen forests. Sal (Shorea robusta) dominated forests and secondary forests also support them. The diurnal golden langurs spend 99 percent of their active time in trees exploring the top and middle strata of forests, though in degraded habitats they descend to the ground. 130 131 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Highly social golden langurs live in diverse social frameworks such as uni male–multi Golden langurs are seasonal breeders and June to January is the breeding season. The female troop or society, bi male-multi female troop, multi male-multi female society, typical golden coat colour of the species can be observed only during the breeding all male bands or societies and lone males. Uni male–multi female troops are more season. The estimated gestation period is 168 to 180 days, and inter-birth interval is common and stable. Average troop size varies in different habitats and generally ranges two years. January to June is the birthing season. Male golden langurs attain sexual from 2 to 12 individuals. Inter-individual bonding between the troop members is very maturity at 5 to7 years, while the age of sexual maturity for the female is four years. strong which is the key to their peaceful societies. The golden langur is a Schedule-I species in the Indian Wildlife (protection) act, 1972, and an endangered species in the IUCN Red list (2020). From 2016 to 2020, it has been The major activities of golden langurs are locomotion, resting, feeding, and monitoring. in the IUCN list of top 25 most endangered primate species of the globe. Chakrashila Other activities include grooming and playing. Golden langurs are folivorous and leaves Wildlife Sanctuary and Manas National Park are the only protected habitats for golden contribute 60 percent or more of their daily diet. Fruits, seeds, flowers and flower buds, langur in India. Habitat destruction and fragmentation are the most severe threats to stem cortex, twigs, bamboo shoots are other food items. Gum feeding, soil feeding, golden langurs in Assam. Fatalities due to electrocution, dog predation and vehicular algae feeding, insect feeding, snail feeding have also been observed. More than 200 accidents are emerging threats. We the people of Assam should do our best for the species of food plants have been identified from different habitats in Assam. Langurs conservation of golden langur which is a part of our rich natural heritage. spend their nights on selective tall trees to avoid predators. d From 2016 to 2020, it has been Greater one-horned rhino in the IUCN list of top 25 most Bibhab Kumar Talukdar endangered primate species EVERY RIVER in this world carries stories of culture and biodiversity of which humans The alluvial of the globe are an integral part. The alluvial floodplain grassland ecosystems of the Brahmaputra floodplain provide an excellent habitat for the greater one horned rhino (Rhinoceros unicornis). grassland The rhino represents the floodplain ecosystem of the Brahmaputra. For Assamese ecosystems people, the rhino is the epitome of the conservation movement in Assam, reflecting the of the success of the conservation efforts which began early in the nineteenth century, when Brahmaputra it was assumed that the Kaziranga area in Assam had only about a dozen rhinos left. provide an excellent The rhino has been a conservation dependent species since early nineteenth century habitat for the because of the threats from poaching and destruction of grassland habitats. The greater one conservation of rhinos in early nineteenth century got a boon through the declaration horned rhino of key rhino habitats in Assam as protected areas. The first sincere efforts to protect the estimated population of a dozen rhinos in Kaziranga was initiated in the year 1905. Kaziranga, Manas and Laokhowa were finally declared as Game Reserves in the year 1908. In the year 1968, the Assam Government realized the need to convert the Kaziranga Wildlife Sanctuary into a national park and began making efforts to enact the Assam National Park Act, which came into effect in 1969. In January 1974, in pursuance of the Assam National Park Act 1968, the Kaziranga was declared as the first Illustration by Tania Zakir National Park covering an area of about 430 square kilometers. Due to proactive conservation initiatives, Assam currently (in year 2020) has about 2,650 rhinos. This conservation success has been achieved due to the dedicated work of the forest officials, including frontline wildlife staff working hard to conserve and protect 132 133 THE RESTLESS RIVER The rhino conservation effort is one of the biggest conservation success stories of India. From just a dozen rhinos left in the wild in early nineteenth century, today there are more 2650 rhinos! 134 135 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION the rhino and their habitats despite diverse challenges. Support and cooperation is being Amphibian and reptile diversity rendered by local communities, complimentary support is being rendered by district administration and Assam police and also by various non-government organisations. M Firoz Ahmed The media also proactively assisted in spreading conservation awareness to reach out to diverse audiences with regards to rhino conservation. The rhino conservation success THE AMPHIBIANS and reptiles are one of the poorly understood groups of vertebrates is the pride of Assam. across the globe. Our understanding about these groups in many areas, bestowed d with high biological diversity has just got momentum. The hills of northeast India and the eastern Himalayas represent a complex of ecosystems of extraordinarily rich biodiversity, resulting from the meeting of three biogeographic regions of the world: Indian, Indo-Chinese, and Indo-Malayan. The Brahmaputra river traversing through the hills and plains of the region for millions of years, continues to influence all forms of life. The unique position, climate and physiography have laid the foundation for proliferation of a variety of ecosystems that raised a diverse biota with high level of endemism. The Himalayas, the topography, the monsoon, the forests, and the river systems, all Once thought together, contributed to the evolution of the region as a hotspot for amphibians and extinct in reptiles: 146 species of amphibians and 180 species of reptiles are recorded in this the wild, the region. This number is only going to increase as explorers and scientists have started black softshell to take more effort to understand their diversity only recently. Positioned next to the turtle lives in Tropic of Cancer, with an altitudinal range from 20 meters to 5,000 meters above sea the lakes and level, the region houses a striking range of habitats, from tropical floodplains and forests networked to alpine meadows and forests, through vast subtropical humid forests as altitude rises channel from south to north. This unique mix of ecosystems is intricately complex. systems of the Brahmaputra Northeast India is characterized by a hot, wet summer, and a cool, usually dry winter. and its major Temperature varies from subzero to maximum 38 degrees centigrade. Annual average tributaries rainfall is above 2,000 millimeters which varies from less than 1,000 millimeters in parts of central Assam to more than 12,000 millimeters in parts of the southern Meghalaya plateau such as in Cherrapunjee and Mawsynram. Understanding reasons for the high diversity of herpetofauna in the northeast region of India can be complex but not impossible. As the Ganges drains into Bangladesh territory and shares the same floodplains as the Brahmaputra, northeast India receives several mainland Indian species such as gharial Gavialis gangeticus, Gangetic softshell turtle Nilssonia gangeticus, Indian bull frog Hoplobatrachus tigerinus and Polypedates taeniatus. Even further, the floodplain connects the region to an African genera of tree frog, Chiromantis sp. found in the east and northeast of India. Asian elephant As we move upstream of the Brahmaputra, the diversity of species of herpetofauna (Elephas maximus indicus) also starts going up. There are as many as 25 species of amphibians and 95 species Red jungle fowl of reptiles found in the floodplains itself. Once thought extinct in the wild, the black (Gallus gallus) softshell turtle Nilssonia nigricans lives in the lakes and networked channel systems of Wild water buffalo the Brahmaputra and its major tributaries. (Bubalus arnee) 136 137 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Diamond- backed lizard (Sitana) Indian bullfrog Just above the floodplains up to the base of the hills, a number of unique and endemic (Hoplobatrachus species of amphibians are found in the region, such as Orang sticky frog Kalophrynus tigerinus) orangensis and Assamese baloon frog Kaloula assamensis. This is the transition zone from floodplains to the hills, where the endemic Assam roof turtle Pangshura sylhetensis, inhabits. Further up, in the lower hills, two species of turtles and tortoises, Asian brown tortoise Manouria emys and Malayan box turtle Cuora mouhotii, indicative of their names, connects the region to the Malaya and the rest of Southeast Asia, bringing in more complexity to its diversity. The herpetological diversity in the northeast hills increases with increasing altitudes up to the mid elevation before it goes down near the snow line. The hills thus also connect Asian to several species of Malayan origin that occur in Southeast Asia, the reason being the roofed turtle similarity in habitats and ecosystems extending to Southeast Asia over Myanmar and (Pangshura Thailand to peninsular Malaysia. sylhetensis) A unique species of amphibia, Jerdon’s tree frog Nasutixalus jerdonii occurs in the subtropical broadleaf forests in the hills of northeast India and southeast Asia that lives in the holes of trees that contain small quantities of water. As life is hard in such an uncommon habitat, particularly for a tadpole confined to such a narrow space without mobility and food resources, the mother comes to their rescue. The female visits such breeding tree holes regularly and deposits unfertilized eggs for 138 139 THE RESTLESS RIVER The largest and longest venomous snake in the world, the King cobra King Cobra is (Ophiophagus the unique snake hannah) species where the females lay eggs in nests her tadpoles on which they feed and grow to miniature frogs one day to explore the The amphibian Scutiger genera are found to occur in the high Himalayas that may made with vibrant world outside. seem inhospitable for them, between 3,000 and 4,000 meters above sea level. It might fallen leaves be possible that they were separated by the rising Himalayas millions of years ago or and guard them Similarly, the forest floors of the tropical forests of northeast India, often with thick they speciated on both the north and south flank of the Himalayas using the Yarlung- until the eggs leaflitters, is home to many species of herpetofauna. The largest and longest venomous Tsangpo-Siang as a biological corridor after the rise of the Himalayas. hatch snake in the world, the King Cobra Ophiophagus hannah occurs widely in the moist evergreen forests. This is the unique snake species where the females lay eggs in nests The Brahmaputra basin in northeast India has witnessed human induced local made with fallen leaves and guard them until the eggs hatch. extinctions of at least two species of reptiles in recent times: the mugger Crocodylus palustris and the gharial Gavialis gangeticus. The mugger was extirpated much earlier, Further upstream of the Brahmaputra river, as it becomes narrower and powerful, it is the gharial followed more recently in the nineteen seventies. Human intolerance known by the name of Siang, and creates a unique topography in the Himalayas. It is towards ‘dangerous’ crocodilians was the primary reason for extirpation of these giant where the Himalayas are cut deep by the Tsangpo and Siang at an altitude of 550 meters reptiles since human occupation of the river basins began overlapping their habitats in at the Xizang-India border with a sharp fall from 2,950 meters near Nyingchi in Xizang. the mid-twentieth century. This transition of Tsangpo through the ‘Great Bends’ creates a pass for several species from Tibet and south China into India using the Himalayan foothills as a conduit. Medo Many species of amphibians and reptiles are endemic to this region or with restricted pit viper Trimerusurus medoensis, and Cross barred treefrog Rhacophorus translineatus range. Such species face high threat to extinction than those widely distributed. However, are two best examples of Indo-Chinese cross over. limited information on distribution of such species hampers diligent evaluation of their conservation status. Among the known species of the northeast region of India, nine While the Himalayas act as a barrier for most terrestrial species between India and species of amphibians, about 6 percent of known species, and 29 species of reptiles, about the Tibetan plateau, some amphibians (Scutiger sp.) still exist across the Himalayas. 16 percent of known species are threatened as per the IUCN red list. 140 141 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION The amphibians and reptiles are known indicators of environmental changes in an MANAS BASIN ecosystem given their high sensitivity to their surrounding environment. Humans have always benefited by their presence. For example, reptiles control the rodent Wetlands of Bhutan population. However, herpetofauna are threatened today due to our own actions leading to diminishing the ecosystem services over generations. This is very prominent, Karma Chopel Ghongsar particularly, where habitats have been converted into agriculture and monocropping by removing many species living there. Pollution of air, water, and soil through BHUTAN HAS a number of wetlands in the form of glacial lakes, marshes, swamps, negative human actions on ecosystems is another major threat to the herpetofauna. and ponds which also have particular biological, spiritual and socio-cultural functions. More importantly, unplanned, and overoptimistic river valley development projects in Wetlands in Bhutan are under increasing pressure from unplanned development, the Brahmaputra basin is a serious conservation concern to amphibians and reptiles. disturbances and lack of awareness among the general public leading to the loss of integrity of the wetland ecosystem. Even though there is no aggregated data to make an unambiguous demonstration, there is a strong perception, backed by informal reporting, that Bhutan is experiencing a drying up of streams and creeks with the disappearance of their associated marshes and swamps. Wetlands support high biological diversity including migratory birds and other flora Culturally and fauna. They are also important for water storage and release which sustains the these wetlands perpetual flow in our rivers that is crucial for our hydropower generation. Culturally and lakes are these wetlands and lakes are revered as sacred sites and are associated strongly with revered as the traditional belief systems and lifestyles. It is reported that 104 bird species inhabit sacred sites and these freshwater ecosystems in Bhutan and many other aquatic plant and animal are associated The critically species such as Rununculus trichophyllus, Hydrilla verticillate, Potamogeton crispus, strongly with endangered R. Tricuspis, Acorus calamus, Acorus grmineus, Shoenoplectus juncoides, Typhus spp., the traditional Elongated Phragmites spp., Equisetum spp., Aconogonum alpinum, Carex spp., Juncus spp. and belief systems tortoise Salix sp. Similarly, large predators such as Panthera tigris tigris, Panthera pardus, and lifestyles (Indotestudo Panthera uncia, and smaller predators such as Neofelis nebulosa, Cuon alpinus, and elongata) Felis bengalensis come to drink water and stalk prey species at water sources. Other mammals associated with wetland ecosystems include Platanista gangetica Lutra lutra, Lutrogale perspicillata, Bubalus arnee, Felis viverrinus, Herpestes urva, Nectogale elegans, Chimarrogale himalayica. While superior technology has brought down cost of solar power production globally, hydropower is still being promoted with misinformation as profitable and ecofriendly in The Coleoptera species Hydraena karmai was discovered from a puddle in a place the upper Brahmaputra basin areas in northeast India. Ecological disaster is inevitable called Zomyuethang behind Punakha Dzong. This species was never known to science from such hydropower dams and reservoirs, with far reaching consequences. A dam before. Several new species of Ephemeroptera (may flies), Plecoptera (stone flies) on a river not only kills the living river, but it also inundates a large area which includes and Trichoptera (caddis flies) EPT taxa were also discovered from the water bodies habitats for endemic, rare, and threatened species of herpetofauna or displacement of in Bhutan in a few weeks of sampling and assessment from Paro, Thimphu, Tsirang individuals living there, causing stress in the ecosystem. and Sarpang Dzongkhags (EU funded Assessment System to Evaluate the Ecological Status of Rivers in the Hindu Kush-Himalayan Region (ASSESS HKH) project led by Policies and planning must be aggressively changed to make the world more livable the author). The impacts of climate change compounded by the ad hoc developmental and sustainable for our future generations. This is more so in the light of climate activities will wipe these newly discovered species and others even before they are change events. Value of ecosystem and nature needs to be part of our economic and discovered, signaling the importance and the need to address the impacts of climate development agenda to ensure that we grow sustainably. change and ad hoc developmental activities with great urgency. d 142 143 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION The relict species of dragon fly larvae, Epiophlebia laidlawi was found in the headwater of Drey Chhu stream above Dechencholing, Thimphu and in Lamchela Chhu stream in White-bellied heron Chendebji, Trongsa. This species is categorized as rare and highly threatened and the only other places where it is ever found to this day is in eastern Japan and Nepal. This Indra P Acharja species is an indicator of the pristine water quality. THE WHITE-BELLIED heron (Ardea insignis) is a large wader species of family Ardeidae, order Pelecaniformes, found in freshwater ecosystems of the Himalayas. Historically known to be found across South Asia, it is now one of the rarest birds in the world, having disappeared from most of its historical range including Nepal and Karma Chopel Ghongsar Bangladesh. The global estimated population is between 49 and 250 adults according to IUCN data, however fewer than 60 individuals are known to live in the wilds of Bhutan, Northeast India, China, and Myanmar. There are five actively breeding pairs The White- in Bhutan and are the only currently known breeding population in the world. The bellied heron is heron is categorized as critically endangered under the IUCN Red List of threatened now one of the species since 2007 and the species is also protected under respective laws in all the rarest birds in Hydraena Karmai (left picture) found only in Bhutan; Epiophlebia laidlawi (right) range countries. the world indicator of pristine water quality. Bhutan acceded to the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands on 7 May 2012. Currently Bhutan has three Ramsar sites: 1. Bumdeling Wildlife Sanctuary, Tashiyangtse; 142 ha; 27°40’23”N 091°26’29”E. This glacial valley in the northeast Bhutan was a rice producing area. At least 74 bird species including the endangered black necked cranes (Grus nigricollis) inhabit this site. Other endangered species recorded at the site include the snow leopard (Panthera unica), tiger (Panthera tigris tigris), Asiatic wild dog (Cuon alpines primaevus) and Himalayan musk deer (Moschus leucogaster). 2. Khotokha in Wangdue District with an area 114 ha; 27°25’55”N 89°59’33”E, is located west of the Black Mountain range. Khotokha wetland is one of the sources for the tributaries of the Punatsang Chhu, and also provides drinking water and irrigation water for potato farms. The subalpine shrub marsh, consisting of peat bogs and fens, is one of the last remaining places in Bhutan where summer-winter migrations of farmers are practiced. The black necked crane along with other endangered species such as the Himalayan musk deer (Moschus leucogaster) and the Asiatic wild dog (Cuon alpines primaevus) inhabit this site. 3. The Gangtey-Phobji is the third and largest wetland in Bhutan of international importance. This site lies in a wide glacial valley with scenic beauty and clear streams in the valley such as Nakey Chhu, and Khewang Chhu. This site comprises of rich ecosystems and provides prime winter habitat for up to 300 black necked cranes (Grus nigricollis), and other globally threatened species such as the endangered red panda (Ailurus fulgens) and tiger (Panthera tigris tigris), and the vulnerable sambar (Cervus unicolor). d 144 145 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION The white-bellied heron is the second largest heron standing up to 130 centimeters Fish diversity tall with a wingspan of nearly 2 meters and weighs up to 5 kilograms. The heron has a dark greyish body with contrasting white belly and vent, white-streaked scapulars, D B Gurung fore neck, and upper breast with prominent crest and long sharply pointed black bill with slight serration on the tip of the lower mandible. Juveniles are darker than adults, Ichthyology in Bhutan with browner-tinged vent, the neck is more streaked, the plumes are smaller, and the Bhutan is rich in freshwater biodiversity. Bhutan has four major river systems bill is shorter and greyish in colour. White-bellied herons are sexually monomorphic viz. Amochhu (Toorsa), Wangchhu (Raidak), Punatsangchhu (Sankosh), and and differentiating sexes visually is almost impossible. During breeding seasons, the Drangmechhu-Mangdechhu (Manas)28. There are 2,674 glacial lakes in Bhutan and the plumage turns light grey with a whitish neck and crest. largest glacier has an area of 36 square kilometers and is located in the Punatsangchhu basin29. Besides rivers, lakes and glaciers, Bhutan also has 3,027 high altitude wetlands The white-bellied heron is a rare, elusive, and highly sensitive piscivore species, including supra-snow lakes30. inhabiting freshwater rivers, streams, lakes, and wetlands up to 2000 meters altitude. The herons forage in silent open waters by walking along the shallow banks of up to The National Research Centre for Riverine and Lake Fisheries of the Department of 60 centimeters depth with low to medium riffle. They are non-migratory but move up Livestock of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forests has prepared a checklist of 104 to 200 kilometers from one feeding locale to another looking for food during seasons species from the Amochhu, Wangchhu and Punatsangchhu river basins of western when food is scarce. Generally, they are solitary, but groups of up to 4 are seen during Bhutan31. However, since ichthyology is a new science in Bhutan, many of these species Bhutan is rich breeding seasons and up to 6 are seen before juveniles attain independence. They are are identified up to the genus taxa only. in freshwater There are only very silent and only make loud croaking calls; auk auk auk urrrrrr, during courtship biodiversity. five actively or when alerted. Threats to Water Resources and Fish Conservation About 51.44 breeding pairs About 51.44 percent of the country’s geographical area has been declared as Protected percent of in Bhutan Unlike many other heron species which breed in colonies, the white-bellied heron Areas which include National Parks, Wildlife Sanctuaries, Strict Nature Reserve, the country’s and are the breeds in solitude. Generally, the breeding season begins from January and juveniles and Biological Corridors32. It is perhaps assumed that the protected area system takes geographical only currently fledge by end of June, but sometimes it prolongs through July or August. They build care of the aquatic biodiversity and aquatic ecosystems per se, but this is not the case. area has been known breeding simple platform nests of dried twigs and small branches without foliage on tall trees Climate change, hydropower dams, farm road construction, mining, and introduced declared as population in with open canopy at a height of 10 to 30 meters, both on conifer and broadleaved and invasive species are some of the major conservation threats for native fish species. Protected Areas the world species, within 10 to 100 meters from the nearest waterbodies, preferably on slopes with ample open space and good exposure to sun, at an altitude of 200 to 1,500 meters. Hydropower projects The average clutch size is three, the incubation period is 30 to 33 days, the average The construction of hydropower projects results in blocking fish migration, habitat brood size is of two and nestlings fledge 70 to 75 days after hatching. Juveniles reach fragmentation, river-bed siltation and other environmental degradation around the independence and leave their parents after 2 to 3 months of fledging. dam construction site. Construction of fish ladder and lifts may not be the best options when the minimum flow of the river is not maintained below the dams for most part The distribution range of the white-bellied heron has shrunk by 90 percent over the of the year once the power plants start operating. century. The extremely low and shrinking population across the region is attributed to human exploitation of river systems and disturbance in core foraging and breeding Introduced and invasive species habitats. The small gene pool with a few breeding pairs restricted to small geographical In 1940, the Scottish origin Brown trout ova were transported to Darjeeling from range is of immediate concern. The conversion of sections of rivers or tributaries or Kashmir, from which some developing fry were transported to Bhutan, reared in Haa entire rivers to hydroelectric dam regimes is the single biggest threat to the white- hatchery and the fingerlings released in Haachhu river in 194133. In Bhutan, so far there bellied heron and its habitat across the range. Most of the habitats are very susceptible is no assessment on the impact of introduced species on the native species. However, to disturbances both man-made and natural, making the species highly vulnerable to field observations indicate that the fingerlings of native species are rarely found in areas extinction. The call to save this species from extinction is urgent and the only way is where Brown trout has established successfully. to save our rivers. Besides Brown trout, many species of fish are introduced through aquaculture, fish d market, aquarium trade and socio-religious practice called Tsethar – live release34,35. Clarias gariepinus Burchell is one such species which has established in Amochhu 146 147 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Endangered fauna of the River basin Illustrations by Tania Zakir Western Hoolock Gibbon (Hoolock hoolock) Golden Langur (Trachypithecus geei) Masked Finfoot (Heliopais personatus) Greater Adjutant (Leptoptilos dubius) Gangetic River Dolphin (Platanista gangetica) Golden Mahseer (Tor putitora) Fishing Cat (Prionailurus viverrinus) Clouded Leopard (Neofelis nebulosa) 148 149 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION River, bordering the Indian state of West Bengal36. This fish primarily feeds on the topographical features, combined with high humidity have created diverse habitats and fingerlings of native species. Oreochromis niloticus (Linnaeus), Cyprinus carpio novel niches conducive for various species of flora and fauna41. Linneaus, Hypophthalmichthys molitrix (Valenciennes), Hypophthalmichthys nobilis (Richardson), Ctenopharyngodon idella (Valenciennes), Cirrhinus mrigala (Hamilton), A total of 579 bird species belonging to 57 families and 17 orders have been recorded in Catla catla (Hamilton), Labeo rohita (Hamilton), and Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum) Sikkim, which is about 44 percent of all the birds found in India42. Although there are are other species introduced in aquaculture in Bhutan. Among these species, the records of collection of birds dating back to the middle of the eighteenth century during Rainbow trout (O. mykiss) has the potential to become an invasive species. Additionally, British expeditions, the first systematic study on birds of Sikkim was undertaken by Salim there are also some aquarium species appearing in the country for which there is Ali which led to the publication in 1962 of the book “Birds of Sikkim”43. Sikkim has a no account. number of wetlands and, hence, bird species dependent on water bodies (either aquatic or depending on water for some activities) are well represented. A majority of the aquatic Road construction and mining birds are migratory species, and some species use Sikkim as stop-over during migration. Sub-standard farm road construction has resulted in downstream sedimentation, soil Careless erosion, changes in hydrological characteristics, increased surface runoff, deforestation, There are 22 species of birds restricted to Eastern Himalaya Endemic Bird Area out disposal of and loss of biodiversity37. Careless disposal of excavated road materials often results in of which 12 species are found in Sikkim. The endemic species are Tragopan blythii, excavated muddy river water causing considerable damage to aquatic biodiversity. Arborophila mandellii, Harpactes wardii, Sphenocichla humei, Spelaeornis caudatus, road materials Babax waddellii, Certhia discolor, Brachypteryx hyperythra, Actinodura nipalensis, Recent studies often results in The environmental costs of mining include mud slides, sedimentation downstream, soil Tickellia hodgsoni, Phylloscopus cantator and Yuhina bakeri. Similarly, 38 bird species are have highlighted muddy river erosion, and water pollution besides noise and air pollution38. In southern Bhutan, during listed in the IUCN red list of threatened species of which fourteen are Vulnerable, two are the importance water causing monsoon, few overburden slips from the mines have been noted in blocking of river and Endangered (Falco cherrug and Aquila nipalensis), six are Critically Endangered (Aythya of indigenous considerable stream courses temporarily. Therefore, priority should be given to maintaining certain baeri, Gyps indicus, Sarcogyps calvus, Gyps bengalensis, Emberiza aureola and Ketupa farming systems damage environmental standards in the construction of farm roads and mining operations. zeylonensis) and sixteen are Near Threatened44. Seven species of birds found are listed in for conservation to aquatic Appendix I and five species are listed in Appendix II of the Convention on International of birds in the biodiversity Low priority species Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). Similarly, four species region While Bhutan is recognised for its conservation efforts, its priorities are on protection of birds (Lophura leucomelanos, Gyps bengalensis, Gyps indicus and Gracula religiosa) are of charismatic megafauna such as the Royal Bengal tiger, snow leopard, and golden included in the Schedule-I category of Wildlife Protection Act of India, 1972. mahseer. In the process, some Near Threatened, Threatened or Endemic species such as the Anguilla bengalensis (Gray), Bagarius bagarius (Hamilton), Clarias magur The Government of Sikkim has designated 11 Important Bird Areas (IBAs) in Sikkim (Hamilton) and Parachiloglanis drukyulensis39 are overlooked. Species such as P. and notified one bird sanctuary (Kitam Bird Sanctuary) for the conservation of birds. drukyulensis have a very narrow distributional range, occurring in few streams of Additionally, there are one biosphere reserve and national park and seven wildlife southern Bhutan which are under anthropogenic pressure. Therefore, such species may sanctuaries (including Kitam) in Sikkim which protect the habitats of birds as well as need to be given conservation priority as well and assessed for IUCN Red List. other flora and fauna. Our recent studies have highlighted the importance of indigenous farming systems for conservation of birds in the region, but policy intervention is d necessary in order to protect these biodiversity rich ecosystems. TEESTA BASIN d Taxonomic diversity of birds JAMUNA BASIN Bishal Thakuri and Bhoj Kumar Acharya Wetlands THE INDIAN state of Sikkim located in the Teesta basin in eastern Himalaya, forms a S M Sadik Tanveer part of the Himalayan Biodiversity Hotspot, and is one of the 36 globally significant biodiversity regions40. The variation in elevations in the Teesta basin ranging from 300 THE FORMATION of beels and other wetlands on the left and right banks of Jamuna meters to 8,586 meters, resulting in distinct gradation of vegetation, climate and other River depend both on geomorphological processes as well as environmental changes. 150 151 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Environmental changes are not necessarily natural, rather such a change may take place from different studies and surveys50. Flora found along the banks of the beel includes as a result of human interference at various levels. Broadly, the formation processes a perennial grass known as kans or kash (wild sugarcane). Date palms, dhol kolmi of all category wetlands are divided into two (i) autogenic and (ii) allogenic45. The (pink morning glory) and simul (cotton tree) are also found in and around Chalan autogenic process is related to the river regime, such as channel migration, cutoff, loop beel. The fruit from the date palm is used to make jelly, while the sap is boiled to formation, and allogenic processes include various types of human intercessions. On make a sugary product called “jaggery”51. the right bank of the Jamuna, wetlands were formed as a result of the shifting of the course of Teesta river in 1787 and reduction in the flows of tributaries such as Atrai, d Karatoya and Punarbhaba rivers. On the left bank of the Jamuna, wetlands were formed by the shifting of the old course of the river46. Riverine birds The allogenic changes that take place mainly as a result of human activities are responsible for formation of many beels and ox-bow lakes in the left bank of Jamuna Sayam U. Chowdhury river. Major changes are observed in the river regime after the commissioning of regulatory works on rivers. Construction of structures such as embankments and RIVERINE HABITATS are possibly one of the most neglected ecosystems in terms bunds for flood control and irrigation has caused drastic changes in the river course of conservation efforts in Bangladesh52. However, the sandbars, waters, pools and and altered the wetland environment. In addition, human encroachment across the floodplain grasslands of Padma and Jamuna river systems support a wide range of The beels and river and impeding the natural flow of the river significantly changed the flow regime globally important wildlife. The alluvial channels and adjacent floodplains of these other water and the denudation pattern of rivers, accelerating the siltation rate of the river as well two rivers are highly productive, as they are sustained by dynamic hydrologic and bodies on as of beels and large ponds. riverbanks provide ideal Beels are of different shapes, sizes and depth. Some of them are partly or fully infested habitats for with floating mats of aquatic plants. Reeds, grasses and bushes comprise the common feeding, resting natural vegetation in the shore areas of beels. The swampy and marshy areas, such as and breeding of jalah, pitoni, and doloni, are shallower than the beels. They are normally developed a large number close to riverbanks and on ageing shallow beels. In general, the beels and other water of fishes, birds bodies on riverbanks provide ideal habitats for feeding, resting and breeding of a large and various number of fishes, birds and various aquatic animals. aquatic animals Chalan Beel Chalan beel, a seasonal water body, is the largest beel and constitutes one of the largest, most important watersheds in north central Bangladesh. It consists of a series of depressions, interconnected by numerous channels that form more or less one continuous sheet of water during inundation (following the monsoon), covering an area of about 375 square kilometers47. The water area then shrinks to a 52 to 78 square kilometers residual cluster of smaller beels of varying sizes during the dry season48. Chalan beel is rapidly silting up and shrinking down. Chalan Beel has a unique natural beauty and provides habitat for diverse wildlife including a variety of fish, aquatic invertebrates, birds and others aquatic animals upon which the local economy and livelihoods of people of surrounding area depends49. At least twenty-seven species of mammals, and thirty-four species of reptiles, with amphibians including seven species of frogs and toads can be found on the banks of the beel. A total of 81 fish species including 72 indigenous and 9 exotic species under 12 fish orders, 27 families and 59 genera have been recorded 152 153 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION sediment transport regimes, as well as nutrient mobilization and transport through thick-knee Esacus recurvirostris and Indian thick-knee Burhinus indicus appeared to annual flood cycle and water supply53. These extremely productive floodplains have declined in Bangladesh. support early successional tall grasses dominated by wild sugarcane (Kash) Saccharum spontaneum54 and several other grass species. These grasslands support 22 avian However, recent surveys along the major rivers of Bangladesh indicate that the Padma species of global concern including the Critically Endangered yellow-breasted bunting and Jamuna river systems still provide breeding and wintering habitats to substantial Emberiza aureola55 and Vulnerable bristled grassbird Chaetornis striata, both of which populations of resident and migratory birds57. These include the Critically Endangered are grassland specialists that inhabit tall grasslands particularly in riverine or swampy Baer’s pochard Aythya baeri (known to stopover in large rivers during migration), areas. Endangered steppe eagle Aquila nipalensis, Vulnerable common pochard Aythya ferina, Asian woollyneck Ciconia episcopus, Indian skimmer Rynchops albicollis, Indian Waterbirds such as the black-bellied tern Sterna acuticauda and river tern Sterna spotted eagle Clanga hastata, greater spotted eagle Clanga clanga, eastern imperial aurantia were once common along the large river systems of Bangladesh. However due eagle Aquila heliaca and 11 other Near Threatened birds58. to large-scale destruction of riverine habitats, these species have become extremely rare in Bangladesh and elsewhere. The black-bellied tern has been uplisted in 2012 Large rivers of Bangladesh also support of the Critically Endangered gharial Gavialis from Near Threatened to Endangered due to a rapid and continuous decline over the gangeticus (possibly only migratory population), the Endangered Ganges river dolphin last 27 years, leading to almost becoming extinct in a large part of its range56. Platanista gangetica, crowned river turtle Hardella thurjii and Indian narrow-headed softshell turtle Chitra indica59. The population of resident birds that nest on sandbanks such as little tern Sterna albifrons, small pratincole Glareola lacteal, river lapwing Vanellus duvaucelii, great Human impact on riverine biodiversity is more apparent in Asia than any other part of From left to right: Black-headed ibis (Threskiornis melanocephalus); Little egret (Egretta garzetta); Black-winged stilt (Himantopus himantopus) 154 155 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION the world. Flow regulation, construction of large dams, flood control, over-harvesting Wildlife of Jamuna basin of fish, pollution and conversion of riverine wetlands to agriculture are common threats to many Asian rivers60. Sand and gravel extraction for development is common Sheikh Muhammad Abdur Rashid in Padma and Jamuna rivers, especially around large towns61. As a result of this ongoing degradation of riverine ecosystems, some taxa have been gravely affected, especially THE GHARIAL is a flagship species of the Jamuna Basin and critically endangered in riverine birds62. Bangladesh. Gharial nesting records in the river Jamuna at Pechakhola, Bera Upazilla, Pabna date back to the nineteen seventies. In the nineteen eighties and in the early These stresses on the overall riverine ecosystems reduces potential roosting and nesting nineteen nineties, gharial nests were recorded from Char Khidirpur, Padma River (in habitats of riverine bird species and other resident wildlife. However, even where the Rajshahi District) and Baladuba Char (Kurigram District) in the Jamuna River. During habitat remains suitable, hunting in winter by local or visiting sport-hunters, collection later surveys by Centre for Advanced Research in Natural Resources and Management of eggs and chicks of sand-nesting birds in late-winter are frequent along the Padma (CARINAM) in the Padma and Jamuna rivers during 2009 to 2011 only juveniles and Jamuna rivers. These practices pose a common threat to riverine birds and reduce (between 1 to 2 meters) were found, and no nests could be detected, even though their overall population. Due to the reduced level of fisheries resources, competition several suitable nesting sites were observed. between riverine birds and local fishermen may also be expected, although no evidence of this has been observed so far63.  The Asian freshwater dolphin (Platanista gangeticus) is another flagship species of the Jamuna river. Based on the results of a study conducted by CARINAM, three dolphin For the protection of these dwindling riverine species, several steps could be sanctuaries were designated by the government; one in the Jamuna River and the The Jamuna undertaken including establishing riverine protected areas. The sandbanks, grasslands second in one of the tributaries (Selunda-Hurasagar) of the Jamuna River, while the basin overlaps Flow regulation, and islands (which remain in state ownership) are not leased out and hence any third is in the Padma River. the Central construction change in management will not be resisted by leaseholders unlike other wetland sites Asian and of large dams, in Bangladesh. Hence, designating riverine sanctuaries/protected areas would be The Jamuna basin overlaps the Central Asian and East-Asian-Australasian migratory East-Asian- flood control, relatively straightforward,64 and further surveys are recommended to identify breeding bird flyways and many migratory birds particularly ducks and waders use this route Australasian over-harvesting sites of all waterbirds that nest on riverbanks. during migration. Among the raptors, kites, shikra, peregrine falcon, buzzards, and migratory of fish, pollution winter visitors like ospreys, harriers, and others can be regularly seen. Unfortunately, bird flyways and conversion of Once identified, these sites can be declared as sanctuaries in addition to the sites the vultures are not seen anymore, however, Eurasian griffon and cinereous vulture and many riverine wetlands that are already proposed to Bangladesh Forest Department under Ministry of occasionally visit the Jamuna basin area. migratory birds to agriculture Environment and Forests. There also needs to be a comprehensive conservation particularly are common strategy for the Padma and Jamuna rivers, including sustainable management The sandy riverbanks in the Jamuna basin provide nesting and basking habitat for ducks and threats to many plans for both fisheries and wildlife. In order to understand the overall health of freshwater turtles, gharials, smooth-coated otters, several species of kingfishers, bee- waders use this Asian rivers the riverine ecosystem, an indicator bird monitoring approach could be established eaters, sand larks, and bank mynas. The grass cover of the sand bars, mainly Saccharum route during targeting species that are still widespread such as the little pratincole, Indian spot- spontaneum, Typha domingensis, and Phragmites karka support and provide nesting migration billed duck and plain martin. habitats for a variety of small grassland bird species mainly prinias, larks, lapwings, lesser whistling teals, spotbill ducks, baya weaver, streaked weaver, black-breasted The Bangladesh Wildlife Preservation Act protects all water-bird species that occur weaver, buntings, munias and many more. Rare bird species like the black stork, in these rivers. Therefore, enforcement by the government and support by local common merganser also visit the sand bars. NGOs are needed to tackle bird hunting and prevent illegal habitat encroachment. In addition, awareness-raising activities in villages along these rivers should be The shallow inundated chars, cultivated land and the adjacent human settlements along carried out to educate local people, especially fishermen and other natural resource the river bank support several species of amphibians which include the common toad harvesters, of the importance of birds and other wildlife to maintain a healthy (Duttaphrynus melanostictus), marbled toad (D. stomaticus), bull frog (Hoplobatrachus riverine ecosystem. tigerinus), skipper frog (Euphlyctis sp.), green frog (E. hexadactylus), several species of cricket frogs (Fejervarya sp.), Polypedetes sp., Hylarana tytleri, Kulaula sp., the recently recorded Microhyla nilphamariensis, and the unusual Humerana humeralis. d 156 157 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION The gharial or the fish-eating crocodile is amongst the longest of all the crocodilians. Once found in freshwater river systems from Pakistan to Myanmar, the critically endangered gharial is on the brink of extinction and is found today only in a few locations in India and Nepal. 158 159 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION Freshwater turtles are threatened by the conversion of wetlands, demand for trade and consumption by some as food. The commercial trade from early nineteen seventies till late nineteen nineties has almost exterminated many of the populations and once common species have become rare and some are critically endangered. The species encountered within the basin include Batagur kachuga, Pangshura tecta, P. tentoria, P. smithii, Hardella thurjii, Morenia petersi, Lissemys punctata, Nilssonia gangetica, N. hurum, and recently Nilssonia nigricans has also been found within the basin. Reptiles include Burmese pythons (Python bivittatus), python, venomous snakes such as Naja kaouthia, N. naja, Bungarus caeruleus, B. walii, B. niger are found, and in recent years Daboia russelli is often reported from the villages in the vicinity of the riverbank and also from the chars. Other nonvenomous snakes include Enhydris enhydris, Eryx conicus, Ahaetulla nasuta, Coelognathus radiatus, Dendrelaphis pictus, Lycodon aulicus, Oligodon arnensis, Ptyas mucosa, Sibynophis sagittarius, Amphiesma stolatum, Xenochrophis cerasogaster, X. piscator, Ferania sieboldi, Indotyphlops braminus, and many more. Although small reptiles are hard to find and are often left unrecorded, some common lizards have been observed and recorded by CARINAM. These include Calotes versicolor, Gekko gecko, Hemidactylus brookii, H. flaviviridis, H. frenatus, Eutropis The Ilish represents a shared history, a common ecosystem, and close economic ties between Bangladesh carinata, E. dissimilis, Lygosoma bowringii, L. punctata, Varanus bengalensis, and V. and India. The fish contributes to one percent of the total GDP of Bangladesh flavescens. d Hilsa fisheries M Niamul Naser and Anisur Rahman The river shad, THE JAMUNA river system is important for migratory fishes and as nursing grounds hilsa is the for natural spawned carp fishes. The river shad, hilsa (Tenualosa ilisha) is the national national fish fish of Bangladesh and the most important single species for fishery in the country. The of Bangladesh. hilsa (Tenualosa ilisha) holds a special place in the hearts and in the diets of people living This fish in this region. Locally known as the “Macher Raja Ilish”, or the “king of the fishes”, this fish received the received the Geographical Indicator registration in 2017. Geographical Indicator The hilsa accounts for nearly half of the total marine catch, and about 12 percent of total registration fish production of the country contributing about 1 percent to GDP. About 450,000 in 2017 fishers are directly employed in hilsa fishing with an indirect employment of about 2.6 million people in the wider hilsa sector (trading, processing etc.). In 2017-18, a total 541 metric tons of hilsa was caught from this river system, out of which 320 metric tons were caught from the Jamuna river. 160 161 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION The distribution of hilsa mainly depends on water flow and flooding of the rivers. In years of heavy flooding, they are caught in the small channels and floodplains. Considerable quantities of hilsa are also caught in the lower Arial Khan, Madhumati, and Padma rivers, with lower quantities in the Jamuna and Brahmaputra rivers. The hilsa in breeding season migrates from the Jamuna towards upper Brahmaputra river basin of Assam, India. The hilsa lives and breeds in the Jamuna river due to its unique water quality and habitats; particularly the plankton (both phytoplankton and zooplankton) available in this area are suitable as food for hilsa. During last few decades over-fishing and indiscriminate catching of jatka (juvenile hilsa) had reduced the hilsa population in the river. To sustain as well as to increase hilsa production, several management measures have been undertaken by Department of Fisheries under the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock. Conservation of jatka through declaring six fish sanctuaries in the major nursery and spawning grounds of riverine and estuarine system and prevention of hilsa fishing for 22 days during the peak breeding season are the most important initiatives. Due to conservation of jatka, the abundance of grown up/sub-adult hilsa has increased considerably. Overall, there has been a gradual revival of hilsa population, but the threats still remain, as these fish are often caught before they reach maturity of the first spawning stage. d Madhupur National Park56 M. Monirul H. Khan Top left: Grey heron (Ardea THE 80 KILOMETERS avulsion of the river Brahmaputra by the year 1843 created two cinerea) rivers in central Bangladesh: Jamuna (main Brahmaputra) and Old Brahmaputra. Between these two rivers lie a fertile highland called the Madhupur Tract. Even a Top right: hundred years ago a major part of the Madhupur Tract was covered by moist deciduous Lesser coucal forest dominated by sal (Shorea robusta) trees. The sal forest used to be teeming (Centropus The Madhupur with wildlife including some charismatic megafauna like the Indian rhinoceros bengalensis) National Park (Rhinoceros unicornis), tiger (Panthera tigris tigris), leopard (Panthera pardus), Asian holds one of the elephant (Elephas maximus) and Asiatic black bear (Ursus thibetanus), but none of Bottom: last remaining them currently survive in the Madhupur Tract. Both the forest and the wildlife were Oriental magpie natural sal destroyed mercilessly by humans. robin (Copsychus forest patches saularis), the in Bangladesh During the Mughal and the British colonial era, the local landlords or zaminders national bird of preserved some wilderness areas of the Madhupur Tract in order to facilitate game Bangladesh hunting for the elites. Two pockets of these areas in Madhupur and Bhawal eventually got legal protection and became the first legally designated protected areas in Bangladesh. Having an area of 84.36 square kilometers, the Madhupur National Park was formally 162 163 THE RESTLESS RIVER LIFE: BIODIVERSIT Y OF THE REGION established in 1982. It is situated about 125 kilometers north of Dhaka City, in Tangail District, beside the Tangail-Mymensingh Highway. The Park is historical not only because it is the first of its kind, but also because it was the training and sheltering ground of the freedom fighters during the Liberation War in 1971. The Dokhola Rest House in the park is also historical because the drafting of the Bangladesh Wildlife Order, 1973, was done here under which the park was formally established in 1982. The topography of the Madhupur National Park and its surrounding areas mainly consist of flat- topped highlands or chalas intersected by many lowlands or baids. The highest altitude of topped ridges is 15 meters above the mean sea level. The climate is moderate, with the temperature rising up to 37°C in May and dropping down to minimum 10°C in January. The depressions or chalas are flooded every year during the tropical monsoon from June to September. The soil is loamy, clay and sandy loam, and mostly looks reddish due to rich iron content. The Park is The Madhupur National Park holds one of the last remaining natural sal forest patches historical not in Bangladesh where about 40 percent of the area is covered with sal trees. It represents only because it an important and treasured part of Bangladesh due to its rich biological and cultural is the first of its diversity that still prevails despite considerable deforestation in the last few decades. In kind, but also Tangail District alone the sal forest has shrunk to 10 square kilometers in 1990 from because it was 200 square kilometers in 1970. The ethnic Garo community, together with the local the training Bengali community, live in scattered villages in and around the park. According to an and sheltering estimate in 1989, about 100,000 Garo people live in Bangladesh, of which about 14,000 ground of live in the Madhupur forest area. They have been living there for the last few centuries. the freedom They cultivate paddy in the lowlands, and pineapple and cassava in the highlands. The fighters during Government of Bangladesh has permitted about 4,500 Garo people to reside in the the Liberation park area since 1968. War in 1971 There are at least 176 vascular plant species in the park, including 73 tree, 22 shrub, 27 climber, 45 medicinal plants, 8 grass and 1 palm species. The sal trees grow in association with Dillenia pentagyna, Lagerstroemia parviflora, Adina cordifolia, Miliusa velutina, Lannea grandis, Albizia spp., Bauhinia variegata, Spondias mangifera, Butea frondosa pigeon (Treron phoenicopterus), red-breasted parakeet (Psittacula alexandri), small Brown fish and Barringtonia acutangula. The undergrowth is shrubby and includes Eupatoriun minivet (Pericrocotus cinnamomeus), spotted flapshell turtle (Lissemys punctata), Tokay owl (Ketupa odoratum, Pennisetum setosum, Asparagus racemosus and Rauwolfia serpentina. gecko (Gekko gecko), Bengal monitor (Varanus bengalensis), painted bronzeback tree zeylonensis) Plantations of Acacia spp., Tectona grandis, Cassia siamea, Morus spp.,Teminalia arjuna snake (Dendrelaphis pictus), banded krait (Bungarus fasciatus), Indian balloon frog and Syzygium cumini are seen in buffer areas around the park. (Uperodon globulosus), Indian bull frog (Hoplobatrachus tigerinus) and stripe sticky frog (Kalophrynus interlineatus). The Madhupur National Park is the only known area About 21 species of mammal, 140 bird, 32 reptile and 21 amphibian species occur in Bangladesh where the rare stripe sticky frog is found. in the Madhupur National Park. It is a major stronghold of the globally threatened capped langur (Trachypithecus pileatus), which occurs in groups headed by an alpha The Madhupur National Park remains open for visitors throughout the year and is male. Another globally threatened mammal, the fishing cat (Prionailurus viverrinus), easily accessible by road. It is a popular tourist attraction due to its diversity, scenic rarely occurs in the park. Among other notable wildlife there are rhesus macaque beauty and proximity to Dhaka. The Park can be visited even in a day trip from Dhaka (Macaca mulatta), golden jackal (Canis aureus), barking deer (Muntiacus muntjak), City. Irrawaddy squirrel (Callosciurus pygerythrus), crested serpent eagle (Spilornis cheela), red junglefowl (Gallus gallus), Indian pitta (Pitta brachyura), yellow-footed green- d 164 165 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND 4. GROW Living off the land Vasudha Pangare Kshirode Roy Jin Tao Dhrupad Choudhury Kinlay Tshering Xiawei Liao Raju Mandal Md Ayub Hossain Shahriar Wahid Fazlul Karim Mohammed Mainuddin Pooja Kotoky Md Hossain Ganesh Pangare 166 167 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Glossary Agroecological/agroclimatic Agroclimatic and agroecological zones are regions with similar Terraced agriculture can be rain-fed or irrigated and is usually found Terraced agriculture zones climate, rainfall, soil types, topography, vegetation, and water on slopes which are more than 30 percent. Terraced fields decrease resources. An overview of the zones provides a holistic view of erosion and surface runoff and are effective for growing crops ecological characteristics and their relation to agricultural practices. requiring much water, such as rice. Terraces are made by levelling land on the hill slopes and in many places occur as a result of many Transhumant pastoral Transhumance2 is the regular movement of herds among fixed years of cultivation. points in order to exploit the seasonal availability of pastures. Transhumant pastoralists often have a permanent homestead and In wet rice cultivation, the land is thoroughly ploughed and flooded Wet rice cultivation6 base where crops are grown for home consumption. Older members with water upto 5cm in depth. In case of clayey or loamy soil the of the community remain here throughout the year. A characteristic depth of the water is upto 10 cm. Post puddling the land is levelled feature of transhumance is herd splitting; the herders take most of so as to ensure uniform water distribution. Seedlings are sown or the animals to search for grazing but leave the resident community transplanted after leveling. with a nucleus of lactating females. In rainfed agriculture cultivation predominantly depends on Rainfed agriculture7 Agropastoral Agropastoralists3 can be described as settled pastoralists who rains, allowing single or double crops as per the rainfall pattern of cultivate sufficient areas to feed their families from their own crop the region. production. While livestock is still valued property, their herds are smaller, possibly because they no longer rely solely on livestock and In irrigated agriculture water is provided artificially to crops. Irrigated agriculture8 depend on a finite grazing area which can be reached from their Irrigation systems draw water from surface and groundwater villages within a day. Agropastoralists invest more in housing and sources and are also designed to harvest and channel rainwater. other local infrastructure and, if their herds become large, they Irrigation systems generally consist of diversion channels, surface often send them away with more nomadic pastoralists. drainage tanks and wells. Diverting or storing and lifting water from rivers and streams with the help of dams and a network of canals as Agroforestry pastoral mixed This system typically incorporates different resources through well as field channels is the most popular system for using water for production systems cropping, livestock raising and forestry and gets established over a irrigation. Groundwater is lifted from wells, borewells and tubewells long period of time. with the help of non-mechanised and mechanised devises. In mountain regions hill streams and glaciers are the assured sources Crop-based livestock Farmers keep only enough livestock that can be fed on crop residues of water and these are tapped by a variety of diversion channels production4 and by-products, especially in spring and winter. using gravity flow, taken directly to the fields or stored for future use. Shifting cultivation5 Shifting or jhum cultivation is a form of agriculture, in which an area of ground is cleared of vegetation and cultivated for a few years and Subsistence agriculture occurs when farmers grow food crops to Subsistence agriculture then fallowed for regeneration until its fertility has been naturally meet the needs of themselves and their families. In subsistence restored. Shifting cultivation is an age-old practice that occupies a agriculture, farm output is targeted to survival and is mostly for distinct place in tribal agriculture and its economy, constituting a local requirements with little or no surplus. vital part of the socio-economic framework of tribal life. 168 169 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS in the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system are dynamic and have been shaped over centuries by farming households living within specific ecological and social ecosystems in each basin and sub-basin of the river system. Most agricultural systems integrate crops and livestock, the level of integration differing according to the natural environment, climate, nutrition and economic needs of the households, and social and community influences. Farming households have adapted farming practices to changing circumstances, natural, ecological, social, political, and the prevailing policy environment. Climate variations, droughts and floods are important drivers for changes in cultivation practices and crop diversification in the river system. Agropastoral households in the Yarlung Tsangpo basin with its high altitude, low temperatures, short growing season, and variable climate follow a unique plateau agriculture and livestock management system. Indigenous communities in the Siang basin with its hilly terrain and plant agrobiodiversity practice shifting cultivation, an agricultural system strongly linked to their culture. Terraced agriculture is practiced in the hilly regions of the Manas and Teesta sub basins. Wet rice cultivation is practiced in the lower reaches of the river system in the Brahmaputra and Jamuna basin. Tea has a special place Wet rice in the culture of Yarlung Tsangpo and an intriguing history in cultivation in the the Brahmaputra Valley. Rice is a common crop throughout Brahmaputra and the river system except in the high altitudes where barley and Jamuna Basin wheat are grown. Water availability either by means of rainfall or irrigation is an important determinant High altitude of the farming practice and cropping pattern adopted by farming households. The dry Barley in the season rice cultivated in the Jamuna basin and Brahmaputra basin is largely dependent Yarlung-Tsangpo on irrigation. A recent study1 estimates that the quantity of water used for irrigation Basin from the river system in the Jamuna Basin in Bangladesh is highest during winter months when the dry season rice is in its early stages of cultivation, and before the spring rains arrive. In the Brahmaputra Basin in India the quantity of water used for irrigation is highest in March, in the early stages of the first growing season of the year. This chapter provides an overview of agricultural systems, major crops and livestock, in four main basins and two sub-basins located within the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system and highlights the unique characteristics of the agricultural systems in each basin and sub-basin. 170 171 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND 172 173 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS in the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna river system BRAHMAPUTRA BASIN12,13 – compiled by Vasudha Pangare Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural system Major crops and livestock YARLUNG TSANGPO BASIN 9,10, zone Central Brahmaputra Valley zone Wet rice cultivation Rice, maize, potato, vegetables and oilseeds Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural systems Major crops and livestock Tea cultivation Tea zone & elevation Jute Temperate semi-arid and arid Agropastoral Cattle, yak, sheep, goat Cattle, poultry, goat, pig, buffalo zone. Barley Hill Temperate zone Shifting cultivation Rice, maize, sesame, cotton, tapioca, ginger, Mean 4920 – 4949 m turmeric, arum, cucurbits, beans Sub-frigid, semi-arid zone. Agropastoral Cattle, yak, sheep Poultry, cattle, goat, pig, sheep Mean 4870 m Barley Lower Brahmaputra Valley zone Wet rice cultivation Rice, maize, potato, vegetables and oilseeds Sub-frigid, semi-humid zone. Agropastoral Cattle, yak, sheep, goat, chicken Tea cultivation Tea Mean 4499 m Barley, spring wheat, pea, rapeseed, apples, Poultry, cattle, pig peaches, potatoes, vegetables in greenhouses North Bank Plain zone Wet rice cultivation Rice, maize, potato, vegetables and oilseeds Temperate humid or semi-humid Crop based livestock Yak and zo Tea cultivation Tea zone. production Poultry, cattle, pig, Buffalo Mean 4145 m Rainfed agriculture Cereals, rapeseed Upper Brahmaputra Valley zone Wet rice cultivation Rice, maize, potato, vegetables and oilseeds Irrigated agriculture Tea cultivation Tea Sub-tropical humid. Agroforestry pastoral Yak, cattle, swine, goat Poultry, cattle, pig, Buffalo Mean 1642 – 2552 m mixed production MANAS BASIN14 systems Winter wheat, winter barley, maize, rice Shifting cultivation Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural system Major crops and livestock SIANG BASIN 11 zone Alpine zone Transhumant pastoral Yak, sheep, goat Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural system Major crops and livestock 3,600-7,500 m zone Cool temperate zone Transhumant pastoral Yak, sheep, goat Alpine zone Transhumant pastoral Yak, Dzo-Dzomo, sheep 2,600-3,600 m Livestock rearing 3500 + m Rainfed agriculture Wheat, potato, buckwheat, mustard, barley Temperate sub-Alpine zone Shifting cultivation Barley, wheat, rice, millet, maize, potato, Warm temperate zone Terraced agriculture; Rice, wheat, potato, seasonal fodder, vegetables 1500 – 3500 m buckwheat, pulses, mustard, Aram 1,800-2,600 m irrigated Apple, plum, peaches, pears, walnut, Dry sub-tropical zone Rainfed and irrigated Rice, maize, mustard, barley, legumes and vegetables 1200-1800 m agriculture vegetables Yak, Dzo-Dzomo, sheep, pig, goats Humid sub-tropical zone Terraced agriculture; Wheat, mustard, Sub-tropical hill zone Shifting cultivation Upland rice, maize, finger millet, beans, 600-1200 m irrigated Cardamom at higher elevations 1000-1500 m tapioca, yam banana, sweet potato, ginger, Mandarin orange at lower elevations cotton, tobacco, chilli, sesame, vegetables Rainfed agriculture Maize, millet, mustard, legumes, ginger, Terraced agriculture: Citrus, pineapple, pome and stone fruits vegetables rainfed and irrigated Pig, cattle, Mithun, goats Wet Subtropical zone Subsistence agriculture; Rice, wheat, maize Mild tropical plain zone Wet rice cultivation Rice, oilseed, sugarcane, jute, potato, sweet 100-600 m irrigated <200 m potato Rainfed agriculture Maize, millet, legumes, mustard, Niger, tubers, Buffalo, cattle, pig vegetables 174 175 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND TEESTA BASIN15 Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural system Major crops and livestock zone Temperate zone Subsistence agriculture Wheat, barley, high altitude maize, potato, 1524 – 2743 m cabbage, beans, peas, apple, peach and pear Cattle, poultry, goat Sub-tropical hill zone Terraced agriculture Maize, rice, cardamom 610 – 1524 m Agroforestry Cattle, goat, buffalo Alpine zone Transhumant pastoral Yak, dzo, sheep, goats, ponies 3962 + Agropastoral Sub- temperate zone Shifting cultivation Barley, wheat, potato, cabbage, apple, maize, 2743 – 3962 m Terraced agriculture peas, peach, medicinal plants, tubers Cattle, poultry, goat, ponies JAMUNA BASIN16 Agroecological/agroclimatic Agricultural system Major crops and livestock zone Wet rice cultivation Old Himalayan Piedmont Plain Irrigated agriculture Rice, potato, wheat, maize, sugarcane Wet rice cultivation Rice, potato, mustard, maize, wheat, tobacco Active Teesta Floodplain Irrigated agriculture Poultry, cattle Wet rice cultivation Rice, wheat, maize, potato Teesta Meander Floodplain Irrigated Poultry, cattle Wet rice cultivation, Rice, field pea, mustard, onion, lentil Karatoya-Bangali Floodplain  irrigated Poultry, cattle Wet rice cultivation, Lower Atrai Basin rainfed and irrigated Rice, wheat, mungbean Rice, potato, mustard, wheat, maize, sugarcane Active Brahmaputra-Jamuna Wet rice cultivation Poultry, cattle Floodplain  Rice, potato, mustard Young Brahmaputra and Jamuna Wet rice cultivation Poultry, cattle Floodplain  Rice, mungbean, potato, maize Old Brahmaputra Flood Plain and Wet rice cultivation Poultry, cattle Jamuna Floodplain  176 177 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND YARLUNG TSANGPO BASIN North Tibet Plateau - grassland animal husbandry ecological area Located in the alpine zone between Kunlun Mountains, Tanggula mountains and The huge height The Yarlung Tsangpo Basin is located in southern Tibet, and includes major parts of Mountain Kailash - Nyainqêntanglha mountains, with an average altitude of more difference has Shigatse, Lhasa and Shannon prefectures and part of Nyingchi prefecture. This region than 4,500 meters, this area accounts for about two-thirds of the land area of Tibet formed a variety is the main agricultural area of Tibet Autonomous Region. Most of the population is Autonomous Region. The average temperature in July, the warmest month, is less than of agricultural concentrated here, along the Yarlung-Tsangpo, Lhasa and Niachu rivers. 6 °C. There is freezing all year round. In the northern Tibet plateau north of Shiquanhe, climate zones Ando and Naqu, the average temperature at the surface of 80 centimeters in winter and unique is between - 4 ~ 7 °C. Permafrost is widely developed, with almost no crop growth. climate Agroclimatic zones and agricultural husbandry There is a vast natural grassland, mainly composed of a small number of native grass characteristics types. It is the main grassland animal husbandry area of Tibet Autonomous Region, Jin Tao and the number of livestock accounts for about 30 percent of the total number of over 17 million livestock in the region. Yaks, sheep and goats are the main livestock types in TIBET AUTONOMOUS Region is the main body of the Qinghai Tibet Plateau, with an this area. There are a small number of horses and pigs in the area below 4,000 meters average altitude of more than 4,000 meters. In terms of its typography, the continuous above sea level. mountains and rivers divide Tibet into three different natural areas: the northern Tibet Plateau, the southern Tibet Valley and the eastern Tibet mountain canyon. With the South Tibet Yarlung Tsangpo valley – agricultural and husbandry ecological area change of temperature and precipitation, the huge height difference has formed a This area is located between the Gangdise mountains and Himalayas, i.e. the Yarlung variety of agricultural climate zones and unique climate characteristics: strong solar Tsangpo River and its tributaries. The average altitude is 3,500 meters. There are many radiation, rich sunshine, low temperature, less accumulated temperature, temperature flat valleys and lake basins with different width such as Lhasa River, Nyanchu River, decreases with the rise of altitude and latitude, large daily temperature difference, clear Nyang River and other valleys, which are usually 5-8 kilometers wide and 70-100 dry and wet periods with more rain at night; long dry and cold winter with more gale; kilometers long. The climate is relatively mild, the annual average temperature is 5-8 °C, cool and rainy summer with more hail. the average annual precipitation is 300-450 millimeters, the frost free period is 120-150 Figure 1. The trend and distribution of the Qinghai Tibet Plateau mountains Figure 2. Dry farming map of Tibet s N ain s Qilia n Mo Nagqu o unt unta Ngari in M ins hch Aer Severe Dry Medium Dry Humid Qaidam Basin Mild Dry Ka Region Region Region ra Region ko Chamdo ra m Kunlun Mountains Ra Mild Dry ng Lhasa Humid e Qinghai Plateau Region Bay an Shigatse Region Har Mo unt ain s Nyingchi Tan Northern Tibet ggul Lhoka a Ra Plateau nge Ka ila e tains Rang 0 75 150 300 450 600 sR glha un Km an tan Mo ge nqên an Nyai g du H en Him South Sichuan-Tibet High- ala Tibet V ern yas alley Mountain Valley 178 Mo 179 unt ain s THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Eastern Tibet - agriculture, forestry and animal husbandry ecological area Located to the east of Naqu City, this region has a series of high mountains and deep valleys that gradually turn from east-west to north-south. The main part is Jinsha River, Lancang River and Nujiang River (referred to as Sanjiang River Basin) drainage area of Hengduan Mountains. It is high in the north and low in the south, with an altitude of 5,200 meters in the north, more than 3,000 meters in the south, and a height difference of more than 2,000 meters between the top and the bottom of the valley. The vertical difference in climate is obvious. The mountain top is often covered with snow all the year round, the hillside is densely covered with forests, and the Piedmont farmland is interlaced. It is a typical combination area of agriculture, forestry and animal husbandry. This area is the place with the best temperature conditions in Tibet. The annual average temperature is above 15 °C, frost free period is more than 270 days, the average temperature in the warmest month (July) can be more than 20 °C, the average temperature in the coldest month (January) is also above 8 °C, the annual accumulated temperature of ≥ 10 °C can be as high as 4700 ~ 5100 msl, the rainfall is abundant, and the annual average precipitation is more than 600 millimeters. It is the main natural forest area in Tibet, and the income from forest products is the main source of income for farmers in this region. The cultivated land area is small and scattered, most of which is distributed in the valley area or hillside terrace. Every year, the crops can be planted for two to three seasons, suitable for planting corn, rice and other warm food crops, as well as sugarcane, tea, citrus, oil tea, banana and other subtropical economic crops and forest fruits. The three basic factors of heat, The rest of Tibet is basically a sub cold climate, with an annual average temperature water and soil of - 0.6 ~ 4 °C and an average temperature of about 10 °C in the warmest month (July). in the region There are many natural disasters and frost almost all year round. Most areas are pastoral determine areas. Only in some places with good microclimate environment can spring barley and agricultural roots of genkwa17 (Daphne) be planted. production and crop distribution General overview of agriculture and animal husbandry in Tibet Yak dung cakes days, the average temperature in the warmest month is about 15 °C, the accumulated High altitude terrain, low temperature, cold and changeable climate, short effective stored for fuel in temperature ≥ 10 °C is about 2,000 °C, and 85 percent of the annual precipitation growth period of plants, slow growth and development of animals, has formed a unique Tibet is concentrated from June to September. The crops can be ripened once a year. The plateau agriculture and animal husbandry, which also makes the output of agricultural main crops are winter wheat, highland barley, rape, pea, potato, green feed, etc. The and livestock products in Tibet low. The three basic factors of heat, water and soil in economic forest fruits in the temperate zone such as apples and walnuts can also be the region determine agricultural production and crop distribution, among which heat planted, as the area is suitable for the growth and planting of a variety of cool crops. condition is the key. Altitude has a significant effect on temperature in Tibet, and the The vast majority of highland barley is spring highland barley, and winter highland difference of temperature limits agricultural production and crop distribution. The total barley is only distributed in the valley agricultural area below 3,700 meters above sea area of Tibet Autonomous Region is 1.2,284 million square kilometers. The cultivated level; winter wheat is the main wheat, accounting for more than 70 percent, the rest is land is distributed in strips or sheets along rivers. The cultivated land area is about spring wheat; beans are mainly peas, and some potatoes. This area has a concentrated 350,000 hectares, accounting for 0.3 percent of the total area. The valley cultivated land population, a vast grassland, relatively flat terrain, concentrated arable land, and good accounts for 70 percent of the total area of Tibet cultivated land. The grassland area is soil conditions suitable for crop growth. The per unit yield of crops is the highest about 82.07 million hectares, accounting for 71 percent of the total area. The forest land in Tibet, and it is the most important agricultural region with the combination of area is 17.9,819 million hectares, accounting for 14.6 percent of the total area. The main agriculture and animal husbandry in Tibet Autonomous Region. areas of agricultural and animal husbandry production in Tibet Autonomous Region 180 181 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Agriculture Xiawei Liao Agricultural GDP18 The gross output value of agricultural products in Tibet, including farming, forestry, animal husbandry and fishery, has more than tripled from RMB 5.1 billion (approximately US$ 0.73 billion) in 2000 to RMB 17.8 billion (US$2.54 billion) in 2017, and is approximately 13.5 percent of the provincial GDP. Animal husbandry contributed the largest share, 51.7 percent, to the provincial agricultural GDP, followed by farming products, 44.0 percent. Forestry products and fishery make up very small proportions, 1.7 percent and 0.2 percent respectively in 2017. Crops Out of Tibet’s total land area of about 1.2 million square kilometers, most of which is made up of highland deserts and glacier areas, only less than 2,500 square kilometers land was cultivated for agricultural use in 2017, and the total crops output was 2,427.5 tons. Figure 3 shows the area of cultivated land and total crop output in Tibet from 1990 to 2017. Figure 3. Area of cultivated land and total crop output in Tibet Sheep are the grassland animal husbandry ecological area located in the North Tibet Plateau The gross account for and the agricultural and animal husbandry ecological area located in the South Tibet 2450 1200000 output value 60% of the River Valley. 2400 of agricultural 1000000 total livestock products in Area of cultivated land (km2) Total crops outputs (tons) 2350 in Tibet The main crops planted in Tibet include winter and spring barley (naked barley), winter 800000 Tibet, including and spring wheat, rape, pea, potato, and buckwheat. Rice, corn, soybean, millet, chicken 2300 farming, claw grain and other crops are also planted in the area below 2,300 meters above sea 2250 600000 forestry, animal level. Among the crops, highland barley has the largest planting area, about 180,000 400000 husbandry and hectares, wheat 41,000 hectares, rape 28,000 hectares, green fodder 48,000 hectares and 2200 fishery, has more vegetables 30,000 hectares. The average yield of spring highland barley is about 4,200 2150 200000 than tripled in kilograms per hectare, wheat 4,700 kilograms per hectare, beans 3,800 kilograms per the last 15 years 2100 0 hectare, rapeseed 2,000 kilograms per hectare, vegetables 29,900 kilograms per hectare 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 and forage 8,500 kilograms per hectare. Area of cultivated land (km2) Total output of main crops (tons) Tibet’s livestock and poultry are mainly yak, sheep, goats, pigs, horses, donkeys, mules, and chicken. The main livestock are cattle and sheep, of which sheep account for 60 About 55 percent of the cultivated land is used to grow highland barley (Figure 4). percent of the total livestock, cattle account for 36 percent, and other livestock account Among the 74 counties in Tibet, there are in total 65 counties growing highland barley, for a relatively small proportion. The average body weight of local adult yaks is 200 at altitudes ranging from 800 to 4,750 meters. Wheat occupied the second largest area kilograms, the heaviest of which can reach 400 kilograms, and they will be released of land, but with a decreasing trend from about 20 percent of the total cultivated land in 7-9 years of breeding; the weight of sheep may be between 40 to 50 kilograms, the in 1990 to only 13 percent in 2017. A decreasing proportion of land is being used to heaviest being 60 to 70 kilograms; and the weight of adult goats may be between 25 grow beans as well, from 10.56 percent in 1990 to 1.56 percent in 2017. On the other to 30 kilograms; pigs are mainly local Tibetan pigs, with the weight of 30 kilograms, hand, growing proportions of land are being used to grow vegetables and green feed, mainly distributed in forest and agricultural ecological areas. which together occupied 20.92 percent of the cultivated land in 2017. 182 183 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND 184 185 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Figure 4. Composition of crop productions in Tibet Figure 6. Land productivity for highland barley and wheat in Tibet 100% 800 90% 700 80% Land productivity (tons/km2) Others 70% 600 Oil bearing crops 60% 500 50% Tubers 400 40% Beans 30% 300 Wheat Wheat 20% 200 Highland Barley Highland Barley 10% 100 0% 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Figure 5 shows the land cultivated under various crops in the Tibetan prefectures in the Yarlung Tsangpo Basin in 2017. Tea, apple and pear plantations are occupying increasing land in Tibet, growing Initial evidence substantially from 1.49, 5.08 and 0.41 square kilometers respectively in 1990 to 7.90, indicates Figure 5. Cultivated land in main Tibetan prefectures in the Yarlung Tsangpo 28.76 and 4.32 square kilometers in 2017. Accordingly, annual tea output has grown that increase Basin in 2017 from 66 tons to 91 tons during the same period, while apple and pear productions have in cropping grown from 3,696 and 319 tons, respectively to 11,044 and 1,309 tons. intensity on 1000 Green Feed the Tibetan 900 The effective irrigated area in Tibet has increased from 1,543.7 square kilometers in plateau could 800 Vegetables 2001 to 1,810.8 square kilometers in 2017, occupying an increasing share in the total be attributed to Cultivated land (in km2) 700 600 Oil-bearing Crops cultivated land from 67.10 percent to 76.92 percent. Among which, the areas that climate warming 500 Tubers are irrigated electromechanically have increased from 58.1 square kilometers to 69.8 400 square kilometers during the same period. Beans 300 200 Wheat Initial evidence indicates that increase in cropping intensity19 on the Tibetan plateau 100 could be attributed to climate warming. The area suitable for single cropping increased Highland Barley 0 from 19,110 square kilometers in 1970s to 19,980 square kilometers in 2000s, expanding Lhasa Shigatse Nyingchi Shannan from the downstream valleys of Lhasa River and Nyang Qu River to upstream valleys. The area suitable for double cropping gradually increased from 9 square kilometers in Highland barley has the largest production in Tibet, more than doubled from 1970s to 2,015 square kilometers in 2000s, expanding from the lower reaches of Yarlung 0.37 million tons in 1990 to 0.79 million tons in 2017, which is followed by wheat Tsangpo in Lhoka Prefecture to the upper ones, as well as the Lhasa River tributaries. productions. However, after peaking at 0.31 million tons in 2000, wheat production The upper limit elevation suitable for single cropping rose vertically from 5,001 meters has kept decreasing to only 0.2 million tons in 2017, almost the same production level above sea level to 5,032 meters above sea level from 1970s to 2000s, and that of double as in 1992. cropping rose from 3,608 meters above sea level to 3,813 meters above sea level. Tibet has implemented various measures to increase the land productivity, such as Organic farming scientific fertilization, mechanical seeding, pest and disease control. From Figure 6, it From 2015 to 2017, total chemical fertilizer use per hectare has steadily decreased from can be seen that land productivity for both highland barley and wheat has increased 255 kilograms to 213 kilograms. Nitrogen fertilizer is occupying a decreasing share, substantially over the last 30 years, from 307 (highland barley) and 393 (wheat) tons from 52.15 percent to 32.64 percent while compound fertilizer is occupying a growing per square kilometers in 1990 to 566 (highland barley) and 609 (wheat) tons per square share, from 27.85 percent to 42.53 percent. kilometers in 2017. 186 187 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND The main insect pests include locusts, aphids, underground pests, spiders, and caterpillars22. The main diseases are barley bacterial stripe disease, stripe disease, wheat rust, and smut. Locust is a unique species in the Qinghai Tibet Plateau, which has three characteristics of migration, outbreak and destruction. Affected by the continuous climate change, it seriously endangers the production of agriculture and animal husbandry, food security, income increase of farmers and herdsmen, and even the ecological environment. Aphids are mainly wheat aphids, rape aphids and other insect pests. They are very fast in reproduction speed, covering the whole Tibetan area. Red spider (Tetranychidae) is widely distributed and can cause harm to many plant species. They have very strong reproductive capacity, especially in high temperature and drought climate. Traditionally, knapsack hand sprayer is used to spray pesticides for pest and disease In recent years, control, which is labor intensive. After 2015, coordinated prevention and control has accompanying been promoted in Tibet, adopting large-scale pesticides application and spraying the decreasing machines. consumption of chemical Livestock fertilizers, There are in total 0.88 million square kilometers of grassland in Tibet23. Animal organic farming husbandry makes up 44.9 percent of the provincial agricultural GDP and 19.4 percent has seen an of the provincial GDP. In total, there were 17.56 million livestock in Tibet in 2017. expansion While the number of cattle and buffaloes has kept almost constant at around 6 million, the number of sheep and goats has decreased substantially from peaking at 25 million in 2004. The number of hogs has increased slightly from 0.16 million in 1990 to 0.42 in 2017. (Figure 7) In recent years, accompanying the decreasing consumption of chemical fertilizers, Figure 7. Number of livestock in Tibet organic farming has seen an expansion in Tibet. In 2019, a new project proposes to Sheep and Goats Cattle and Buffaloes Hogs implement organic barley farming in more than 2.9 square kilometers in Linzhou 20 County in Lhasa, which is expected to benefit 3,089 people in 510 households bring 18 on average RMB 6,900 (approximately USD 975) income increase per household and 16 Number of livestock, year-end (million) RMB 1,168 (approximately USD 165) income increase per capita20. 14 12 In Gangba County in Shigatse City, through organic farming and certification, the price 10 per one sheep has increased from 800 RMB (approximately USD 113) to 1700 RMB (approximately USD 240.26) in 2016 and the total economic output of sheep farming 8 in Gangba has reached RMB 1.53 billion in 2016, increasing by RMB 0.9 billion from 6 2013. It has led to income per capita increase of RMB 1,500 for sheep farmers 21. 4 2 Main agricultural pests 0 Almost 50 percent of the total cultivated land in Tibet is affected by crops diseases, 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 pests and the problem of weeds. Every year, 10 to 30 percent of agricultural production is affected. 188 189 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND In terms of livestock products, more beef than mutton is produced in Tibet (Figure growing in the warm season and for keeping livestock in the cold season. Plastic film 8). In 2017, there were 225.4 thousand tons of beef and 63.5 thousand tons of mutton for agricultural use has increased from 249 tons in 2001 to 1,843 tons in 201724. produced in Tibet, with only 11.4 thousand tons of pork. Diary production has increased by almost three times from 157.5 thousand tons in 1990 to 421.9 thousand Before greenhouse technology was adopted in Tibet, vegetable production had been tons in 2017. Milk production was 370.6 thousand tons in 2017. Figure 9 shows the low due to cold night temperatures. The promotion and utilization of greenhouses has livestock production in the main Tibetan prefectures in the Yarlung Tsangpo basin basically solved the climate constraint for vegetable production. In 2011, the area under in 2017. vegetable cultivation grew to 230 million square kilometers. The extent of greenhouses reached over 30 million square kilometers. In 2011, there were 214 green houses in Figure 8. Livestock products in Tibet Ngari prefecture, producing 2,074 tons of vegetables and supplying 50 percent to 80 250 Pork 450 percent of the vegetables in summer25. Output of pork, beef and mutton (thousand tons) Beef 400 Mutton In 2017, over 60 million RMB (approximately 9 million USD) was invested in the 200 Diary Product 350 Mozhu County in Lhasa to build a modern agricultural demonstration park. There are Diary products (thousand tons) 300 over 80 greenhouses in the park, with distribution centers and cold storage centers. 150 250 Peppers, tomatoes, melons and eggplants are the main crops. The park has provided employment for over 80 people and paid an annual dividend of over 2,000 RMB 200 100 (approximately 309 USD) to over 90 poor households26. 150 100 50 50 0 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Figure 9. Animal products in main Tibetan prefectures in the Yarlung Tsangpo Basin in 2017 180000 160000 Animal products (in tons) 140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0 Lhasa Shigatse Nyingchi Shannan Pork Beef Mutton Milk Greenhouses TIBET IS rich in sunlight resources; the Direct Normal Irradiance is the highest among Chinese provinces. The utilization of greenhouses is a major component of agriculture modernization in Tibet. Greenhouses in Tibet are often built for vegetable 190 191 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Highland barley Xiawei Liao TIBETAN HIGHLAND barley, also known as naked barley and hulless barley,27 is the main cereal crop cultivated on the Tibetan Plateau for at least 3,500 years28. It is one of the oldest crops of the world and even likely to be the first crop cultivated by humans29. It is called ‘Qingke’ in Chinese and ‘nas’ in Tibetan. Barley can be categorized by the number of its rows, ie. two-rowed, four-rowed and six-rowed hulless barley. While four-rowed hulless barley is the most common type in Qinghai province of China, six-rowed hulless (or naked) barley has been a major staple food of Tibetans for generations. It is used for food, feed, brewing and medicinal purposes. The sown area of highland barley occupies more than 50 percent of the cultivated land in Tibet30. Highland barley is a very important cereal crop in the Tibetan plateau due to its high level of cold tolerance, short growth period, high yield, early maturity and strong adaptability. Generally, spring barley is sown from March to May and harvested from July to September and the production period is about 100-130 days. The seedling can withstand the temperature of minus 10 degrees centigrade31. Winter barleys are normally sown in October. Highland barley has higher nutritional components than rice, wheat and corn as calcium, phosphorus, iron, copper, zinc, manganese and selenium than corn. It also contains 18 kinds of amino acids, especially the ones that are essential for the human body33. Highland barley has higher nutritional components than rice, wheat and corn. Among food crops, highland barley is characterized by its high protein, high fiber, high vitamin, Tibet has been improving the productivity of highland barley. From 1990 to 2017, low fat and low sugar contents. Hou and Shen32 examined the nutritional contents of the yield of highland barley per square kilometer in Tibet has increased substantially 29 highland barley varieties in China and found that their protein content ranges from from lower than 400 tons to more than 600 tons per year34. Since 2013, Tibet has 8.74 percent to 13.15 percent and fat content ranges from 2.44 percent to 4.48 percent, been promoting the cultivation of the barley variety ‘Zangqing 2000’; by 2016, over 50 differing substantially by varieties. Highland barley also contains oleic acid, linoleic percent of the total barley cultivation comprised of this variety. acid, and linolenic acid and is rich in Vitamins B and C. The soluble fiber and total fiber are higher than other cereal crops. It has a higher content of microelements such 192 193 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND TSAMPA made from Highland Barley is the staple food of Tibetan people. Tsampa is a dough made with roasted barley flour and yak butter. The roasted barley flour is mixed with boiled water or tea, ghee (yak butter) and kneaded into balls. The tsampa served with buttered tea is salty, while the tsampa made into porridge is often sweet. Tibetan people eat tsampa at every meal, and bring it along as a ready-made meal when traveling. The tsampa not only provides nutrition but also fortifies the people to withstand the cold climate. 194 195 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND SIANG BASIN Vasudha Pangare WHEN THE Yarlung-Tsangpo leaves China and enters India, the section of the river before it becomes known as the Brahmaputra, is called Siang. The Siang basin is divided into four agroclimatic zones ranging from an altitude of above 3,500 meters above sea level to below 900 meters above sea level. Shifting cultivation or jhum and settled agriculture on terraces and flat land are the two main agricultural systems in the mountain regions below 3,500 meters. Settled agriculture is both rainfed and irrigated. Crops Siang basin has a plant agrobiodiversity which supports the cultivation of about 70 crop species. Crop biodiversity is the main characteristic of the food supply system, contributing to its sustainability. About 134 plant species35 are consumed by the people in this region. The agroclimatic zones and hilly terrain of the basin is conducive to the cultivation of spices, aromatic and medicinal plants, flowers, and mushroom. More than 80 percent of the crop production is organic is nature, cultivated without the use of chemical fertilizers and agrochemicals. Data available for the year 2017-201836 indicates that 81 percent of the cropped area is under organic practice. There are two cropping seasons in the Siang Basin, monsoon or kharif (southwesterly monsoon season from July to October) and winter or rabi (post-monsoon season or winter season from October to March). Upland rice is the main crop and is grown in association with maize, finger millet, beans, tapioca, potato, ginger, mustard, and large cardamom. Sweet potato, cotton, tobacco, chilli, sesame and off-season vegetables are also grown. In general, the productivity is highest for rice in both the seasons. The production of pulses is 20 percent more in the rabi season37. Thirty-five percent of the net cropped area was under double cropping during the Mithun in cropping seasons in 2016-201738. Out of the total rainfed cropped area, 54 percent was Siang basin Indigenous under settled agriculture and 46 percent was under shifting cultivation. Approximately pig breed in 17 percent of the gross cropped area was irrigated. Out of the total irrigated area, 46 Siang Basin percent was flat land and 54 percent was terraced. The nature of the terrain makes it difficult to install large irrigation systems in the region. Many traditional, community- based irrigation systems are still in use. These systems channel water from mountain streams and rivulets to the fields for irrigation purposes. Livestock Among the different species of livestock, yak, dzo-dzomo and sheep are reared mainly in high altitude alpine and temperate pastures and grazing lands. Mithun are reared almost all across the basin. The livestock census of 2012 shows a high increase in mithun population39. Cattle, goats and pigs are also reared in all parts of the basin except buffaloes which are found in warmer climates in the lower reaches of the basin. Pig rearing is a popular and traditional occupation since time immemorial. Most of the pigs reared are indigenous breeds. Pork constitutes 60 percent of the total food of animal origin consumed by the local population. 196 197 THE RESTLESS RIVER Apatani fish-rice area in the villages of Hing, Siro and cultivation40 Ziro. The fields are separated by 0.6 meters high earthen dams supported Ganesh Pangare by bamboo frames. These dams serve to hold water and soil in the fields. THE APATANI tribe lives on the Ziro Millet is grown on these dams in order plateau located at an elevation of 1,572 to strengthen them. Bamboo and pine meters above sea level in the Lower are planted around the fields. Since Subansiri part of the Siang Basin. the fields are located in valleys, the This plateau lies between the Kamala, soil remains fertile due to the nutrient Khru and Panior ranges in the Eastern wash-out from the hill slopes. Fertility Himalayas. Traditional varieties of is maintained due to the manure which The Apatani rice, Amo and Mipa, under wet rice is available from the waste occurring system of rice cultivation, rainfed millet, maize, swine, from the pisiculture which is practiced cultivation is not poultry and fish are the important in the rice fields and from the manure found anywhere components of this unique agricultural of domestic animals. Refuge from else in the world. system. homesteads is also used; channels The preservation leading to the field carry refuse along of biodiversity The knowledge of the traditional wet with the rainwater from the habitation life of these springs and streams is the systems and women contribute in the area is rice cultivation system has been passed to the fields. closely dependent upon the health most of the labour required for closely linked down from generation to generation. of the catchment from where they maintaining the channels. with the practice Using natural gradients and contours The rice fields are irrigated by an originate. The catchment has a good of the Apatani to prepare and cultivate the fields and intricate system of channels and ducts forest cover which is being preserved In the 1950s the Apatanis initiated an rice farming irrigate them, this farming system which carry water from the Kele river by the community. Water is distributed innovative method of fish-rice farming, system covers about 30 square kilometers of and the streams that flow into it. The through a management system in which fish is cultivated within the that ensures irrigation equitably to rice fields. Small pits are dug in the rice fields located in the upstream and fields, filled with water and fingerlings downstream areas. After the upper are put in these pits. During the fields receive their share of the water, monsoon the fields are kept submerged the outlet channel is opened so that with 5 to 10 cms of water. The fish move the next series of fields receive water. around in the entire submerged area. If This method is followed until the water is scarce, the fish return to the pits last field is reached. However, in this and grow there. process it takes some time for the water to reach the tail end. During The Apatani system of rice cultivation this time the lower fields have to is not found anywhere else in the world. remain without water. To overcome Research has proved that the system is this problem, a separate channel at the highly efficient and helps to preserve the head is made from the mainstream ecosystem in which it is practiced. The through which water is diverted to farming system is still largely organic in fields located at the tail end. The nature. The preservation of biodiversity place where the channel separates is in the area is closely linked with the called a boring. The community takes practice of the Apatani rice farming collective responsibility to maintain system. 198 199 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND jhum and hence diligently observe strict cultivation phase is a rich repository of fallow management practices even as agro-biodiversity with an average of over JHUM CYCLE they clear a plot for cultivation. Plot 40 crops being grown, including diverse preparation begins towards end November landraces of each crop. On a landscape December-January or early December when vegetation is level, shifting cultivation systems comprise selection of new plots based on presence/absence of carefully cleared from a pre-designated of rich agro-biodiversity living gene some selective vegetation, type of soil, and the crop to regenerating fallow. Branches of tall trees banks, interspersed with a mosaic of be grown, followed by cutting and slashing are lopped, while others are felled at different aged regenerating fallow forests. January-February breast height and the trunk left standing Viewed from this perspective, shifting burning of slash and distribution of ash in the field; SHIFTING CULTIVATION for coppicing after the first rains. Tree cultivation, therefore, is not just an sowing of early rice and other location-based crops. stubs and roots of selected plants are left agricultural practice, but one that includes February-March Jhum: a misunderstood undisturbed and together, these plant a sequential forest management practice terracing of steep slopes and higher areas, preparing practice parts regenerate into new shoots at the onset of rains and as cultivation proceeds, at the landscape level. Ignorance of this view attempting to replace the practice has contours with half burnt old logs, weeds, stems, etc. and sowing of maize setting the process of forest regeneration encouraged the promotion of wet terraces March-April Dhrupad Choudhury into motion. The slashed biomass is left and permanent plantations at the cost of sowing of some vegetables mainly in the boundaries, to dry for about two months after which regenerating fallows, effectively shortening and tuber varieties along the peripheries that act as live SHIFTING CULTIVATION is the useful parts are retrieved from the plot for fallow cycles and permanently changing fence for protection against animals predominant agricultural practice in firewood, building houses, fencing and the landcover. The approach has resulted April-May most of the catchment areas of the timber and the remaining debris set afire in erosion of forest cover and depletion weeding and sowing of paddy by women with Siang and Brahmaputra basins. Locally towards end February or early March. of the rich agro-diversity in the process, minimum soil disturbance known as jhum, the practice traditionally Fire is used to convert the biomass into severely restricting opportunities for October-November consisted of a short cultivation phase of ash and nutrients, hastening the process harnessing the diverse agro-germplasm harvesting, grain kept aside for seed one or two years – though exceptions of decomposition, while also helping to as building blocks for tomorrow’s stress exist and a cultivation phase of 4-5 control weeds and pests by killing off seeds tolerant crops, or for safeguarding forests years is also known - followed by a long and propagules of weeds, and eggs and and the ecosystem services rendered by Shifting fallow phase of over 25 years, sufficient larvae of pests through the intense heat them, both essential for adapting to the cultivation is to allow for rejuvenation of the soil generated during burning. Post burning, growing challenges resulting from a sequential and regeneration of the fallow into seeds of legumes, cucurbits, vegetables, climate change. agricultural mature secondary forests. Common spices and some cereals are dibbled into and forest perceptions of the practice view it as the soil while others, particularly upland management subsistence, economically unviable paddy, millets and oilseeds are broadcast system that is and environmentally destructive. This onto the slopes, thus following a ‘zero practiced on perception views shifting cultivation solely tillage’ practice. After cultivation for a the same plot as an agricultural practice and strives to year or two, the jhumiya moves to clear a of land but replace it with settled agriculture. This fresh fallow, leaving the cultivated fields separated view overlooks the fact that shifting to rejuvenate and regenerate into fallow in time cultivation is a sequential agricultural forests. Jhumiyas move to a new plot every and forest management system that is second or third year in order to conserve practiced on the same plot of land but soil nutrients and not ‘bleed Mother Earth separated in time. dry’ - a move misinterpreted by scientists to indicate the depletion of soil nutrients. Shifting cultivators, or jhumiyas know that fallow forests are the backbone of A shifting cultivation landscape, in the 200 201 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Jhum: A cultural tradition Vasudha Pangare SHIFTING CULTIVATION or jhum is an age-old practice constituting a vital part of the socio-economic framework of tribal life. Jhum cultivation is not just a source of livelihood but is traditionally allied to the culture, customs and ethnicity of the people. Each stage and activity in the jhum cycle is associated with festivals and rituals, as indicated in location-specific traditional calendars of events. A shifting Shifting cultivation is important for cultivation ensuring food security, as in addition to landscape, in staple foods like rice and tubers, maize the cultivation and millet, a broad range of vegetables phase is a rich and herbs as well as a large number of repository of medicinal plants are grown in fields and agro-biodiversity fallows. Many varieties of rice are grown and is important in the jhum fields. Various crops are for ensuring grown on the contour bunds constructed food security with bamboo for soil conservation. Some farmers cultivate cash crops like turmeric, ginger and large cardamom for commercial purpose. Rice is also used for making local beer. Indigenous women perform 70 percent of the work related to shifting cultivation41. They are responsible for the selection of seeds, for weeding the fields, gathering, processing, and selling the surplus products. Men a sharp stick and two-three seeds are sesame and vegetables. Men broadcast cultivation cycle. Indigenous women do the identification of land suitable dropped into the hole. This technique seeds of crops like millets and small possess a rich knowledge of seeds, crop for shifting cultivation and the land involves minimum soil disturbance millets. varieties and medicinal plants, and preparation, women help in clearing and requires expertise and practice. transfer this knowledge to the younger the land. Sowing is done by women The dibbling and sowing of seeds are Both men and women make the generation. Indigenous women preserve using the dibbling technique in which done exclusively by women, usually firebreaks, harvest the crops, and seeds and play a key role in preserving a small hole is made with the help of for crops such as maize, pulses, cotton, conduct the rituals during the shifting agrobiodiversity. 202 203 THE RESTLESS RIVER BRAHMAPUTRA BASIN Vasudha Pangare FROM THE Siang Basin, the river enters the state of Assam. The section of the river that flows Livestock through Assam is known as the Brahmaputra. The contributes to Brahmaputra basin is situated between the hill food and crop ranges of the eastern and north-eastern Himalayan production for range in Eastern India. There are five agroclimatic smallholder zones in the Brahmaputra basin. Shifting farming cultivation is practiced in the hill temperate zone. households and Wet rice cultivation and tea cultivation are the are important main systems in the valley zones; rice is the main as savings, as a staple crop and tea is the main cash crop. Tea is source of daily grown in four agroclimatic valley zones. Assam is cash income, known for its tea gardens, and the world-renowned and as insurance Assam tea gets its distinctive flavour from the soil against adversity, and climate of the Brahmaputra valley. particularly in the face of climate Crops uncertainties Five crop combination systems of rice, maize, potato, vegetables and oilseed are found in the fertile alluvial plains of the Brahmaputra Basin. This region is also the second largest producer of Jute in India. Jute is cultivated in an area of 75,140 hectares with an average yield of 1,923 kilograms per hectare. Rice is a three-season crop; autumn, winter and summer42. Autumn rice is called Ahu and is usually sown in February–March and harvested in July–August. Winter rice or Sali Livestock is sown in July–August and harvested in November–December. Summer rice or Boro Almost 90 per cent of the rural households keep indigenous livestock of one species is sown in November–December and harvested in March–April. Boro is considered a or the other; cattle, buffalo, sheep, goat, pig, poultry47. Livestock contributes to low-risk rice with 30 to 40 percent higher yield43. Data for 2016-201744 shows that the food and crop production for smallholder farming households and are important average yield of Ahu (autumn) rice cultivation was 1,380 kilograms per hectare, the as savings, as a source of daily cash income, and as insurance against adversity, average yield of Sali (winter) was 2,023 kilograms per hectare, and the average yield of particularly in the face of climate uncertainties. Animal traction is still used. Cattle Boro (summer) rice was 2,773 kilograms per hectare. and buffalo are important for agricultural operations whereas milk production is secondary. Agriculture in the valley is challenged by floods and high rainfall, particularly in the kharif (monsoon) season. The State Agriculture Department45 promotes rabi (winter) There are pockets of nomadic systems of cattle rearing, mostly in the fringes of crops by developing irrigation facilities through the installation of Pump Sets (Shallow the forests. In recent years, farmers have begun to keep improved livestock and Tube Well & Low Lift Pump). Assured irrigation has been effective in raising cropping commercial poultry. Livestock is largely fed on crop residues, and food waste. intensity to 146 percent46. High-producing animals are given concentrated grain-based feed as supplements. 204 205 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Coping with floods access to institutional credit are found to be more successful in this strategy. This apart, the farms with a diversified cropping pattern have been able to extract more returns Raju Mandal by compensating for losses in output of one or two crops by others that do not suffer such losses. These coping mechanisms by the farmers in the flood plains of Assam have ASSAM IS home to a large network of rivers. The rivers Brahmaputra and Barak, and important policy relevance for attaining and maintaining a higher growth rate of the their tributaries play an important role in the lives and livelihoods of people in the agriculture sector and making farming a remunerative profession in the state. plains of the state. Because of its unique geological location in the foothills of the Himalayas the abundance of monsoon precipitations and fertile alluvial soil deposition by the rivers during rainy season have enabled majority of the population to depend on cultivation as the principal source of livelihood for generations. However, being located in a heavy rainfall zone, excessive precipitations in the state and upper catchment areas during monsoon cause widespread water logging and flood—sometimes four to five times in a year—in the plain areas of the state. The plains of Assam, covering 81 percent of total geographical area and accommodating 97 percent of total population of the state, are highly prone to floods48. The flood-proneness of Assam is around four times the national figure as 39.58 percent of total area of the state is flood-prone compared to the corresponding national figure of 10.2 percent49. Although flood is a known and regular annual phenomenon in Assam, its varying timing, intensity and frequency pose a great risk and uncertainty particularly for the crop growing sector. Floods in the early phase of the monsoon mainly damage the Ahu seasonal type of paddy. But floods occurring late in the season are most devastating as they damage the standing Sali paddy, which happens to be the main kharif (monsoon) crop of the state. Apart from causing instability in production, occurrence of frequent Although flood floods is one of the factors responsible for low rate of adoption of modern techniques is a known and of agricultural production. regular annual phenomenon Notwithstanding the fact that the agriculture sector of Assam is highly exposed to flood in Assam, its risk every year, more than half of its workforce still depends on it for their livelihoods. varying timing, Naturally the question arises as to how the farmers in the state are surviving in the face intensity and of flood induced production risks while they do not have any institutional safeguards frequency pose like crop insurance. In this regard Goyari50 and Mandal51 using district level aggregated a great risk and data have found that the attempt to minimize production risk arising out of recurring uncertainty floods has led many farmers to adjust the cropping pattern and/or season as a result of particularly which there has been a decline in the acreage shares of kharif (monsoons) food grains for the crop that are largely affected by flood, and a corresponding increase in the acreage shares growing sector of rabi (winter) food grains and vegetables. Such adaptations by the farmers have been possible particularly after the introduction of privately-owned shallow tube well based irrigation system in the state in the mid-1990s52. Analysis of farm level data and interactions with farm households by Mandal53 reveals that the farmers who are exposed to greater risk arising from floods tend to adopt a cropping pattern that is more diversified across crops and seasons to hedge against flood induced risks and limitations in agriculture. Farmers with better irrigation facilities and 206 207 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND MANAS BASIN wetland agricultural areas is rice followed by wheat and mustard. Citrus (mandarin orange) plantation in the lower altitude and cardamom in the higher elevations are Kinlay Tshering and Vasudha Pangare the main cash crops. In the sloped dryland agricultural areas, maize, millet, mustard, several types of legumes, ginger and vegetables are the predominant crops. THE MANAS river, flowing through Bhutan is an international tributary of the Brahmaputra river.54. Agricultural production Agriculture56 is one of the Five Jewels of the Economic Development Policy57 of Bhutan. Bhutan is broadly divided into six major agroecological zones55 corresponding with In 2017, the crop sector contributed about 10.64 percent of the total Renewable Natural altitude range and climatic conditions, for the purpose of agricultural planning. At Resources sector contribution to the country’s Gross Domestic Product. Agriculture higher altitudes, livestock rearing is the most common source of livelihood, with some provides employment to 57.2 percent of the total population58. Although only 2.75 dryland farming. In the lower altitudes, agriculture is widely practiced in terraced percent of the total land is under cultivation59, agriculture production in Bhutan has irrigated wetlands and drylands. The main crop cultivated in the terraced irrigated made significant contribution to enhance food and nutrition security and reduce Terraced The main crop rice fields in cultivated in Bhutan the terraced irrigated wetland agricultural areas is rice followed by wheat and mustard 208 209 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND rural poverty. Rice is the major crop associated with food security and has cultural About 2,650 households have been supported by the National Organic Programme to significance for the people of Bhutan. It symbolizes a way of life and epitomizes practice organic agriculture on 2,250 hectares of agricultural land. Training, inputs, environmental and landscape beauty. infrastructure, equipment, product development and marketing support have been provided to the households. Twenty-four farmer groups/cooperatives have been With an average farm size of 0.89 hectares60, often spread over different agro-ecological formed. Three retailers, and one exporter support the production and marketing of zones and altitudes, most farmers practice subsistence to semi-subsistence integrated organic produce. Three organic manure production plants have been established to farming systems. In many parts of the country, farmers continue to depend on the supply bio-inputs for organic production. monsoon rains, which have become ever more erratic and unreliable. Though the country is blessed with many river systems, their use in agriculture had been limited The Local Organic Assurance System (LOAS) certification was established in Rice is the major due to unavailability of appropriate technology to tap irrigation potential. In 2017, 2017 for locally produced organic products. In collaboration with National crop associated assured irrigation covered about 27,500 hectares of cultivated land. In an effort to Certification Body (BAFRA) and International Certification Body (IMO) for with food security reduce irrigation water scarcity, 212 water harvesting reservoirs were constructed on organic certification, 10 products have been certified including potato, garlic and and has cultural cost sharing basis at various locations. carrot from Gasa, turmeric from Zhemgang, seabuckthorn, chamomile, mint from significance for the Bumthang, Green Tea from Trongsa, and rhododendron and lemongrass essential people of Bhutan. Approximately 90 percent of rural farmers raise some form of livestock61 for dairy oils from Mongar. It symbolizes products, draught power, meat, and dung. For most small holder farmers, livestock a way of life provide a ready source of income to help purchase the necessary inputs for crop A flagship program on organic agriculture was approved for implementation in and epitomizes production such as seeds and fertilizers. Most agro pastoralists graze their livestock the Twelfth Five Year Plan (2018-2023), to commercialize organic production for environmental and in nearby forests and keep them in sheds during the night. Dung is used for crop export and domestic market, and to make organic inputs available in the country landscape beauty production, greatly reducing or eliminating the use of chemical fertilizers. Cattle is on a larger scale. most preferred because of its multiple uses. Poultry is raised for eggs and pigs for meat. Horses are used for traction and transport. Over the last decade, farming in Bhutan has seen a dynamic shift from subsistent to commercialized farming. Farm mechanization has been promoted with power tillers and mini tillers, and rural accessibility has been improved. The major interventions that have triggered this transition process are investments in irrigation and farm roads; electric fencing to protect crops from wildlife damages (3,492 kilometers of electric fencing was installed across the country); development and promotion of high yielding crop varieties and protected cultivation; focused commodity approach, agricultural land development including sustainable land management practices and provision of essential support services including market infrastructures62. A total of 841 different post-production structures were established to reduce post-harvest losses and add value to agricultural produce. Organic agriculture63 The Ministry of Agriculture and Forests launched the National Framework for Organic Farming in 2006. The inherently organic nature of Bhutanese farming systems guided the evolution of the country’s development of organic agriculture. The approach and strategies promoted conservative, sustainable, self-sustaining, resilient production systems that prevented exploitation of ecosystems and sustainable use of natural resources. Under the National Organic Programme, about 10,387 hectares of land is currently under organic management, out of which 7,837.5 hectares comprises forest land certified for collection of various Non-Wood Forest Products. 210 211 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND TEESTA BASIN Vasudha Pangare THE TEESTA River originates in the Himalayas and flows through the Indian States of Sikkim and West Bengal before joining the Jamuna in Bangladesh. Flowing through the length of Sikkim, the Teesta River is considered to be the lifeline of the state. The basin has four agroclimatic zones. Shifting cultivation, terraced agriculture and subsistence agriculture are the main agricultural systems. The hilly terrain and difficulty in access to markets has made villages self sufficient; most households are engaged in subsistence agriculture, and produce food grains for home consumption, with shortfalls being met by supplies under the public distribution system64. Milk is traded across the rural areas, in outside markets as well as in the milk cooperative society areas. Milk constitutes a major source of household income. Meat markets are local, confined to village clusters both in the case of beef and chevon. Eggs Shifting are traded among village clusters but the poultry meat is kept for home consumption65. cultivation, terraced Crops agriculture Sikkim is rich in biodiversity with abundant plant species because of which the soil is and subsistence rich in organic matter content and makes the nutrient conversion easier. Sustainable agriculture farming practices that conserve and maintain the fragile ecosystem are important are the main for soil and ecosystem protection. A variety of crops can be produced because of the agricultural varied agroclimatic conditions in the basin. Most of the agriculture is organic and has systems. Most of traditionally been in practice since ages66. the agriculture is organic and Agricultural holdings are spread between an elevation of 300 to 3,000 meters. Farming has traditionally is done in about 10.20 percent67 of the total geographical area of the state. Most of the been in practice cultivable lands are terraced. Marginal holdings and small holdings together comprise since ages about 50 percent of all operational holdings and occupy 41 percent of the total area. Agriculture is largely rainfed with traditional system of cultivation and low inputs. Due to topographical features, medium/major irrigation projects are not feasible and therefore only minor irrigation channels are installed. About 11 percent68 of the cultivated area is irrigated. Traditional communities in the upper reaches of the basin, in the cool temperate and lower alpine zones between 2,500 to 4,000 meters, grow wheat, barley, and seasonal vegetables such as beans, potato, cabbage, cauliflower, and radish in the summer when the snow melts. Large cardamom-based and farm-based traditional agroforestry can be found in the subtropical to warm temperate zones at an elevation between 600 and 2,500 meters. Wet rice cultivation is practiced in terraces and along river valleys in the tropical zone at an elevation greater than 500 meters. Other crops include maize, buckwheat, urad (black lentil) rice bean, soybean and 212 213 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND mustard. Orange and pears are the main horticultural crops; ginger, cardamom, turmeric and cherry pepper are the main spice crops; peas, bean, tomato, potato are the main vegetable crops. Off-season vegetables are being cultivated extensively. In recent years, a large number of farmers have adopted floriculture as a commercial venture and the cultivation of flowers like cymbidium, rose, gerbera, anthurium is generating a good income. Livestock Livestock production had always been an integral part of the rural livelihoods in Sikkim and is predominantly the endeavour of small producers69. Marginal and small farmers own nearly 85 percent of all species of livestock and poultry, even though they own or operate less than 55 percent of the farmland in Sikkim. Even the tiny organised poultry industry in Sikkim is made up of small broiler farms. Over 80 percent of all rural households own livestock (often a mix of several species) as part of the traditional mixed crop-livestock farming system, earning substantial incomes and enriching family diets with nutrient rich animal products. Income from livestock is thus a substantial contribution to the subsistence farming systems in Sikkim. d JAMUNA BASIN Jamuna basin The Brahmaputra River flows through the Indian state of Assam and enters Bangladesh is one of the after the Assamese town of Dhubri. In Bangladesh the river is known as the Jamuna three major and is the last stretch of the river system before it meets the Ganges river. river systems of Bangladesh. The Agriculture basin is often characterized as Md. Ayub Hossain a granary or the Jamuna basin is often characterized as a granary or the breadbasket of Bangladesh. breadbasket of Agriculture systems in the basin Agriculture or farming remains the mainstay of the people of this region. The crop the country Jamuna basin is one of the three major river systems of Bangladesh. Brahmaputra- profile includes multiple crops such as rice, cereals and cash crops such as sugarcane, Jamuna and old Brahmaputra with their main tributary Teesta and a good number oilseeds, pulses, and tobacco. Besides these, many fruits, vegetables and spices are also of small tributaries and distributaries constitute the largest floodplain of Bangladesh. grown. The Brahmaputra-Jamuna drains the northern and eastern slopes of the Himalayas and has a catchment area of 5,83,000 square kilometers70. The administrative districts Agroforestry is a popular and widely practiced intervention in Jamuna basin. of Panchagarh, Thakurgaon, Dinajpur, Kurigram, Rangpur, Nilphamari, Lalmonirhat, Agroforestry is commonly practiced in establishment of fruit orchards especially in Gaibandha, Joypurhat, Naogaon, Rajshahi, Bogura, Shirajganj, Pabna, Jamalpur, early stages of plantation (1-3 years). Some shade crops like turmeric, ginger, and Mymensingh, Narayanganj, Munshiganj, Manikganj and Dhaka are included in the grasses, are cultivated in this area. Social forestry73 is generally practiced by 39.4 Jamuna basin71. The land of Jamuna basin is alluvial soil and it is fertile. Jamuna basin percent of farmers for fuelwood, fruits, and timber. About 24.6 percent of households consists of eight agro ecological zones. The total area of the Jamuna basin is 3,962,077 also practice roadside plantation, about 11.8 percent are involved in embankment hectares which is 27.67 percent of the total land area of Bangladesh72. cropping74_75. 214 215 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Figure 10. Agricultural production in Bangladesh in 2018-19 area and 41.15 percent triple cropped area. The area and production of maize in Jamuna basin is increasing day by day. Farmers are cultivating mainly hybrid maize80. About 60 40.00 percent of total maize production in the country is in Jamuna basin81. 36.28 35.00 Irrigation systems 30.00 The farmers of Jamuna basin practice multiple cropping system, hence the fields get irrigated more than once a year. The sum of these multiple gross irrigated areas is about Production (in million tons) (Egg in billion number) 25.00 4.24 million hectares82. About 80 percent of Jamuna basin area is irrigated. Government 20.00 organizations such as Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation, Barind 17.11 Multipurpose Development Authority and Bangladesh Water Development Board 15.00 10.03 9.92 10.00 7.51 The soil of 5.00 4.18 4.95 4.27 3.38 3.86 Jamuna basin is 1.09 2.60 1.60 The positive 0.38 1.03 comparatively 0.00 benefit of Rice Wheat Maize Pulses Oilseeds Spices Sugarcrops Jute Fruits Vegetables Tuber crp[s Fish Meat Milk Egg more fertile than increasing use other regions of of groundwater the country. Most irrigation is Agricultural produces area of the basin that almost the is suitable for whole region agricultural crop Crop production in the basin has achieved production The soil of Jamuna basin is comparatively more fertile than other regions of the food self- country. Most area of Jamuna basin is suitable for agricultural crop production. There sufficiency and are three main seasonal types of rice grown in Jamuna basin; aus, aman and boro has contributed rice. Aus is a pre-monsoon rainfed crop, aman is a rainy season rice, whereas boro is significantly to irrigated rice grown during the dry winter season (January through May). Transplanted rural wealth aman and boro rice are grown all over the Jamuna Basin. Aus rice is cultivated in some creation locations. Due to its higher yield potential (3.4 tons ha-1) compared to aus (1.6 tons tons ha-1) and aman (2.0 tons ha-1), boro rice production has expanded in the last three are involved in executing some big irrigation projects. The country enjoys tropical decades76. Boro rice is widely cultivated, contributing about 55 percent of the overall monsoon climate with two prominent seasons; dry season (November-May) and wet rice production77. season (June-October). Up to 85 percent of the annual rainfall occurs between June and September. Mean annual rainfall ranges from about 1,200 millimeters in the west The main field crops in Jamuna basin are cereals (rice, wheat, maize, millets, etc.), to almost 6,000 millimeters in the northeast83. In Jamuna basin about 88 percent land pulses (lentil, grasspea, chickpea, mungbean and blackgram, etc.) oilseeds (mustard, is irrigated by groundwater and rest is irrigated by surface water. The positive benefit of groundnut, sesame, sunflower, etc.), vegetables (Potato, radish, tomato, brinjal, sweet increasing use of groundwater irrigation is that almost the whole region has achieved gourd, pumpkin, bittergourd, pointed gourd, snake gourd, leafy vegetables, etc.) and food self-sufficiency and has contributed significantly to rural wealth creation84. spices (onion, chilli, garlic, ginger, turmeric, etc.). Different types of local and exotic fruits are grown in different seasons. Irrigation is applied first in Boro rice and vegetable cultivation and then for wheat, maize, oilseeds and spices. Aman rice is mainly cultivated under rainfed condition, About 200 cropping patterns are followed in this region. The cropping intensity (211 but sometimes supplementary irrigation is required if monsoon rain is not sufficient. percent) is higher than the national average (195 percent) of the country78. As a whole Shallow tubewells and deep tubewells are the major groundwater lifting devices in the crop diversity index of Jamuna basin is 0.90 which indicates a high crop diversity79. Jamuna Basin area. There are also low lift pumps for surface water irrigation, but their The region includes 7.58 percent single cropped area, 48.09 percent double cropped numbers are insignificant and concentrated near the river and irrigation canal. About 216 217 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND dominated by carps (indigenous and exotic), pangas and tilapia. The aquaculture production both in fresh water and brackish water has significantly increased during the last two and a half decades with development of technology. Inland fishery in Jamuna basin is composed of rivers, beel and ponds. The beel is a Bengali term used for a relatively large surface, static waterbody that accumulates surface run-off water through an internal drainage channel90. The most famous beel in the country known as the Chalan beel is located in Jamuna basin. In the Jamuna basin, 86 percent of total production of inland fish91 is from aquaculture. Major inland fishes in Jamuna basin are major carp (Rui, Catla, Mrigal), minor carp (Kalibaus, Bata, Ghania, etc.) exotic Carp (Silver Carp, Grass Carp, Common Carp, Mirror Carp, Big Head Carp, Black Carp, etc.), cat fish (Boal, Air, Silon, Rita, etc.), snake head (Shoil, Gazar, Taki), live fish (Koi, Singhi, Magur, etc.) and small fish (Mola, Dhela, Punti, Khoilsha, etc.) The major stakeholders of aquaculture include fish farmer, hatchery owner, farm/hatchery technicians/workers, input (feed ingredient, fertilizer, hormone, chemical, instrument etc.) importers/suppliers, feed mill owners, homestead feed The aquaculture producer, fisher, fish processor, fish transporter, wholesaler, exporter, retailer, consumer, production both technology provider (government and non-government) and many more92. in fresh water and brackish Almost 58 percent of the lifted water is used for boro rice cultivation and the rest is used for Livestock production water has all rural irrigating other crops. About 68 percent of the groundwater is lifted from shallow Livestock is an integral component of the complex farming system in Bangladesh as it not significantly households tubewells and rest from deep tubewells85. These pumps are operated by diesel engine, only serves as a source of meat protein but is also a major source of farm power services increased rear livestock electric power and a few by solar energy. Solar irrigation pump is a new and emerging as well as employment93. The livestock sub-sector provides full time employment for during the last irrigation technology and is becoming popular in Jamuna basin. There are about 1,600 20 percent of the total population and part-time employment for another 50 percent two and a half solar irrigation pumps operating in Bangladesh, among them about 60 percent are in of the total population94. The poultry meat alone contributes a substantial 37 percent decades with Jamuna basin86. Most of the irrigation pumps are used on custom hire basis. of the total meat production in Bangladesh. The GDP contribution of this sub-sector development of has been a modest 1.47 percent and the share of livestock in agricultural GDP is 13.62 technology Fisheries and aquaculture percent95. Livestock species available in Bangladesh are the most versatile in relation to The fisheries sector, in Bangladesh, plays a crucial role among the poor as a main or existing integrated agricultural farming system. About 24.5 million heads of cattle are additional source of employment, livelihood and income. The sector is the second largest distributed in Jamuna basin. About 85 percent of cattle are indigenous in origin and part-time and fulltime employer in rural areas. Bangladesh produced 4.27 million tons rest of them are Red Chattogram, Pabna, North Bengal Grey and Munshiganj96. of fish during 2017-18 from inland and marine waterbodies and aquaculture contributed more than 50 percent of the total production87. Fisheries accounts for 3.69 percent of About 98 percent households in Jamuna basin keep cows and population of cows is Bangladesh GDP, 22.60 percent of agriculture sector and 2.5 percent of total export 3.3 per household. Buffalo and sheep in this area are very small in number. About 16 earnings. It also contributes 60 percent of the animal protein intake in Bangladesh. percent households keep goats with an average size of 2.9 per sheep keeper household97. Bangladeshi people largely depend on fish to meet their protein needs88. Until the 70s, About 33 percent of households are involved in semi-scavenger housing for goat, duck, there was an abundance of fish in the natural waters-the floodplain, rivers, rivulets, and hen rearing as climate-resilient practice for livestock rearing in Jamuna basin. beels, lakes, ditches and canals of the country to satisfy the demand of fish. Presently, capture fish production has declined to about 50 percent, with a negative trend of 1.24 About 2.90 million tons of meat and 4.23 million tons of milk are produced in Jamuna percent per year89. basin. The eggs produced from both local and commercial brides of poultry and ducks in this area are 46.56 million98. The dairy and poultry farms have grown rapidly In the past the major source of fish production in Bangladesh was the inland open in this area. Almost all rural households rear local poultry and ducks for their own water capture fisheries. Now aquaculture has become an emerging sector of fisheries in consumption. Sometimes the housewife of a household sells excess poultry, duck and Bangladesh. Inland pond culture represents the mainstay of aquaculture in Bangladesh, eggs for cash which is used for children’s food and education expenses and to buy accounting more than 80 percent total recorded aquaculture production and presently cosmetics and cheap ornaments. 218 219 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Agriculture in northwest Bangladesh Figure 11. Geographic characteristics of northwest Bangladesh (Source: Peña-Arancibia et al. 2020) Shahriar Wahid, Fazlul Karim and Mohammed Mainuddin Water and agricultural livelihoods In 1974, Bangladesh suffered its worst famine. Acute food shortages resulted in the mass starvation of millions. Successive governments targeted food self-sufficiency as their key strategic development goal. The outcomes have been most encouraging. Today, the country is mostly food self-sufficient99 and one of the largest rice producers in the world. The noted positive achievement of the last few decades has been possible due to water and land management reforms such as widespread adoption of the minor irrigation system, liberalization of the water market, strengthening of extension services, and participation of private and government organizations. However, climate and other environmental changes pose a major challenge to food self- sufficiency. Northwest Bangladesh is a case in point (Figure 11). The region is bordered by two major transboundary rivers - Ganges (called Padma River in Bangladesh) in the Today south and Brahmaputra in the east (called Jamuna River in Bangladesh) and part of the Bangladesh is Ganges-Brahmaputra Basin. It produces thirty-five per cent of the nation’s dry season mostly food self- rice and sixty per cent of wheat and maize100. sufficient and one of the largest Challenges of declining surface water flow in rivers and groundwater table in recent rice producers in times is a serious threat to the livelihoods of millions of farmers101–102. In severely the world dry years, many poor agricultural labourers seek to out-migrate from rural areas to bigger cities in search of better livelihoods options. Past mass internal out-migration of agricultural labourers from greater Rangpur region who did not get a job to survive during the Monga seasons103 is well documented. Repeated episodes of such events can catalyse political unrest and social instability and their impact on rural livelihoods is a source of concern for Bangladesh. Here, we present a first-hand account of the irrigation trend and how it can sustain agricultural growth in the northwest region of Bangladesh. Changing irrigation dynamics Irrigation plays a crucial role in crop production in northwest Bangladesh. It scales down crop loss, allows multiple and high yielding variety cropping and reduces excessive dependence on rainfall. Both surface and groundwater were used for irrigation in the region. However, surface water availability in the major rivers of northwest Bangladesh started to decline three decades ago. Dey et al104 reported that the yearly mean river water flow has reduced by about fifty per cent on an average in major regional rivers since 1980. The worst-hit districts are Dinajpur, Rangpur, Bogra and Rajshahi. Shortage of surface water from rivers, ponds, and canals during the dry season forced the farmers to rely on groundwater to irrigate farmland, found within 4-8 meters below the ground surface, to cope with the intermittent surface water supply. The government 220 221 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND of Bangladesh supported the farmers to adopt groundwater irrigation by lifting the more than two crops a year, with up to four crops in some areas. Peña-Arancibia et restriction on irrigation pump standardization, allowing import and operation by al106 estimated a large increase in the area planted with Boro (dry season) rice (from the private sector and subsidizing farmers’ energy consumption to lift groundwater. 116,007 hectares to 1,598,105 hectares) and a large decrease in the area of the early Strong institutional support was provided by several agencies including Bangladesh wet season (Aus) rice (from 954,226 hectares to 225,190 hectares). Cultivation of Boro Agriculture Development Corporation and Barind Multipurpose Development rice requires a higher amount of water and a longer period to irrigate compared to Aus Agency and large national projects like National Minor Irrigation Development crops and transition to Boro rice cultivation comes at the cost of substantially more Project under the Ministry of Agriculture. This has resulted in a drastic increase in irrigation. Additionally, farmers increasingly plant potatoes, wheat, maize, oilseeds the ratio of surface water and groundwater use for total irrigated agriculture in the and pulses during the dry season. last two decades. Today, about ninety-five percent of the irrigation water in northwest Bangladesh comes from groundwater105. Access to cheap groundwater has changed Unabated promotion and popularity of groundwater irrigation come at a price. The the cropping pattern markedly during the last decades in the region. Farmers grow increasing extraction of groundwater for irrigation without any increase in rainfall 222 223 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND has significantly lowered groundwater table of northwest Bangladesh especially in the The Bangladesh Agriculture Policy116, which called for the use of surface and districts of Rajshahi, Dinajpur, Bogra, Pabna and Rangpur. Rahman et al107 observed groundwater to accelerate crop intensification and increase yield, is a move in the right that dry spells have become more frequent than ever before. The total annual rainfall direction. Efforts need to continue to accelerate and coordinate the activities of various over the region has been continuously reducing in the last three decades directly agencies involved in surface and groundwater irrigation programmes and ensure river impacting aquifer recharge108. Farmers are not able to adequately irrigate their farmland flows in the major rivers many of which are transboundary in nature. Markets need Today, about due to increasing cost of lifting water from a deeper aquifer, and in some years even to be created for non-rice crops and agricultural extension services need to facilitate ninety-five lack adequate drinking water during the dry season. Every year the groundwater farmers’ transition to less water demanding crops. Management approaches such as percent of table remains below the suction lift limit (6 meters) of the suction-mode pumps (e.g. variable and/or crop-specific irrigation rates and efficient irrigation scheduling can the irrigation shallow tube well) in sixty percent of the monitoring wells for about 3 to 6 dry season play an important role in reducing demand. In an era of climatic extremes, planners water in months109. Peña-Arancibia et al110 analysed a large number of (over 1,200) groundwater and farmers will need to augment natural water supply through innovative technology northwest monitoring well data collected by the Bangladesh Water Development Board and as managed aquifer recharges. Transboundary water cooperation will play a crucial Bangladesh reported that during January 1980 to December 2015, groundwater table declined by role to ensure waters in the rivers since many come across international boundaries comes from 0.08 meters every year over the region. In three southern districts of Naogaon, Rajshahi from upstream. groundwater and Nawabganj, the groundwater table fell by 0.2 meters every year. These findings are consistent with other researchers111. Another major reason for the lowering of the groundwater table is declining river flow in the major rivers. Though the surface water-ground water interaction is a complex process, water flows from the Jamuna River to the aquifer (rechange) are about five times higher than the water flows from aquifer to the river (discharge)112. The flow of the transboundary Teesta River is one of the major contributors to groundwater recharge in Dinajpur and Rangpur districts where predominantly silty clay soil has higher hydraulic conductivity113. River flow Sustainable reduction in the major transboundary rivers of the Brahmaputra basin (Jamuna and irrigation Teesta Rivers) in Bangladesh will create more head difference for water to flow from management the aquifer to the river thereby adding to the challenges to groundwater irrigation. will require managing the The falling groundwater table indicates large declines in groundwater storage over time two ostensibly and the northwest region lost about 3.74 km3 of groundwater during 2003-2016114. distinct water Many planners and researchers fear that if groundwater extraction continues to increase sources as one in the future, it will push the groundwater levels down to such levels that it may not get replenished adequately and call to increase the use of surface water irrigation. Kirby et al115 point out that excessive water withdrawal may cause a lower equilibrium level of groundwater aquifer and suggests local level studies to improve the sustainability of irrigation in the region. Sustaining agricultural growth Food self-sufficiency in northwest Bangladesh heavily relies on irrigation. Changing climatic condition such as reducing rainfall, increasing over-reliance on groundwater irrigation and reduction in transboundary river water flow pose serious challenges to planners and farmers alike. No single policy intervention and practice change will be adequate to face the challenge. Past water dynamics clearly highlight the importance of treating surface and groundwater as a hydrologically connected singular source of water and recognising that changes in either affect the other. Sustainable irrigation management will require managing the two ostensibly distinct water sources as one. The government will need to think about reducing irrigation demand through rationalizing less water demanding crops. 224 225 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND TEA Tibetan Tea Xiawei Liao TIBETANS DRINK butter tea every day. Butter tea is made by mixing butter that is made from yak or sheep milk with brick tea and salt. A typical Tibetan breakfast includes butter tea with tsampa, a Tibetan pancake made from highland barley flour. For Tibetans living a nomadic lifestyle with high-fat and low vegetable and low fruit diets, butter tea not only warms up the body against the coldness but also supplements the dietary fibers, helping to break down and digest the oil. According to anecdotal evidence Tibetan monks started to grow tea trees between AD 220 to 280 but did not succeed due to the harsh climate. Modern tea plantations started Butter tea not in 1956 when the army based on Rima County planted 200 tea trees that survived and only warms up thrived. In 1971, Tibetan provincial agriculture and husbandry department imported the body against 0.1 million kilograms of tea tree seeds from Sichuan, Yunnan and Hunan and sowed the coldness but them in over 20 counties at altitude ranging from 1,570 to 3,700 meters above the sea also supplements level. Although most seeds did not survive the cold and harsh climate, tea plantations the dietary started to develop in several counties such as Chayu, Milin, Linzhi, Motuo and Bomi117. fibers. Yigong tea Currently, tea plantations118 in Tibet are mainly located in the Yigong village of the plantation is Bomi county and Motuo county in the Nyingchi prefecture in the Southeastern part the highest tea of the province. Yigong tea plantation is the highest tea plantation in the world. The plantation plantation covers an area of 1.47 sqaure kilometers. In 2013, it produced 3,200 kilograms in the world of Tibetan black tea, 3,600 kilograms of Nyingchi green tea, 900 kilograms of dark tea, 34,000 kilograms of brick tea and 3,000 kilograms of autumn tea. Since 2010, Motuo county has developed 13 highland organic tea plantations with a total area of 2.86 square kilometers. The main tea types are Fuding white tea, Ti kuan yin and pekoe. From 1990 to 2017, the area of tea plantations in Tibet has increased from 149 to 790 hectares119. However, tea production in Tibet is not enough to support the population’s tea consumption, therefore Tibet imports large amount of tea from other provinces in China, such as its neighboring Sichuan. d Assam Tea Pooja Kotoky ASSAM IS the largest contiguous tea-growing area in the world120. Only those teas grown and manufactured in tea estates located in the Brahmaputra valley qualify to be called 226 227 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Assam teas. Both Orthodox and CTC (Crush/ Tear/Curl) varieties of tea are manufactured here. Assam Orthodox Tea is a registered Geographical Indication (GI). The distinctive second flush orthodox Assam teas are valued for their rich taste, bright liquors and are considered to be one of the choicest teas in the world. The Brahmaputra valley with its high rainfall, high humidity, and rich loamy soil provides the perfect environment for growing the tea that is most famous for its strong, smooth and malty taste. Half of India’s tea production comes from Assam. The estimated annual average production of tea in Assam is about 630-700 million kilograms121. The Assam CTC tea auction centre is the world’s largest, and the world’s second largest in terms of total tea auctioned. The Assam is Tocklai Experimental Station, established in 1911, the largest the world’s oldest and largest research station of contiguous tea- its kind, carries out clonal propagation and growing area in constant research in order to retain the flavours of the world. The Assam teas. Assam CTC tea auction centre History of tea in Assam is the world’s The tea industry in Assam is about 172 years old. largest, and the In 1823 Major Robert Bruce discovered wild tea world’s second plants growing in Assam with the help of a local largest in terms noble man, Maniram Dutta Borua ‘Dewan’ in an of total tea adventure and trade trip to Upper Assam by boat. auctioned Maniram Dewan introduced Bruce to Singpho Chief Beesa who presented Bruce his first bowl of wild tea found in the Singpho village near Margherita in Upper Assam. Bruce made an agreement with the Chief to supply some plants and seeds. In the following year Singpho Chief kept his commitment by handing the plants and seeds to Major Robert Bruce’s brother C.A. Bruce who visited Sadiya town. Later these were sent to Dr. N. Wallich, botanist to the East India Company and Superintendent of the Botanical Garden in Calcutta. In 1834, Lord William Bentinck the Governor- General at that time, set up a tea committee to explore and discover new land for tea cultivation in India. The Tea Committee received 228 229 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND communication and reports from Col. Jenkins, the then Commissioner of Assam largely employed to pluck tea leaves, while male employees work in maintenance of estates that the tea plants found in Assam were of indigenous variety. The following year a (including pruning), factory work, pesticide application and weed removal. Women are scientific committee proceeded to Sadiya for research. They ascertained that the tea often paid lower wages than men. plants found in the North Bank of Brahmaputra were of indigenous kind and there was great similarity in the topography and the climatic conditions to that of the Chinese A sizable number of small farmers especially in upper Assam have taken up tea cultivation province of Yunnan, which was known for tea production. during the last 15 years. As per 2016124 data, out of the total number of tea gardens, there were 84,577 small growers with a total area of 78,203 hectares under tea cultivation, and 767 big C.A. Bruce travelled through the length of the Brahmaputra valley and along Buri Dihing growers with a total area of 226,197 hectares under tea cultivation. Total tea produced in 2016 river, and discovered wild tea grown in places such as Phakial, Tingri near Indo-Burma was 642,180 (000) kgs. As of 2017-18, 676,000 tons of tea leaves were produced in 312,000 boarder. With his knowledge of languages and mannerism of the natives he became hectares of land which accounted for 51.7 percent of the total national production of India. instrumental in establishing friendly relations with the hill tribes and their chiefs and transferred forests and waste lands from the tribals to the British Government. Bruce The relative contribution of small growers to tea production is more than 20 percent125 and started plantations at Jaipur and Chabua with the local tribes and set up nurseries at the big gardens purchase a major part of the green leaf production of the small tea growers. Chota Tingrai and Hukanpuki to have large plantation drives by 1840. Using clone varieties of tea seedlings on small holdings, these small and marginal farmers are dependent on their crop as the main source of income. Although these farmers are In order to streamline business operations in Assam and import tea to London, in February challenged by low farm gate prices, limited market channels, poor access to credit and low of 1839 Bengal Tea Association was formed in Calcutta and a joint stock company – Assam levels of farmer organization, the positive aspect of lower production costs is what keeps Company was formed in London. Both the companies were amalgamated as the Assam them going. Some small tea growers have ventured into organic tea cultivation126. Company within the year and became the first private owned tea company to operate Chars or Currently, the in Assam. Initially the company made losses because of the high cost of production but d riverine islands tea plantation started recovering and profiting from 1848. In March of 1841 the first auction sale of formed by the is the largest Assam tea manufactured by Singpho Chief Ningrula and the Government plantation braiding of the employer among took place in Calcutta. Sensing opportunities a number of private enterprises approached AGRICULTURE ON THE CHARS Brahmaputra the organized the Government in London and Calcutta to obtain tea plantations. river, keep sector in Assam, Brahmaputra valley changing in employing about The tea industry started to change after 1850s when George Williamson Senior and his shape and size more than cousins formed Williamson, Magor & Co in 1853 and started private plantations. They Vasudha Pangare due to the effect 6.86 lakh produced 21,000 kgs tea in 200 acres land in 1857. By 1859 there were 160 gardens, 57 of floods and persons daily were privately owned and rest by Assam Company, the Jorehaut Tea Company, The East CHARS OR riverine islands formed by the braiding of the Brahmaputra river, keep changing erosion India Company, the Lower Assam Tea Company and the Central Assam Tea Company. in shape and size due to the effect of floods and erosion. Many of the chars remain stable long enough for vegetation to grow and for settlements to establish. Islands which are stable Although the tea industry has gone through many ups and downs over the years for a decade or more are generally utilized for growing horticulture and plantation crops, in terms of financial stability, price fluctuations, changes in demand and supply, and islands which are relatively less stable are used for growing short duration seasonal great improvements have also been made in the yield per acre, in the grouping of crops such as vegetables. A majority of these chars remain fallow and unutilized. Even in gardens under a limited number of companies, in the progressive mechanisation the case of chars used for cultivation, agricultural land keeps changing during the entire and rationalisation of production and in increasing their efficiency in regard to the crop cultivation season from sowing to harvesting. productivity of labour122. Modernisation of factories and production techniques also took place. The Indian Tea Control Act,1933, was enacted and an International Tea The total area of vegetative chars has increased in the past three decades in the Brahmaputra Committee and Indian Tea Licensing Committee were instituted. Valley and approximately 146 thousand hectares area127 of char lands have been stable for the past ten years. Two crops are cultivated during the non-flooding months from Present scenario November to April on chars in the Lower Brahmaputra Valley. Crop cultivation is almost Currently, the tea plantation is the largest employer among the organized sector of the negligible compared to the large size of the islands, in the Upper Brahmaputra Valley, as state, employing about more than 6.86 lakh persons daily123. Although an almost equal the chars here are less stable. In the Central Brahmaputra Valley, seasonal migration of char number of female and male employees work in these plantations, female labour is dwellers occurs for crop cultivation; char dwellers do not have settlements here. 230 231 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Jamuna Basin Kshirode Roy CHAR LANDS of Bangladesh have a good potential for increasing agricultural production. The country has about nine million hectares of total cropped land, which is decreasing at the rate of 0.73 percent per year due to housing, roads, industries and other infrastructure development. On the other hand, the total area of chars of four big rivers Padma, Meghna, Jamuna and Brahmaputra and their 500 branch-rivers and tributaries is about one million hectares, and is increasing every year. The Bangladesh government has given special emphasis on increasing agricultural production in char areas to reduce the vulnerability of disadvantaged people living there. Chars in First year of agriculture on a newly formed char Kurigram, Jamalpur, Gaibandha, Bogra and Sirajganj districts have a population of about 6.5 million people of whom 2 million are extremely poor. In general, Kurigram district is considered as the poorest district of the country. Char dwellers largely depend on crop agriculture, fishing and livestock-rearing for their livelihoods. Char soils are predominantly loamy sand, loam and sandy loam. These are deficient in most of the plant nutrients, have very low organic matter content and Char lands of minimum water holding capacity. Generally local crop varieties having very low yield Bangladesh have potential are cultivated in these areas, therefore, the average yields are lower than the a good potential national average yield. However, high yielding variety seeds of boro rice, wheat, maize, for increasing vegetables and some other crops are grown by many farmers. agricultural production. Char The main crops grown in the kharif I season (mid-March to mid-July) are aus rice, jute dwellers largely and sesame. In the kharif II season (mid-July to mid-November) aman rice is grown depend on crop and in the rabi season, boro rice, wheat, maize, mustard, chilli, onion, groundnut, agriculture, fishing potato, sweet potato and vegetables are grown. The irrigation facilities in char lands are and livestock- very limited and used mostly for boro rice and to some extent for wheat and vegetables. rearing for their Generally electric connection is not available in those areas; farmers have to use diesel livelihoods engines for operating pumps. The price of diesel in char areas is higher than on the mainland. Therefore, the cost of irrigation and ultimately the production cost in char Agriculture being stabilized on the char during the second and third year areas is higher than on the mainland. Common vegetables grown in the char lands are pumpkin, cucumber, radish, brinjal, and pointed gourd. Farmers can make more profits from vegetables than from rice, jute or sesame. Therefore, more farmers produce vegetables. Many of the farmers of the major milk producing district of Sirajganj are currently producing Napier grass along with vegetables. They grow this quick-growing grass for sale as well as for using it as feed for their cattle for increasing milk production and for fattening. Flooding is a common phenomenon from mid-June to September. Late sown aus rice and aman rice are mostly affected by floods. However, due to huge sedimentation and carbon influx, flooded soils remain fertile. When devastating flood occurs, houses of Fully developed agricultural fields on the char after 5 to 8 years 232 233 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND most char dwellers are damaged. Farmers living there have to take temporary shelter To increase crop production in char areas, government and nongovernment organizations on unsubmerged roads and even have to move to slums of towns and cities and return have implemented many programmes to increase annual incomes and improve the after the flood recedes. Some of them taking shelter in towns and cities do not return livelihood of farmers. These programmes include activities such as demonstration of to the chars and find new ways of earning their livelihood. modern agricultural technologies, training of farmers on improved crop production, primary education, health care, improvement of infrastructure, activities for the Farmers of char areas do not usually practice modern agricultural technologies like empowerment of women, all of which contribute directly and indirectly to agricultural mainland farmers. Modern technologies need costly inputs like high yielding variety and livelihood improvement. In recent years, research institutes have implemented seeds, fertilizers of both macro and micro-nutrients, and pesticides, all of which poor many programmes to introduce high yielding varieties in char areas through on-farm farmers of char areas cannot afford. As most farmers cannot mortgage lands, they demonstrations. Depending on agro-ecological zones, different technologies have cannot get loans from banks. Because of transport problems, price of seeds, fertilizers, proved appropriate in different chars, many of which have been adopted by farmers pesticides, etc. are costlier than the mainland. Farmers make very little profit from and increased crop production. For example, a farmer of the Brahmaputra Char has selling their produce because the input costs are higher. Primary education, health and spent Tk 18,000 (approximately USD 212) on an average for cultivating pumpkin on agriculture extension services and support to cope with natural calamities, like flood 200 raised sandbars and sold them at Tk 42,000 (approximately USD 495.5). He made and soil erosion are minimal. a net profit of Tk 24,000 (approximately USD 283) in one cropping season. 234 235 THE RESTLESS RIVER GROW: LIVING OFF THE LAND Many NGOs and international organizations have implemented programmes to support women’s participation in agriculture development and have ascertained that women have increased their access to new knowledge on modern agriculture. Women who participated in these programmes are able to produce better quality products, maintain better quality seed through better storage facilities and have access to product marketing. As these women have increased monetary contribution in the family, they are able to provide better food and clothing to their children and invest in their education and health care. In general, the average benefit cost ratio of crop farming with GO-NGO supported programmes is more than that of un-supported programmes. As an outcome of various programmes, agricultural production has increased, and livelihood has improved for char dwellers. These can further be improved if transportation and communication facilities are improved, government social safety net programmes are enhanced and compulsory primary education programmes for boys and girls are implemented. d Hand-dug tube-wells Md Hossain HAND PERCUSSION (sludger) or hand drilled shallow tube-wells are common Women who sources of drawing groundwater on the chars of Bangladesh. This technology can tap participated groundwater from a depth up to 7 meters below the surface and can be used effectively in these in soft sub-surface sediments comprising mostly of sand and clay. programmes are able to A drilling derrick is constructed with local bamboos. The main crew continues the produce better hand-chopping on the boring pipe, while other crews exert pressure on the boring pipe quality products, by means of a hand-driven lever, made of bamboos and/or pipes. A small pit is made maintain better near the derrick in which locally available clay and water is mixed to make drilling quality seed mud. Conventionally drillers used cow-dung, which is being strongly discouraged due through better to its impact on water quality. A steel pipe is used for the uppermost 2 meters section, storage facilities on the top of which the hand pump is installed and the remaining portion consists of PVC pipe. Hand percussion The diameter of the tube is most commonly 0.4 meters (1.5 inch). Number 6 Hand (sludger) or hand drilled Tubewell, a lever operated suction pump, is generally used. Once the tube-well is shallow tube-wells are installed, continuous pumping is done for a reasonable time so that the well becomes a common source of free from drilling mud. The cost of installation of a shallow tube-well of 100 meters groundwater on the depth, could be around 20 thousand Bangladesh Taka (approximately 250 USD). chars of Bangladesh d 236 237 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S 5. PEOPLE One river, many cultures Ganesh Pangare Sanjoy Hazarika Farzana Begum Marc Foggin Runa Khan Pooja Kotoky Ambuj Thakur Manjil Hazarika Gorky Chakraborty Sushmita Mandal Preetee Sharma Yulha Lhawa Xiawei Liao Paresh Borah Bushra Nishat 238 239 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S THE YARLUNG Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River is one river system Whatever the exact timeframe of the arrival of the first hunter-gatherers and that acquires various names along its journey, transcending three countries and pastoralists in the highlands, as d’Alpoim Guedes and Aldenderfer6 point out, it is three major faiths, and assimilating many local customs and practices along its clear that when farmers first arrived from surrounding lowlands to the margins flow. The banks of this majestic river have been dotted with settlements since time of the plateau, possibly as early as 10,000 BP, even as they brought new crops and immemorial and many an ancient civilisation has flourished in its basin. The river new agricultural technologies, “they did not move into a void but rather a land has impacted and shaped the lives of people living on its banks, carrying with that was full of other people.” Beyond livestock and their many milk products, the it numerous untold and re-told myths, stories that have shaped and continue to most common staple food that is eaten by both farmers and pastoralists is barley, shape various customs and traditions as well as progress and development. As which was most likely introduced into southern Tibet between 4,500 and 3,500 BP7. Sanjoy Hazarika says, this river system encompasses “Asia in Miniature”. While the Roasted barley flour or tsampa has always been a convenience food – versatile, long- geography and fractured frontiers of the basins and sub-basins of the river system lasting, portable – and thus a predominant part of people’s fundamental diet. As are fascinating in themselves, it is the population that holds even more interest: such, tsampa may even be recognized as a core element in Tibetan identities8. the cultural diversity and shared history. Straddling the ages and the mountains, the people of this winding trail form an anthropological bridge between South and Livestock on the Tibetan plateau include sheep, goats, yak, and horses. But amongst Southeast Asia. these, the yak epitomizes best Tibetan pastoralism, as life on the plateau would Marc Foggin YARLUNG TSANGPO BASIN Tibetan Nomadic Pastoralists Marc Foggin Straddling the THE TIBETAN PLATEAU constitutes the world’s largest and highest mountain ages and the region, covering nearly a quarter of China’s land area. At over 2.5 million square mountains, kilometers and averaging around 4,500 meters above sea level, it is mostly the people of inhospitable for crop cultivation. Over vast areas of the plateau, therefore, only this winding nomadic pastoralism can be practiced, a livelihood that is contingent on substantial trail form an flexibility and adaptability by herders to respond to harsh, often changing, and anthropological generally unpredictable climatic conditions. The environmental situation also has bridge between traditionally necessitated seasonal mobility to ensure survival of domestic livestock South and and their herders with the very limited productivity of the grasslands during the Southeast Asia short annual productive growing periods. From recent archaeological research, it appears that hunter-gatherers lived permanently in the cold-harsh environment of the Tibetan plateau from at least 8,500 to 7,400 years ago, and possibly as early as 12,700 years ago1. Some ecological studies suggest an anthropogenic creation of pastoral landscapes by early livestock holders, by removing trees to create or promote pasture lands, may have begun as early as 8,800 before present (BP), during the mid-Holocene climatic optimum2. Others, however, suggest that such human-modified environments appeared only later, c. 5,900 BP3. Genetic data on early domestication of yak also provide estimates ranging from c. 10,000 BP4 to c. 5,000 BP5. 240 241 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S simply not be possible without it. In many ways, the yak is to Tibetan pastoralists Horses also play a very important role in Tibetan pastoral areas, even though smaller what fields of barley and other crops are to Tibetan farmers – or, as Robert Ekvall9 in economic impact, with horsemanship being a highly regarded skill and much aptly wrote in regard to livestock kept by Tibetan drokpa, or “high-pasture people”: praised especially through horse races and other contests at annual festivals, testing both horsemen and horses’ performances to the maximum10. Many dwellers of the Tibetan plateau… develop and tend other fields, not of the soil, but better adapted to the harsh ecology of that bleak land… livestock, Globally, rangelands occupy about 40 percent of the earth’s total land surface. For which are the ample base of a vastly different economy… Within the production its part, the high Tibetan steppe extends around 3,000 kilometers from east to west cycle of a subsistence economy, “fields on the hoof ” occupy the place in nomadic and 1,500 kilometers from south to north. With a strong continental climate and pastoralism that soil fields occupy in sedentary agriculture… It is the care of very high elevations, this ecoregion also comprises the headwaters of many major these livestock which makes nearly half of the Tibetan people “pastoralists”; and Asia rivers, including the mighty Yarlung Tsangpo, better known downstream as because what they own, tend, and harvest is on the hoof [i.e., livestock] in wide the Brahmaputra River11. In the highlands, the Yarlung Tsangpo flows through both pastures that require much movement, they are also “nomadic.” agro-pastoral and crop-based livestock production systems, with the former most prominent in the higher altitudes of the western region, also recognized as the cool semi-dry agropastoral ecological zone12. Traditionally, at least until a few decades ago, there were three main groups of The yak people present in the Tibetan rangelands: hunters, nomadic pastoralists, and crop epitomizes farmers. The latter two groups have always maintained particularly close ties, to best Tibetan mutual benefit, exchanging meat and other livestock products for barley in autumn, pastoralism, in order to sustain themselves through the long winters. Tibetan hunters, on the as life on the other hand, always have depended on wildlife, often migratory, and therefore had to plateau would move seasonally according to natural patterns13. Large populations of wildlife were simply not be decimated, though, especially from the 1950s through to the end of the 1970s, and possible now wildlife populations persist only in substantially lower numbers. Fortunately, without it with improved legislation as well as greater public awareness about conservation and the development of a regional network of protected areas, much Tibetan wildlife is now recovering, hunting as a livelihood is now gone, with most former hunters now practicing pastoralism, raising livestock in combination with a range of other socio- economic activities. Overall, Tibetan pastoralists today are less ‘nomadic’ than they once were, due largely to recent government policies that have encouraged varying levels of sedentarisation along with relocation and urbanization of herders and intensification of production systems, sometimes leading to fairly challenging scenarios of nomads without pastures14. Such rapid changes also have given rise to some concerns over people’s sense of identity15, which has been demonstrated, for example, amongst many First Nations in Canada to be highly and consistently correlated with people’s sense of wellbeing and hope for the future16. At the same time, encouraging developments also are arising in China, such as with large-scale conservation endeavours including the creation of a new national park system17 in which more participatory and inclusive approaches are now being trialled and progressively adopted, particularly through a model of community co-management in China’s newest protected areas18. Today, for those who identify with being drokpa – i.e., Tibetan nomadic pastoralists, 242 243 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S the high-pasture people – whether or not they still engage exclusively in livestock herding, or engage in herding at all, is beside the point. In either case, their sense of identity broadly remains closely tied to the grassland where they grew up, to their yak and other livestock, to their long and rich cultural heritage as well as the surrounding natural heritage – a land in which the wildlife is and always has been, in their words, the “jewels of the land”. Building and With new and rapidly changing circumstances largely brought about through strengthening increased connectivity, or globalisation, with a virtual shrinking of the world, two partnerships responses are needed: first, a major re-thinking about whether or not food systems that include and people’s livelihoods should even be subject to the criterion of specialisation- traditional for-efficiency19, considering the many non-monetary values of yak, grasslands, knowledge of the and pastoralist livelihoods; and secondly, in the interim, novel approaches must long-standing also be found whereby sustainable development may be promoted, with equity, custodians across economic sectors and all the varied segments of the population. Toward of the land, this end, different models of rural development are being explored, ranging from will support the development of community cooperatives, associations, and social enterprises the collective to value-add projects centred on wool processing and handicrafts, to individuals’ interest of all pursuit of higher education for achieving personal dreams for business, art, research, stakeholders civil service, etc. Through the latter, it should be possible in the future for more local perspectives, for the voices of the high-pasture people, to be more resonantly heard, adequately considered, and integrated into planning and action for a more sustainable future for all. As outlined by UN Food & Agriculture Organization already many years ago, but still very relevant today20, there are many profound changes taking place in the Tibetan plateau region, with both negative and positive impacts on the fate of the grazing lands and on everyone who depends on them. These changes include major infrastructure developments and market reorientations within pastoral systems, policies to settle pastoralists and reduce their traditional mobility, significant expansion of protected areas, promotion of crop production where previously good pastoral land was used by herders, and, not least, climate change with alterations in precipitation and temperature and increasingly frequent natural Linguistic Diversity on the Tibetan Plateau disasters (such as snowstorms and drought). Building and strengthening the right partnerships to address these issues, inclusive of local and traditional knowledge Yulha Lhawa and of the long-standing custodians of the land, will support the collective interest of all stakeholders affected by the state of the environment on the Tibetan plateau ASIA IS the most linguistically diverse continent in the world and is home to almost – from the local pastoral communities, living in the remote, high-altitude Yarlung a third of global language hotspots, clusters of endangered languages in small Tsangpo headwaters, to the herders, farmers, forest dwellers and town dwellers geographic regions. Thus, the region carries a significant weight of global linguistic living far downstream. diversity. A common misconception, in both popular and academic representations, is that Tibet is a monolingual region. However, a growing body of research attests that Tibet is linguistically diverse21. This aligns with both global and national patterns d of linguistic diversity in low latitudes and rugged terrains with high biodiversity like the Tibetan Plateau, especially in the eastern part. 244 245 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Minority languages on the Tibetan Plateau are languages that are linguistically distinctive from Tibetic or Sinitic (Chinese) languages. These minority languages Yak: the treasure of the highland24 are often unrecognized by the state and within Tibetan communities, under the assumption of a one-to-one relationship between language and ethnicity. The Xiawei Liao persistent emphasis on learning written Tibetan is also another major reason why there is little room for Tibetan minoritized languages within Tibetan communities THE YAK is a unique cattle species that lives in the high mountain grasslands of and Tibetan literature even. the Himalayas and the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau, at altitudes between 3,000 to 5,000 meters. These mammals live at the highest altitudes in the world and can Asia is the most Approximately 230,000 of the 6.2 million Tibetans in China speak one of these withstand severe cold temperatures of minus 30 degrees to minus 40 degrees linguistically minority languages other than the three acknowledged tongues: Amdo, Kham centigrade. diverse continent and U’tsang. In 2018, Roche and Suzuki22 identified up to sixty minority languages in the world spoken both by Tibetans and other ethnic groups. In 2019, Suzuki and Tashi Nyima23 The wild yak is a protected animal in China. There are more than 14 million yaks and is home to identified four additional languages, so the latest estimate is sixty-four languages in in the world, 90 percent of which are distributed in the high and cold regions of almost a third of total. There is a common saying across Tibet that every valley has its own tongue, China’s Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau at an altitude higher than 3,000 meters. Among global language which hardly seems like an exaggeration. them, 3.9 million yaks are found in Tibet, accounting for 30 percent of the total hotspots, clusters and ranking second only after the Qinghai province of China, which is home to of endangered These minority languages are spoken by small populations and are only transmitted 4.9 million yaks. languages in small to the next generations orally. Many are endangered based on the UNESCO geographic regions 9-factor framework for language vitality, mostly due to pressures coming from Yaks can adapt to the ecological environment of high altitudes, low atmospheric both increasing integration into the modern Chinese state and standardization of pressure and low oxygen content. The length and thickness of their fur vary with Tibetan language and culture. People are traditionally farmers and nomads, and the seasons. In the cold season, yaks have thick hair under their chest to protect the these minority languages are only spoken in these villages with no media or school chest, internal abdominal organs, external reproductive organs, breasts and joints usage. from freezing. They also have small skin surface areas and extremely underdeveloped sweat glands to prevent from losing heat. Yaks have wide mouth and flexible lips so Standard Tibetan is the prestige language in Tibetan society. Social attitudes that they can eat the short grasses. On average, one yak can eat 26 to 30 kilograms regarding Tibet’s minority languages also typically undermine their vitality. of fresh grass per day. Tibetans are known to use pejorative terms to refer to the minority languages of Tibet. These include the Tibetan terms ‘dre skad ‘ghost language’ and log skad Three types of yaks are found in Tibet: alpine yaks, Pali yaks and Sibu yaks. Tibetan Yaks can adapt ‘backwards language’, and the Chinese term niaoyu ‘bird language’. These languages alpine yaks are of two types: mountain yaks and grassland yaks. Alpine yaks are to the ecological are identified with ethnicity; and in general, speakers of minority languages tend mostly black and are similar to wild yaks. The famous Jiali yaks are a type of alpine environment of to have a negative attitude towards their own languages. In recent years, there has yak that live in the Jiali County in the Nagqu Prefecture. Pali yaks live in the alpine high altitudes, been a wave of interest in learning written Tibetan among many minority language meadow grassland, subalpine (inter-forest) grassland, swamp meadow grassland low atmospheric speaking communities. and mountain shrub grassland in the Pali Town of the Shigatse prefecture. Pali yaks pressure and low are mainly black, and a few are pure white. oxygen content The number of identified minority languages might expand as more and more research is being carried out in less-investigated geographical areas. Regardless They usually have a wide head, flat forehead, and a slightly concave face, with round of how many languages are spoken in Tibet, it is certain that there will be fewer eyes, thin noses and large ears. The distance between the two horns of Pali yaks is languages in 50 years’ time if we do not actively preserve them. Recognizing and large, which is one of the main characteristics of Pali yaks. Sibu Yaks are located in describing the region’s minority languages is an essential step towards preservation the Lhasa River Basin, close to the Shannan prefecture in the south in a transition of individual languages and providing data for further research and revitalization zone from agriculture to animal husbandry. Sibu yaks graze all year around in the work. If this is done well, we might be able to avoid a fate which seems to await most Sibu Valley, at an altitude of 3,789 to 4,200 meters. of Asia, the world’s most linguistically diverse continent. d 246 247 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Livestock on the Tibetan plateau include sheep, goats, yak, and horses. But amongst these, the yak epitomizes Tibetan pastoralism, as life on the plateau would simply not be possible without it. Yaks are one of the most important domestic animals in most of the pastoral area on the Tibetan plateau. Nomads place so much value on the yak that many refer to them as ‘nor’, which also means ‘precious gem’ or, more generally, ‘wealth’. The yak, in many ways, defines nomadic pastoralism across most of the plateau. Yaks provide milk and milk products, meat, hair, wool and hides. They are also used as draught animals and for riding. Yak dung is an important source of fuel in an area where firewood is not available. The yak makes life possible for people in one of the world’s harshest environments. There is little doubt that the presence of wild yaks, and their later domestication, was the single most important factor in the adaptation of civilization on the Tibetan plateau.25 248 249 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S BRAHMAPUTRA BASIN Asia in Miniature Sanjoy Hazarika THE STRETCH of the Far Eastern Himalaya from Sikkim, India, eastward is significantly different from the rest of the mountain range. The reach of the Ganga plains, of Hindu ethos and historical Moslem influence, is much more muted here. If anything, many of the animistic hill tribes have gone the other way by embracing Christianity. Unlike the cultures of the faraway flatlands, these eastern communities are more directly linked to the Tibetans of the north, or the Indo-Chinese of the south and east.   The region is also unique in its geography. Although part of the same Himalayan range, these southern latitudes nurture a lush tropical landscape drenched by one of the highest precipitation rates in the world—strikingly different from the high While the desert of Ladakh or the dry terraces of west Nepal. The High Himalaya itself is geography lower at these extremities; with the peaks descending eastward from Mount Everest and fractured (8,848 meters) in the Khumbu, to Kanchenjunga (8,598 meters) at the Nepal-Sikkim frontiers of border, to Namcha Barwa (7,756 meters), standing guard as the great bend of the this region are Tsangpo. About here, the Himalaya breaks southward into Burma and dwindles fascinating in away eastward into hills of the Hengduan mountains of Sichuan-Yunnan. themselves, it is the population The western part of the Himalayan range is neatly packaged into a progression of that holds even states from Pakistan to Nepal to Bhutan. But here in the east the range becomes more interest: a geopolitical jigsaw, crossing national frontiers with impunity. The rectangle of the cultural the Far Eastern Himalaya is broken up among five nation states, little Bhutan, the diversity and Northeast of India, the Chittagong Hill Tracts of Bangladesh, the Arakan region shared history of northern Burma, the southeastern tip of Tibet and the hills of Yunnan. While the geography and fractured frontiers of this region are fascinating in themselves, it is the population that holds even more interest: the cultural diversity and shared history. The babel of languages heard along this Himalayan flow includes the guttural Tibetan and its offspring Dzongkha, the sweeter Assamese in the Brahmaputra valley, and the lilt of Tibeto-Burman tongues in the hills of Nagaland, Manipur and Mizoram. This region is Asia in miniature, a place where the brown and yellow races meet. Taking a south-north transect, for example, you encounter the Bengali migrants in Assam, Tibeto-Burmans in the Himalayan mid-hills, and the Khampa of the high plateau. Going west to east, the spectrum is even more diverse from the people of Tibetan stock, the Bhutia and Lepcha of Sikkim and the Ngalong Dzongkha-speaking people next door in Bhutan, the population takes on Tibeto-Burman hues with the Sarchop 250 251 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S of eastern Bhutan. Eastward, the communities become progressively less ´Tibetan´ India is often considered as a major crossroad of movements of prehistoric and more ´Burman´. The variety is outstanding. ancestors from Africa, the cradle of humankind, to the Far East. While discussing the dispersal routes of these early humans through South Asia, the Brahmaputra Straddling the ages and the mountains, the people of this winding trail form an basin and its surrounding hill tracks is considered as a narrow strategic corridor anthropological bridge to Southeast Asia, where the roots of many still lie. The between the gigantic high Himalaya in the north and Bay of Bengal and the Indian Khasi of Meghalaya are believed to have come from Kampuchea and still speak a Ocean in the south. However, it may be noted that the sub-recent alluvial deposits form of Mon-Khmer, although because of British missionary influence they use the English alphabet. The Thai Ahom migrated from Thailand to Assam 600 years ago and settled in a land they reported was as valuable as gold. d Archaeology and prehistory A fine rock-cut Manjil Hazarika sculpture of Bhogasanamurti WHO WERE the first inhabitants of the Brahmaputra basin? When did they start of Vishnu on the living in the basin? From where did they arrive in the valley? How did they start bank of the river Manjil Hazarika cultivating rice in the valley? Who built the brick and stone temples, stupas, Brahmaputra in sculptures, ramparts seen in the valley? How did the cultural development and Manikarneswar in assimilation take place? These are some questions that boggle our mind when we North Guwahati think of the history of the people residing in the extensive fluvial landscape of the Brahmaputra basin with so much of ethnic, linguistic and cultural diversities. To of the Brahmaputra valley may not give fruitful results for such an antiquity of seek the answers, one may look into the archaeological remains spread across the around 2 million years before present. Vigorous sedimentation might have covered river basin and its tributaries and the associated historical events. earlier deposits bearing artefacts and fossils or been washed away, if there ever were any. The fluvial activities of over-flooding and changes in the course of the river Brahmaputra and its tributaries have also affected many of the ancient and early medieval archaeological sites in the region. Moreover, frequent earthquakes have brought down majority of the structures and temple complexes built during the ancient and medieval period. For understanding the earliest remains of human habitation in the Brahmaputra valley, one needs to look at the surrounding hilly areas which has produced some important prehistoric sites. Many Stone Age sites dating back to the Palaeolithic hunter-gatherer period have been recorded from the uplands of Garo-Khasi-Jaintia Hills, Naga Hills, Manipur and Tripura. Many of these stone artifacts have been equated with the Hoabinhian or similar industries of Southeast Asia that fall within Rock cut votive the Late Pleistocene/Early Holocene geological period. Hoabinhian is a technological stupas at Sri tradition of prehistoric hunter-gatherers-fishers that existed approximately during Manjil Hazarika Surya Pahar the last 43,000 to 7,000 years before present in a broad region from southern China, Archaeological northern Vietnam, Malaya, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, Sumatra, Taiwan and Site in Goalpara northeast India. 252 253 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S The next important phase is the Neolithic period starting at around 4,500 years Intermittent trade between India and China through the valley and surrounding before present. During this phase the inhabitants of the Brahmaputra basin and areas provided a base for these earliest state formations. The Brahmaputra river the surrounding hilly tracts started making polished and chipped stone axes, adzes system acted as a thoroughfare for the hinterland trade networks. The lower reaches and other utilitarian tools, handmade pottery of either plain or cord-impressed of the Brahmaputra which joins the Padma (Ganga) in Bangladesh, is another varieties. They settled in the foothills and uplands, exploited the aquatic natural important cultural zone of ancient Bengal where Buddhism flourished in the early resources and forest products and cultivated food crops like rice in the uplands as centuries of the Common Era. well as in the nearby marshy areas. This coincides with the advent of the various Areas like Goalpara in the confluence of Krishnai-Dudhnoi-Brahmaputra Rivers, the regions in and around Guwahati popularly known as ancient Pragjyotishapur, Dhansiri-Doiyang valley were some of the key areas of historical development since the beginning of the early centuries of first millennium AD. Mention may be made of the site of Sri Surya Pahar in Goalpara having evidence of three Indian religious sects of Buddhism, Jainism and Hinduism, which is often equated with Ellora of Maharashtra. Excavation at the site of Ambari in the heart of Guwahati city yielded evidence of cultural materials dating back to the Sunga-Kushana period. The Varmans of ancient Pragjyotishpura-Kamarupa had close ties with the Guptas ruling in a large part of north, central and east India. With a more organised way of The Brahmaputra administration, trade, cultural exchange reflected in the inscriptions, coins, pottery, river system acted stone sculptures, brick and stone structures, most areas of the lower and middle as a thoroughfare Brahmaputra valley were brought under a more homogenised cultural and political for the hinterland structure during the nineth to twelfth centuries AD under the Pala dynasty. trade networks. The lower The Tai-Ahoms entered the upper Brahmaputra valley in the beginning of the reaches of the thirteenth century from the kingdom of Pong in the upper Irrawaddy basin, a Brahmaputra is polity that straddled a part of upper Burma and the adjacent portion of the Chinese another important province of Yunnan. It gave rise to the Ahom kingdom, assimilating many of the cultural zone of petite kingdoms in the area. The six hundred years of their long rule witnessed a ancient Bengal well-organised political and administrative structure supported by systematic where Buddhism agricultural practices, construction of roads, ramparts, forts, besides secular and flourished religious monuments, and giant burial mounds known as the Moidams, mostly in Austro-Asiatic and Tibeto-Burman language speaking groups from neighbouring the upper and middle Brahmaputra valley. The chowkis (military check posts) along Southeast, East and South Asian regions. These assumptions are based on available the courses of the rivers and the battles of Saraighat near Guwahati fought by the archaeological, historical, linguistic and human genetic data. Slowly they expanded Ahoms against the invading forces are testimonies of their naval warfare. Similarly, in population size and intensified the agricultural activities in certain fringe areas of the Koch kingdom flourished in the lower part of the valley and shaped the cultural the valley. They used large stones to erect burials in memory of the deceased and for sphere of western Assam. Another notable feature of the medieval period is the rise commemorating certain events and demarcating boundaries. This tradition known of the Vaishnavite sect propounded by Saint Srimanta Sankardeva and his disciples. as megalithic has persisted until today among various ethnic communities. Iron was The Satras (monasteries), Naamghars and Kirtanghars (prayer halls) spread through a precious metal smelted by the late Neolithic communities. the entire length and breadth of the valley, including the famous island of Majuli in the middle of the Brahmaputra are some important contributions of the Vaishnavite Chieftain groups based on ethno-linguistic and cultural background emerged, movement. slowly leading to the formation of petite kingdoms occupying the hills. Exchange of ideas, development of trade and commerce among them and arrival of newer Throughout the history, the people living in the plains of the Brahmaputra and the groups of people from the Gangetic valley in the last part of the first millennium BC surrounding hill tracts had close cultural and societal ties. This is easily observed in led to the rise of smaller principalities in the Brahmaputra basin and its tributaries. their customs, tradition, folklores, culture and mode of subsistence. This symbiotic 254 255 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S 256 257 THE RESTLESS RIVER cultural milieu in a strategic geo-political setting covering a wider area of undivided Assam has shaped the cultural identity of the Brahmaputra basin. Influences of topography, environment and ecology are well reflected in the cultural traits among the people inhabiting the Brahmaputra basin in the past as well as in the present. d Ancient fluvial trade route Preetee Sharma THE HISTORICAL period begins in the Brahmaputra valley from the mid-fourth century Common Era (CE) onwards. We do get a lot of references about the Kamarupa-Pragjyotisha or ancient Assam region in literature such as the Ramayana, Mahabharata, Kalika Purana and so on. These literatures mostly talk about the mythical king Naraka, the first king of Pragjyotisha, in great detail. But historically route of Brahmaputra as it was the most convenient and faster transportation route. this information could not be verified with any other reliable sources such as A very significant historical source for studying about Early Assam are the epigraphic inscriptions. The first three historical dynasties of the region of Brahmaputra Valley sources. A total of 32 inscriptions have been found in the region belonging to this are the Bhauma-Varmana (mid-fourth to mid-seventh century CE), Salastambha period. Most of these inscriptions are records of land grants made by the kings of (mid-seventh to tenth century CE) and the Palas of Kamarupa (tenth to thirteenth the three dynasties. Thus, these inscriptions provide a lot of information about century CE) as reflected in the epigraphic sources. places where villages were settled; information about the social groups and the hierarchies within; religious preferences; and crucial insight into the economic life The river played This period in the history of the valley from fourth till the first quarter of the of the Brahmaputra Valley in the Pre-Ahom times. In an eleventh century CE land a very significant thirteenth century CE is also referred to as the Pre-Ahom period, which as a term grant we find the mention of different categories of boatmen: namely Candenauki, role in binding the was popularised by historian Nayanjot Lahiri through her work “Pre-Ahom Assam” Daksinapatinauki and Sadhavanauki. The emphasis on segregating the boatmen entire length of the published in 1991. In the region of the Brahmaputra valley, the coming of the Ahoms plying on the Lauhitya or Brahmaputra on the basis of the area of operation or valley by providing into the valley in 1226 CE from beyond the Patkai range is considered a major break distance covered or goods transported by the boats within these historical records ease of economic in the historical processes of the region. Historians also consider the coming of the shows the crucial role played by the river Brahmaputra. The river played a very transactions and Ahoms as the beginning of the medieval era in the region, just like in the Indian significant role in binding the entire length of the valley by providing ease of transportation subcontinent the coming of the Sultanate rulers is the marker of medieval times. economic transactions and transportation which in turn led to homogenisation of which in turn led Historians also intermittently use terms such as Ancient Assam and Early Assam to culture and other social practices in the historical times. to homogenisation refer to this period where the latter term is the most popular one. of culture d In the historical processes of the valley the river Brahmaputra played a central role which is reflected in the way most archaeological sites of importance are located in the fluvial zone. Sites such as Ambari at Guwahati, Suryapahar at Goalpara Tai-Ahoms of Assam have yielded very rich cultural metrial reflecting the larger connections within the Brahmaputra valley and also beyond. In fact, at Ambari a substantial amount of Ambuj Thakur turquoise glazed potsherds, whose origin is traced to the Arab domain, have been found which shows Ambari was connected to the Indo-Arab trade network of the THE TAI-AHOMS of Assam are a branch of the great Dai race of Southeast Asia that early medieval times. Also, at Ambari the discovery of Chinese Celadon potsherds came from Mung-mao, the present-day Ruili area in Southwest China’s Yunnan shows the region’s connection with China in the early medieval period. And most of province, in the early part of the Thirteenth Century CE. According to the Deodhai these networks and connections seem to have been maintained through the fluvial Asam Buranji (the Ahom Chronicles) their leader, Chao-lung Siukapha (1189 258 259 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S – 1268 CE) through his grit and determination, rallied his 9,000 camp followers Pragjyotishpura, or City of Eastern Lights, in the Seventh Century CE. But it was and 300 war horses to establish a powerful kingdom on the verdant plains of the under the stable leadership of the nearly six-hundred year old Ahom rule that it Brahmaputra valley in Upper Assam after subjugating the various local kingdoms emerged as a cohesive socio-political and cultural unit. In the period from 1228 including the Chutiyas, Barahis, and Marans. Interestingly, Chao-lung Siukapha to 1826 CE, the Brahmaputra valley witnessed an immense churning within, entered this valley through the Tipam area, bound on the one side by the Patkai withstanding and adapting to numerous external stimuli, which gave shape to the Hills, and the Buri Dihing River, on the other. True to their traditions of being greater Assamese identity. Siukapha and his successors, managed to do what few valley people settled beside water courses, Siukapha also tested his luck along the dynasties have seldom achieved in history, being conquerors, they assimilated their courses of both the Brahmaputra and its major tributaries like the Buri Dihing and customs and traditions with the local populace thereby blending into a unique synthesis of ideas and emotions. One of the major achievements of the Ahoms lay in building up a durable economy Another important under the rubric of the Paik system, which was a system of corvee labour and had innovation of parallels in Southeast Asia like the Prai system in Thailand, amongst others. In a the Ahoms was non-monetised economy, human labour was invaluable and this system catered well the introduction in administering the country. First reorganised during the reign of Siusengpha or of wet-rice Pratap Singha (1603 to 1641 CE), by the astute Momai Tamuli Barbarua, father of cultivation in the famous general Lachit Barphukan, it followed the decimal system in organising Assam. The very the officers of state administration. Each individual was considered a paik and four reference of of them formed a got. Land was state-owned and these paiks were assigned fallow Mung-Dun-Chun- land to cultivate in lieu of paying a part of the produce as tax. They also had to Kham alludes render services to the state and the royalty in various forms such as military service, to their instant construction works, royal household duties. likeness for the golden paddy and Both Shihabuddin Talish, the Mughal chronicler (Tarik-i-Asham) accompanying oilseed fields of his master Mir Jumla, and later Aurangzeb’s general Ram Singh have attested to the Brahmaputra the dexterity of this system and sang paeans to the fastidiousness of the people of valley Assam for the love of their motherland, in their accounts in the mid-seventeenth century CE respectively. Later on, the system saw further modifications during the reign of Siurempha or Rajeswar Singha (1751 to 1769 CE), when the numbers of the got were reduced to three. The various officers commanding the paiks were the Bora (20 men), Saikia (100 men), Hazarika (1,000 men), and Phukan (6,000 men). The commanders-in-chief of Upper Assam and Lower Assam, the Barbarua and the Barphukan had 12,000 paiks with them. However, due to the depredations of the Dikhou, to establish his foothold in the ‘Land of Golden Gardens’ or Mung- the Moamaria rebellion and the Burmese invasions towards the end of the Ahom Dun-Chun-Kham. The capital was finally chosen near Simaluguri, adjacent to the monarchy, this system declined. Naga Hills, and named Che-Rai-Doi or Charaideo, meaning the ‘City of the Sacred Hill’. Ever since then, it became the royal burial ground with almost all of Siukapha’s Another important innovation of the Ahoms was the introduction of wet-rice descendants interred in mounds, called the Maidams, akin to the Pyramids of Egypt, cultivation (Sali) in Assam. The very reference of Mung-Dun-Chun-Kham alludes but rarely explored until now. to their instant likeness for the golden paddy and oilseed fields of the Brahmaputra valley. Their agrarian character was suitably put to test in the regions’ fertile alluvial Assam, or ancient Kamarupa, has a glorious history since the days of the Bhauma- soil and multiple varieties of paddy like Ahom Sali, Khampti Sali, Pakhi Sali, Aanki Naraka dynasty finding mention even in the epic Mahabharata. It reached its apogee Sali, Kar Sali were cultivated using improved water conservation techniques. Later during the days of Kumara Bhaskaravarman, a contemporary of Harshavardhana on, in the early nineteenth century CE, British officials like Francis Buchanan of Kannauj, when the Chinese traveller Hieuen-Tsang visited the capital city Hamilton noted that the paddy constituted about three quarters of the agrarian 260 261 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S produce of the kingdom. Sir Edward A. Gait also wrote in his A History of Assam that the local people lived in ease and comfort with every article of domestic consumption produced in their own fields, something that Shihabuddin Talish had also spoken about a hundred and fifty years earlier. The Ahom rulers were master builders and the palaces like the Karengghar and Talatalghar, in the old capitals of Garhgaon and Rangpur, are living examples of refined architectural styles. The great reservoirs like the Borpukhuri, Joysagar and Rudrasagar besides the numerous temples along their banks, as well as the sports pavilion, Rangghar, are testimonies of their interests in leaving their mark in the region’s history. These tanks were designed in such a way that the water levels have never receded to this day even during dry seasons. A special type of cementing glue, Koraal, made of materials such as lentils, fish, river sand, honey, and lime, The Brahmaputra was used in construction activities, which gave the walls of these buildings not only valley is a densely durability, but also strength. It should be noted that most of these buildings have populated region. survived till date in this highly seismic zone, including the great earthquakes of Considered to 1897 and 1950 CE. be the heart of Assam. The Ahom coins were also fine specimens of currency which had a very high silver The different content of about 94 percent, with denominations ranging from the gold mohur communities of to one-thirty-second of a rupee. Octagonal in shape, they had the names, regnal the valley have years and salutations to deities like Vishnu, Shiva, Shakti on the obverse and the brought colour reverse sides, besides the royal dragon symbol. While gold was sourced from the and vibrancy rivers of Assam, with special guilds called the Sonowals assigned to the task, silver to the state’s was supplied from the faraway mines of Yunnan through the Southern Silk Route landscape (Nanfeng Sichou Zhilue). As late as 1809 CE, British officials noted that the kingdom had a brisk annual trade amounting to a hundred thousand rupees along this route Cultural landscape including commodities like horses, silver, cowries, lac, and silk. Farzana Begum The Ahoms were warriors and repulsed as many as fourteen invasions from the western side, including the Mughals. The Ahom victory in the Battle of Saraighat THE BRAHMAPUTRA valley is a densely populated region. Considered to be the (1671 CE) still echoes in the hearts and minds of Assamese people. They had not heart of Assam, the valley stretching from Sadiya in the east to Dhubri in the west is only a strong infantry, but also a powerful navy consisting of different types of canoes the cradle of bustling cities and towns, bucolic villages and hamlets, serene chars and and boats required for navigating the treacherous channels of the Brahmaputra and chapories (sand bars), and picturesque islands inhabited by diverse communities. its tributaries. Experts in constructing earthen forts and embankments, the Ahoms The valley is the meeting ground of numerous linguistic and racial groups and is used natural vegetation to their advantage in defending their realm. However, a treasure house to the anthropologist. Presently, Assam is home to communities towards the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries CE, religious strife and belonging to different tribes, castes, languages and religions. These communities political disunity sapped the vitality of the administrative system, paving the way have been living in close proximity over a long period of time, which has led to for the British to finally annex the kingdom in 1826 CE after signing the Treaty intermixing of racial and cultural elements. The different communities of the valley of Yandabo with the Burmese. However, the Tai-Ahoms still remain an influential have brought colour and vibrancy to the state’s landscape. community in Assam today and their past achievements cannot be allowed to fade away in the mists of history. A unique feature of the state is the presence of a large number of tribes, comprising 12.41 percent of the state’s population. Many of the tribes have common ancestry d but also distinct cultural traits, which distinguish them from one another. Through 262 263 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Tai Phake A small ethnic group residing in Assam radiant with it’s own culture and tradition. Tai Phakes migrated to the north eastern part of India from the Howkong valley of Myanmar in 1775. 264 265 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S The Rabhas are believed to have come to Assam from Tibet at different stages of time in waves of migration. They have close linguistic and cultural affinity with the Bodo and Garo tribes. The Garos and Karbis reside in both the hills and plains of Assam. The Garos call themselves as Achik Mande meaning ‘Hill Man’; they follow the matrilineal family structure and trace their lineage through females. The Karbis call themselves as ‘Arleng’, meaning man. Some authors opine that ‘Arleng’ also refers to “slope dwellers”26. The Tiwas living in the plains are settled cultivators and the Tiwas living in the hills practice jhum (shifting) cultivation. The Tiwas living in the plains have assimilated the Assamese way of life and have been deeply influenced by Vaishnavism. The hill Tiwas have maintained their traditional culture. The unique Jon Beel mela, which is an annual event during the month of January, provides an opportunity to witness the ancient traditional barter system practiced among the different ethnic communities. The Kacharis who used to collect gold or ‘son’ from the bank of the Subansiri River The word ‘Mi’ came to be known as Sonowal Kacharis. The people of the tribe are deeply influenced means man by Vaisnavism, but traditional Bathou Puja (worship of Lord Shiva) is observed with and ‘Shing’ sacrifice of animals. The Dimasa Kachari consider themselves the descendants of means water/ the Brahmaputra; the tribal meaning of the word ‘Dimasa’ is ‘son of a big river’. ‘Di’ river. Therefore, means ‘water’, ‘Ma’ means ‘big’ and ‘Sa’ means ‘son’. Mising means the tribe living The Ahoms belong to the Tai ethnic group of the Mongoloid race. They came to by the side of Assam during the early part of the thirteenth century. The kingdom which Sukapha, the water or historical records the origin of the tribes can be traced back to 800 years ago, but the first Ahom king of Assam established in 1228 continued till 1826, leaving behind river studies of their migration stories, folklores, and songs indicate that the tribes have a rich legacy in the history of this land. a long existence preceding the historical period. A majority of the tribes belongs to the Mongoloid group and are members of the Tibeto-Burman language family. The The Deoris is another riverine community of Assam. The term ‘Deori’ means the Bodos form the largest tribal group in terms of population, followed by the Misings. ‘offsprings of God and Goddess. The Deoris also known as Jimochanya functioned Other tribes like the Rabhas and Karbis also have sizeable populations. as the priests of the Chutiyas of Assam27. Originally from the banks of the river Kundilpani at Kundil, presently known as Sadiya, the Deories traveled along the The Bodos also known as Boro or Boro Kacharis are regarded as one of the earliest Brahmaputra river and initially took shelter in the sand bars. settlers of this region, their main concentration is now on the northern bank of the river Brahmaputra from Dhubri in the west to Dhemaji district in the east. The Also nestled in small pockets are found several communities including the Tribes Misings are the second largest scheduled tribe in Assam in terms of population. The who follow the Buddhist religion and inhabit the upper region of Assam. The Tai word ‘Mi’ means man and ‘Shing’ means water/river. Therefore, Mising means the Khamtis are said to have migrated to Assam from Bar Khamti (Khamti Lung) in tribe living by the side of the water or river. The socio-economic and cultural life of Burma during the eighteenth century. The Tai Phakes are the descendants of the the Misings is closely linked to life on the riverbanks. They construct their houses Tai royal officials and had a principality of their own in Hukong valley in the Patkai on piles. They are expert swimmers and use boats and rafts for transport. Years of range of mountains. In 1777, they arrived by boat at Kokilamukh and later settled in living on the riverbanks have taught them to cope with the floods that occur every Naharkatiya. The Tai Aitonias and the Tai Turungs have also migrated from Burma. year. The intimate relation of the Mising tribe with the river is an accepted truth and the saying – Noi Suwani Miri which means that the river is made beautiful because The Singpho tribe believes that they migrated to this region through the Brahmaputra of the Miri (Mising)- reflects this sentiment. via the Sampo River between 800 and 700 B.C. Although these tribes have over times 266 267 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S developed their own individual identity, there are many traits, which they share in common. Racially they belong to the Tibeto Mongoloid races and trace their origin from Myanmar or Burma. They came to this region in series of migration from ancient times. All are followers of the teachings of Buddha. They share similarities in food, clothing, economic activities, religious rites and festivals. These small but ethnically rich Buddhist tribal groups have made the landscape of the state more brilliant and colourful with their presence. They practice agriculture; rice cultivation is the primary occupation. They are also expert horticulturists. The women in all the tribes are expert weavers. Amidst the diversity in society and culture, there are many commonalities, which bind the people of Assam. Rice, fish, the use of Khar, (Alkaline) and Tenga (Sour) in their curry are loved by all the communities. An upper and lower wrappers are the traditional attire of a woman of Assam, and each tribe/non-tribal community has a different name for it in their language, Bihu the festival associated with the seasons and agriculture is celebrated by all people from different religions, castes and tribes. These are only a few of the attributes that unite the people of the hills and plains of Assam. These are examples of harmony and inclusiveness imbibed in the society and culture of the land of the Brahmaputra. d The Char people Gorky Chakraborty CAN A piece of land ‘float’ in water of a flowing river? If it floats, will it ‘flow’ with the river? Does such a ‘flowing-float’ sustain life and livelihood for the humans? If it does, how does one categorise it: as land, water, or both, or none! Well, these were the puzzles which were explained to me by my fellow traveller in a city bus in Guwahati, until an argument picked up regarding the ‘quality’ of the currency note provided by him as fare. The conductor reacted with a ‘slur’, soon followed by Can a piece of land few other passengers, ultimately resulting in his forced de-boarding from the bus. ‘float’ in water of a In utter bewilderment, I too went out, as if to continue our conversation which got flowing river? If it interrupted abruptly. The man was shivering in fear, an accumulated rage within floats, will it ‘flow’ made him angry too, unable to speak properly and sobbing intermittently, he tried with the river? telling me that he hailed from the char areas of the river Brahmaputra in Assam. I tried consoling him feeling bad at his hapless plight, followed by loss of words and silence, until he asked me “will you come to our place?” and went further with his invitation saying “what I had been narrating to you so far will be in front of your eyes, and you, yourself can make out what is a char: land, water, both, yet none! My tryst with chars thereby began on the roads of Guwahati, the largest and fastest growing urban agglomerate in northeast India. The search for academic literature 268 269 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S on these areas left me depressed as they were almost non-existent. But the incident in the bus, the slur, the land that floats and flows yet sustains life and livelihood albeit temporarily and questions about his identity agitated me until I decided to study these areas applying academic lenses. Under colonial rule, in-migration of the traditionally skilled cultivators from the populous districts of neighbouring Bengal to the wasteland of the Brahmaputra valley, was encouraged to meet the rising food grains requirement of the state and also satisfy the ever-increasing demand for raw jute from the mills in Bengal, thereby adding to the revenue generating capacity of Assam. The Census Report of 1911 mentions large scale movement of people from East Bengal to Assam, mainly to the Goalpara district. What started flowing in trickles soon transformed into waves and till the end of the colonial era, the migrant people constituted about one-tenth to one-sixth of the state’s population, settled in more than 6,213,000 acres of wasteland, increasing the cropped area from 2.40 million acres to 4.79 million acres in Assam. While this heralded a sea change in the agricultural scenario in the Large scale Brahmaputra valley, increasing enormously the acreage, yield and productivity of a anthropogenic wide variety of crops along with revenue, it also changed the socio-cultural profile settlements were of the state. established on the chars of the Large scale anthropogenic settlements were established on the chars of the Brahmaputra Brahmaputra valley as many of these farm-settlers from East Bengal chose to live on valley. The 1992-93 the chars. A large section of these migrants was already used to living and cultivating survey reveals that in fluvial plains in East Bengal and thereby could negotiate the Brahmaputra flood there were 2,089 plains. Interestingly, as the chars were within the river, they were geographically char villages in the exclusive, as a result, the settlers remained outside the mainstream population Brahmaputra groups which had settled in far-off areas from the river. The chars were thus both the geographically ‘other’ and the settlers became the socio-culturally ‘other’ in terms of their identity. After more than four decades into the post-colonial era, the state undertook a socio- economic survey of the chars of the Brahmaputra, to assess the life and livelihood patterns of its dwellers. The first survey was conducted in 1992-93 followed by another in 2003-04; till date they remain the only source of macro data concerning these areas. The 1992-93 survey reveals that there were 2,089 char villages in the Brahmaputra, where Barpeta district (351) in lower Assam had the highest numbers followed by Dhubri district (313), which borders Bangladesh. In the 2003-04 survey, the data shows a different trend, more villages in Dhubri than in Barpeta, indicating the change in the fluvial regime of the Brahmaputra. These surveys revealed that the chars constitute 4.60 percent of the total land in the state and 4 percent of its cultivable land and are inhabited by 9.37 percent of the state’s population. Evidently, there is excessive pressure on land for survival, land which is impermanent and prone to regular flooding and recurrent erosion. As a 270 271 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S result, the density of population in these areas is more than double (690 persons per square kilometer) compared to the state average (340 persons per square kilometer). More than 81 percent of the population in the chars is illiterate, perhaps one of the largest illiterate population groups in India. The findings of these surveys may be summed up by quoting the poverty estimates. The population living below the officially determined poverty line increased from 48.89 percent to 67.89 percent from the survey period 1992-93 to 2003-04. Due to these abysmal conditions, migration remains an important ‘escape’ route for the char dwellers. These impermanent chars when eroded, migrate downstream. They re-appear, of course if not fully eroded, through accretion towards the tail. The char dwellers exhibit different patterns of migration: moving to central locations within a char from the eroding peripheries; migrating to a more stable char usually nearer to the banks; shifting to relatively stable places within the riverine flood plains; migrating to urban locations seasonally; and if possible, to urban places for good. Despite producing a diversified crop profile and exhibiting a higher crop intensity compared to the mainland, impermanence of land, lack of legislative and revenue safeguards along with abysmal conditions of health and literacy entwined in skewed As per local income and land occupancy, the chars remain the most impoverished and neglected literary records areas in Assam. Where the char dwellers are caught in a bind of uncertainties: the and folklore, river fosters the uncertainty of life and livelihood, land and water, and migration to Majuli has existed the mainland ushers in the uncertainty of identity. for more than five hundred d years. There is evidence that the Ahom kings also Majuli Island consolidated their rule on the island Sushmita Mandal engineering terms, they are a silent testimony to the efforts ongoing in Majuli to arrest the eroding banks from being further eaten away. But as one sees, these efforts MAJULI, OR “land locked between two parallel rivers” is the world’s largest inhabited have been futile in the face of a raging river. The shrinking of Majuli is documented river island located in the middle course of the Brahmaputra river in the state of from the colonial era. A map prepared by A J Mefat Mills of the British East India Assam in India28. The island is a conglomerate of 248 cadastral villages spread over Company in 1853 shows Majuli’s land mass at 1,246 square kilometers. The 1993 an area of roughly 487.55 square kilometers29. However, the true extent of the island maps prepared by the Brahmaputra Board show only 880 square kilometers as the today is unknown due to the shifting nature of the river that constantly erodes the total landmass. However, after the monsoons of 2001, the recorded land area of riverbanks and reshapes it. Islets (locally known as chaporis), beels or wetlands, ox- Majuli was approximately 425 square kilometers. The river takes away earth but also bow lakes and streams cover 14 percent of the total geographical area of the island30, creates new land masses. In these newly formed sand bars (locally called chapori) making it an ideal habitat for birds (both resident and migratory) and aquatic animals and humans live, not knowing when they will be again washed away by the diversity. devouring river. The memory of this shifting relationship between land and water is etched on the eroded banks. The loss of land in Majuli has meant a loss of both As one de-boards at Majuli’s Kamalabari Ghat, the new sediment deposited from homestead and land for farming. Erosion and accretion are a distinct feature of the last monsoon greets you. Further ahead there are concrete structures that braided river systems and while people have been juxtaposed between the two, life lie along the banks of one of the streams. Referred to as porcupine structures in in Majuli progresses from day to day, negotiating such paradoxes. 272 273 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Life on Majuli Island 274 275 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Majuli is juxtaposed between the impermanence of a shrinking landmass and a continuing cultural-religious heritage. The cultural-religious component is intangible and the physical component in the form of the sattras are continually relocated and hence reconstructed. History is written in Majuli with water; it eludes the usual frameworks for measuring heritage. In 2006, Assam passed the Majuli Cultural Landscape Region (MCLR) Act, aimed at “prevention of loss of value and authenticity of the cultural landscape of Majuli” and established the Majuli Cultural Landscape Management Authority (MCLMA). This institution is entrusted with implementing an inclusive management plan, involving local stakeholders in an integrated effort to protect the unique heritage of the island. The rhythm of life on this island is clearly guided by the seasons; summer is the season of high activity when roads and embankments are repaired/fortified for the ensuing monsoons that would again take away some life and livelihood. Soon after the flood waters recede, the wetlands are teeming with fresh stock of fish that the river brought along with it. The new sediment deposited in the fields is ready to be ploughed and planted with a variety of paddy, vegetables, and oil seeds. Winters are a time of tending the crops, harvesting ones that are ready and spending some time at leisure as well. People’s reverence to the Gods is best expressed through their regular visits to the naamghar (village level religious institution), each morning and evening. Festivals like the Bhaona festival are an opportunity for the villagers to As per local literary records and folklore, Majuli has existed for more than five hundred years. There is evidence that the Ahom kings also consolidated their rule on the island. The remnants of an erstwhile fort that was built on the island are a testimony to that. The key point of Majuli’s transition into a unique cultural landscape was seeded in the setting up of Sattra (Vaishnavite monastery) in the fifteenth century. The Assamese Bhakti saint, Srimant Sankardeva came to the island and imparted teachings of Lord Krishna through performing arts. He used innovative methods of communicating spiritual teachings that included music, dance and theatre, most of which exist till this day. It was Sankardeva along with his successor Madhavdeva, who set up several monastic institutions called sattras, where monks spend their lives in reading scriptures, engaging in performing arts and devoted to the worship of Lord Krishna. It is believed that as many as 65 sattras existed in Majuli at the turn of twentieth century, but due to the floods coupled with erosion, several of these have shifted base to the mainland. Currently about 22 Sattras exist in Majuli. It is a major seat of Vaishnavite culture in Assam and is much revered and worshipped by locals. The sattriya culture is the mainstay of local tourism in Majuli and figures prominently in the itinerary of any devout Vaishnav in Assam wishing to visit the seat from where it spread across the state. 276 277 THE RESTLESS RIVER congregate and enjoy the traditional theatre form known as mukha bhaona, which evolved as part of the Sattriya culture and uses mukha (masks) of mythological characters for storytelling. Mask making as an art form is closely linked to Vaishnavism. The Chamaguri Sattra in Majuli has traditionally been known for making the masks used in the traditional theatre; it is a hereditary skill passed on from generation to generation. But over the years this art is dying as the youth have demonstrated little interest in keeping it alive. We had the privilege of meeting Kosha Kanta Deva Goswami, Sattradhikari(head) of Chamaguri Sattra, master mask maker, whose family is devoted to mask making. He and his family have been engaged in various outreach activities and have held trainings to pass on the knowledge so that the art form can survive. In 2003 Kosha Kanta Deva Goswami was recognized for his contributions by the Sangeet Natak Academy. His family besides making the big masks used in mukha bhaona also makes small replicas that have found ready takers among tourists who find it convenient to carry them as mementos from Majuli. Majuli reveals Locally available materials like bamboo, cane, clay, cow dung and vegetable dyes itself as a vast are used in making these masks. The framework is made by weaving spliced strips mosaic of paddy of bamboo or cane into a loose structure, over which cloth (now paper is also used) and mustard is pasted using a light mixture of clay and water. This is sun dried, after which the fields crisscrossed features are carved out using a mixture of three parts clay to one-part cow dung. plan for the island with extensive consultations32. People are moving towards an with wetlands After these dry, the mask is painted using vegetable dyes. Accessories such as hair unknown future, where things operate beyond their powers and make them helpless. and streams, with are stuck using locally available materials like jute. A mask takes anything between From climate change to embankment politics, to floods and lives washed away by concrete bridges 12 and 15 days to complete. The masks portray characters from Indian mythology, the Brahmaputra, Majuli could have been a sad and poetic tale of loss. But it is not. in some places including gods and goddesses, demons, birds and animals. Because in their transient world, people of Majuli have devised ways of living with and rickety river water. It is this spirit of the people and their way of life that deserves to be protected. bridges at others Majuli reveals itself as a vast mosaic of paddy and mustard fields crisscrossed with It is the “Majuli way of life” that merits a heritage label. wetlands and streams, with concrete bridges in some places and rickety river bridges at others. The idyll that it symbolizes is far from reality for its residents. Limited d connectivity to the mainland is one of the main concerns. Aspirations, especially of the youth coalesces around the idea of a bridge that would connect the island to the mainland. Given that infrastructure like embankments have provided little relief, the Tea tribes bridge promises much more, such as connectivity, and access to emergency medical facilities, and markets. But the tricky terrain is a cruel pin sticking into such bubbles Pooja Kotoky and Paresh Borah of hope. The alluvial flood plain of Brahmaputra is unstable and will only support vast quantities of water passing over it, but not permanent concrete structures. ASSAM THE “land of Red River and Blue Hills” is known around the world for its tea33 and has been a major industry contributing to the economy. The backbone of Impermanence is the only way of life in Majuli. People anchor themselves into their the tea industry is the labour provided by tribal communities who were brought cultural way of life and build their hopes around a stable and yet elusive future. to Assam nearly 200 years ago to work in tea plantations. The tribals who settled Uncertainty looms large, floods and erosion have become more pronounced in the tea plantations over the years were identified as Tea Tribe (collectively) or in recent years due to changes in the climate31. Plans are afoot to conserve this Cha Jana Jati. Today this community represents 20 percent (6.5 million) of Assam’s largest inhabited river island in the world, declaring it a no-plastic zone, exploring total population34 and is composed of Santhal, Munda, Khond, Kharia, Ho, Gond, traditional methods of arresting erosion, developing an integrated conservation Bhumij, Kurukh and 112 other tribes. 278 279 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S In the face of acute shortage of manpower to clear forests and expand plantations, The indigenous groups of the state and have formed a unique identity bearing the Assam Tea Company began to bring in labour from outside the state. The labourers historical impression of colonial plantation life. Having no connections with their were brought to Assam from Bihar & Jharkhand (Ranchi, Hazaribagh, Chaibasa places of origin and intermingling with various cultures in the plantation setting of and Dumka); Bengal (Santhal Parganas, Bankura, Birbhum and Midnapur); Orissa Brahmaputra valley, the tea tribes have developed a composite community culture (Sambalpur, Balasore, Cuttack and Koraput); Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh in which the elements of the tribal culture of the Jharkhand region are predominant. (Raipur, Balghat, Bhandara, Bundelkhand, Ghazipur and Gorakhpur). And a small number were brought in from South India and Maharashtra. The present generation in the tea plantations is looking beyond life in the tea gardens. They are aspiring to create a separate identity from their parents; some are In late nineteenth century several natural calamities like earthquake, drought, flood, now first-generation graduates, and some are taking up skill development programs famines, epidemics and poverty gripped millions of lives in north-west provinces, provided by the Government and private organizations and getting recruited as Orissa, north Bengal and central India. Poor peasants and landless labourers who teachers, nurses, and mechanics. were victims of exploitation and indebtedness to zamindars or landlords, fell into the traps of contractors’ false assurances of better and easier work opportunities, d higher wages and land for cultivation in Assam. In order to recruit labourers two main systems of recruitment were followed; Boat clinics: ships of hope Contractor System (1859 to 1915) and Sardari System (1870 to 1959).35 Contractors were the licensed people whose ultimate objectives were to collect as many people Pooja Kotoky as possible to work. Without any restrictions, contractors adopted all kinds of Letters of fraudulent methods and transported labourers to Calcutta depot on foot, trucks THE BRAHMAPUTRA valley has a network of 2,500 river islands known as chars communication and goods trains, then to Assam in most inhumane and inhospitable conditions. or saporis which are home to 2.5 million people. Most of the islands lack basic between the It will not be wrong to say that they were literally uprooted from their existence, infrastructure and services like health care, schools, roads, electricity and drinking Company and heritage and culture to an unknown new world on false hope and deception to work water and sanitation. During monsoon there is no accessibility and communication Government have as ‘indenture labours’. The transportation journey became complicated during the between the mainland and the river islands. Most men from these marginalized revealed that rainy season because of the strong velocity and current of the Brahmaputra. It took communities migrate to the mainland for work, leaving behind vulnerable women streamer boats 135 to 140 days to reach Sadiya from Calcutta. and children. were introduced in the eighteen Letters of communication between the Company and Government have revealed sixties exclusively that streamer boats were introduced in the eighteen sixties exclusively to transport to transport labourers from Calcutta depot to Assam36. Because of the inhospitable journey, labourers from many lost their lives due to sickness and unavailability of treatment before reaching Calcutta depot the different tea estates in Assam, where living conditions were overcrowded and to Assam hazardous. They were not permitted leave from duty during sickness and did not have guarantee of personal freedom and liberty. The labourers were imposed with draconian rules to live and work; any violation of rules resulted in flogging, beating, and at times were brutally killed. Female labourers were pressurized to increase the birth rate and abortion was strictly prohibited to create ‘future’ generation of labourers. Post Indian Independence, with the implementation of the Plantation Labour Act of 1951 the basic standards of living for plantation workers improved. About 3 to 4 million labourers belonging to the tea tribes work in the tea industry. Today the tea tribes comprising of 96 ethnic groups, have no connections with their original homes. Since the colonial period, tea tribes have remained cut-off from the other 280 281 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S In June 2004, the Centre for North-Eastern Studies and Policy Research (C-NES), the spread of the novel coronavirus disease. They launched awareness campaigns under the leadership of Sanjoy Hazarika, launched a unique initiative to bring in the islands about the newly emerged disease and advocated the need for social mobile relief and health care facilities by boat to these marginalized communities. In distancing and carrying out community surveillance and testing. the same year (2004), C-NES won the World Bank’s India Marketplace competition for the innovative concept of “A Ship of Hope in a Valley of Floods”, and the prize money of USD 20,000 (about ₹1.37 million now) led to the construction of the first d boat clinic. Named  Akha, which means hope in Assamese, the first boat clinic was built with local raw material with the help of boat-builder Kamal Gurung. Made of wood, the boat is 65 feet in length and equipped with an out-patient department, a laboratory, cabins, toilets, water supply and a power generator. Fourteen more have been added since. The mobile health services were first started in partnership with the district administration in Dibrugarh. Later the services were expanded to Dhemaji and Tinsukia districts. In August 2008, as the waters raged around Lamba  Sapori, an island home to the Mishing community in Dhemaji, a couple, Punyadhar and Oiphuli Morang, watched helplessly as their two-year-old daughter, Moina, suffered an acute asthmatic attack. “A Ship of Hope Having seen the boat clinic pass by the sapori several times, they had some idea of in a Valley of its schedule. So Punyadhar stood atop his house and waved vigorously to the  SB Floods”. The boat Shahnaz, which was plying these waters. The team spotted the couple and made its clinics are at work way to their home, where medication was administered, and the child recovered. 24/7, 365 days This is just one incident out of hundreds which demonstrate the importance and a year value of the boat clinics. After being proven as an effective and successful model the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM), Government of Assam proposed collaboration and signed a unique private-public partnership in 2008. As of 2019 the Boat Clinics are working in 13 districts. Each boat has 2 doctors, one or two auxiliary nurses, a lab assistant and a pharmacist. These boat clinics provide curative care, reproductive and Runa Khan childcare, family planning services, basic laboratory services, emergency services and care during pandemics, epidemics, disasters and public health emergencies. Awareness programmes are also carried out on family planning, health and hygiene, nutrition and sanitation. The boat clinics are at work 24/7, 365 days a year. JAMUNA BASIN One of the special highlights of the project is the Brahmaputra Community Radio FRIENDSHIP hospital ships Station (BCRS) popularly known as Radio Brahmaputra established at Dibrugarh with the aim to target tea garden labourers and most remote islands. Currently, the Runa Khan radio reaches 14 islands, 30 tea plantations and more than 180 villages and three districts along and across the Brahmaputra on FM 90.4. EIGHTEEN YEARS ago, while visiting a char (island) on the River Jamuna, I was invited into the home of a family I had met by the riverbank. It was a humble Till March of 2019, over 2.7 million people have received basic health care services. hut made of straw and living within it was a family, along with the one cow they Annually 3,40,000 cases are handled by the Boat Clinics in all the 13 districts in possessed and the entirety of their belongings. Families like theirs barely have the Brahmaputra valley. In 2020, the Boat Clinics became the main catalyst during enough to eat two meals a day, yet I saw the wife feeding their sick child the 282 283 Runa Khan second meal of the day, just before dusk fell. It was only rice with a little onion. I Should I kill her?’ A handicap, another mouth to feed, social ostracism, and a pain asked the mother. ‘Why do you not feed her a little later so that she will sleep at watching the child suffer daily. night, contented?’ Perplexed, she looked at me with disbelief in her eyes. ‘What an extravagance!’ she exclaimed. ‘One taka (1 cent) of kerosene to light a lantern so A reverberating shock, pain, anger at the injustice broke my heart and led me to they could eat after dark! If the child falls asleep now, she will not know that she look for any solution I could find. These were areas where even the trawlers for is hungry at night.’ passenger transport used to stop plying at dusk due to remoteness and insecurity. Where the nature of the land and climate eclipsed the possibility for any permanent Another mother came with a baby who was suffering from cerebral palsy and asked infrastructure. These were the chars of the Jamuna: silted, nomadic islands formed me, ‘doctor (the village quack) said that there is nothing to be done for my child. and broken upon the river’s whim. Access to any basic services be it roads, electricity, 284 285 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S schools, hospitals, shops, police were totally unheard of. Millions lived on such chars Langalbandh festival and fair all over the country. THE LANGALBANDH fair or Gur-Pukur’s fair is one of the major religious festivals In the strife towards saving lives FRIENDSHIP started the first hospital ship on of the Hindu community in Bangladesh. The festival occurs on the eighth day of these shores. Now we could even deliver tertiary care to their doorsteps! The the lunar month which coincides with the Bengali month of Chaitra. During the Lifebuoy Friendship Hospital was followed by the Emirates Friendship Hospital on festival also known as Astami snan or holy bath Hindu devotees take a bath in the the Jamuna, and now five new hospital ships are on the verge of being launched on Old Brahmaputra river, the channel that flows through Jamalpur, Mymensingh and the Jamuna, Padma (Ganges) and other rivers of Bangladesh. Langalbandh. There are a number of ghats (steps leading to the river) or bathing places by the river, but Langalbandh and Panchami ghat on the west bank of As the Lifebuoy Friendship Hospital ship brought much needed healthcare, I Brahmaputra, are considered to be most sacred. realized just a ship was not enough! What would happen to the patients we were leaving behind? Those needing simple contraceptives or surgical follow ups? Thus, The belief of the devotees is that the holy or sacred bath will please Lord Brahma, FRIENDSHIP developed a three-tier healthcare system, the first of its kind in the provide salvation and mental purification. Thousands of people, both from the world, so no one would be left behind. 1st Tier: Ship Hospitals; 2nd Tier: Satellite country and abroad, visit the place every year for the holy bath. The fair is also a Clinics, where healthcare teams set up bimonthly medical camps in communities major tourist attraction. The fair lasts for three days, beginning on the day before the around the hospital giving primary care and follow ups. 3rd Tier: Friendship holy bath and ending in the day following the bathing festival. Community Medic-Aides: community women to take healthcare to the doorstep of every family. To link the three tiers, we used mHealth, a software that would assist to FRIENDSHIP diagnose, treat and refer patients. This way, we provide free and comprehensive care developed a three- to 6.5 million people a year, 60 percent of whom are women. tier healthcare system, the first But Saving Lives, needed global healthcare and comprehensive interventions. For of its kind in the poverty alleviation could not be ignored if that child was to eat three meals a day. world. Integrating Empowerment for the communities and to reach the services, climate action was our work with needed. Schools, trainings, access to finance and preparedness and support, even lessons learnt linkages through to governments were created. Every solution and step built on from nature, we mobility and innovation. have made a most robust global The rivers change daily. Erosions, floods, tropical tornados, famines today have healthcare system become unpredictable and extreme. Integrating our work with lessons learnt from nature, we have made a most robust global healthcare system. As the land and people move, so could the solutions. FRIENDSHIP’s integrated approach spanning over 18 years has rendered more than 36.25 million services for these climate-impacted migrant communities. Once upon a time, our very culture and life was ingrained and inseparable from the rivers and nature. Now, most of us reside within the secured glass bubbles of our cities and societies, so sheltered from nature’s wrath and generosity. Many of us have moved far away from designing our services geared to the one thing we cannot fight: nature and the environment. Humanity’s greatest challenges will come from nature in the coming years. Those who live in harmony with nature and the environment will know how to cope and survive. And it is only by respecting the environment and working alongside it, can we find the solutions in regions such as these chars of the Jumna. Sheikh Rokon d 286 287 THE RESTLESS RIVER P E O P L E : O N E R I V E R , M A N Y C U LT U R E S Bard of the Brahmaputra: Bhupen da Hazarika Atisha Dipankar Srijnan (or Srigyan) Sanjoy Hazarika Bushra Nishat TO MILLIONS he was simply ‘Bhupen da’, a legend recognized and honored in India “He crossed the mountain and Bangladesh. Covered with perilous frost: He is the Atish of Bangla While India posthumously gave him the Padma Vibhushan (he had earlier been Who lit the light of learning in Tibet”...... awarded the Padma Shri and Padma Bhushan civilian honors), his stature in South Asia was demonstrated when Dhaka honoured him with the Muktijoddha Padak, REGARDED AS the most enlightened the country’s highest civilian award. Indeed, he was cherished in Dhaka as much as and outstanding Buddhist scholar and he was in Guwahati. His song on the war of Bangladesh’s freedom, Joi Joi Nobo Joto philosopher, Atisha Dipankar Srijnan was Bangladesh (hail the newborn Bangladesh), is a stirring marching tune, which was born near the Padma in Bangladesh and on every Bengali’s lips during those harrowing days as that momentous struggle for breathed his last on the banks of the Yarlung liberation gathered strength and inspired the battle for freedom. And when Bangladesh Tsangpo near Lhasa in Tibet. Born to a royal was born, he was welcomed there like a hero. His songs were not limited to Assamese family as Chandragarbha, he was given and Bengali, and his rich baritone was equally at ease in Hindi, Urdu and English. the title named Dipankar Srijnan meaning the ‘one who has the lamp of wisdom in The waterways of Assam were the source of inspiration for his lyrics. ‘The his hands’ after initiation into Buddhism. Brahmaputra is the lifeline of Assam,’ he said. One of his notable collaborations for Invited by the king, he travelled to Tibet in Doordarshan was Luit Kinare (by the banks of the Luit), a mosaic of ordinary tales 1042 where he received the name of Atisha, a that was both cheerful and poignant. Perhaps the best example of the humanistic Tibetan reference to peace. ideals that imbue his works is Manuhe Manuhar Babe (For mankind), composed in 1964. ‘If we do not care for our fellow human beings, who will?’ sings the bard. It Atisha had a lengthy career as an academic is a song that needs to resound across Assam and the north-east at times of strife. at the Buddhist monastry, Vikramasila (in Nalanda, Bihar, India), travelled and lived in Sumatra, Indonesia for over a The waterways He was without doubt one of the greatest living cultural communicators of the decade but it was in Tibet where he found his final calling in life37. It took Atisha of Assam were region, swaying millions with the power and passion of his voice, and the message and his companions almost two years to travel on foot from India to Tibet across the source of of universal brotherhood and humanism. He had a genius for weaving a magical mountainous terrains of the Himalayas amidst climatic hazards and also attacks inspiration for tapestry out of traditional Assamese music and lyrics. In the process, he breathed by dacoits. The main route was from Palpa in Nepal to Manas Sarover38. In Tibet, his lyrics. The new life into the language, synthesizing old and new strands of music, and instilling Dipankar reformed Buddhism; he refined, systematized, and compiled an innovative Brahmaputra is a sense of pride in the Brahmaputra valley. Bard of the Brahmaputra.  But he was and thorough approach to bodhichitta known as “mind training” (lojong in Tibetan). the lifeline more than that: he was a passionate fighter for rights, for the poor (his early and later Atisha also wrote on engineering and agriculture and devoted more than a decade of Assam, songs drive home the messages of equality, humanity and brotherhood especially in of his life for the well-being of the Tibetan people. He employed his engineering Bhupen da said times of pain and tragedy) and who believed in the importance of means over ends. skills for construction of a dam in western Tibet for protecting communities from floods and helped in setting up an irrigation system by digging canals which led to It was because of his persistence as head of the Sahitya Kala Parishad that the Satriya boosting of agricultural productivity39. dance, performed originally in the satras or Vaishanvite monasteries, is today recognized as one of India’s ‘national’ dance forms. Bhupen Hazarika was at the Dipankar wrote, translated and edited more than two hundred books, which helped confluence of these great streams, bringing them together in his unique way, with spread Buddhism in Tibet. Tibetans revere Dipankar, granting him a rank second humanity and equality as his principles and symbols. only to Gautam Buddha and refer to him as Jobo Chhenpo (a great God)40. d d 288 289 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R 6. HARNESS Tapping the River Xiawei Liao Uttam Kumar Sinha Qu Bin M Niamul Naser Minakshi Bora RTI International & ELMS Ganesh Pangare Shanaj Laila 290 291 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R THE YARLUNG Tsangpo Brahmaputra Jamuna river system provides water for The share of industrial water uses increased from 5 percent in 2006 to over 8 percent irrigation, and domestic use along the entire length of the river system, supporting in 2011 and then decreased and stabilized at around 5 to 6 percent in recent years. the water-dependent livelihoods of riparian communities such as agriculture and The share occupied by domestic water uses have almost tripled from 3 percent to fisheries. In some sections of the river system, water is used in industries and for nearly 9 percent during the last decade. power generation as well. Figure1: Historical water use change in the Yarlung Tsangpo from 2006 to 20172 Infrastructure In the Yarlung Tsangpo basin, recent trends show increasing water usage for industrial 2.5 systems, such and domestic purposes. Due to a small population and limited development in the Total water use Agriculture Water use from the Yarlung Tsangpo (billion m3) Industry Domestic as hydropower Tibetan region of China, water quality is relatively pristine in the upper reaches stations, inland of the river system while the water quality can be seen to deteriorate downstream 2 waterways, with increasing human activities. In the Brahmaputra and Jamuna basins, the river and ports have also provides a wide range of other benefits that are important to riparian social been gradually economies, such as inland water transport. Hydropower production is gaining 1.5 developed to increasing appreciation in the upper hilly regions. Most of the water withdrawn harness such from the river in Brahmaputra and Jamuna basins is used for agricultural purposes. 1 benefits provided by the river Infrastructure systems, such as hydropower stations, inland waterways, and ports 0.5 have been gradually developed to harness such benefits provided by the river. While the river presents a natural barrier for connectivity between two banks, the acceleration of bridge building has overcome such barriers and significantly 0 increased the connectivity in the basin, which also plays a fundamental role in the 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 social and economic development of the riparian communities. d Water uses for irrigation, industrial and domestic purposes RTI International & ELMS1 YARLUNG TSANGPO River is an important source of water for the Tibetan Region in China. Water supply from Yarlung Tsangpo on average makes up about 60 percent of the total water supply in the Tibet Autonomous Region, rising from 40 percent in 2008, indicating the increasing importance of the river to the social economy of Tibet. Even so, water use from the upstream Yarlung Tsangpo remains low compared to the volume of water available from the river. From 2006 to 2017, total water use increased from 1.76 billion cubic meters (bcm) to 2.14 bcm, peaking at 2.25 bcm in 2014. (Figure 1). Although agriculture is the largest user of water, the share of agricultural water use has decreased from over 92 percent in 2006 to just above 85 percent in 2017. Domestic water use has increased by the largest margin, by over 230 percent, from 2006 to 2017, compared to 60 percent for industrial water uses and only 12 percent for agricultural water uses. 292 293 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R basin, some 80 percent of irrigation originates from groundwater, particularly for the cultivation of boro rice4, which has been an important driver for attaining food self-sufficiency in Bangladesh in the last two decades. Currently, there are more than 1,270 Flood Control Drainage and Irrigation (FCDI) schemes in the country, developed by the Bangladesh Water Development Board (BWDB) and the Local Government Engineering Department (LGED) and covering more than 6 million hectares. From 1995 to 2015, LGED developed around 720 small-scale water resources sub-projects that improved water management for around 450,000 hectares of land. In addition, there are four barrages across the Teesta, Tangon, Buri-Teesta, and Manu rivers, which are used as diversion structures for supplementary irrigation. Irrigation development, accompanied by high yielding value crop development, particularly boro rice, and making use of the abundant groundwater resources, has shown spectacular results in the country. Due to climate change and unregulated groundwater use, less water is available for Irrigation irrigation during the dry season in a large part of the Jamuna basin. Therefore, a well- development, planned irrigation management system is essential for gradually increasing crop accompanied intensity as well as yield. Irrigation efficiency needs to be improved with modern by high yielding water management technologies to enhance food productivity through optimal value crop use of available water resources. As part of the climate change strategy, creation development, of water reservoirs and rainwater harvesting in rain-fed/coastal/hilly areas will be particularly encouraged, and small-scale water resources systems may be developed. boro rice, and making use of Domestic and industrial water uses in the Jamuna basin are mostly derived from the abundant groundwater sources. The pumping of groundwater has increased with increasing groundwater population in the basin. As a result, land subsidence has become a growing concern, resources, and has pushed urban water managers to more strongly consider a substantial switch has shown to surface water sources. Owing to concerns about water quality, such a switch spectacular would require higher water treatment costs, and could exacerbate the competition results in the for water in the dry season, inducing tradeoffs with agricultural and navigational country water uses. More targeted and managed groundwater recharge during wet periods could help offset these rising pressures but has not previously been practiced in a In the Brahmaputra and Jamuna basins, surface water irrigation is mainly confined systematic way. to the flat and fertile lands of the valley, though small-holder irrigation also occurs in the hilly upstream terrain of the Brahmaputra and Teesta basins. Large-scale The importance of water resources for the industrial sectors in Bangladesh, an irrigation is supported by several barrages, including India’s Teesta Barrage, which important engine for the country’s growth during the last 10 to 20 years, is growing regulates the discharge for nearly 1 million hectares in India and about 150,000 rapidly. Whereas water demand is still low compared to the agriculture sector, hectares in Bangladesh. This infrastructure could irrigate 750,000 hectares in industrial use is expected to grow by 440 percent by 2050. Water resources are Bangladesh3. Surface water irrigation in these zones is highly water intensive and particularly important for the textile, fertilizer, and leather industries, both in terms three rice crops are commonly grown (aus, amman, and boro); the first two depend of consumptive needs and in view of the pollution pressures caused. Water is also heavily on floods, while the boro crop, which achieves by far the highest yields, is used in thermoelectric power generation both as a cooling agent and for steam planted as floods recede. Risks of crop failure during the early monsoon are highest; generation used for power generation. The textile sector accounts for more than 85 a large flood event can destroy those crops and does so with regularity. In the Jamuna percent of all export earnings, more than 10 percent of GDP, and provides direct 294 295 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R employment to more than 4 million workers. Both textile and leather sectors have It is claimed that K+ in waters of the global river is primarily from the silicate minerals high growth rates projected for the next 20 to 30 years. leaching, and in small amounts from other sources that often include one or more among evaporite minerals, fertilizers, rain waters and the decay of land plants10. d Therefore, with few fertilizers or decay land plants along the Yarlung Tsangpo basin, the concentrations of K+ presented relatively low levels. It has been widely accepted WATER QUALITY that Cl– in surface waters of rivers contributed by the cyclic salts is expected to decrease with increasing distance from the sea11. Yarlung Tsangpo river With the major contribution of the rainfall during the monsoon season to the Majority of the Qu Bin annual discharge of the Yarlung Tsangpo12, water chemistry is inevitably affected by dissolved solids the precipitation which is dominated by the India monsoon. However, as the roof of in the Yarlung GENERALLY, THE Yarlung Tsangpo had an alkaline aquatic environment: pH in the the world, the high elevation Himalaya blocks most of the water vapor flux from the Tsangpo are Yarlung Tsangpo basin was between 8.3 to 9.0 with an average of 8.8. TDS (total Indian Ocean to the Tibetan Plateau and declines the precipitation in this area13. As mainly derived dissolved solids) varied greatly from 66 mg L-1 to 265 mg L-1 with an average 157 a result, the concentration of Cl- in the Yarlung Tsangpo was lower than most rivers from various rock mg L-1 in the mainstream channel, which was higher than that of the world average. in the world. weathering as The water chemical characters of the Yarlung Tsangpo vary along the whole river well as numerous system, and are significantly shaped by the different geology, meteorological and Figure 2: Average concentrations of major cations of the mainstream of the geothermal anthropogenic conditions within the river basin5. Yarlung Tsangpo and rivers in the other regions in the world. (Modified from springs and Qu et al.14) mineral-rich The water chemical The Tibetan Plateau is the youngest and highest plateau in the world, where TDS (mg L-1) alpine lakes characters of weathering and physical erosion take place at a fairly high rate6. Solutes in the Yarlung the Yarlung Tsangpo river waters have multiple sources, deriving from physical, chemical and Tsangpo vary biological processes in the drainage basin such as weathering of rocks, groundwater Yarlung Tsangpo (mainstream) along the whole supplication, precipitation transportation, and as well as anthropogenic input7. It river system, and has been proposed that the majority of the dissolved solids in the Yarlung Tsangpo Asia average median are significantly are mainly derived from various rock weathering (namely, carbonates, evaporates, shaped by the silicate) as well as numerous geothermal springs and mineral-rich alpine lakes Europe average median different geology, distributed in the Sothern Tibetan Plateau8. meteorological Africa average median and anthropogenic Major ions (Ca , Na , K , Mg , Cl , HCO , SO4 ) in the mainstream of Yarlung 2+ + + 2+ – 3– 2– NO3– conditions within Tsangpo fluctuated but with a general underlying steady trend from the source to North + Central America average median CI– the river basin the downstream. When compared with other rivers in the world, concentrations HCO3– of most ions in the mainstream of the Yarlung Tsangpo were higher than the South American average median world average. For instance, concentration of SO42– in the mainstream of Yarlung SO42- Tsangpo was 37.4 mg L-1, almost four times higher than that of the global average Oceania average median K+ (Figure 2). Na+ Global averages median Besides the precipitation and weathering supply, the evaporation along the upper Mg2+ reaches of the river basin significantly exceeds rainfall because of the abundant Global discharge-weighted average Ca2+ annual global radiation9, both of which could lead to the high ion concentrations (e.g., Ca2+, Na+, Mg2+, HCO3–, SO42–) in the Yarlung Tsangpo. Differently, ions K+ and Cl- in waters of the Yarlung Tsangpo had a lower concentration than the world 0 100 200 300 average level. Concentration (mg L-1) 296 297 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Table 1: Chemicals of health significance as described by international guideline (WHO) and Most of the concentrations of the elements are at low level in river waters of the China national guideline (GB) for drinking-water quality. Concentrations in Yarlung Tsangpo Yarlung Tsangpo compared with the global average19. It should be noted that high were presented in range and average, repectively concentrations of manganese (Mn), copper (Cu), cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) were found in parts of the socio-economically developed regions in the Concentrations Yarlung Tsangpo river basin. The trace element in waters of the Yarlung Tsangpo are Parameter Unit in Yarlung WHO16 Remark GB574917 Remark Tsangpo 15 mainly governed by the weathering of bedrocks followed by up-concentration due to high aridity, human activities might also have an effect on the water chemistry pH 8.3-9.0, 8.8 Optimum: 6.5–8 6.5–8.5   over the region. Notably, in the Yarlung Tsangpo near the Yangbajing, high levels of TDS mg L -1 66-265, 157 18 NA Optimum: <1200 1000 arsenic (As) were observed, which is mainly due to the distribution of arsenic-rich Turbidity NTU 14.2-62.4, 26.1 5 NA springs within the basin20,21,22. Aluminum μg L-1 3.1-128.8, 43 200 200 Antimony (Sb) μg L -1 1.7-18.4, 4.8 20 5 River water chemistry is highly variable by natural environment conditions such Watercourse Arsenic (AS) μg L-1 0.2-80.2, 20.2 10 as basin lithology, hydrology and climate. Based on the pH and ions study, waters within the in the Yarlung Tsangpo river basin were characterized by high alkalinity due to the Yarlung Tsangpo Barium (Ba) μg L-1 5.6-28.7, 15.1 700 700 high concentrations of Ca2+ and HCO3–. TDS was ~157 mg L-1 in the basin fluctuated River can Bicarbonate (HCO3-) mg L-1 28.1-92.1, 68.0 NA Optimum: <600 NA from 66 mg L-1 to 265 mg L-1, which was in a common level compared to other be generally Cadmium (Cd) μg L -1 0.2-14.2, 2.7 3 5 rivers in the world. The ionic characteristic study of river water chemistry of the considered Calcium (Ca ) 2+ mg L -1 12.3-46.3, 27.5 NA Optimum: <250 NA Yarlung Tsangpo was mainly controlled by natural processes, such as weathering pristine Chlorine (Cl) mg L-1 0.4-5.8, 2.3 5 (C) For total chlorine 4 For total chlorine of carbonates, silicates, and evaporites, and drainage from geothermal waters and For total saline lakes. By comparison with the standards from WHO and GB for drinking Chromium (Cr) μg L-1 0.2-4.1, 3.3 50(P) 50 For Cr(+6) water, all ions were within the maximum desirable limits and concentrations of chromium Copper (Cu) μg L-1 0.3-7.4, 2.2 200 100 most elements were under the guideline of WHO. Watercourse within the Yarlung Tsangpo River can be generally considered pristine. Fluorine (F ) – mg L -1 0.1-0.2, 0.16 1.5 1 Potassium (K) mg L -1 0.2-1.2, 0.9 NA Optimum: <250 NA d Lead (Pb) μg L-1 1.6-55.7, 12.4 10 10 Magnesium (Mg2+) mg L-1 1.3-12.5, 4.7 NA Optimum: <150 NA Manganese (Mn) μg L -1 0.8-265, 40.7 400(C) 100 Brahmaputra River Molybdenum (Mo) μg L-1 0.6-2.0, 1.3 70 70 Minakshi Bora Nitrate (NO3–) mg L-1 0.1-2.9, 1.1 10 For nitrogen (N) 10 For nitrogen (N) Sodium (Na+) mg L-1 1.2-9.1, 5.2 NA Optimum: <200 200 BRAHMAPUTRA RIVER plays an important role in the life and livelihood of the riverine Sulfate (SO4 ) 2– mg L -1 11.0-112.8, 38.7 NA Optimum: <500 250 population apart from supporting unique watershed ecology and therefore its water Uranium (U) μg L-1 0.7-4.2, 2.2 30 (P) NA quality assessment is pivotal. Unfortunately, proper water sampling and laboratory- Zinc (Zn) μg L-1 2.2-60.6, 17.0 NA Optimum: <3 1   based water quality assessment covering the entire length of the river is largely missing in case of Brahmaputra River. Hence, the establishment of a detailed and scientific Note: NA= no health based guideline value is provided; According to WHO Drinking-water Quality 4th edition (2011): field-based water quality database for the river is very much essential for deploying and A = Provisional guideline value because calculated guideline value is below the achievable quantification level; strengthening a proper water quality management plan. An attempt has been made C = Concentrations of the substance at or below the health-based guideline value may affect the appearance, taste or to analyze an already existing database procured by Prof Dulal C Goswami under the odour of the water, leading to consumer complaints; Northeastern Integrated Flood and Riverbank Erosion Management project (Assam) D = Provisional guideline value because disinfection is likely to result in the guideline value being exceeded; sponsored by Asian Development Bank during the year 200723. Unlike other water P = Provisional guideline value because of uncertainties in the health database; quality studies done so far on the Brahmaputra, the advantage of this study is that it T = Provisional guideline value because calculated guideline value is below the level that can be achieved through practical covers the entire length of the river in Assam in the upper, middle and lower reaches treatment methods, source protection, etc. 298 299 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Figure 3: Map showing the sampling sites Table 2: Water Quality of Brahmaputra River at selected sampling sites Kahai Parameters Pach Ali Matmara Tekelifuta Dhansirimukh Sakopara Khanajan Palasbari Gumi Spur Color Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Colorless Water Quality Samping Locations in Brahmaputra River, Assam Odor Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Temperature 20 18 22 20 21 22 24 22 19 pH 7.5 5.8 7.4 6.2 7.1 6.9 6.7 6.7 7.7 EC 3400 800 2000 1800 2400 2600 3100 3000 3600 TSS 172 189 137 169 180 197 193 183 229 TDS 13.6 15.7 12.9 12.1 14.2 17.1 17.4 16.9 18 Total Hardness 64 42 46 50 52 42 52 48 50 Calcium 12.02 14.43 12.83 16.83 13.6 14.4 13.07 12.02 15.23 Magnesium 51.97 27.572 33.18 33.17 38.4 27.6 38.93 35.98 34.77 DO 6.49 8.91 8.91 12.16 8.1 9.7 7.41 9.73 10.54 BOD 4.2 4.6 3.6 3.9 4.2 3.2 3.46 3.25 3.96 Chloride 34.02 25.56 22.72 29.82 27.4 24.1 27 27 26 Legend Sampling Points Sulphate 7.44 4.69 10.78 12.11 6.7 8.4 10 10 10 Sandbar Nitrate 3.91 4.32 4.21 2.76 2.3 1.8 3.14 3.26 BDL River Ammoniacal 3.8 4.5 1.2 1.8 3.1 2.8 2.8 2.4 2.1 Nitrogen Phosphorus BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL Manganese BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL Iron 0.87 0.9 0.91 0.86 0.76 1.12 1.84 1.12 0.9 Like all other each with multiple sampling points. The sampling sites are namely Pach Ali, Kahai Indian rivers, Spur, Matmora, Tekelifuta, Dhansirimukh, Sakopara, Khanajan, Palasbari and Gumi Fluoride 1.4 1.07 1.33 1.6 1.4 1.07 1.27 1.46 1.37 coliform (Figure 3). Arsenic 0.002 0.003 0.01 0.012 0.002 0.001 0.004 0.001 0.002 contamination is considerably A total of 24 different water quality parameters viz. color, odour, temperature, Lead BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL BDL high in the pH, electrical conductivity (EC), total suspended solids (TSS), total dissolved solids Total Coliform 9 12 7 9 9 11 9 9 11 Brahmaputra (TDS), total hardness, calcium, magnesium, Dissolved Oxygen (DO), Biochemical river along major Oxygen Demand (BOD), chloride, sulfate, nitrate, ammonical nitrogen, phosphorus, Fecal Coliform 1 2 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 locations at the arsenic, iron, manganese, lead, fluoride, total coliform and fecal coliform were vicinity of human analyzed by following the standard protocols given by Trivedy and Goel24 and N.B: All the parameters are in mg/l except temperature (˚C), pH, electrical conductivity (µS/cm) & Arsenic (ppb); BDL-Below habitation APHA25. Based on the collected data an overview of the water quality status has been Detection Limit obtained and the results are presented in Table 2 given below and are discussed in the Source: Field monitoring and analysis done by Department of Environmental Science, Gauhati University subsequent paragraph. 300 301 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R city reports very high coliform count in the recent past (Central Pollution Control Board report). Notably, bacteriological quality of the Brahmaputra River water is generally worst during May and June when a lot of surface runoff occurs during the early monsoon outbreaks. Besides, another water quality parameter, that is, turbidity, which was not monitored during the present study, is also of major concern in the river. According to a report by East Siang Public Health Engineering Department during the year 2017, turbidity level as high as 425 NTU was recorded in the Siang river which is a major contributor of the Brahmaputra river. The excessive suspended sediment load during rainy seasons is responsible for the high turbidity levels in the river water. Excessive turbidity of the Brahmaputra river in the recent times is also related to the geological instability of the region. As the river valley and its adjoining highlands lies in geologically unstable and seismically active Eastern Himalayan belt, it experiences frequent earthquakes. These earthquakes trigger massive landslides and the debris thus generated in turn increases the turbidity of the river water26. Furthermore, in order to attain a broader perspective about the overall water Excessive quality status, a water quality index (WQI) calculation was also performed using turbidity of the Weighted Arithmetic Index method27. WQI aims at assigning a single value to the Brahmaputra water quality of a source by translating a list of parameters and their concentrations river in the present in a sample into a single value28. A pioneer work by Brown et al29 stated that recent times is according to the range of WQI values, five water quality status categories can be also related to classified: 0 to 25 is excellent; 26 to 50 is good; 51 to 75 is poor; 76 to 100 is very poor; the geological and finally, above 100 is unsuitable for drinking and fish culture. The WQI values instability of calculated in the current study ranged from a minimum of 29.8 to a maximum of the region 74.5. Out of nine sampling sites, four sites, namely, Pach Ali, Tekelifuta, Sakopara and Palasbari exhibited good water quality status with WQI values less than 50. While the remaining five sites, Kahai Spur, Matmora, Dhansirimukh, Gumi and Khanajan, exhibited poor water quality status with WQI values ranging between 50 and 75. Proper treatment is suggested prior to any use of the water falling under poor category. Fortunately, direct pollution sources are mostly absent in the Indian stretch of the Brahmaputra River channel and moreover, owing to the huge amount of water discharge carried by the river, the pollutants added to it easily gets dispersed or diluted with time and space. However, a concerning fact about the overall water Out of the 24 parameters examined, six parameters, that is, pH, electrical conductivity quality of the Brahmaputra river is that some of its tributaries like Dibru, Bhugdoi, (EC), magnesium, fluoride, iron and coliform count were observed to have crossed Dhansiri, Gelabil and Bharalu are considered to be very polluted which in turn are either the desirable or the permissible limit given by various standardization contaminating the otherwise pristine water of the Brahmaputra river to a great agencies such as BIS and ICMR. The survey indicates that surface water quality of extent. The present set of data will provide valuable insights in designing a suitable the Brahmaputra River is acceptable in terms of mineral content and organic matter. and holistic water quality management scheme in the Indian part. However, like all other Indian rivers, coliform contamination is considerably high in the Brahmaputra river along major locations at the vicinity of human habitation. d River Bharalu, a tributary of Brahmaputra which drains through the Guwahati 302 303 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Jamuna River With the establishment of British rule in 1826 C.E., the From a river to a drain: the necessity of an all-weather road for the purpose of M Niamul Naser Bharalu river facilitating military transport was strongly felt by 1836 C.E. By 1865 C.E., some steps were taken to construct THERE ARE quite a few cities and urban areas situated on the banks of the Jamuna Shahnaj Laila such a road. In order to sustain a large workforce, 32 and its tributaries, but there are no major industrial zones along the river. Pollution supply chains had to be maintained, especially the usually originates from domestic waste and agricultural sources along the river. The Originating in the Khasi Hills of India’s north-eastern supply of firewood for fuel. With a sanction from the water quality parameters are within national standards as can be seen from Table 3 state of Meghalaya, the nearly 13 kilometers long Bengal government in 1872 C.E., the Bhoraldhap and water quality improves during monsoon as any pollution is flushed away by the Bharalu river starts off as the Bahini/Bihini near the forest area near Rani, adjacent to the Deepor Beel, river. Basistha Ashram at its foothills. According to Puranic was identified as a suitable site for felling timber, from legends, Lord Brahma’s son, the great sage Basistha, which the tree-logs would be floated to Guwahati by Table 3: Physicochemical condition of the Brahmaputra and Jamuna river system meditated at this very site to rid himself of a curse the river Bharalu. This is one example of the use of the 33 of Bangladesh given by one King Nimi. On Lord Vishnu conferring Bharalu as a waterway. him with a boon of salvation, the sage brought down However, this entire stretch of the river has been River System Year pH DO mg/l BOD mg/l TDS mg/l Chloride References mg/l the three streams (Tridharas) of the celestial Ganga, polluted today due to rampant urbanisation and the namely, Sandhya, Lalita, and Kanta, to this point and unchecked disposal of waste into its waters, rendering Brahmaputra R 2016 7.18-7.78 5.8-7.6 1.0-2.2 52.2-168.0 4.0-12.0 DOE 2017 absolved himself of all sins by taking a ritual bath there. it unfit for human consumption. It has become a sewer 2012 6.63-8.1 5.4-9.4 2.0-4.2 71-163 2.0-8.5 DOE 2014 Herein, the combined tridharas came to be known as and sections of it are known as the Mora Bharalu (Mora 2010 6.82-7.28 4.0*-6.6 1.8-12.4* 62-120 4-8.5 DOE 2012 the Basistha Ganga. On the banks of this river sprang is Assamese word for dead), with putrefying stench up an ashram attributed to sage Basistha and is both wafting through the air. The river’s catchment areas of Jamuna R 2016 6.76-8.19 6.4-8.5 1.2-4.2 62.2-125.3 4.0-10.0 DOE 2017 a holy place as well as a popular picnic spot today. In central Guwahati are urban sprawls, and the prescribed 2012 7.2-8.46 5.9-8.5 2.8-11.0* 63.1-165.6 1.5-8.5 DOE 2014 1764 C.E., the Ahom King Rajeswar Singha built the width of its channel (40 feet) has been reduced to only 2010 6.16*-8.7 4.6*-7.4 2.0-5.0 66.0-170.0 3.0-14.5 DOE 2012 Jogeswar Shiva Temple within the ashram complex, 5-10 feet at many points due to encroachment. The surrounded by the Garbhanga Reserve Forest which is a Bharalu has been named as one of the 71 most polluted Meghna R 2016 6.08-7.09 0.8*-7.1 0.2-8.4* 28.1-228.0 2.0-30.99 DOE 2017 rich elephant habitat. rivers in India by Central Pollution Control Board. 2012 6.24*-7.6 5.2-7.2 0.3-3.4 45.0-150.0 3.0-11.0 DOE 2014 A few kilometres from this point, the river Such problems have led to flash floods inundating 2010 6.75-7.3 5.0-12.0 6.9*-20.2* 26.0-195.0 2.5-18.0 DOE 2012 bifurcates into two rivulets – the Basistha flowing many areas annually during monsoon. Moreover, towards the Ramsar site, Deepor Beel (Beel is an the dangerously high levels of diarrhea causing fecal Tista 2016 7.24-7.54 6.45-7.55 1.9-3.2 65.0-255.0 NA DOE 2017 Assamese word for a lake); and the Bahini, meandering coliform bacteria make the water unsafe for drinking. 34 EQS** values for 6.5 – 8.5 ≥5 ≤6 1000 150-600 DOE 2017 through Guwahati city before emptying into In 2013, the Pollution Control Board of the Bangladesh the Brahmaputra at Bharalumukh (mouth of the Government of Assam, following the guidelines of Bharalu literally).30 It flows through areas like Beltola, the National River Conservation Directorate of the * Values indicating the anomalies from EQS given by Department of Environment (2017) Ganeshguri, R.G Baruah Road, before taking a sharp Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of ** EQS, Environmental Quality Standard of Department of Environment (2017) turn from the Assam State Zoo, whereon it comes to India, came up with a Detailed Project Report to clean be known as the Bharalu. The river passes through up and restore the Bharalu.35 A Feasibility Report of Comparing the river water qualities, in 2010, 2012 and 2016, the total dissolved some of the densest population clusters of the city the Guwahati Development Department of Assam solids (TDS) and chlorides content were in good values of ranges for the DOE including Ulubari and Sarabhatti before it meets the Government has also listed the Bharalu as one of (2017) environmental quality standards (EQS). The pH, dissolved oxygen (DO) and Brahmaputra.31 the priorities of Guwahati Smart City development Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) have always been a challenge for the rivers of Historically, riverine transport was the preferred project involving a number of measures. It remains Bangladesh (see * values). In 2010, the pH values of Jamuna and in 2012 in Meghna medium of movement of people and goods in Assam a mammoth task and needs proper planning and fell slightly below the standard values. The slight alkalinity of water could be due to since it was inexpensive and the topography difficult. execution.36 soil pH or for domestic and agricultural wastes disposed in the banks of the river. The DO, in 2010, falls slightly below the EQS values in Brahmaputra and Jamuna rivers, while in 2016, it was far below in Meghna river system. For the Brahmaputra 304 305 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R and Jamuna rivers this may be due to low water flow and for Meghna river due to industrial effluents in the lean water flow period. The BOD indicates that the sewage contamination was earlier due to sporadic issues in both Brahmaputra and Jamuna rivers; but common in Meghna river system. Looking at the values of the upper riparian segments of Teesta river along with the Brahmaputra and Jamuna rivers, the northern rivers are in good aquatic state, especially for fishes. Further, the downstream Meghna river water quality is recently getting altered. There is a lack of detailed biological productivity and elements like plankton and benthos in the river ecosystem. d NAVIGATION Inland navigation Uttam Kumar Sinha Yarlung Tsangpo river In a region where water is predominantly used for irrigation and with seasonal variation in rainfall, along with higher level of urbanization, maintaining channels for navigation is inherently difficult. Frequent flooding during the monsoons makes inland navigation more arduous. However, if the policy directive is to maximize broader social, economic and environmental benefits, then the inland navigation highest inland waterways cargo movement (one tonne over one kilometre) in the projects could not only support greater and faster economic growth but also lead world. It considers inland port infrastructure critical to its global trade growth and to higher cooperation among the riparian countries. Navigation channels on the has targets to improve the waterways with calls for strengthening shipping capacity, rivers as they flow and cut across the territorial boundaries in the region should expanding roadway and railway networks, and building large-scale logistics centres. be designed to become “pathways for prosperity” by interfacing with the social Even on the Mekong River, China plans to develop 500 tonnes shipping navigation and economic needs of the riverine communities rather than being narrowly capacity along the 630 kilometers stretch of the river from Yunnan province to China has the implemented for transportation utility by moving large containers from one river Luang Prabang in Laos. largest network port to another. The emphasis on transboundary river cooperation cannot be less of waterways and highlighted. For example, careful site-selection and constructing more storage The middle reach of the Yarlung Tsangpo River is about 100 kilometers and the highest inland dams in the upper reaches of the rivers could provide the twin benefits of flood the elevation changes from 3,993 to 2,780 meters above the sea level, with an waterways cargo management and adequate water flows for navigation in the downstream plains. average gradient of 0.13 percent. Annual precipitation in the middle reach of the movement (one Upstream-downstream cooperation on inland navigation is not unique as such Yarlung Tsangpo river decreases dramatically from 60 millimeters in Nyingchi, tonne over one arrangements are witnessed in several basins like the Nile, Amazon, Rhine and the to 43 millimeters in Lhasa, to 28 millimeters in Gyantze. There are no significant kilometre) in Danube with discernable social and economic benefits including mechanisms to inter-annual precipitation changes. Precipitations are concentrated from June to the world protect the environment and ecology of the rivers. September, making up 90 percent of the annual total. The inflow of the middle reach of the Yarlung Tsangpo river mainly depends on precipitation, ice melting and Inland navigation on the Yarlung Tsangpo is not a priority for China like, for example, groundwater recharge. Inter-annual flows are relatively stable37. Since 1962, there the Yangtze river, winding through 9 provinces from east to west, which is regarded have some been short-distance transport around the Milin County. However, due as an economic super-zone or more commonly as the ‘golden waterway’ generating to the large elevation change and high altitude, the potential for inland waterway 40 percent of China’s GDP. China has the largest network of waterways and the development in Tibet has largely remained unutilised. 306 307 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R River transportation Along with the development of modern infrastructure such as roads and railways, the river system is still a major mode of transportation for goods and people in India and Bangladesh. Waterways can be a cost efficient, environment-friendly mode of transport with huge potential to enable diversion of traffic from over-congested roads and railways. 308 309 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Brahmaputra River India, on the other hand, has 14,500 kilometers of recorded inland waterways. History of inland water transport on the Brahmaputra38 As compared to other means of transport, inland waterways are the least capital- intensive and with relatively low infrastructure costs, it is best suited to carry over- Brahmaputra in Assam has served as a means of transport and communication of merchandise dimensional cargo (ODC). Despite such advantages, waterways trade in India and people from and to Assam. Long before the advent of the railway system into Assam, the river constitutes less than 4 percent of the total inland cargo movement. maintained the link with other parts of the country through the network of its waterways and hundreds of boatmen were employed in its services. It was the lifeline of Assam. At various stages in the history of the Indian sub-continent’s economic growth, waterways helped to create economic wealth. In probably the most authentic physical The modem steamship service between Assam and Calcutta was first introduced by a Calcutta-based account of the Indian frontier, the Imperial Gazetteer of India (1909) describes the British-owned river transport company, the India General Navigation and Railway Company Ltd, which Brahmaputra basin as the “great highway” of the Himalayas from the plateau of Tibet was founded around 1844. Another British-owned company which started operation was the River to the plains of Assam. Like the Indus in the north-west, the bend of the Brahmaputra Steamer Company that was founded in 1867 and subsequently renamed as River Steam Navigation Company. Later on, both these companies came to be known as the Joint Steamer Companies. In 1967 the Central Inland Water Transport Corporation, a Government of India undertaking, became the legal successor of the joint steamer companies, in Calcutta. The river service was well organized, an infrastructure developed on the riverine route, and it became one of the world’s most flourishing internal trade routes. The river was the bulk carrier of Assam’s tea and jute to Calcutta, two of the country’s most valuable foreign exchange earners. The steamer services from and to Calcutta were finally closed down during the Indo - Pakistan conflict of September 1965 and the century old, checkered history of the inter- state trade and commerce came to an end. The main exports of Assam, tea, leather, and jute have to find their way to Calcutta for internal distribution in India and export overseas. These have necessarily to be carried by the inland waterways. Tea has to be carried by the river route not only because the railways cannot carry the entire traffic, but because the waterway is quicker than by rail and the tea warehouses in Calcutta are so located that they can mostly be used in conjunction with water transport.” Imports into Assam from Calcutta were food grains, foodstuffs, salt, mustard oil, iron and steel materials, cement, cloth, textiles, etc. involvement in river navigation, while road and rail enjoyed continuous state support during the British rule. Despite extension of the Assam-Bengal Railway Inland waterways enfolds the Himalayas in the south-east and as the Gazetteer notes, “This magnificent from Guwahati to Tinsukia in 1902 and to Lumding and Dibru-Sadiya in 1903; 98 are the least natural outlet of the glacier and snow-fed drainage of the north is still a matter of percent of the weight of the trade was carried by the Brahmaputra in the Assam capital-intensive speculative interest to geographers, although enough of it is known to justify the valley during the time. and with relatively expectation that it may yet be recognized as one of the world’s highways.” low infrastructure With the partition and the ensuing politics, the significance of inland waterways in costs, it is best suited Romesh Dutt, the eminent economic historian had expressed, “Nature had provided the stream of development thinking remained much neglected in the region since to carry over- India with great navigable rivers which had been the high roads of trade from 1947. dimensional cargo ancient times. And the system of canals, fed by these rivers, would have suited the requirements of the people for cheaper although slower transit, and would have This is fundamentally changing now with the realisation that waterways can be a at the same time increased production, ensured harvests and averted famines.” He cost efficient, environment-friendly mode of transport with huge potential to enable went on to describe how narrow commercial considerations prevented the state’s diversion of traffic from over-congested roads and railways. In 2016, through an Act 310 311 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Bangladesh has over 24,000 kilometers of rivers, rivulets and canals of which one-fourth of Parliament, India designated 111 rivers as national waterways and signalled a Dhubri to Sadiya in Assam. are navigable strong stake in harnessing its network of rivers for inland navigation. during the Jamuna River monsoon and In addition to the 111 rivers already identified for development of waterways, there Bangladesh has over 24,000 kilometers of rivers, rivulets and canals of which one- nearly one-sixth are about 116 rivers, that can provide 35,000 kilometers of navigable stretches. fourth are navigable during the monsoon and nearly one-sixth during the dry periods. during the By overlooking these natural waterways, the logistics cost in India today runs About 50 percent of Bangladesh’s cargo traffic moves through these waterways along dry periods very high at about 18 percent. Comparatively in China it is 8 to 10 percent and with nearly one-quarter of all the passenger traffic. Most of the freight transported 10 to 12 percent in most European countries. Inland waterways transport is cost by waterways in Bangladesh is bulk cargo including construction materials, effective when compared to rail and road transport. Calculations suggest that the petroleum products, fly-ash, fertilizers and food grains. There are over 22,000 cost of transporting cargo by waterways is one-fourth the cost of transport by rail registered vessels engaged in trade and passenger movement. In addition, there are and one-sixth the cost of transport by road. In an age of environmentally sound more than 750,000 local or country boats for transport of goods and people. These approaches, trade on waterways leaves a small carbon footprint. Estimates suggest are the lifelines for the poorest communities. Bangladesh is emphasizing strongly that 1 horsepower can carry 4,000 kilograms load in water but only 150 kilograms on regional inland waterways transport with its Connectivity Project Phase 2. The by road and 500 kilograms by rail. One litre of fuel can move 105 tons weight per focus of these initiatives will be largely on long-distance trade and transport, bulk kilometer by inland waterways but only 85 tons per kilometer by rail and 24 tons per cargo, connecting the sea ports and the National Waterways 1 (NW1) to National kilometer by road. India has a vision plan on the Brahmaputra section of the river Waterways 2. It is developing large number of waterways as a national priority. Some called the National Waterways 2 (NW2) and is currently focused on the route from of them will connect with those in India to facilitate transboundary navigation. 312 313 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R The Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Authority (BIWTA) established 21 inland Cargo Traffic (billion ton-km) river ports and 380 landing stations in the country through 2014. In 2013–14, BIWTA Total Road % Rail % IWT % recorded 87.40 million passengers and 35.18 million tons of cargo for the nine major 1975 2.6 0.9 35% 0.7 28% 1.0 37% river ports. Inland water transport is mainly used for the transport of bulk, dry bulk, and liquid bulk of construction materials, food grains, fertilizer, clinker, petroleum 1996 10.7 6.9 63% 0.8 7% 3.0 30% products, and other products. A large fleet of about 10,000 inland vessels are engaged Annual Growth 6.9% 8.6% 0.8% 0.1% in the carriage of goods and passengers. There are also approximately 750,000 boats 1996-2005 powered by pump engines operating mainly in the rural waterways. 2005 19.6 15.7 80% 0.8 4% 3 16% Source: World Bank (2007) BIWTA’s ongoing activities include dredging of waterways, procurement of dredgers and ancillary crafts, development of an inland container terminal at Table 5: Employment in Inland Water Transport (IWT)41 Ashuganj, improvement of inland ports and landing stations, development of landing stages in rural areas, and development of waterways around Dhaka city. IWT Employers Employed IWT Employers Employed An inland container terminal has been developed through a joint venture project of Public Sector Private Sector BIWTA and Chittagong Port Authority with an annual handling capacity of 116,000 Bangladesh Inland Water 4,000 Landing Stations 668,000 TEUs39, which is to be followed by another four inland container terminals under Transport Authority construction by the private sector. Bangladesh Inland Water 5,000 Inland Vessels 75,000 Transport Corporation About 50 Despite being the cheapest mode of transport, the popularity of inland waterways Department of Shipping 60 Dockyards 101,000 percent of transport as a mode of passenger and cargo transportation has been declining. Bangladesh’s The modal share of inland waterways transport fell from 16 percent passenger and Country boat and 5,500,000 cargo traffic 37 percent cargo in 1975 to 8 percent passenger and 16 percent cargo in 200540. Mechanized country boat moves through Much of the competition came from the road transport system. Inland waterways County boat yard 10,000 these waterways transport has suffered because many rivers of the country have been deteriorating Total 6,363,000 along with both from natural, morphological processes and from withdrawal of water from nearly one- the rivers causing decreased dry season navigability. This was further aggravated by Table 6: Existing Navigation Routes in Bangladesh quarter of all poor or no maintenance of navigability, weak regulations and safety standards, low the passenger allocation of budgetary funds, and general under-investment by both public and Route Length (km) Remarks traffic private sectors. Tables 4 and 5 below illustrate the declining share of inland-water Alaipur-Raita-Laxmipur 32 During lean period the transportation (passenger and cargo) from 1975 to 2005, and Table 6 shows that Paksey-Lauskandi-Ghoramara 7 minimum depth remains almost all the existing routes fall in the basin area. 1.5 m Talbaria-Shantigram-Sengram 25 Table 4: Modal share of passenger and cargo Sengam-Habaspur-Stabaria 3 Nazirganj-Durgapur 6 Passenger Traffic (billion passenger-km) Padma-Jamuna confluence 14 Total Road % Rail % IWT % Sub total 87 1975 17.0 9.2 54% 5.1 30% 2.7 16% Alaipur-sarda 14 Hydrographic survey 1996 66.0 52.0 79% 3.9 6% 10.1 15% Sardu-Rajshahi 15 never carried out Annual Growth Premtali-Godagari 6 7.1% 6.6% 0.7% 1.3% 1996-2005 Sub total 35 2005 111.5 98.4 88% 4.2 4% 8.9 8% Total 122 Source: Mishra et al. 201242 314 315 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Sand quarrying Sand quarrying is an important source of livelihood in India and Bangladesh; but needs to be monitored in order to alleviate the negative impacts 316 317 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R the town of Dhubri on the Bangladesh border and Sadiya in Assam and the 71 kilometers NW-6 on the Aai river in Assam (through Bangladesh) will open up greater economic benefit in the region benefiting the Indo-Gangetic plains, Bangladesh and the north-eastern states of India, which suffer from huge logistic cost of essential supplies. The waterways connectivity presents to Bangladesh an opportunity to sell its commodities like garments, pharmaceuticals, and leather to India, Bhutan, and even Nepal. Currently Bangladesh sources less than 10 per cent of import from India, and less than 1 per cent of exports. A situation that will rapidly change for the better as the navigational routes are further developed. Table 7 shows that all inland water transportation protocol routes either origin or terminate in Chandpur, which is within the greater Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna basin with river ties to the entire Brahmaputra River system. Table 7: Description of Protocol International Routes with India International navigation Route Shoal Year of Name Class Distance # Length Min. depth Survey Uttam Kumar Sinha (km) (km) (m) Raimangal-Chandpur route INLAND WATERWAYS transport on the Brahmaputra is particularly promising between India and Bangladesh. The protocol agreement between these two countries Raimangal-Chalna II 119 2 1.7 1.6 and 2.2 2010 remains a stable framework for transit and trade. The Bangladesh-India joint Chalna-Mongla I 16 1 0.5 2.1 2010 communiqué, published in January 2010 during the visit of the Prime Minister of Mongla-Ghasiakhali I 31 1 20.0 0.5 2010 Bangladesh to India, showed that an understanding had been reached to introduce Ghasiakhali-Chandpur I 200 - - - 2004 transit trade through Bangladesh to connect mainland India and its northeast. This was considered as a breakthrough attempt to re-align Bangladesh’s long-term Chandpur-Daikhawa route The waterways development strategy with neighboring India. The India-Bangladesh Protocol on Chandpur-Aricha II 119 - - - 2006 connectivity Inland Water Transit and Trade (PIWTT) signed in 2015 allows for inland vessels Aricha-Sirajganj II 92 6 6.0 (-)1.3-(+)1.8 2010 presents to of one country to transit through specified routes of the other country with each Sirajganj-Bahadurabad II 88 5 5.0 (-)1.3-(+)1.0 2010 Bangladesh an country providing facilities of ‘ports of call’. opportunity to sell Bahadurabad-Chilmari II 62 5 5.0 (-)1.2-(+)2.2 2010 its commodities The following year, a vessel from Kolkata traversed Bangladesh to the north-eastern Chilmari-Daikhawa II 37 3 3.0 0.1 -1.5 2010 like garments, Indian state of Tripura highlighting the value of the protocol routes in boosting Chandpur-Zakiganj route pharmaceuticals, the isolated markets of northeast India and allowing the region access to the and leather to industrial and market centres in India and Bangladesh. The 19th PIWTT Standing Chandpur-Bhairab Bazar I 123 NA - 2002,2006 India, Bhutan, Committee meeting between the two countries in 2018 significantly improved the Bhairab Bazar-Madna III 63 1 10.0 1.2 2010 and even Nepal protocol routes with the inclusion of Rupnarayan river (NW-86) and expanded Madna-Ajmiriganj III 47 1 23.0 (-)1.0 2010 the number of ‘ports of call’ from five to six on each side by including Kolaghatin Ajmiriganj-Sherpur III 71 - - - 2010 in West Bengal and Chilmari in Bangladesh. Standard-operating procedures for movement of passengers and cruise vessels on the inland routes were also agreed. Sherpur-Zakiganj III 115 1 1.5 1.5 2010 Combining the services of the 1,620 kilometers NW-1 on the Ganga-Bhagirathi- Source: Mishra et al. 201243 Hooghly river system and the 891 kilometers NW-2 on the Brahmaputra between 318 319 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R In addition, Bhutan is also benefitting. Landlocked Bhutan can finally find access Enhancing navigation to the sea through downstream India and Bangladesh. For the first time in July 2019, using the Brahmaputra waterways from Dhubri in Assam to Narayanganj Uttam Kumar Sinha in Bangladesh, Bhutan was able to ship stone aggregates using India as a transit. The cargo was first transported by land routes from Phuentsholing in Bhutan HAVING UNDERSTOOD the overall benefits of inland waterways and factored the to the Dhubri jetty covering a distance of 160 kilometers and thereon by ship to cooperating actors in the equation, the question of how to enhance the scope of Narayanganj. The cargo capacity was 1,000 MT equivalent to 70 trucks on road. The the Brahmaputra waterways becomes pertinent. The Brahmaputra has enormous development of Jogighopa in Assam as a logistics hub for movement of cargo to and potential to capture the regional aspiration but before it is fully realized it has a from the north-eastern states and Bhutan gives fillip to the development of inland serious challenge to overcome and that being ensuring adequate water flows waterways on the Brahmaputra. particularly during the dry months. The bilateral approach with India and Bangladesh on the Brahmaputra continues to Storage dams: Building storage dams in the upper reaches of the Brahmaputra basin outline its engagement. In the context, therefore, the lower-riparian cooperation on can provide multiple benefits notwithstanding the negative social and ecological the Brahmaputra is of greater value. The sub-regional platforms like the Bay of Bengal impacts of building such structures. A cost-benefit analysis suggests that some of Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC) the negative impacts can be off-set by the positive gains. which has transport and communication as one of the 14 sectors of cooperation and the Bangladesh-Bhutan-India and Nepal (BBIN) initiative to enable people For one, the storage dams will result not only in a perennial and reliable inland and cargo movement across borders can act as a catalyst for cooperation on inland waterways transport but will also bring higher availability of water in the dry months waterways. for drinking water supplies, irrigation and industrial and commercial use. Second, it will enhance flood management capabilities leading to lower social and economic d 320 321 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R costs of floods and third with an all-season water transportation, climate change The World Bank-funded Assam Inland Water Transport Project is a timely venture mitigation efforts will be strengthened. to help modernize the waterways transport services by building terminals, installing night navigational aids, connecting more areas and ensuing easy accessibility in all It is estimated that for every tonne per kilometer of transportation on water seasons. This has the potential to spur economic trade at one level and at another to GHGs emission is calculated to be 25 percent of that of transport by road. Fourth, facilitate education and health services to the riverine communities. development of water storage dams would require long-term planning, financial capabilities, sub-regional cooperation among the Brahmaputra-basin actors like Furthermore, as Bangladesh is a cornerstone to enhancing inland waterways and Bangladesh and Bhutan and above all provincial or intra-state understanding any plans to expand India’s ambitious national waterways will have to include in the north-eastern region of India. As a spin-off the overall benefits and gains trade to and through Bangladesh, given the recent traction in the bilateral relations from inland waterways transport can encourage water use efficiency in the water Bangladesh is seeking Indian investment in almost 100 special economic zones sectors. Significant water savings could further result in enhanced flows during (SEZs). India could take advantage of the proposal particularly in constructing dry season. cargo terminals, which are in shortage in Bangladesh. Additionally, Bangladesh could consider allowing Indian vessels to load/unload at all designated ports of River dredging: Bangladesh has also taken a decision to dredge its rivers, and it call, a courtesy that India offers to Bangladeshi vessels, and adopt improved vessel will be advantageous for India to extend dredging services to Bangladesh. In fact, standards. dredging work on Ashuganj-Zakiganj section on the Kushiyara river and Sirajganj- Daikhowa section on the Jamuna has commenced with India providing 80 percent of d financial contribution. Once the work is complete, the river route, it is expected, will become navigable all year round for cargo vessels boosting further the connectivity and economic gains in the region. As a spin-off the Navigation services: Night navigation services for safe shipping and navigation overall benefits between Pandu-Silghat stretch of the NW2 near the Bangladesh border has and gains from already been implemented and such systems and technologies like the river inland waterways navigation information system or the differential global positioning system transport can that India has installed at various locations on the NW2 should be offered to encourage water Bangladesh. use efficiency in the water sectors The technical and infrastructural advancement of the NW2 is driving hydrographic surveys and feasibility studies, many of them already completed, on a number of rivers meandering the north-eastern states. The total navigational length calculated is 1,213 kilometers of which the prominent ones connected to the Brahmaputra are the Subansiri (NW95), Dhansiri (NW31), Lohit (NW62), Aai (NW6), Beki (NW73), Dehing (NW30), Kopili (NW57) and Puthimari (NW82). The Aai and the Beki along with the Drangme Chhu or the Manas and the Mo Chhu or the Sankosh flow from Bhutan and empties into the Brahmaputra in Assam while the Wang Chhu confluences with the Brahmaputra in Bangladesh after traversing through West Bengal. Inland water transport infrastructure: Particularly for Assam, the development of the inland waterways transport cannot be more critical. A vast populace both urban and rural need transport facilities and rely on small ferry services for their daily activities and livelihood. There are, however, operational limitations to these services. 322 323 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Liuwu Bridge: The first multi-bridge flyover on the Lhasa River Liuwu Bridge is the first modern flyover in Tibet located on the Lhasa River. Its construction was completed in 2007. The whole bridge is 29 meters wide and 1,660 meters long with the main bridge and two approaches, south and north. The design of the Liuwu Bridge has embodied many Tibetan cultural details such as the lotus shaped pier, which symbolizes luck. Lhasa Bridge: The most scenic bridge on a tributary of Yarlung Tsangpo Having been completed on July 1st, 2006, Lhasa bridge has become one of the most scenic spots in Tibet. The bridge is 940 meters long in total and located at an altitude of 3,700 meters above the sea level. It is only 2 kilometers from the Lhasa station and about 5 kilometers from the city center of Lhasa. The bridge is designed as flowy while kha-btags (traditional ceremonial scarf in Tibetan Buddhism) welcome guests from far away. The design also resembles snow mountains that are seen everywhere in Tibet. Brahmaputra river The mighty Brahmaputra river, flowing through the Assam valley is one of the longest rivers in India. Brahmaputra river is known as the lifeline of Assam state and separates the northeastern states from the rest of India. Six rail and road bridges have been constructed over the Brahmaputra in Assam and four new bridges are Bridges and connectivity proposed. Xiawei Liao Dholia Sadiya Bridge, Dhola Sadiya Dhola Sadiya Bridge or Bhupen Hazarika Bridge across the mighty Brahmaputra Dhola Sadiya BRIDGES CREATE connections. They allow safe passage where previously was not river (Lohit River, a major tributary of the Brahmaputra River) at 9.15 kilometers, Bridge or Bhupen possible or was much more difficult. While the River and its tributaries are full of is the longest bridge in India and become operational in 2017. Prime Minister Hazarika difficult topographies, many bridges have been built. A selection of the bridges in the Narendra Modi inaugurated India’s longest road bridge over Brahmaputra River on Bridge across basin is listed and illustrated here in this section. 26 May 2017. the mighty Brahmaputra Yarlung Tsangpo river A year after the Dhola-Sadiya Bridge was inaugurated, the Government of India river at 9.15 announced plans for a longer bridge over the river Brahmaputra, which is likely kilometers, is Qushui Bridge: The first modern highway bridge in Tibet to be completed by the year 2026-27. It will run between Dhubri in Assam and the longest bridge Qushui Bridge is located in the Qushui County in Tibet, 60 km to the Southwest Phulbari in Meghalaya, close to the Bangladesh border. At 19.3 kilometers, the new in India of Lhasa. As the first modern highway bridge in Tibet, it entered into operation on bridge will be twice as long as the Dhola-Sadiya Bridge. August 1st in 1966. The bridge is 300 meters long and 10 meters wide. Bogibeel Bridge, Dibrugarh Yarlung Tsangpo Bridge: The longest bridge on the Yarlung Tsangpo Bogibeel Bridge  across the Brahmaputra river in Dibrugarh is the longest road The Yarlung Tsangpo Bridge, also called Cross Yarlung Tsangpo Bridge, is the longest and rail bridge in India. The 4.94 kilometers long road-cum-rail bridge connects bridge on the Yarlung Tsangpo until now. The construction started in April 2003 and Dhemaji district and Dibrugarh district of Assam. This is also Asia’s second longest started being used in August 2005. The bridge is 12 meters wide and 3,797 meters rail-cum-road bridge, longest combined rail and road bridge in India and second long with 108 openings. Each opening spans across 35 meters. The bridge is built on longest bridge in Assam after Bhupen Hazarika bridge. a total of 216 pile foundations. 324 325 THE RESTLESS RIVER The Jamuna Bridge, also known as the Bangabandhu Bridge, is the longest bridge in Bangladesh. It has been named after the founder president of Bangladesh - Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Saraighat Bridge, Saraighat New Saraighat Bridge, Guwahati  Saraighat Bridge in Guwahati is the first rail-cum-road bridge over mighty The 1.49 kilometers long new Saraighat Bridge over the Brahmaputra river near old Brahmaputra river in Assam. The Saraighat Bridge over the river Brahmaputra links Saraighat rail-cum-road bridge was inaugurated in 2017. This is the second bridge the northeast region with the rest of the country. on Brahmaputra river at Saraighat. Saraighat Bridge Kolia Bhomora Setu, Tezpur Jamuna river in Guwahati Kolia Bhomora Setu (Bridge) is a 3.15 kilometers long road bridge over the is the first rail- Brahmaputra river near Tezpur, connecting Sonitpur with Nagaon. The bridge The 18.5 meters wide and 5.63 kilometers long Jamuna Bridge, also known as the cum-road bridge is one of the most important links between the northeastern states and rest Jamuna Multi-Purpose Bridge, or the Bangabandhu Bridge, was opened in 1998 and over mighty of India. is the longest bridge in Bangladesh. It has been named after the founder president Brahmaputra of Bangladesh - Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. The bridge connects the river in Assam Naranarayan Setu, Jogighopa district of Bhuapur on the east bank of the river to the town of Sirajganj on the west Naranarayan Setu is another important road-cum-rail bridge over the Brahmaputra bank. The bridge carries both road and rail traffic, as well as gas, electricity and river in Assam, connecting Jogighopa with Pancharatna. The 2.284 kilometers telecommunications and was designed to bring the north-west region of Bangladesh long double deck bridge is listed as one of the  most impressive rail-cum-road into the country’s mainstream economy and make inter-regional trade easier. It is bridges of India. part of the Asian Highway and the Trans-Asian Railway establishing a strategic link between the eastern and western parts of Bangladesh44. 326 327 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R Using water power to make incense Incense sticks are an important component of worship in Tibetan culture. Incense sticks are lighted in temples, homes, place of work and business and are an essential part of daily life. These pictures depict the process of using the power of flowing water to turn the wheels of the grinders for making a paste of the fragrant wood which is used to make the incense sticks. 328 329 THE RESTLESS RIVER Hydropower production RIT International & EIMS THE YARLUNG-Brahmaputra-Jamuna Basin has the potential for power generation from large storage dams as well as run-of-river and micro-hydro installations. Despite unmet demand for energy in the region, only a limited number of projects have been implemented to date45. The most important include the Zangmu Dam and several other storage projects in China46, the aforementioned Teesta Barrage (which has a capacity of 67.5 MW), two other Teesta dams under construction in India (Low Dam III and IV), and several mid-sized structures on tributaries of the Brahmaputra in Bhutan. Bhutan has seen improvements in development The Yarlung- outcomes through investment in hydropower Brahmaputra- production and export. Analyses show that Jamuna Basin has control infrastructures in this basin mainly the potential for advance energy production, except for the Teesta power generation Barrage, which is mainly for irrigation. Dams far from large storage upstream in the basin may provide only limited dams as well flood protection due to modest storage-to-flow as run-of-river ratios and their inability to buffer against the and micro-hydro heavy monsoon rainfall that falls in downstream installations portions of the basin47. Upstream dams, however, could have a major influence on augmenting dry season flows. The Zangmu hydropower station at the middle reaches of the Yarlung Tsangpo started operating in 2015. It is located next to the southern Tibetan county of Gyaca, which has a population of around 17,000. Located in a V-shaped valley at 3,200 meters above sea level, the Zangmu hydropower station is regarded as the highest in the world. The 510-MW plant is the largest in Tibet and equivalent to the entire existing hydropower-generating capacity of Tibet48. The Siang River is also endowed with rich hydropower potentials, amounting to more than 46 GW49. But it has been seen that hydropower development depends on various factors which include technical difficulties and political 330 331 THE RESTLESS RIVER H A R N E S S : TA P P I N G T H E R I V E R India have already signed agreements for distribution of power. Currently with only one hydropower plant of 230 MW, Bangladesh is yet to take part in the negotiations. Possibilities for inclusion for Bangladesh exist, as the country is already allowing India for trans-shipment of goods between Assam and Meghalaya and the Kolkata port of India. India and Bhutan have enjoyed long and fruitful collaboration in the hydropower sector by providing clean electricity to India, generating export revenue for Bhutan, and further strengthening the bilateral economic linkages.51 The two countries have successfully concluded several power sharing agreements. In 1961, India and Bhutan signed the Jaldhaka agreement, constructing the Jaldhaka project situated on the Indian side of Indo-Bhutan border in West Bengal. A major part of the power produced at The sale of Jaldhaka hydropower plant was exported to southern Bhutan. In hydropower 1987, Bhutan’s first mega power project, the 336-MW Chukha accounted for Hydropower Project (CHP) was fully funded by the Government the largest share of India with a combination of grant and loan. of Bhutan’s GDP. It is also the Subsequently, the two countries also signed the Agreement on most important Cooperation in the Field of Hydroelectric Power (HEP) in July export item 2006, which outlines the framework for cooperation in the field contributing of Hydropower. In 2008, the two countries further signed the about 40 percent Protocol to the 2006 Agreement and agreed to increase the export of Bhutan’s total of electricity from Bhutan to India from 5,000 MW to 10,000 MW exports by the year 2020. Of these, three projects totaling 2,940 MW (1,200 MW Punatsangchu-I, 1,020 MW Punatsangchu-II and 720 MW Mangdechu HEPs) are under construction. The Brahmaputra opposition, dearth of adequately investigated projects, land acquisition problem, basin provides environmental concern, regulatory issue, long clearance and approval procedure, The sale of hydropower accounted for the largest share of Bhutan’s GDP. It is also the scope for mutual the dearth of good contractor, and sometime law and order problem are the cause most important export item contributing about 40 percent of Bhutan’s total exports. benefit of the for the slow development of hydropower. India finds her interests fulfilled in alleviating their power deficiency by supporting stakeholder Bhutan and Bhutan in turn finds an opportunity to optimize its national income countries with Although Assam has one of the lowest hydropower potentials in India’s northeastern through power exports to India. respect to energy states, it has harnessed the maximum hydropower potentials in the region. generation Among all the northeastern states in India, Assam has harnessed maximum hydro In addition to hydropower, sources of cooling water are going to be a major issue for potentiality, 55.14 percent, followed by Sikkim 15.6 percent and Meghalaya 11.78 large-scale thermal power plants. Water is required in various processes at thermal percent. Currently, Assam has a capacity to produce 680 MW of hydro power, with power plants, primarily for cooling purposes. Significant volumes of water are used another 275 MW capacity unexploited50. to cool down the steam exiting the steam turbines to dissipate the residual heat. Air cooling tower technology could be a solution if adequate water cannot be arranged The Brahmaputra basin provides scope for mutual benefit of the stakeholder from the respective rivers. countries in respect to energy generation. India and Bhutan have hydropower potential, and both these areas have a list of planned hydropower plants. Bhutan and d 332 333 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N 7. GOVERN Framework for co-operation Ganesh Pangare Bushra Nishat Xiawei Liao Shafi Sami Gautam Bambawale Golam Rasul Taylor W Henshaw Jayanto Bandyopadhyay Anamika Barua Ambuj Thakur 334 335 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N INTRODUCTION Ganesh Pangare and Bushra Nishat ACROSS THE globe, investments in infrastructure development such as roads, embankments, dams, barrages, diversions, irrigation schemes and power facilities, while bringing visible benefits at the local and national level, are also creating multiple burdens and risks to the river and millions of people who are dependant for their lives and livelihoods on the rivers, associated wetlands and aquatic resources. In the case of international/transboundary rivers like the Yarlung Tsangpo-Brahmaputra-Siang-Jamuna, these risks and burdens are made more complex by sovereignty implications and There are 263 geopolitical dimensions. Countries and governments need to move transboundary towards a perspective of shared opportunities for positive regional water sources benefits, while keeping in mind national and local needs and in the world interests. Transboundary water management needs to harmonise that straddle or water policies and standards and brings into focus issues at different cross political levels and across sectors, encompassing not only technical but also boundaries of one social and economic implications. This is the reason it is important or more sovereign to understand, national as well as regional arrangements of all states, constituting countries in a basin. over 80 percent of worlds fresh water Development in the Basin has historically been piecemeal and sources – rivers undertaken on a project-by-project basis at the country level. and aquifers Agreements between riparian countries in the region are mostly bilateral and may or may not have a holistic approach to water resources management. The complex geopolitics between riparian countries has been amplified by an incomplete basin knowledge base, the varying professional water resources management and technical capacities of the basin countries, and power asymmetry among the riparians. The absence of a basin-wide cooperative framework has translated into missed opportunities for regional economic growth, including in agriculture, hydropower development and trade, inland water transport, and disaster risk reduction. This section is an inventory of the water management institutions, policies and transboundary agreements for the riparian countries of the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang- Brahmaputra-Jamuna basin – China, India, Bhutan and Bangladesh and also looks at challenegs and opportunities in the region. Rustam Vania d 336 337 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N International1 and policy framework for the mandate to manage international/transboundary issues related to the Yarlung- transboundary water management Tsangpo. China In addition those two departments, China Renewable Energy Engineering Institute under the MWR and the National Energy Administration are involved in Hydropower Taylor W. Henshaw Development Planning along international rivers; Ministry of Emergency Management, Department of Flood and drought prevention (MWR) and Department of Water CHINA SHARES about 40 major transboundary watercourses with Afghanistan, Project Operation Management (MWR) are involved with dam operations along Bangladesh, Bhutan, Cambodia, India, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Laos, Mongolia, the international rivers; Bureau of Water Transport of the Ministry of Transport is Myanmar, Nepal, North Korea, Pakistan, Russia, Tajikistan and Vietnam. Most responsible for transport activities on international rivers. transboundary waters are located in the southwest area of the country (including: Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna; Shiquan/Indus; and Lancang/Mekong). Although transboundary rivers seem to be not of major concern to China’s water policy Among these transboundary rivers, 12 originate in China. China is located upstream makers, since it is hardly discussed or seen in China’s policies, reports, governmental on most of its shared transboundary rivers. mandates and so forth, China has a record of (mostly bilateral) formal institutions with its neighboring countries regarding all different aspects related to transboundary Transboundary China was one of three countries to vote against the 1997 Convention on the Law of the river cooperation, for example, hydrological data sharing, navigation, fisheries, water water Non-Navigational Uses of International Watercourses (UN Watercourses Convention). sharing, economic cooperation. It should be noted that China’s transboundary river management Although China is not a party to Multilateral Environmental Agreements on water, cooperation institutions are primarily bilateral and less multilateral and most of them needs to it supports the principle of exchanging data and information with its neighboring harmonise riparian states2. water policies and standards According to Feng and He3 – “trans-boundary water is mainly the responsibility of and brings into Ministry of Foreign Affairs because it relates to the relationship among the riparian focus issues at countries. Yet given that Ministry’s lack of specific knowledge of water resources, it different levels must always be assisted by other ministries related to water issues”, most importantly and across Ministry of Water Resources (MWR), Ministry of Ecology and Environment sectors (MEE), National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), National Energy Administration (NEA) as well as Energy State-owned Enterprises (SOEs) who are involved with hydropower development on international rivers. The leading unit, Division of International Rivers is set up under the Department of International Cooperation, Science and Technology of MWR whose mandates include: “In charge of foreign affairs related to international rivers, research and formulate related policies, organize and coordinate negotiations related to international rivers.” Furthermore, in accordance with the 2002 Water Law, revised from the 1988 Water Law, which stipulates that “the state shall exercise a water resources management system of river basin management in conjunction with jurisdictional management”. the South-western rivers, including the Yarlung-Tsangpo, sit under the jurisdiction of the Changjiang Water Resources Commission. To summarize, within the MWR, Changjiang Water Resources Commission has the mandate to manage domestic issues with respect to the Yarlung-Tsangpo River as a River Basin Organization, while the Department of International Cooperation, Science and Technology has 338 339 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N do not focus exclusively on transboundary watercourses but on a broader cooperation agenda. In the north, a number of Sino-Russian transboundary water accords are in place (including the 2008 China-Russia Agreement Concerning the Reasonable Use and Protection of Transboundary Waters). The least formal arrangements are in place with South Asian countries regarding especially the Indus and Yarlung Tsangpo - Brahmaputra river basins. However, there has been a long history on transboundary water cooperation between China and India, which dates back to the 1950s and the process is summarized by Feng et al4 as below in Table 1. Table 1. China-India cooperation on transboundar rivers5 Year Events Cooperation 1950 Diplomatic ties established in 1950; Provisions of discharge data in 1955, and of hydrologic the prime ministers visited each information (discharge, rainfall, and water level) in 1957. other in 1954 1984 Agreement on trade in 1984. Indian In 1993, agreement on environmental cooperation signed, prime minister visited China in 1988 along with gradual restoration of Sino-Indian relations 1997 Protocol on Cooperation In 2002, MOU and the Implementation Plan on the Yarlung- Tsangpo/Brahmaputra 2003 Declaration on the Principles of MOU in 2005 and Implementation Plan in 2008. The Expert Relations and Comprehensive Level Mechanism on Trans-border Rivers (ELM) established Cooperation in 2003; Joint in 2006, and the Work Regulation in 2008. MOU in 2008 and Declaration in 2005 Implementation plan in 2010. 2010 Joint Communique MOU in 2010 and Implementation Plan in 2011 on the Langqen Zangbo/Sutlej River. 2013 Joint Declaration; Agreement on MOU in 2013 and the Implementation Plans upon the Border Defence Cooperation. Yarlung-Tsangpo/ Brahmaputra in 2013 and in 2014. MOU on Strengthening Cooperation on Trans-border Rivers in 2013 economic development of all riparian countries” and the “cooperation on trans- 2015 Joint Declaration In 2015, MOU upon the Langqen Zangbo/Sutlej River. border rivers will further enhance mutual strategic trust and communication as well as 2018 Informal summit of the top leaders In 2018, MOU and Implementation Plan upon the Yarlung- strengthen the strategic and cooperative partnership.” A revised implementation plan Tsangpo/ Brahmaputra; the 11th meeting of the ELM held; (containing technical details of provision of information, data transmission methods China notified of emergency information on a landslide on the and cost settlement) was executed in June 2014. mainstream to India. An Expert Level Mechanism (ELM) was established in 2006 between China and India China has reached memorandums of understanding with India and Bangladesh on to discuss interaction and cooperation on the provision of flood season hydrological flood control and sharing hydrological data on the river. In 2002 China agreed to data, emergency management and other issues as agreed regarding transboundary provide flood season hydrological data (water level, discharge and rainfall) at three rivers. The ELM has held 11 meetings since its establishment, and only one annual stations located on the river from June 1 to October 15 every year. The MOU expired meeting cancelled, in 2017 because of the border conflicts. Normal issues discussed in in 2007. Similar five-year MOUs were reached in 2008 and 2013. In 2013, China agreed the agendas include reviewing previous bilateral cooperation and utilization reports to provide an additional 15 days of hydrological data (May 15 to October 15) each year on the provision of hydrological information, and discussion of the MOUs and the on the River. The parties agreed to “further strengthen cooperation on transboundary relevant implementation plans. Other issues agreed on by both sides (but without rivers, cooperate through the existing Expert Level Mechanism on provision of flood- detailed information) include strengthening cooperation, exchanges on the situation season hydrological data and emergency management, and exchange views on other of the projects on the Yarlung-Tsangpo - Brahmaputra, notification on blockages of issues of mutual interest.” Both sides recognized that transboundary rivers and related the mainstream, and so on6. In general, the ELM is the normal channel and a technical natural resources and the environment are “assets of immense value to the socio- decision supporting organization between China and India to facilitate transboundary 340 341 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N India Taylor Henshaw INDIA HAS entered into a number of transboundary water agreements, ranging from water allocation to hydropower development, with Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China and Nepal. India-China Agreements India has reached MoU with China on flood control and sharing hydrological data in the Yarlung Tsangpo. In 2002 China agreed to provide flood season hydrological data (water level, discharge and rainfall) at three stations located on the river from June 1 to October 15 every year. The MOU expired in 2007. Similar five-year MOUs were reached in 2008 and 2013. In 2013, China agreed to provide an additional 15 days of hydrological data (May 15 to October 15) each year on the river. The parties agreed to “further strengthen cooperation on transboundary rivers, cooperate through the existing Expert Level Mechanism on provision of flood-season hydrological data and emergency management (see below), and exchange views on other issues of mutual interest.” Both sides recognized that transboundary rivers and related natural resources and the environment are “assets of immense value to the socio-economic development of all riparian countries” and the “cooperation on trans-border rivers will further An Expert Level enhance mutual strategic trust and communication as well as strengthen the strategic Mechanism was and cooperative partnership.” A revised implementation plan (containing technical established in details of provision of information, data transmission methods and cost settlement) 2006 between was executed in June 2014. India and China to discuss An Expert Level Mechanism was established in 2006 between India and China to interaction and discuss interaction and cooperation on the provision of flood season hydrological data, cooperation on emergency management and other issues as agreed regarding transboundary rivers. the provision of flood season India-Bhutan Agreements hydrological The 1949 (and updated in 2007) India-Bhutan Friendship Treaty provides for data, emergency water cooperation. But it has a limited working scope, and its effects are restricted by perpetual peace and friendship, free trade and commerce, and equal justice to each management the broader Sino-Indian diplomatic relations. other’s citizens. The Treaty is the basis for present-day joint hydropower plants on and other issues Brahmaputra tributaries in Bhutan. China has also entered into comparable MOUs with Bangladesh in 2006 and 2008. In a 2007 Joint Communique, the countries agreed “to cooperate in the field of water India’s Hydropower Partnership with Bhutan resources, utilize and protect the water resources of transnational rivers in the region Bhutan and India have a reciprocal arrangement that sees a power-deficient India keeping in mind the principles of equity and fairness.” In 2008, China entered into supply technical and financial assistance to resource-rich Bhutan to develop numerous hydrological data sharing MoU with both Bhutan and Bangladesh, providing that in hydropower projects for the benefit of both countries Bhutan relies on the export of flood season, China will provide hydrological information to Bhutan and Bangladesh power (which accounts for about 20-25 percent of GDP) for sustainable development, from three hydrological stations along the main stream of the Yarlung Tsangpo. while India acquires much-needed energy to drive its rapidly growing economy. d Since 2007, cooperation between Bhutan and India has been enhanced through 342 343 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N agreements over long-term purchases and Indian financial support for hydropower of principles” on sharing the Teesta waters. The two countries could not reach projects in Bhutan, as well as the introduction of public-private partnership arrangements. agreement in 2011. In March 2013 the President of India assured Bangladesh of India’s India and Bhutan have signed memoranda of understanding to reach this installed commitment to a “fair, reasonable solution” on the Teesta and stated that consultations capacity target. Ten hydropower projects have been planned for implementation over with stakeholders would take place. Bhutan’s 10th and 11th Five-Year Plan cycles. The installed capacity additions by 2020 will tap a projected 42 percent of Bhutan’s technically feasible hydropower resources. India-Bhutan Agreements An India-Bangladesh-Bhutan Working Group on Water and Power has been established An India- In addition to hydropower development, India and Bhutan have cooperated to for sub-regional cooperation on water resources management and hydropower Bangladesh- establish the Comprehensive Scheme for Establishment of Hydrometeorological and development. The first meeting was held in April 2013. The parties agreed at that time Bhutan Working Flood Forecasting Network on Rivers Common to India and Bhutan (1979). This network to prepare a framework for trilateral cooperation. There has been no further reporting Group on Water consists of 35 hydrometeorological stations located in Bhutan. (These stations are on the Working Group’s progress. and Power has maintained by Bhutan with funding from India). A Joint Expert Team (comprised of been established officials from both governments) tracks the progress of the network. The two countries d for sub-regional have also formed a Joint Group of Experts on Flood Management. This entity discusses cooperation on and assesses the probable causes and effects of the recurring floods and erosion in the Bhutan water resources southern foothills of Bhutan and adjoining Indian plains. It recommends remedial management measures. Taylor Henshaw and hydropower development India-Bangladesh Agreements BHUTAN SHARES a 600 kilometer border with India on the east, south-west and India is not party to any agreements with Bangladesh on the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang- west; and a 470 kilometer border with China on the north and northwest. Bhutan’s Brahmaputra-Jamuna. international water agreements primarily focus on hydropower projects with India. The country also has flood forecasting and warning agreements with India and The Teesta, a tributary of the Jamuna, has been a longstanding issue between India and China. Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) is the designated ministry of the Royal Bangladesh since 1952. India has constructed the Teesta barrage at Gazaldoba, West Government of Bhutan which oversees the foreign relations of Bhutan. The Ministry Bengal, upstream of the India-Bangladesh border, to provide water to northern parts has the Department of Multilateral Affairs which focusses on transboundary water of West Bengal. In 2010, during the 37th Indo-Bangladesh Joint River Commission, management. As per Bhutan’s National Water Policy7: Bangladesh proposed a draft “interim agreement” and India offered a “statement • Trans-boundary water issues shall be dealt in accordance with international laws and Conventions to which Bhutan is a signatory. • Cooperation in information sharing and exchange, appropriate technology inwater resources development and management, flood warning and disastermanagement shall be initiated at the national, regional and global levels. Bhutan was an absentee to the 1997 UN Watercourses Convention vote and has not ratified the Convention. The Bhutan Water Policy recognizes the tremendous potential of hydropower for socio- economic development and export. The Policy states that transboundary water issues are to be dealt with in accordance with international law and conventions to which Bhutan is a signatory, while taking into consideration the integrity of the rivers and the legitimate water needs of riparian states. Cooperation in information sharing and exchange, appropriate technology in water resources development and management, flood warning, and disaster management are to be initiated at the national, regional, and global levels. The National Environment Commission is empowered to address matters of international water cooperation. 344 345 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N Flood Forecasting and Warning In addition to hydropower development, Bhutan and India have cooperated to establish the Comprehensive Scheme for Establishment of Hydrometeorological and Flood Forecasting Network on Rivers Common to India and Bhutan (1979). This network consists of 35 hydrometeorological stations located in Bhutan. (These stations are maintained by Bhutan with funding from India). A Joint Expert Team (comprised of officials from both governments) tracks the progress of the network. The two countries have also formed a Joint Group of Experts on Flood Management. This entity discusses and assesses the probable causes and effects of the recurring floods and erosion in the southern foothills of Bhutan and adjoining Indian plains. It recommends remedial measures. d Bangladesh Taylor Henshaw BANGLADESH HAS a dense network of rivers (about 405), khals (floodplain channels) and wetlands. The country shares 54 rivers with India and three rivers with Myanmar. The major rivers are the Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna (Nepal, Bhutan and China are also river system riparians). Bangladesh is downstream on all three major rivers. These rivers lead into the world’s largest delta (and the Sundarbans mangrove forest). biological pollution of the rivers flowing through these countries, by managing the Bangladesh Bangladesh voted in favour of the 1997 UN Watercourses Convention but has not discharge of industrial, agricultural and domestic pollutants generated by human has a dense ratified it. action; and network of (f) Seek international and regional cooperation for education, training, and research rivers (about The 1999 National Water Policy contains policy for fostering international cooperation in water management. 405), khals in water management. These provisions are:8 (floodplain (a) Work with co-riparian countries to establish a system for exchange of information The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) formulates and executes the foreign policy channels) and and data on relevant aspects of hydrology, morphology, water pollution, ecology, of the Government of Bangladesh and represents the State to foreign governments wetlands. The changing watershed characteristics, cyclone, drought and flood warning, and to and international organizations. While MOFA maintains liaison for any bilateral or country shares help each other understand the current and emerging problems in the management international issues, it is the relevant ministries that guide MOFA on technical matters, 54 rivers with of the shared water sources; in case of of transboundary water, this is Ministry of Water Resources (MoWR). Any India and three (b) Work with co-riparian countries for a joint assessment of all the international rivers MoU related to transboundary water resources is also signed by MOWR, but treaties rivers with flowing through their territories for better understanding of the overall basins’ and agreements are dealt by the Prime Minister’s office with support from MOWR and Myanmar potentials; have to be approved by parliament. In case of issues like inland navigation and energy (c) Work jointly with co-riparian countries to harness, develop, and share the water (hydropower) the main minsitries are Ministry of Shipping and Ministry of Power, resources of the international rivers to mitigate floods and augment flows of water Energy and Mineral Resources respectively, however MoWR participates in related during the dry season; meetings and is consulted in decision making. Under MoWR, JRC is agency that is (d) Make concerted efforts, in collaboration with co-riparian countries, for responsible for transboundary water resources management. management of the catchment areas with the help of afforestation and erosion control for watershed preservation and reduction of land degradation; Joint Rivers Commission Bangladesh (JRC) (e) Work jointly with co-riparian countries for the prevention of chemical and The Joint River Commission is a bilateral working group established by India and 346 347 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N those relevant to the transboundary rivers. However, Bangladesh is not party to any agreements with India on the Brahmaputra-Jamuna River. Indo-Bangladeshi Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Peace Bangladesh and India signed the Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Peace in 1972 (consisting of a Preamble and 12 Articles), which provided a broad scope for bilateral relations. The Preamble specified “peace, secularism, democracy, socialism and nationalism” as the common ideals “to maintain fraternal and good neighbourly relations and to transform their border into a border of eternal peace and friendship”. Over water resources, the parties agreed “to make joint studies and take joint action in the fields of flood control, river basin development and the fields of hydroelectric power and irrigation. While the Treaty’s signature sparked other agreements, the governments declined to renegotiate or renew the Treaty when it expired in 1997. In December 1996 both the countries signed the ‘Treaty on Sharing of the Ganges Waters’ at Farakka. The mutual agreement provided an arrangement for sharing of the Ganges waters at Farakka in a spirit of mutual accommodation and the need for a solution to the long-term problem of augmenting the flows of the Ganges. Although Bangladesh and this treaty focusses on the Ganges basin, this is considered as a milestone between the India have a two contries. long standing Protocol In Sepetember 2011, the “Framework Agreement on Cooperation for Development” on Transit Bangladesh in the Indo-Bangla Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Peace that was between Bangladesh and India was signed by the two Prime Ministers. Article 2 states and Trade signed on March 19, 1972 and came into being in November, 1972. As per the treaty, the that “to enhance cooperation in sharing of the waters of common rivers, both Parties will through inland two nations established the commission to work for the common interests and sharing explore the possibilities of common basin management of common rivers for mutual waterways of water resources, irrigation, floods and cyclones control. JRC’s main activities include benefit”. Article 2 of this agreement stipulates that “the Parties will cooperate in flood which was first carrying out comprehensive survey of the river systems shared by the two countries, forecasting and control”; and “they will cooperate and provide necessary assistance to signed in 1972 formulate projects concerning both the countries in the fields of flood control and to each other to enhance navigability and accessibility of river routes and ports”. implement them, to formulate detailed proposals on advance flood warnings, flood forecasting, study on flood control and irrigation projects on the major river systems Protocol on Inland Water Trade and Transit (PIWTT) and examine the feasibility of linking the power grids of Bangladesh with the adjoining Bangladesh and India have a long standing Protocol on Transit and Trade through areas of India, so that the water resources of the regions can be utilized on an equitable inland waterways which was first signed in 1972. It was last renewed in 2015 for five basis for mutual benefit of the people of the two countries.9 JRC is also responsible for years with a provision for its automatic renewal for a further period of five years. The dealing with riparian countries of Bhutan, China and Nepal. Protocol allows mutually beneficial arrangements for the use of their waterways for movement of goods between the two countries, one of the waterways being the Jamuna. Bangladesh-India Agreements Bangladesh and India developing two stretches of Bangladesh inland waterways on a Cooperation between India and Bangladesh started with the first treaty ‘India- 20:80 cost sharing basis10. Bangladesh Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Peace’ signed in 1972. This paved the way for building further relations in various sectors including trade, water allocation Bangladesh-China Agreements and transportation. In December 1996 both the countries signed the ‘Treaty on Sharing In 2008, Bangladesh agreed to a “Memorandum of Understanding upon Provision of of the Ganges Waters’ at Farakka. The mutual agreement provided an arrangement for Hydrological Information of the Yarlung Tsangpo - Brahmaputra River in Flood Season sharing of the Ganges waters at Farakka in a spirit of mutual accommodation and the by China to Bangladesh”, with China. This document provides that, in flood season, need for a solution to the long-term problem of augmenting the flows of the Ganges. China will provide hydrological information to Bangladesh from three hydrological Additionally, there are around 100 MoUs between Bangladesh and India and some of stations along the main stream of the Yarlung Tsangpo. 348 349 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N India-Bangladesh-Bhutan Working Group on Water and Power Agreement to make cross border trade and transport in and through the northeastern An India-Bangladesh-Bhutan Working Group on Water and Power has been established region of India to and from Bangladesh, Bhutan and Nepal more efficient.15 for sub-regional cooperation on water resources management and hydropower development. The first meeting was held in April 2013. The parties agreed at that time Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation to prepare a framework for trilateral cooperation. There has been no further reporting (BIMSTEC) on the Working Group’s progress. The Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC) is an international organisation of seven nations of South Asia and d Southeast Asia that are dependant on the Bay of Bengal. The BIMSTEC member states are Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka and Thailand. This sub-regional organization came into being on 6 June 1997 through the Bangkok Multilateral cooperation in the region Declaration. The regional group constitutes a bridge between South and South East Asia and represents a reinforcement of relations among these countries. The objective OVER THE last couple of years, a new area of cooperation between the countries have of building such an alliance was to harness shared and accelerated growth through emerged. The first regional body, South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation mutual cooperation in different areas of common interests by mitigating the onslaught (SAARC) was established in 1985. Along with SAARC, other sub-regional institutions of globalization and by utilizing regional resources and geographical advantages. have materialized. While most of them are trade and connectivity oriented, the evolving institutional mechanisms and the growing political will offer opportunities to include critical water-energy-food issues. The Bangladesh, South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) Bhutan, India, The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) was founded in Nepal (BBIN) Dhaka as a vehicle for political and economic cooperation. Currently, the member sub-regional countries are Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan initiative is and Sri Lanka. China is one of the nine observers at SAARC summits.12 The SAARC envisioned maintains permanent diplomatic relations at the United Nations as an observer and to improve has developed links with multilateral entities, including the European Union. The economic SAARC charter stipulates that decisions are to be unanimous and that “bilateral and cooperation and contentious issues” are to be avoided. connectivity among the four The stated areas of cooperation of SAARC does not include water, and SAARC activities South Asian have been limited to ‘soft areas of cooperation’ such as holding seminars, workshops and countries trainings.13 Although, SAARC Meteorological Research Centre and SAARC Disaster Management Centre (SDMC) promotes collective research on weather, meteorology and disasters (including floods). Bangladesh, Bhutan, India and Nepal (BBIN) initiative The Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal (BBIN) sub-regional initiative is envisioned to improve economic cooperation and connectivity among the four South Asian countries. This initiative allows to bypass some of the more complex political issues of SAARC and engage in direct discussions on connectivity in the four countries.14 The Initiative looks at land and inland waterways connectivity and energy, could be an effective sub-regional institutional mechanism  for better water and hydropower cooperation. The first achievement of the BBIN initiative has been the Motor Vehicles 350 351 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N Unlike many other regional groupings, BIMSTEC is a sector-driven cooperative and Tourism, respectively. With time other issues like border trade and management, organization. Starting with six sectors—including trade, technology, energy, transport, information technology, transnational crimes, illegal immigration, sports, to name a tourism and fisheries—for sectoral cooperation in the late 1997, it expanded to few, were also taken up. But the overt stress was always on improving connectivity embrace nine more sectors—including agriculture, public health, poverty alleviation, networks by tapping into the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for counter-terrorism, environment, culture, people to people contact and climate change, Asia and the Pacific’s (UNESCAP) decades-old proposals of linking Asia through its in 2008.16 Compared to SAARC, BIMSTEC has greater trade potential. Given the Pan-Asian Highway and Trans-Asian Railway networks respectively. It found echo it fairly harmonious relationship among member states of BIMSTEC, improving its an earlier article in Beijing Review written in 1984 by Pan Qi, a former Vice-Minister The joint performance is an achievable goal. The success of BIMSTEC does not render SAARC for Communications of China, to open up Southwest China to the rest of the world by statement futile; it only adds a new chapter in regional cooperation in South Asia. Two decades developing connectivity networks19. reiterated the since its inception, however, BIMSTEC’s successes have also been minimal.17 necessity for One of the major outcomes of these deliberations was the successful organisation developing d and completion of the BCIM Car Rally from Kolkata to Kunming in February 2013, connectivity covering a distance of nearly 3000 kilometres and traversing through one of the among the sections of the old Southern Silk Route with cities like Jessore, Dhaka, Silchar, Imphal, four countries The Bangladesh – China- India- Myanmar (BCIM) Mandalay, Ruili, Dali on the way. Way back in 2009, then Chinese President had called through Forum upon promoting Yunnan as a bridgehead for the markets of China, South Asia and railways, air, Southeast Asia respectively, and this rally could be seen as a step in that direction. By waterways and 2013, the term bridgehead was replaced by Qiaotoubao or ‘Opening Up’ to be in tune roads, as also Ambuj Thakur with China’s official policy of peace and development. the digital and energy sectors THE BCIM Forum is a Track II initiative that evolved out of China’s need to open up Despite the institution of a Joint Working Group between the officials of the four its land-locked Southwest frontier provinces of Yunnan, Sichuan and Guizhou to the countries and up-gradation of this initiative to an official Track I status, post-2013 it huge markets of South Asia through the warm water ports of the Indian Ocean Region. remained in cold storage for a long time due to the BCIM’s coming under the ambit The principal mover has consistently been the Yunnan Provincial Government, along of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). It was only after the BCIM was dropped from with the Yunnan Academy of Social Sciences (YASS) playing a seminal role. This the list of corridors in the Second BRI Meet in early 2019 that the decks were clear BIMSTEC has coincided with India’s weighing its various options in developing its own land-locked for the process to move ahead. In June 2019, on the sidelines of the 7th China-South greater trade Northeastern Region under the ambit of its Look East Policy. Moreover, countries like and Southeast Asia Think Tank Forum and the South and Southeast Asia Commodity potential. Bangladesh and Myanmar also wished to join the bandwagon of these to economic EXPO and Investment Fair in Kunming, the 13th BCIM Forum Meeting was held Given the fairly giants to open up their economies for greater investment and looking out for markets in the nearby city of Yuxi as a very low-key affair. The joint statement reiterated the harmonious to sell their products. It began to take shape on a preliminary conference on Regional necessity for developing connectivity among the four countries through railways, air, relationship Development in India and China in New Delhi on 19th-20th November 1998, where waterways and roads, as also the digital and energy sectors. among member representatives from the two countries met to deliberate on a wide range of issues states of of mutual cooperation. The term ‘Sub-Regional Cooperation Zone of China, India, d BIMSTEC, Myanmar and Bangladesh’ was explicitly mentioned by the senior YASS academic, Che improving its Zhimin, with emphases on win-win cooperation, multi-lateralism, multi-polarity, and performance developing the periphery18. PERSPECTIVES ON HYDRO-DIPLOMACY is an achievable goal With such a background, the first conference between Bangladesh, China, India and Benefits from transboundary river cooperation Myanmar was convened in Kunming, Yunnan, on 15th-17th August 1999, where a whopping ninety delegates from the Chinese side participated against a total of Ganesh Pangare and Bushra Nishat 39 combined from the rest three countries. The agreement to create a coordinating forum for such deliberations was agreed upon and it was christened as ‘The Kunming COOPERATION OVER shared waters hinge on economics, legal frameworks, Initiative’. From 1999 to 2019, a total of thirteen meetings have been held in all the four international law, international relations, geopolitics and hydrology. Transboundary countries on a rotational basis, with a major focus on the three T’s – Transport, Trade water management is a long-term social, political and diplomatic effort and needs 352 353 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N to be revisited and adapted according to the prevailing situation. Hydro-diplomacy could increasingly play an important role in strengthening and securing international relations and regional stability provided that it demonstrates concrete results on the ground; results for water, food and energy security, for a green economy, for healthy ecosystems and climate resilience, for people’s health and well being and equity. Agreements or treaties between riparian countries are mostly bilateral and may or may not have a holistic approach to river management. The conventional approach to hydro-diplomacy has been mostly focussed on negotiations on formulating a formal agreement or ‘treaty’ between two governments. The details of this agreement are usually prescribed by diplomats, government delegates and bureaucrats based on international conventions and standards. According to IUCN20, this approach presumes hydro- diplomacy takes place under the authority of sovereign governments. While formal agreements at the official level are absolutely necessary, this approach often disregards that water resources are managed at multiple scales, thus for these agreements to work on the ground and to be acceptable at the national or country level, involvement of water users at different levels including local communities are also essential. A wide spectrum of formal and informal agreements, concentrating on concrete actions and sustainable solutions based on local priorities need to be in place. This means an all-inclusive approach with participation and involvement of a broad range of stakeholders including local communities, local governments, technical agencies, economic and private sectors. These agreements would then become the practical building blocks that augment and improve the potential for national governments to reach high-level agreements encouraging an operational roadmap for improvement in water governance towards sustainable development at the basin level21. Hydro- diplomacy approaches have the potential to play a facilitating and bridge-building Hydro-diplomacy role to support and enable these agreements to be put in place at different levels and organisations (RBOs) that involve different stakeholders. RBOs need to work alongside could increasingly between governments. Hydro-diplomacy starts with national interests and needs to other regional platforms across sectors and with the drivers of change in different play an be embedded in effective processes from the initial dialogue to being able to progress rivers and different basins. Agreements will work on the ground only if they involve important role all the way to a constructive and enforceable agreement and its joint implementation at water users and have their support and take into account local politics. In order to in strengthening national and regional levels between riparian interests. catalyse and mobilise hydro-diplomacy, it is necessary to have in place processes and securing in national agendas and in international dialogues, and also processes that support international How does hydro-diplomacy work? How can it become an effective tool? How can hydro- interaction with stakeholders. Education of stakeholders, communication and capacity relations and diplomacy be put into practice? The answers lie in addressing three key challenges: development, and strengthening of national institutions is required in order to make regional stability a) building consensus, these processes effective. Platforms and partnerships for dialogue that work across b) building institutions for hydro-diplomacy; and sectors and constituencies and inform and backstop governments would need to be put c) identifying and catalysing the processes necessary to mobilise hydro-diplomacy. in place. Effective governance at the national level, sound policies and laws that align with trans-boundary issues would also need to align with hydro-diplomacy processes. It is important to keep in mind that consensus building in hydro-diplomacy starts There would need to be a better understanding of the issues that countries and citizens with national interests, including economic development, security, and concerns want to solve and what their concerns are. Lastly, it would be necessary to drive the and needs of the local population. Consensus building then requires trust and application of the existing international processes related to water. political will, platforms for dialogue and transparency, knowledge and information, capacity and tools for integration of competing demands and for identifying mutual Hydrodiplomacy stems from the need to negotiate where competing and even benefits. Institutions for hydro-diplomacy include “truly” representative river basin conflicting interests towards shared water resources are present. National institutions 354 355 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N involved in the management of water in transboundary rivers focus on their own Nations deriving benefit from water treaties find it prudent to hold on to them and national interests, often with consequences to the riparian needs and interests of the continue to draw its advantage. The most remarkable resilience has been demonstrated countries with whom they share the water resources. As pressures on water resources by the Indus Water Treaty signed in 1960 between India and Pakistan; it survived more continue to increase with the prospect of climate change, population growth and fast than half a century’s bitter hostility between the neighbors and withstood two bitterly developing technologies for water abstraction, water allocation and sharing between fought wars between them. transboundary riparian states is likely to create frequent and more intense tensions. In response to this challenging reality, hydrodiplomacy could prove to be a crucial tool in ensuring that shared water resources are managed efficiently, sustainably and equitably. d Water and Diplomacy C M Shafi Sami EXPERTS APPREHEND that in not too distant future almost half of world population will come under severe threat of water scarcity. Many ecosystems will be unable to cope with the rapidly growing demands of the basic needs, improvement of quality of life and economic development of an ever-increasing world population. As scarcity accentuates balancing the competing needs of societies will become a contentious issue between regions within many countries of the world. It will be an even more formidable task in case of international or trans-boundary water resources which are shared by two or more states. The enormity of the task can better be appreciated when we realize that there are 263 trans-boundary water sources in the world that straddle or cross political boundaries of one or more sovereign states, constituting over 80 percent of worlds fresh water sources – rivers and aquifers. Most of the water basins are shared by just two countries; others are shared by three or more countries – with the Danube River being shared by as many as 18 nations. As many as 145 countries of the world have territories within one or more trans-boundary water sources. More than 95 percent of the territories of as many as 33 countries lie within international river basins making them totally dependent on shared water resources. Trans-boundary water resources there is a strong cover about half of the land surface of the earth and as much as forty to fifty percent of belief that rather the total world population is dependent on shared water resources. than causing open conflict, On the other hand, there is a strong belief that rather than causing open conflict, trans- trans-boundary boundary water can serve as stimulus for cooperation. The need of water together with water can serve the prospect of sharing benefits from equitable use of these common water resources as stimulus for for sustainable socioeconomic development provides incentives for trans-boundary cooperation inter-state cooperation. According to the Food and Agricultural Organization, over the For long the international community has deliberated on various theoretical last millennium more than 3,600 treaties on international water resources have been approaches governing the utilization, share, management and quality control of negotiated with more than 200 such treaties being signed during the last century alone. the shared water resources. These have resulted in the formulation of four major Another significant aspect of cooperation in water sector is that once cooperation is doctrines over a period of time. The main characteristics of these are presented in forged the benefits of cooperation ensure that it becomes enduring and resilient. easily understood simple terms. 356 357 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N The Doctrine of Absolute Territorial Sovereignty was propounded in 1885 by US Attorney General J. Harmon and is popularly known as Harmon Doctrine. It gave all riparian states full and unlimited rights to whatever it wished to do with the water course falling within its territory without any regard for the needs and concern of other riparian countries. In reality this doctrine gave exceedingly favorable dispensation to an upper riparian state; a country having absolute sovereignty over the portion of an international watercourse within its borders would be free to use or divert all of the water from an international watercourse, leaving none for downstream states. This doctrine was invoked by the US on the flows of the Rio Grande river as an upper riparian state vis- a-vis Mexico. Interestingly, the USA itself rejected this doctrine in 1950 during its dispute over the waters of Columbia River in which Canada was the upper riparian state with USA lying down stream. On the other extreme and diametrically opposed to the Harmon Doctrine is the Doctrine of Absolute Territorial Integrity which asserts that a lower riparian country has the right to demand uninterrupted natural flow of water from the territory of any upper riparian state. This doctrine held that an upstream state could do nothing to interfere with the natural flow of the river into a downstream state. The third doctrine that deserves mention is the Doctrine of Limited (Restricted) Territorial Sovereignty which seeks to strike a reasonable balance between the earlier Diplomacy, the two doctrines. This doctrine gives recognition of a state’s sovereignty over the water medium of inter- resources in its territory but enunciates that all states have equal sovereignty over the state interactions, common water resources and hence sovereignty of one state is not unfettered and is has a pivotal ‘limited’ by the sovereignty of another state. Simply put every state has the sovereign right role in balancing to use waters lying within its territory provided its use does not prejudice the sovereign the competing rights and uses of another state sharing the common watercourse. This doctrine The 1997 UN Convention represents an important step towards the strengthening interests of states guarantees reasonable water to all co-riparian states under reasonable conditions; the of the rule of law in international waters. Of particular importance is the principle doctrine seeks to espouse the principle of equitable utilization and no harm done to embodied in this Convention requiring a state to utilize the watercourse, in its other riparian states. The fourth doctrine is known as the Doctrine of Community of territory, in a manner that is equitable and reasonable vis-à-vis the other states sharing Co-riparian States or Community of Interests. It is an attempt to improve upon the that water course. Another crucially important provision is the obligation imposed concepts in the doctrine of limited sovereignty. It enunciates a common legal right on a state not to cause any significant harm to other states sharing an international There is now of all co-riparian states on international water resources. The doctrine establishes a water course. The Convention also puts an obligation on a state undertaking any an explicit perfect equality of all riparian states in the use of entire water course and excludes any project to notify other states of planned activities to allow the other states to assess recognition that preferential privilege for any riparian state in relation to others. if there would be any a significant adverse effect; the intention is to obviate such all riparian adverse effects. These are very positive and important principles which will promote states are entitled There is now an explicit recognition that all riparian states are entitled to the use of good governance in this increasingly critical area of international relations. to the use of international water course in an equitable and reasonable manner. Another important international principle has now achieved international recognition that riparian states have an Conflict or cooperation on international waters - clearly there are two contradictory water course obligation not to cause significant harm to the other riparian states and all riparian and clashing prognoses before us. Whether it is averting the threat of conflict or in an equitable states shall exercise due diligence in the utilization of international water resources. harnessing the prospects of cooperation the challenge before the world is formidable. and reasonable Although these principles have generated interminable debates on how exactly to The quality of governance of trans-boundary waters will play a role of paramount manner determine reasonableness, equity, significant harm and due diligence, these concepts importance in determining which of these two courses mankind will opt for. As are indeed important milestones in achieving good governance of international water decisions relating to utilization, share, management and quality control of the courses. Some of these norms and principles are contained in the 1966 Helsinki Rules international water fall within the jurisdictions of more than one country, the on the Uses of the Waters of International Rivers and the 1997 UN Convention on governance encompassing these elements will bring into play inter-state interactions. Non-navigational Uses of International Water Courses. Diplomacy, the medium of inter-state interactions, has a pivotal role in balancing 358 359 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N the competing interests of states. One also When the Government of India discovered in 2007 that China was building a series of has to reckon that the dynamics of water cascading dams on the middle reaches of the Brahmaputra at Zangmu, Dagu, Jiacha negotiations is in a state of flux as it moves and Jiexiu the first reaction from Beijing was to deny such claims. Little realizing from zero-sum attitudes to positive-sum that modern satellite cartography available commercially could clearly pick up the integrative win-win approaches, from right construction activity underway, the denials then gave way to statements that these based volumetric sharing to the creation were all run-of-the-river dams which would not lead to large scale storage of water. and sharing of benefits derived from water India and China first concluded and signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) resources. This development will create more for Sharing of Hydrological Data on the Yarlung Zangpo/Brahmaputra in 2002. This economic opportunities and simultaneously MOU provides for the annual meeting of an Expert Level Mechanism (ELM) whose bring into play additional political challenges. job it is to assess how the mechanism of data sharing has been working. Fairly regular Synthesizing and harmonizing the complex meetings of this ELM have taken place over the years although not each and every year. mix of economic opportunities and political However, the ELM has resulted in Indian and Chinese water experts getting into the challenges will thus impose pronounced habit of talking and cooperating with each other. I, for one, believe that this habit is demands on diplomacy. much more than many other nations do with China on trans-boundary rivers. I have had the good fortune of participating in a few of these ELMs and I vouch for the fact There is a growing feeling among experts that while at the start the two delegations would view each other with some suspicion, India and China that these principles and laws need to be over time this has changed, and the two sides do have a cooperative attitude when they first concluded more concrete and precise. Simultaneously meet. The MOU has been extended beyond its original 5-year period and continues to and signed a with harmonizing inter-state interests, in be an area of cooperation for India and China. Memorandum of clearer and unambiguous terms it will be of Understanding vital importance to concretize and crystallize When I was India’s Ambassador to China in 2017-18, we had one experience which (MOU) for principles and laws relating to the regimes depicts how cooperation can indeed play a positive role in saving lives and property Sharing of of these precious resources and to create when there are blockages on the Yarlung Zangpo in Tibet, China. The ELM had a Hydrological institutional mechanism that will have the meeting in China in mid-March 2018. I remember being informed by my colleagues Data on the capacity of enforcement as well as conflict who attended the meeting that it had been a relatively pleasant one and the two Yarlung Zangpo/ resolution. On all these counts diplomacy will delegations had got to know each other relatively well. Later that summer, late one Brahmaputra Rustam Vania be called upon to play a role of crucial and evening one of our Embassy officers received a call from a contact in the Chinese in 2002 overwhelming importance in the days ahead. Ministry of Water Resources to inform us that there had been a blockage of part of the river in the middle reaches in Tibet, China. The information was being shared since d the blockage was leading to the formation of a kind of lake. The pressure from the water could burst the blockage and could lead to a large mass of water flowing down the river into India. Such a flood could potentially have damaging consequences in Recollections of India – China Cooperative Exchanges our country. On my instructions, the Indian Embassy in Beijing immediately relayed on the Brahmaputra the information shared by China to our own Ministry of External Affairs as also our Ministry of Water Resources as well as the Cabinet Secretariat. This last action was Gautam Bambawale essential since there were at least two separate State Governments involved namely Assam and Arunachal Pradesh. Hence, informing the Cabinet Secretary was essential, INDIA IS the lower riparian on the Brahmaputra which originates in the highlands since he and his Secretariat could convey the news to the States in India. of the Tibet Plateau, flows eastwards in China and then makes what is described as a “great bend”, enters India and flows westward. The mighty Brahmaputra in India is used Surely, a few days later the water at the blockage site had sufficient pressure to blow off for irrigation, transportation and power generation and has a central role in a complex the blockage, which had occurred due to a landslide. That mass of water began moving ecosystem22. Through history, monsoon flooding of the river has caused misery and down the Brahmaputra. It would reach India within two days especially the areas in loss to several generations. India which are settled and fairly low lying. 360 361 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N Then began a vigil for all of us involved on the Indian and Chinese sides. We began to received almost hourly updates from the Chinese Ministry of Water Resources on where the flood had reached and what was the flow of water at places where they had measuring stations. This information was immediately relayed to India. I recollect one instance where the Cabinet Secretary of India held a video conference with me in Beijing and the Chief Secretaries of the two States of India involved. Based on the data received from the Chinese side, our own hydrologists were able to project by extrapolation how high the flood would be in different parts of India. Based on these projections, in turn, a fair number of people living in low lying areas on the banks of the Brahmaputra were evacuated by our authorities. Such cooperation Now, it was our turn to share with China what steps we had taken based on the is not merely information shared by them. When I did so and informed about the thousands of possible but also people evacuated, and how we were possibly saving lives due to this cooperation implementable between India and China, I found my Chinese interlocutors feeling very satisfied with when the the scope and level of cooperation the two countries had achieved. personnel involved clearly understand Within two days, as the experts had predicted, the flood had reached India and the the potential level of the Brahmaputra swelled significantly. However, the flood peak was in line for saving lives, with what our hydrologists had predicted and was not of a magnitude to create too crops, habitations. much damage. The lower lying areas, particularly in Assam, were flooded but there Suspicion must was no loss of life due to the evacuations of the populace which had already been be replaced by a effected. The flood peak passed down the river in a few hours and with it so did the Framework for cooperation in the GBM Basin23 desire to cooperate crisis. All of us dealing with the issue heaved a sigh of relief, but we also had a feeling of satisfaction with what we had achieved. The next day as the Indian Ambassador to Golam Rasul China I wrote out a letter to the Chinese Ministry of Water Resources outlining and highly appreciating the level of cooperation we had been able to reach. THE EASTERN Himalayan countries of Bangladesh, Bhutan, India and Nepal, along with the Tibet Autonomous Region of China, are interconnected by the river systems What are the lessons from this particular incident that I took away with me? They are: of the Ganges (or Ganga), the Brahmaputra (known as Yarlung Tsangpo in China and (a) Cooperation on trans-boundary rivers between nation states, increases welfare of Jamuna in Bangladesh) and the Meghna. Together these three river systems are often people in all the cooperating countries. referred to as the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna (GBM) basin, covering an area of (b) Such cooperation is not merely possible but also implementable when the personnel 174.5 million hectares. At present about 700 million people live in the GBM basin, involved clearly understand the potential for saving lives, crops, habitations. comprising more than 10 percent of the world’s population. The average annual water Suspicion must be replaced by a desire to cooperate. flow in the GBM basin is estimated at around 1160 billion cubic meters. The GBM (c) Big countries need to take a large-hearted approach to trans-boundary river cooperation. basin is geographically connected and has a high level of economic complementarity (d) Sharing of information must be a two-way street. It cannot just be the upper riparian and interdependence. It is also closely linked hydrologically, and these links lead to a sharing data and information with the lower riparian. Indeed, the lower riparian high degree of interdependence and call for cooperative governance of water resources. also needs to share with the upper riparian how such data has been utilized. (e) We need more cooperation rather than less on major river systems across the globe. These river systems are rich in water, land, and forest resources. They provide fertile agricultural flood plains and feed into one of the most productive estuarine ecosystems Based on these recollections, I do hope that India and China can consider expanding in the world, the Sundarbans, which sustains the lives and livelihoods of millions. their cooperation on trans-boundary rivers such as the Brahmaputra. Despite such richness in natural resources, the region is one of the poorest in the world. Rapid population growth, the fast pace of urbanisation together with economic d development have increased the pressure on this finite resource. Water resources in 362 363 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N the region are distributed very unevenly over time and space. About 84 percent of It is estimated that the GBM river systems have about 200,000MWof hydropower the rainfall occurs between June and September and 80 percent of the annual river potential, of which half or more is considered feasible for harnessing. Alongside this, flow takes place in the four months between July and October. Huge amounts of water establishment of an inter-country power grid could facilitate the integration of different during the monsoon period trigger floods and other hazards, whereas in the dry power systems and the export of excess hydropower from Nepal and Bhutan to India season the water is insufficient to meet the requirements for irrigation, navigation, and Bangladesh. Besides hydropower, the GBM river systems offer a huge potential for and maintaining minimum environmental flow in the rivers. While the need for water the development of water resources for irrigation, navigation, transportation, fisheries, has increased rapidly, water supplies have become more erratic as a result of both poor tourism and ecosystems. management and climatic effects. Water transportation is another area for potential improvements. The Ganges, the Upstream- The Need for Better Cooperation Brahmaputra, and the Meghna rivers flow into Bangladesh from three directions downstream In the GBM basin, the abundant water during the monsoon leads to hazards such as and merge into a single outlet that constitutes a vast water network. This provides an interdependencies flooding and other natural disasters. At the same time, the GBM basin is very rich opportunity to develop an integrated water transport system. Two countries in the and geographical in water resources, but this potential has remained largely untapped. Upstream- basin, Bhutan and Nepal, are landlocked and this is an obstacle to their industrial growth linkages downstream interdependencies and geographical linkages necessitate the development and overall economic development. It is technically feasible for Nepal and Bhutan to necessitate the of a shared and integrated river system through collaboration among the riparian gain direct access to the sea. Regional cooperation for the development of waterways development of countries. Such collaboration could deliver a number of benefits. The high precipitation has gained momentum in South Asia. Recently, the government of India declared 106 a shared and in the summer monsoon season (June to September / October) renders the Eastern additional waterways and amended the bilateral navigation protocol between India integrated river Himalayan countries vulnerable to natural hazards such as floods and landslides. The and Bangladesh to allow third countries to use their waterways. Waterways along the system through Ganges-Brahmaputra basin is one of the most flood-prone regions in the world. The Brahmaputra and Ganges Rivers could provide a basis for sub-regional connectivity collaboration loss of human life is highest in Bangladesh (on average around 6000 people per year) for South Asia, connecting Bangladesh, Bhutan, the north-eastern states of India, and among the and the number of people affected by floods is highest in India (more than 22 million Nepal to the sea via the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna basin. Nepal could be directly riparian countries per year). While floods cannot be completely avoided, the damage can be minimized connected to the ports of Haldia and Kolkata through India’s National Waterway Waterways along through the joint efforts of governments and those living in the major river basins. For 1, Bhutan could be connected through the Manas River to the Brahmaputra at the the Brahmaputra example, the lead time for flood forecasting can be increased substantially through Jogighopa confluence, and north-east Indian states could be connected to many ports and Ganges exchange of real time data on river flow from upstream areas of the basins. on the Brahmaputra through National Waterway 2. In view of these opportunities, the Rivers could prime ministers of India and Nepal made the decision to develop the inland waterways provide a basis The fundamental problem with water governance in the GBM basin lies in the seasonal for the movement of cargo within the framework of trade and transit and are now for sub-regional concentration of rainfall and spatial variation in its distribution, as well as unreliability working to operationalize the agreement. connectivity in water supplies. These characteristics of water availability mean that water should for South Asia, be stored when it is abundant and redistributed when and where required within a There are also potential political benefits. Transboundary water resources have become connecting framework of regional understanding and cooperation. Literature on potential sites for a contentious issue in the GBM region, as in other parts of the world. With the right Bangladesh, storage reservoirs in India and Nepal, for example, reveals that there is great potential perspective, transboundary water resources can become a source of understanding of Bhutan, the north- for storage of monsoon water in the GBM basin. regional cooperation, and peace. Through cooperative development of water resources, eastern states of current tensions between neighbouring countries can be reconciled to a great extent India, and Nepal Potential for Transboundary Cooperation and this would bring political benefits to all the countries involved through building to the sea Although there are challenges, the opportunities for collaboration are also growing as trust and increasing regional security and economic growth. civil society and other non-state actors emerge, and new forces for cooperation. Challenges. Although the potential benefits of collaborative development of the Hydropower generation. Abundant rain-fed and snow fed water resources and transboundary water resources in the Eastern Himalayan region are huge, there topography with a favourable relief for hydropower generation provide an excellent are a number of challenges that must be met and impediments to overcome before opportunity for generating an enormous amount of hydropower in the basin. The these benefits can be realised. For optimal development, a river basin needs to be energy requirements of the region could be met, and the surplus exported. For managed through an integrated basin-wide approach. Transboundary water resources example, the theoretical hydropower potential of glacial rivers in Nepal is estimated in the Eastern Himalayan region are generally seen from a national perspective, with to be 83,000MW, in Bhutan 21,000 MW, and in north-east India about 58,971MW. a focus on problems of sharing water rather than expanding the benefits through 364 365 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N signing of the Mahakali treaty between India and Nepal and the treaty for sharing Ganges water between Bangladesh and India have opened up opportunities for collaboration in regional water resource development. A Framework on Transboundary Cooperation in GBM Basin There is a strong case for a framework for the cooperative development of transboundary water resources in the basin in order to support the realisation of such benefits. Key aspects of the framework are presented below. • Promote a multi-purpose basin-wide approach for optimum use of Himalayan water resources in an integrated manner. The starting point could be cooperation in flood control, as flooding is a common issue for all countries in the region. Greater efforts need to be made to engage policy makers and other key stakeholders, including the private sector, think tanks, research organizations and civil society on the future interactive challenges of water, energy and food security on the regional level, possible regional approaches, and the potential benefits of integrated management of transboundary water resources at the basin level. • Shift the focus from sharing water to sharing the benefits of water. Link water sector strategies with broader national and regional development goals, including shifting the focus from hydro-diplomacy to a hydro-economic perspective. Shift the focus • Build trust: a concerted effort is required to build trust and confidence so that from sharing negotiations and discussions can start. Mistrust is partly due to poor understanding water to sharing of the benefits and costs of collaborative development and there is a need to promote the benefits of joint research on transboundary water management issues. A concentrated effort water. A concerted and multi-track diplomacy are necessary to overcome the existing mistrust and effort is required build common understanding of the benefits of cooperation and the costs of non- to build trust and cooperation. One of the reasons for mistrust has to do with the sharing of costs and confidence so joint resource development. This narrow perspective often leads to bilateralism and benefits. Mechanisms for sharing the costs and benefits of co-operatively developed that negotiations encourages unilateral and fragmented decisions, with transboundary water resource transboundary water resources need to be established following international and discussions development seen as a ‘zero sum game’ in which the gains of one country must mean standards. Dispute-resolution mechanisms and institutional arrangements also can start losses for another, and negotiations become deadlocked. Moreover, transboundary need to be developed to settle disputes among the riparian countries. water resource management has become a purely diplomatic matter, with little space • Facilitate multi-track diplomacy, with efforts made to facilitate cross-border for civil society, nongovernmental organisations, private sector, and other stakeholders, exchange among civil society organisations, NGOs, academic and scientific who are directly and indirectly involved in water management. This is a major obstacle communities, and government officials. to cooperative development of transboundary water resources. • Undertake joint research by the Eastern Himalayan countries to produce credible information and knowledge, explore development potential and options, and assess However, there has been a positive shift in the region towards cooperative water risks, costs, and benefits of cooperative management to support sound decision management. Although slow, efforts are ongoing to resolve differences over water issues. making. The Bangladesh-India Ganges Treaty states that both countries will work together to • Establish a mechanism and institutional arrangements to coordinate, facilitate and augment the river flows in the upstream and share such waters. This provision opens a strengthen cooperation in water, hydropower, and flood management in the GBM path for regional cooperation to harness the water resources of the GBM basin. Efforts basin. Water management institutions in the region are generally weak and lack are also ongoing in the Koshi basin. Bangladesh has agreed in principle to allow transit the technical, financial and human capabilities needed to develop and implement from Bhutan, India and Nepal to use the Mongla and Chittagong ports. A waterway comprehensive plans for transboundary water cooperation. Building the capacity transit for Bhutan to Mongla port is under consideration. The cooperation between of national and regional institutions and establishing a basin-level coordination Bhutan and India on hydropower development is also a very good start. Similarly, the committee is critical to promote better water governance. 366 367 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N • Explore joint projects for development of transboundary water resources for short, the extreme precipitation events have been reported in the mountainous catchments medium and long-term measures based on mutual understanding and priorities. of neighbouring Lohit and Dibang rivers The tributaries from the rain rich south Joint investments in regional public goods for mutual benefit will be vital. There is a aspect of the Himalaya, from Subansiri to Teesta, make large additions to the flow of need to develop mechanisms for sharing costs and benefits in an equitable manner mainstream Brahmaputra. Thus, the river system has areas of low water availability, as in the provision of regional public goods, particularly along transboundary rivers in Tibet, and areas of high but seasonal water availability, as in the south aspect of the and in regional infrastructure development. eastern Himalaya. The result is high flows or floods, erosion and sedimentation during • Establish a basin-wide data bank and system for timely sharing of meteorological, the summer monsoon, together with shifting of the braided river flows. Important in- hydrological, economic and environmental data and information among the countries sharing the basin. South Asia Water Initiative Activity Brief d Building Trust and Confidence Fostering a Spirit of Cooperation Among the Brahmaputra Interdisciplinary Governance of the Transboundary River Basin Riparians Brahmaputra River System Jayanta Bandyopadhyay THE YARLUNG Tsangpo- Brahmaputra trans-boundary river system is characterised by wide diversity in climate, geology, demography, administration, politics, culture, etc. which provide conditions for potential cooperation as well as disputes among the riparian countries. There have been some analytical studies on the scope of water diplomacy in the Brahmaputra river system24. However, the Brahmaputra is a complex river system and needs much more analytical attention. As a result, the available studies have not yet been of effective use in generating a comprehensive approach to governance of this river system. Based on the trans-boundary status of the Brahmaputra sub-basin, this chapter outlines some of the governance challenges, potential or present or even just perceived Important in- by some analysts. n order to understand these challenges objectively, knowledge of the situ services of characteristic environmental features, like precipitation pattern, hydrological profile, situ services of the flows of the Brahmaputra sub-basin include navigation and fishery, the flows of the geomorphological dynamics, population, land use, irrigation, hydropower potential, which provide livelihood options to many people. Scarcity of flow in the lean season Brahmaputra etc. is necessary. In addition, the human interventions like structures built, or planned seriously affects irrigation for paddy in Assam and Bangladesh. Further, with summer sub-basin include by the riparian countries, will have to be considered. paddy getting increasing importance in food security in Bangladesh, the pre-monsoon December 2019 navigation and scarcity of water in Brahmaputra has also becme an identity of the Brahmaputra sub- fishery, which Precipitation: Spatial and Temporal Variations basin as much the CONTEXT monsoon : The floods. Yarlung-Tsangpo-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River In the dry season, low water availability and an uneven spatial (the “Brahmaputra”) originates in the Chinese Himalayas and distribution of water cause water stress and competition among provide livelihood Based on the annual precipitation, the area of the Brahmaputra sub-basin can be divided flows through India and Bangladesh, with flow contribution users. Climate change is expected to increase evapotranspiration options to in four clear climatic zones. The Yarlung Tsangpo stretch mainly passes through semi- It is in the above background, that the challenges in the governance from Bhutan. Its challenging topography and hydrology and (increasing waterof demand), this trans- alter the spatial and temporal many people arid areas in Southern Tibet in which the annual precipitation is about 400. As it travels boundary sub-basin complex will geopolitical be analysed. environment makeIt needs toone its basin be stressed of the that flows in distribution of the Himalayan precipitation, increase the frequency of floods round Namcha Barwa and starts the descent along the south aspect of the Himalaya, mostsubject rivers are thehigh difficult into world level of uncertainty to sustainably manage. 25, which itselfand can often produce droughts, trans- and accelerate glacier melting. the annual precipitation gradually increases. After entering India near Tuting, Yarlung boundary disputes. Impacts of global warming and climate change will only increase The Brahmaputra Basin is home to 130 million people, of Development in the basin has historically been piecemeal, Tsangpo gets the name Siang, which reaches the plains of Assam at Pasighat (150 this uncertainty. Further, with the political sensitivity and ecological which about 86 percent live in rural areas, and is a major complexity of the and undertaken on a project-by-project basis at the country m), where the annual precipitation goes up to about 4000 mm. However, the most of sub-basin, the traditional approach to governance based source of livelihood. It is prone to major flooding and rapid level. The complexstructures on engineering geopolitics between downstream and geomorphological changes in the wet season, which threaten upstream countries has been amplified by an incomplete basin life and property. knowledge base, the varying professional water resources management and technical capacities of the basin countries, 368 Brahmaputra Basin and power asymmetry among the riparians. The absence of a 369 basin-wide cooperative framework has translated into missed opportunities for regional economic growth, including in THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N BRAHMAPUTRA RIVER Tsangpo. It needs to be stressed that at Zangmu, the flow of Yarlung Tsangpo would be a small part of the total flow of the Brahmaputra at downstream of Bahadurabad in Bangladesh (about 6-7 per cent). The situation can easily be addressed by diplomats SYMPOSIUM 2017 with more openness and more willingness to gather technical information on the part of the protagonists of the Water War Narrative. Commenting on the improbability of Water Wars over dams on Yarlung Tsangpo, Ho28 has commented that “The difficulties in managing the Brahmaputra, and the fact that both China and India suffer from water scarcity, have led to predictions that the two countries will fight over water in the future. Despite these predictions, armed conflict in the Brahmaputra is unlikely in the current context.” Instead, she has raised the question “Why are China and India unable to establish robust mechanisms for cooperation on the Brahmaputra River, The greater issue and how, with little institutionalized cooperation in the Brahmaputra, have both sides in the sub-basin managed to keep their riparian relations from creating open conflicts?” Indeed, future is to generate an governance of the Brahmaputra has to respond to this question urgently. However, this informed and is a localised governance issue for the sub-basin. comprehensive KNOWLEDGE BEYOND BOUNDARIES governance Cooperative Governance for the Whole Sub-basin response to The greater issue in the sub-basin is to generate an informed and comprehensive the monsoon governance response to the monsoon floods, to reduce vulnerability and enhance floods, to reduce alone, will be inadequate. Water science has become highly interdisciplinary now. socio-economic advantages. The governance institution should involve all sub-basin vulnerability Knowledge based on extensive data is now guiding the design of governance institutions. countries: China, India, Bhutan and Bangladesh. and enhance For future interventions to be successful the role of interdisciplinary knowledge will be socio-economic central. Within the available space for this chapter, all challenges in trans-boundary In a period when the scarcity of water has become a global problem, the Brahmaputra advantages governance cannot be discussed. sub-basin finds annual monsoon floods as a major problem. In the context of the complexity of the climate process in the Himalaya, the meteorology of flood producing Firstly, the China-India relations on the various structural interventions made or rainfall events in Brahmaputra is still at a stage of evolution29. All tributaries from the planned by China on Yarlung Tsangpo have got wide media coverage which need some Himalaya have historically recorded anomalous rainfall and produced floods. The Water science clarity. Secondly, what is seen by this author as the primary governance agenda for the catchments of tributaries Luhit, Dibang, Siang and Subansiri face such precipitations has become highly Brahmaputra sub-basin as a whole will be presented. more frequently and flood moderating structures were planned on them without being interdisciplinary followed. The impact of monsoon floods in downstream Bangladesh is also quite heavy. now. Knowledge based on extensive Brahmaputra River Symposium Proceedings China-India Relations and the Yarlung Tsangpo Projects Dam projects on the Yarlung Tsangpo have been the subject of many journalistic writings The four sub-basin countries have to address the flood moderation with a sense of urgency, for which Bangladesh and India may be the prime mover. China should be a data is now all over the world and25 September some th analysts have I –26th, 2017 even warned of a ‘Water Shangri-La’s Eros, New War’ between Delhi China good source of knowledge especially in view of the experiences from the Yellow river30, guiding the design and India over the shared rivers, especially the Brahmaputra. The commissioning of a once devastated by floods and sedimentation. Thus, one important dimension of this of governance series of dams by China built around Zangmu on the Yarlung Tsangpo very much fuelled sub-basin would be cooperative governance and exchange of engineering knowledge institutions such reports. Some of these writings even predicted the drying up of the Brahmaputra among the four countries. Managing flood producing precipitation at the location in Assam as a result of dam construction by China. Indeed, in the context of two most where it falls would be the role of storage structures in the uplands, thus reducing populated countries with ambitious plans for rapid economic growth, competition for the potential damage in the downstream parts. Such a participatory process will also The Energy and Resources Institute enhanced access to limited sources of water is a possibility, leading to prospects of help much needed reduction in suspicion of NGOs, professionals and politicians in serious conflicts, as perceived by SAWI26. On the other hand, depending on the high Bangladesh about upstream designs, as identified by Ahmed31. Thus, urgency exists in level of objectivity in diplomacy, the competition can be replaced by cooperation27. The pushing forward the idea of cooperative governance of the Brahmaputra sub-basin for rise of the ‘Water War Narrative’ has been the result of lack of hydrological clarity on a developing a basin wide strategy for the governance of monsoon floods. complex river system, since many such writings depend on very weak database and do not distinguish between the cartographic and hydrological continuity of the Yarlung d 370 371 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N Fostering a Spirit of Cooperation among the forums; basin dialogue is only bilateral in nature; and negotiations are largely formed Brahmaputra River Basin Riparians by virtue of adversarial positional bargaining.” A Track III Bangladesh-India joint dialogue meeting reflected on the country-level consultations and called for movement in diplomatic participation from Track III to Track II, to include more influential non- Taylor W. Henshaw and Anamika Barua government stakeholders, including prominent ex-bureaucrats that interact regularly with government officials, and to bring in stakeholders from all four riparian countries THE SOUTH Asia Water Initiative (SAWI) is a multi-donor Trust Fund supported by to enable a more holistic conversation on Brahmaputra management issues. the UK, Australia and Norway and managed by the World Bank. SAWI supports a rich portfolio of activities designed to increase regional cooperation in the management of the major Himalayan river systems in South Asia to deliver sustainable, fair and inclusive development and climate resilience. It does this through four complementary outcome areas: strengthening awareness and knowledge on regional water issues; enhancing technical and policy capacity across the region; dialogue and participatory decision processes to build trust and confidence; and scoping and informing investment designs. Its work, structured across three river basins (Indus, Ganges and Brahmaputra) and the Sundarbans Landscape, spans seven countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, India, Nepal and Pakistan. Part of the South Asia Water Initiative’s (SAWI) early engagement on the Brahmaputra Basin included leading study tours for high-level and technical delegations to the Yellow River Basin in China (2014) and the Mississippi River Basin in the USA (2015), where participants discussed pressing Brahmaputra governance issues and learned practical management approaches from basin organizations facing similar water resource management challenges. Notably, the delegations recommended that For such a a “Brahmaputra Forum” be formed at the national level in each riparian country dialogue to and at the basin level. While the national forums would explore local and national be effective, solutions to basin challenges; the regional forum would focus on working toward a the process “joint response mechanism” for issues such as navigation, hydropower investment would need to and food management. For such a dialogue to be effective, they expressed, the increasingly process would need to increasingly extend to higher levels of stakeholders and be extend to nimble enough to deliberate on emerging windows of opportunity for cross-border higher levels of cooperation. stakeholders and be nimble enough During this period, the policy research institute South Asia Consortium for to deliberate on Interdisciplinary Water Resources Studies (SaciWATERs), with The Asia Foundation emerging windows and supporting partners, started a dialogue process in the Brahmaputra Basin, of which of opportunity SAWI was largely an early observer. The first phase of the dialogue process (2013-14) In phase two of the dialogue (2014-2015), SAWI was a behind-the-scenes influencer, for cross-border included six consultation meetings in Bangladesh and India at the Track III diplomatic helping to heighten riparian government awareness of and confidence in the dialogue cooperation level (CSOs, NGOs and academics/ researchers). An initial status report on water process, and to secure participation. For the first time, Track II stakeholders from India management practices and policies for the Brahmaputra Basin concluded that “the (Arunachal, Assam and Delhi) and Bangladesh and Track III stakeholders from Bhutan innumerable channels and tributaries, varied topographical and climate regimes, and and China came together in a multi-country dialogue to share ideas, knowledge and multiple water uses across countries unequal in size and power dynamics have made experience for good governance of the Brahmaputra Basin. The importance of a multi- a straightforward management strategy seemingly impossible; concerns and voices of country dialogue process on the basin was reinforced, with a call to action to move the legitimate stakeholders have largely been neglected in previous basin dialogues and process from Track III and Track II modes to Track I½ mode (where government and 372 373 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N non-government actors deliberate together) and to create a single dialogue platform on generating and sharing knowledge to close the science-policy gap and inform with participation from all four riparian governments. evidence-based decision making in the basin, strengthening institutions, and integrating investments. One of the major outcomes was consensus among the The potential for formal collaboration between SAWI and this dialogue process was delegates that this dialogue process has the potential to navigate the geopolitical identified at a Brahmaputra regional workshop in Dhaka in 2015, where SaciWATERs complexity hindering good governance in the basin, and that it must be sustained to presented findings from the first two phases of operation and expressed need for support rally stakeholders, from community to cabinet, in each of the four basin countries to to sustain the dialogue and expand its reach. For SAWI, partnering with SaciWATERs champion the movement. on a third phase was an opportunity to advance the recommendations coming out of These country the study tours with a credible partner, building on the dialogue’s early achievements, Preparing and organizing the BRS involved holding meetings in China with academics meetings helped and to disseminate evidence generated through SAWI’s basin modeling and analytical acting as advisors to government to ensure there was strong Chinese representation at identify key people activities. SAWI funded and helped implement the demand-driven third (2016-2017) the Symposium. SAWI engagements in India were instrumental in the strong Indian and institutions and fourth (2018-2020) phases of the dialogue, aimed at providing the means, mandate presence at the event, including the Commissioner, Brahmaputra and Barak Basin that can play an and resources necessary to facilitate formal and informal knowledge exchange and Wing, Ministry of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation. important role interaction among key basin stakeholders, fostering a spirit of cooperation to develop in advancing and manage the basin optimally, holistically and sustainably. The call to action agenda set at the BRS sparked the fourth phase of the Brahmaputra the dialogue Dialogue, which was launched in May 2018. This phase has seen the dialogue process and further Combined Track III, II and I½ country-level dialogue meetings took place in Bangladesh institutionalized, with a consortium of institutions connected to government in each understanding (June), China (July), India (August) and Bhutan (September) in 2016. Discussions were riparian country taking facilitation roles—IIT-Guwahati (India), Institute of Water of country- structured around three themes: knowledge sharing and review of water resources Modeling (Bangladesh), Bhutan Water Partnership (Bhutan) and Yunnan University specific views management legal instruments from international experience; economic opportunities (China)—in collaboration with a range of partners working to advance sustainable and opinions on that would help address issues of poverty and food and energy security; and disaster Brahmaputra Basin water resources management. potential management, such as flood risk management and bank erosion control. These country co-management of meetings helped identify key people and institutions that can play an important role the basin in advancing the dialogue and further understanding of country-specific views and opinions on potential co-management of the basin. A regional workshop in Singapore in October 2016 aimed to lay the groundwork for political commitment to a basin-wide multi-purpose institutional framework for managing and developing the Brahmaputra Basin. The small event drew senior government participation from Bangladesh, as well as high- and mid-level stakeholders from Bhutan, China and India, marking a breakthrough in track diplomacy in the basin, and signifying the quality and importance of the dialogue process. Convening this level of participation required a sustained effort by SAWI and SaciWATERs, including several rounds of national-level consultations with high-level stakeholders (including across the multiple Indian states that share the Brahmaputra Basin). The momentum in the third phase led to the Brahmaputra River Symposium (BRS), held in Delhi in September 2017. The BRS brought together 150 delegates, including, for the first time, prominent stakeholders from all four basin riparian countries (including senior government officials from Bangladesh, Bhutan and India and academic institutions with close ties to government agencies in China) exemplifying the strides this dialogue process has made in terms of credibility and importance. The Symposium delegates identified several recommendations to combat the challenges of developing and managing the Brahmaputra Basin. The recommendations focused 374 375 THE RESTLESS RIVER G O V E R N : F R A M E W O R K F O R C O - O P E R AT I O N Dialogue processes on international river basins are closely linked to the geopolitics of the region, and political development in any of the riparian countries could hinder opportunities for dialogue. The Brahmaputra Dialogue has managed political sensitivity risk through the manner in which workshops and discussions are structured. Country- level workshops are held so participants can speak candidly about national and transboundary basin management issues. The regional event discussions are focused on thematic areas that are of common interest to all riparians and relatively apolitical (such as disaster risk management, inland water transport and the water-energy-food nexus). d Outcomes THE EARLY phases of the dialogue process comprised a small group of stakeholders at the Track III and II diplomatic levels. The dialogue has since morphed into an expanded and engaged group up to Track I½. To achieve this transformation, riparian country- level workshops and meetings—supported by informal one-on-one follow-ups with key stakeholders—established the political connection, commitment and momentum long needed for dialogue breakthroughs. The nature of the dialogue discourse is evolving beyond technical management issues, The nature of the opening up thinking toward common understanding across sectors and geographies, dialogue discourse Significantly in the fourth phase, a regional workshop on south-south cooperation and on policy viewpoints. Events are starting to serve as a marketplace of ideas, is evolving and the climate-water-energy nexus was held in Shanghai, jointly organized by bringing together the producers and consumers of knowledge, and Brahmaputra Basin beyond technical Shanghai Institute for International Studies and IIT-Guwahati. This workshop was the knowledge partnerships are emerging. management first multilateral international workshop held within China under the Brahmaputra issues, opening Dialogue. Feedback from workshop participants noted that the forum continues to The dialogue is working through and with a range of partners, which has expanded over up thinking strengthen the built network of government officials, academicians, researchers, NGOs, time and is central to SAWI’s long-term sustainability strategy. The dialogue process is toward common CSOs and media toward co-management of the basin. now institutionalized across the basin, with a consortium of institutions connected to understanding government in each riparian country taking facilitation roles. across sectors Because the international experience demonstrates that the efficiency and and geographies, effectiveness of an international institutional framework largely depends on the social While various CSOs are engaging on the Brahmaputra through multiple activities, they and on policy and political characteristics prevailing within a basin, first-of-their-kind institutional are working largely in isolation of one another. A CSO meeting in Guwahati, India, in viewpoints and power mapping exercises were carried out on the Brahmaputra Basin. Through November 2018 was held to bring the major CSOs together to discuss convergence of literature reviews and one-on-one interviews with key institutional stakeholders, the activities and identify gaps that need to be filled, potentially through future activities institutional mapping is helping further understanding of the complex, multi-tiered under the dialogue. The first-of-its-kind meeting has stemmed fruitful and ongoing management (roles and responsibilities) and policy landscape of the Brahmaputra discussions on identifying CSO synergies and areas for collaborative work. Basin at the domestic and international levels. The power mapping is identifying power relationships and the influence of various institutions in devising policies This first multilateral international workshop on the Brahmaputra in Shanghai in and programs related to (cross-border) water resources management in each of the 2018 marked the Brahmaputra Dialogue’s full active engagement in all four riparian riparian countries. This work will enable the dialogue process to identify the most countries. It also showed China’s increasing interest in regional cooperation in the relevant institutions, key actors and other stakeholders, and their interactions and basin, which will be critical to move the dialogue process forward, with legitimacy. locus of control for future dialogue participation, and to improve coordination and make the dialogue more effective. d 376 377 VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES 8. VOICE Perspectives Nitin Desai Shafi Sami Runa Khan Yang Yi Ravindra Kumar Sinha Yu Hongyuan Ma Jun Sanjoy Hazarika M Panging Pao Ainun Nishat Yumiko Yasuda Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad Imtiaz Ahmed Bibhab Talukdar Karma Chopel Gongsar 379 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES countries jointly meet the challenges more favorable environment and better and move towards a better future? The life to all riparian people in the coming Chinese President Xi Jinping proposed days. The rational and sustainable to consolidate the “cultural foundation” development and utilization of cross- of jointly building a community with border river water resources calls for our a shared future for Asia and humanity. wisdom and cooperation. Specifically, treating each other with Spanning thousands of miles and respect and as equals; appreciating the years, the river plays an important beauty of all civilizations; adhering to economic, social, cultural role for openness, inclusiveness, mutual learning; riparian countries with great potential and keeping pace with the times. for growth now. With the progress of The fast-changing international and the times, we need inject new impetus regional landscapes request all of us to into river for sustainable development, Mutual learning between different follow the trend of our times, jointly to realize civilization connectivity. enhance international cooperation in The river brings not only the past to civilizations the field of cultural governance and the people along the river, but also a sustainable development and build a glorious future. historical circumstances and the same YANG YI pursuit of dreams. From the high altitude Tibet Autonomous Region, deep THE “Yarlung-Tsangpo-Siang- mountains area, the valley stream side, Brahmaputra-Jamuna” River, which to the cross-cultural tea county Assam, finds its origin in the northern foothills and the Ganges Delta, you can hear of the Himalayas, as a trans-boundary the sound of bells from representative river and one of the major rivers of Asia, temples and palaces, you may meet it nourishes the fertile land on both sides the cultural relics created by different of the river, feeds hard working people ethnic groups, they are the products Bangladesh: a land of thousand rivers! and splendid cultures since ancient of cultural exchanges, representing the times. prosperity and glory of the past and "The rational The upper reaches basically belong human history’s quest, also the common RUNA KHAN knots. As you watch it move at a speed and sustainable to nomadic areas, the vast grasslands on heritage of mankind. and with a volume incomprehensible development the Tibetan antelope, Yak and other wild Civilizations have been enriched AWE INSPIRING in its resilience, to those who have never seen a river of and utilization animals’ paradise. The lower reaches and become more colorful through overpowering in its strength and a 25 km in breadth, you are filled with of cross-border benefits for irrigation and transportation exchange and mutual learning. The feeling of continuity between the river astonishment and fear, at this sight. One river water from the water. It’s the cradle of the birth exchange and mutual learning serve as and its communities is possibly what is often overwhelmed with emotions and resources calls for and development of many civilizations, important drivers of human progress struck me when, 20 years ago, I first helplessness, as you witness the chars our wisdom and also a witness to inter-civilizational and global peace and development. came face to face with the mighty River breaking and disappearing with the cooperation." communication and cultural exchanges At a crossroads in world history, Jamuna and the chars (river islands), current. Washed away in front of your among the people, which have their all countries look forward to peace along it’s multiple banks, the people, the eyes as you watch from your boat, meter own characteristics and influence each and tranquility, common prosperity, communities and life. So broad was the by meter the very land where you had other. This civilizational and cultural openness and integration in face of a Jumna that one could fit the city of Paris seen the children play, where crops were blend runs through the river basin. profound unprecedented change in a between its two shores! growing and men came home to their The riparian countries are linked by century. Great hopes go hand in hand During the Summer, the river is wives, just a month ago. The river carrying mountains and rivers, and have similar with great challenges. How can riparian in spate, and can flow at 10, even 12 away in its might, livelihoods, lives and 380 381 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES hope of all those who live on them. Jamuna brings with it life, mobility, food, One is not reflecting on the power of discussion on many issues, not just one These are nomadic islands, like water, cultures, proximity and distance. these rivers, which is immense. Others or two that come to mind. One can only the nomadic people who live on them. It also encompasses our fears. see that power differently: mention see enormous gaps of communication Migrant climate refugees. Families, It is on these seemingly unnavigable, the scale and fall from the Himalayan and comprehension. A dialogue to persons, moving up to 48 times in their unpredictable waters, where foreign heights to a civil or electric engineer and be true must involve all principal lives, island to island, year after year – marine influence could not reach, that his or her eyes will probably light up at stakeholders – the people who are most daring not even to hope. the largest fleet of inland wooden boats the thought of dams and projects that affected by the strife and consequent This river is staggering in its came into existence. Their unique crafts will create a surge of energy. One is not problems, not just those who see wondrous might. Bangladesh is built remained unmatched for millennia. talking about that either. themselves as stakeholders: government "Nowhere else on the silt brought down by the Rivers These boats with their ochre sails are a Who realizes that in the cacophony and its agencies as well as business. in the world Brahmaputra, Ganges and the Meghna. heritage of humanity. Nowhere else in about dialogue and development and Talk about water in India and these do you see the The names of the first two rivers, are the world do you see the variety and the Look East policies, we seem to have are the last groups in the government’s variety and the famous all over the world as two of the technical skills which are used in these forgotten the persistent and critical mind. Water policy and water flows technical skills world’s greatest rivers. Yet as they journey smooth skinned boats of Bangladesh. challenge before us: how do we enable a are classified information even though which are used down from the Himalayas, down the Twenty years ago, the rivers were filled minimum of 3-5 million an opportunity with GIS any decent researcher can in these smooth deltaic plains, the Brahmaputra changes with the ochre sails, of the malar, to cope with floods. Because unless we get the information he or she wants skinned boats of its name to Jamuna and the Ganges panshis, baich, balar. Today these are do that none of our policies or talk is without going on bended knees to the "Unless the most Bangladesh." to Padma and together they meet the reminiscences of the past, except for going to work. government. In our case, the task force marginalized Meghna and as the Meghna, they flow the B613 and the Fleche d’Or which we I am always stunned at the was not even prepared to look at the issue of our people, into the sea. Ironically, neither the mighty built, to preserve their technology and lackadaisical way we approach this of watershed management and problems those who are Brahmaputra nor the mighty Ganges, save some of the last carpenters from an problem, showing concern only when upstream until one of the region’s most river-dependent enters the Bay of Bengal with their untimely extinction. urban conglomerates like Guwahati prominent geographers questioned and among other famous names. The Jamuna teaches us much. are affected by ingress of high water. challenged its members. groups, are Bangladesh is ‘the land of a thousand Humility if we are ever tempted to I think places like Guwahati deserve Again, where is the dialogue? For represented at rivers.’ The rivers are as important to control it and understanding and respect to be flooded because its residents, true dialogue to take place one must the dialogue Bangladesh as veins are to our body if we ever try to work without taking contractors and politicians as well as have the other prerequisites in place table, conditions and laces through as intrinsically. The into consideration its capricious nature. bureaucrats, have destroyed the land – information and transparency, not will not change." below their feet – they have emptied out rhetoric or ‘facts’ as paraded by one side wetlands and built high rises. When the or another. next earthquake hits, don’t be surprised So, unless the most marginalized by high casualties and no amount of of our people, those who are river- disaster preparedness or firefighting dependent among other groups, are exercises will help. represented at the dialogue table, And that is the point: the floods conditions will not change except delineate a political process as much as through growing pressure and violence. an environmental and economic one. It Come floods and overnight people lose Water of despair, waters of hope is the story of the strong and the weak, homes and farms, livestock and life of the poor and the underprivileged savings, forced to live without the basics on the one hand and lawmakers and of human dignity on embankments and SANJOY HAZARIKA in turn flow into that greatest of all policy-makers on the other, with roads for weeks and months without Indian rivers, the Brahmaputra; there are business in between. In some cases civil food security and a change of clothes. THE RIVERS of Northeast India leap and 22 which have already fallen upstream in society is stepping in to fill the breach. And people talk about freedom? Where bound over hills; they do not flow. There Tibet and in Bangladesh three more join But is anyone talking about dialogue; is the freedom from indignity for the are not less than 33 major rivers which it, including the Ganga. a dialogue which includes debate and most vulnerable? 382 383 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES Let that be first addressed by those it or recovering from it) for anything who claim to speak in our name. Let between five to eight months of the them participate in efforts to save our year, how can we have an economic people and improve their economic policy that does not consider this very conditions, instead of hectoring foreign basic factor? countries and abusing those who Massive interventions are being disagree. planned, proposed and implemented Our own group, the Centre across the rivers of the Northeast. for North East Studies and Policy But has anyone studied the impact on Research, although small, works in aquatic life, on the endemic fish species some 25 research sites and has a basic of the region, on the dolphins, one of the Integrated approach to governance of a interactive rural group of not less than most endangered fresh water mammals 2,000 persons ranging across seven in South Asia, of which there are only transboundary river districts of Assam. One demand that some 200 left? We need to script another we have been pressing for some time success story with the dolphin like that "By bringing in is the urgency of building high-rise of the rhino – how can there be Bihu YUMIKO YASUDA coastal and terrestrial ecosystems. "It is important people-centric, platforms where people can take shelter without the xixu? The Integrated Water Resources to engage people-consulting in times of flood, with a separate area for Let me share one small experience THE YARLUNG-Tsangpo-Brahmaputra Management (IWRM) approach aims multiple levels policies which can livestock. We must restore dignity and where we are developing a physical river originates in the Himalayas to ensure cross-sectoral coordination. of stakeholders be implemented basic rights. Surely that is the essence intervention which could, we believe, and flows through China, India, and Currently, all countries are engaged who play simply and with of conversation, understanding and make a difference to river dependent Bangladesh to the Bay of Bengal with in reporting on the degree of IWRM different roles the involvement dialogue? If we are not bothered about communities. I call this the boat of some tributaries flowing from Bhutan. implementation (SDG 6.5.target). in making of those they seek how people live in conditions which hope, because with limited funds and It supports life and livelihoods for Sharing experiences among riparian integration to benefit." defy the very basic definition of human a team of boat builders, traditional approximately 130 million people countries can create an opportunity to happen at the rights – including safety, the right to builders, with new designs and a more It also causes floods, sedimentation, bring stakeholders together to discuss basin-level." clean water, food and shelter – then powerful engine, we are building a boat riverbank erosion, and water pollution. this common approach and find better our policies and projects and that will take health services to people Real time data sharing among the management approaches. GWP is programmes. in time of need – especially during riparian countries in recent years working in many countries to support The GOI’s Look East policy is floods. Why hasn’t this been thought of supported flood risk management, the process of achieving SDG targets, extremely commendable and worthy of earlier? Because there’s no money to be which was possible due to political including its reporting process through support. However, the policy and a lot made, perhaps, if I am permitted to be commitments of the riparian countries. UN custodian agencies. of the thinking around it – connecting cynical In order to maximize benefits from the The second level involves ensuring to Southeast Asia and our neighbours But there are reasons for hope: river and minimize risks, it is critical to integrated management of the river – overlooks one basic point. Without they lie in addressing issues head on. take an integrated basin management from its source to sea, requiring a water transport policy capable of They lie in thinking innovatively and approach at two levels. The first level of enhanced cooperation among riparian moving large volumes of goods by river, out of the box but with our feet on integration is to ensure multi-sectoral countries and stakeholders. At this the Look East policy will run into the the ground and with commitment as integration. River basin management level of integration, it is important to sandbanks of the Brahmaputra. For it well as by bringing in people-centric, requires engagement of various sectors: engage multiple levels of stakeholders does not even consider the most basic people-consulting policies which can for example, industrial and household who play different roles in making of problems: when the region and its be implemented simply and with the activities, which increase sedimentation integration happen at the basin-level. main road and rail corridor are under involvement of those they seek to and may therefore lead to increased In this context, the multi-track water water or affected by water (either hit by benefit. flood levels. Industrial and household diplomacy approach can be effective pollution and waste management impact in achieving healthy management of negatively on water quality, affecting the Yarlung-Tsangpo-Brahmaputra 384 385 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES river. The positive trend in the region scale. The economic corridor approach with the Yarlung Tsangpo was only people to safer zones and deployment is that there are already several efforts taken in the region also pushes and established by British led explorations of emergency response teams. Another and actors contributing to multi-track supports this trend. There are also in 1884-86. Before this discovery, in event occurred on the Siang which water diplomacy throughout the basin. trends in exchanges of benefits across the plains of Assam the Lohit river was created much concern to downstream Multi-stakeholder platforms, including sectors and borders: for example, in mistaken as the Brahmaputra for ages. people. There was sudden darkening and but certainly not limited to the Global the case of inter-sectoral exchanges The Siang river is revered in contamination of the Siang with oily, Water Partnership, could be a vehicle for between electricity supply and internet Arunachal Pradesh and local people dark patches all along the river due to engaging a wide range of stakeholders in access between Bangladesh and India. call the river as ‘Ané Siang’ or Mother mysterious reasons. Suspected reasons the governance of this important river. In 2016, the Indian state of Tripura Siang. From about 300-700 metres included series of earthquakes in Tibet, Tackling both levels of integration started providing 100MW of electricity width all along its flow in Arunachal, massive construction work in Tibet, may sound like an immense challenge to Bangladesh in exchange for 10 the river widens beyond Pasighat in the increased mining activities in Tibet etc. for a large river. However, we are gigabits per second internet bandwidth. foothills to a width of about 10-15 km This contamination and darkening of the observing a trend that can potentially This shows that countries have already reaching the plains of Assam. The Siang Siang affected aquatic life and livelihood move riparian countries and started collaboration outside of the and its tributaries support livelihood of of many people. stakeholders in this direction. At the sectoral ‘box’. Such win-win exchanges lakhs of people in Arunachal Pradesh. During 2018-19, many areas of East basin-level, riparian countries in South among riparian countries illustrates The mighty river supports a vibrant Siang District in Arunachal Pradesh Asia and China historically worked potential to expand at the basin-level, eco-system with a wide variety of flora have been devastated by the rampaging primarily at the bilateral level over their facilitating the promotion of benefit and fauna and a diverse, rich aquatic & Siang river. The rampaging Siang River water cooperation, but there is a trend sharing and exchanges across sectors animal life. In fact there are five districts is threatening many villages of Mebo towards cooperation at the multilateral and borders. in Arunachal Pradesh bearing the name and Pasighat area due to massive soil Siang. erosion by rising levels of the Siang Some recent events on the river river despite deficient rainfall. Many "The mighty in Tibet have caused some serious villagers are unable to sleep peacefully river supports downstream affects in Arunachal. There and many have shifted their houses a vibrant eco- was a massive flood caused by the river to better locations. It is estimated that system with a in year 2000 causing massive devastation about 10,000 Hectares of forested wide variety to downstream areas damaging life and land, plantations, irrigated fields, of flora and property. It is alleged that water surge community burial grounds, schools etc fauna and a and flooding was caused by sudden have been washed away. In fact vital diverse, rich breaching of a massive river blockade roads and bridges are on the verge of aquatic & due to landslide in Tibet. being washed away. It seems that the animal life." Ané Siang or Mother Siang Subsequent to the China floods of continuing contamination of the Siang 2000, India & China signed a MoU in river originating in Tibet has led to 2002 with follow up MoUs in 2013 & rise in the river bed leading to this M PANGING PAO Pradesh. In Arunachal it flows for 2018 on sharing flow information of dangerous and rampaging Siang river. about 260 km and is called as the Siang. the Yarlung Tsangpo. However, till date It is estimated that the river bed of the THE MIGHTY Brahmaputra has different The Siang river enters Assam south there is no water sharing treaty with Siang river has been raised by several names in different nations and regions. of Pasighat, where it is joined by the China. feet leading to the river spreading In Tibet, where it has the longest stretch Dibang river and the Lohit rivers. After Recently in 2018 the Yarlung sideways and causing massive soil of about 1625 km, it is called as the flowing through Assam, the river flows Tsangpo was again blocked due to erosion. The most probable reason Yarlung Tsangpo. The river carries out a into Bangladesh as the Jamuna. landslides in Tibet twice causing for this increase in the river bed is the massive U-Turn at Namcha Barwa and The Brahmaputra's upper course much concern to downstream areas prolonged deposits of cement/oil mix enters India near Gelling in Arunachal was long unknown in India; its identity of Arunachal leading to evacuation of caused by massive construction/mining 386 387 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES activities along the Tibetan side of the a plantation program was also held country except three rivers viz. Amo water resource might be challenged river. which was attended by Forest Man of Chhu in western part of the country, by the new, complex and pervasive Towards preventing further damage India Jadav Payeng and Forest Man of Gongri and Kuri Chhu in the eastern, all dynamics caused by population growth by the rampaging Siang, affected Arunachal Indi Glow. This volunteering of which originate in the southern part and socio-economic development. These villagers of the area created a group work and plantation is planned to of the Tibetan Plateau. challenges will have to be effectively called SEEANG (Siang Eco-System continue to prevent further damage. Water plays a pivotal role in all addressed through appropriate Environment Protection and Nurture The mighty Siang supports, sustains four of Bhutan’s major economic Policies, Acts and Regulations. Further Group) to create awareness and mobilise lives and a diverse, vibrant ecosystem; drivers, viz. agriculture, hydropower, public education and awareness, the affected villages. Under the aegis Siang also destroys and uproots life & tourism and small-scale industry. stakeholder participation and well- of SEEANG, affected villages carried property. Events upstream of the river Agriculture consumes over 90% of water designed developmental programs with out multiple crash programs on self in Tibet have a cascading effect on lakhs resources used in Bhutan where 60% its efficient and coordinated management help basis without Govt support to of downstream people living along the population are engaged in subsistence institutions are important. These create flood protection measures with river. Local people are carrying out farming. Agriculture contributes over are all envisaged and carried out local resources like Bamboo/Wood traditional rituals, shamans are offering 15% to the country’s GDP. under Integrated Water Resources Porcupines, Stone/Net/Sand Bag spurs prayers for Ané Siang to show mercy The energy sector in Bhutan comprises Management (IWRM), which is a & bandhs etc. Entire villages including and protect their villages, fields and almost wholly of hydropower, accounts systematic process for the sustainable men, women & youth worked in these community burial grounds! Is the local 25% of its domestic revenue. Bhutan’s development, allocation and monitoring crash programs voluntarily. Recently and neighbouring govts listening? accelerated development of hydropower of water resource use in the context of projects has set a target of 10,000 MW social, economic and environmental by 2020; and in actual we were able to objectives. "Water plays develop only 2,335 MW till date. Bearing in mind the impacts that a pivotal role Bhutan’s transition from a Least could be visible from rapid hydropower in all four Developed Country (LDC) to an upper development, it is imperative to ensure of Bhutan’s middle-income country rests almost the sanctity of the riverine ecosystems major entirely to the revenues earned through through enforcement of minimum economic hydropower export. Tourism is an ecological flow reserve and the drivers, viz. important source of employment and mandatory provisions on the migratory agriculture, an estimated 20% of non-hydropower pathways for aquatic fauna such as fish hydropower, revenues are also to a large extent ladders. tourism and dependent on the pristine natural The Water Act, its Regulation and small-scale landscapes maintained in their lush and the standards are strictly enforced industry." verdant state with the natural flow of within the country through regular Bhutan: A land rich with water resources pristine river systems. monitoring of the ambient and The 2,674 glacial lakes perching on industrial samples. Any likely hazards the northern high-altitude alpine areas such as flash floods in the basin KARMA CHOPEL GONGSAR form of rivers. There are four major river are mostly small, yet serve as important adjoining the downstream Indian basins, viz. the Amo Chhu (Toorsa), the headwater sources of the riverine territories are intimated through the BHUTAN IS endowed with rich water Wang Chhu (Raidak), the Punatsang systems. The outburst of some of these hydro met stations. A regular biannual resources with long term average annual Chhu (Sunkosh) and the Drangme Chhu lakes from time to time has resulted meeting is held between the experts flows of 73,000 million m3/year giving (Manas), all of which empties into the in enormous flash floods and damages of Bhutan and India on issues of rise to one of the highest per capita Brahmaputra in the Indian plains. The downstream. trans-boundary flooding and hydro- mean annual flow availability of over “Chhu” in its local dialect refers to river The current scenario of abundant meteorological data exchanges. 100,000 m3. However, being landlocked, and by extension also means water. All its water resources are mainly in the the river systems originate within the 388 389 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES Need for co-operation YU HONGYUAN sensitivity and vulnerability. Security nexus provides a new explanation for TO ACHIEVE the SDGs in Yarlung resources competition, cooperation Tsangpo-Brahmaputra-Jamuna River and conflicts, and promotes water "We need to Basin, we need to reorganize the – food – energy research shift from reorganize regional cooperation model, consolidate the technical aspects to foreign the regional the cohesion between energy-food- policy level, and finally provides new cooperation Where is the river born? water development, strengthen international political ideas for resource model, urban-rural water infrastructure, and environmental solutions. In the consolidate restore public health-clean water co- security nexus perspective, as through the cohesion IMTIAZ AHMED helps to produce bumper crops in the developemnt system, alleviate poverty international cooperation to solve between surrounding region. But then the same and inequalities, upgrade sustainable ecological problems is not a simple energy- THERE IS a general perception that a river could be the cause of ‘big floods’ development governance capacity, as technical issue, but an international food-water river is born from its sources, the place and could end up creating havoc in the well as enhance capacity of addressing political and economic issue. Based development." of its origin. But the Yarlung Tsangpo- life of the people in the same region. But climate change and various disasters. on the special political and economic Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamuna gets re-born the course of the river is not dictated by China can also reinforce the advantages that China owns, China and "The Yarlung at every stage of its long, tumultuous nature alone. Human intervention in the cooperation with developing countries, developing countries should jointly Tsangpo-Siang- journey. Throughout its journey to name of development has transformed help with each other and enhance cope with the challenges of security Brahmaputra- destination, it grows to maturity and at the course of the river in a significant mutual understanding and trust. In the nexus is an important opportunity for Jamuna gets one point dies out of aging. The ‘birth’ way. In fact, the craze for development developing world, water, energy and deepening of friendly and cooperative re-born at every of the Tsangpo-Brahmaputra-Jamuna- has allowed for a precise ‘mentality’ to food formed a security nexus with great relation. stage of its long, Meghna is seen in every point of the emerge, which cannot help thinking tumultuous river, indeed, not only with respect to and eventually building bridges, canals journey." its geo-territorial naming, that is, within and dams when confronted by a river. China, India and Bangladesh, but also Development mentality otherwise has with respect to its transformation, for not only concretized, indeed, with instance, from a male deity called the cement and iron rods, the respective Brahmaputra to a female deity called the segments of the river and tributaries in Jamuna. And in this region, the rivers China, India, Bhutan and Bangladesh are Gods and Goddesses. but also distorted the natural flow of In Sanskrit, river is nadi, nadi the river often to the detriment of the The River: A precious Heritage denotes shakti (power), prana (life) river itself. Rivers also have their rights, and atman (soul). The river is both including the right to be relatively life-giver and life-eliminator. The flow pollution free, to be a safe habitat for MA JUN East, with an average elevation of more of water could create both pain and riverine forms of life and, within limits, than 3000 meters above the sea level. It pleasures in the life and living of the to flow freely. It is precisely this ‘right’ THE YARLUNG TSANGPO River is a is one of the highest rivers in the world. people. If the river causes normal floods, and the sanctity that we need to ensure magnificent river, although so few of us What's more, the silver ribbon on the as it is the case with the river almost with respect to this formidable river and really know about it. Originating from plateau also has an amazing amount of every year, then it enriches the soil and there lies the challenge! the glaciers at the northern foot of the water. The annual runoff is three times Himalayas, the Yarlung Tsangpo runs that of the Yellow River. through the south of Tibet from west to At the source of the Yarlung 390 391 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES Tsangpo River and its many tributaries, At the same time, the ecological alpine glaciers bring stable water supply. environment of the Yarlung Tsangpo But the more important reason is that River Basin is very fragile. The the Grand Canyon cut by the Yarlung interference of human activities, coupled Tsangpo River, which suddenly turns with global climate change, may cause to the south, enables the warm and ecological degradation that is difficult humid air flow from the Indian Ocean to to restore and aggravate geological penetrate into the hinterland of Qinghai disasters. Tibet, so that the input water vapor is In recent years, in order to equal to the total water vapor flowing to construct an ecological civilization, Brahmaputra flood plains without Rhino the north of the Yangtze River in China. China has vigorously strengthened The unique topography and landforms environmental protection. Up to now, seems an incomplete proposition endow the Yarlung Tsangpo River with the Yarlung Tsangpo River is still one of extremely high ecological value. In the the cleanest rivers in China. The water upper reaches, there is a unique plateau quality of the main rivers in the basin BIBHAB KUMAR TALUKDAR occupying key grassland patches in "Most of the ecosystem; at the big turning point, is above class III, including the main rhino bearing areas and diseases like political, the Indian Ocean water vapor channel stream of the Yarlung Tsangpo River TO ME, the rhino is the symbol of Anthrax could also pose serious threats economic and pushes the tropical boundary northward and many main tributaries such as the Assam, it reflects the conservation to future of rhinos in Assam. As such we "Rhino is a cultural centers for six latitudes (550 kilometers), and Palong Tsangpo River and the Niyang commitment of Assam and its people need to keep our ears and eyes open to living legend in Tibet are within a vertical height of 5000 meters, it River, which maintain class II water and as such rhino has to be conserved periodically assess the threats rhino are of the flood located in the contains all the natural landscapes from quality all the year round. for our future generations with support facing and initiate timely intervention to plains of Yarlung Tsangpo alpine ice and snow to tropical seasonal The Yarlung Tsangpo River, from all section of the society. While reverse the threats to secure the future Brahmaputra." valley." rain forest, forming a rich biodiversity, together with the Brahmaputra River rhino poaching is visibly being seen of greater one horned rhino – the pride and also conserving the largest forest and Jamuna river at its lower reaches, as the major threat to future of the of Assam. I am sure, we can save the area in Tibet. and even the flat and wide Ganges rhinos, but change in grassland and species in years to come to showcase our The river, more than 2000 River delta formed by the confluence wetland habitats in rhino bearing areas, rhino as living legend of flood plains kilometers long, moistens the land of the Ganges River, jointly supports emergence of invasive plant species, Brahmaputra ecosystems. on both sides and breeds ancient and the ecological environment and social splendid culture. Most of the political, and economic development in the economic and cultural centers in Tibet basin. are located in the Yarlung Tsangpo I hope the publication of this book valley. can enhance the common and mutual The huge elevation drop understandings of the whole river Ganges River dolphin from a concentrated in the middle and lower basin, promote more exchanges and reaches of the River, coupled with the cooperation among relevant parties in trans-boundary perspective substantial discharge, makes the Yarlung the river basin, jointly care for this pure Tsangpo River rich in hydropower and precious water resources, protect potentials. As a geosyncline between this rich and diverse home, and pass it RAVINDRA KUMAR SINHA cetacean as it has many ancient and Indian Ocean plate and Eurasian plate, on to future generations forever. vestigial organs not found in any other the Yarlung Tsangpo River Basin is also THE GANGES River dolphin, Platanista cetaceans of today. It is known as blind rich in mineral resources. gangetica gangetica, commonly known dolphin as its pin-hole eyes without as susu, is an obligatory freshwater crystalline lens and with meagre dolphin which never enters sea; and vestigial retina cannot form image. It is probably the most ancient living is distributed in Ganga-Brahmaputra- 392 393 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES Meghna (GBM) river systems from tidal distribution range, and threats the zone to as far up as rivers are navigable species was facing. At the behest of in India, Nepal and Bangladesh; and Cetacean Specialist Group of IUCN, I Karnaphuli-Sangu river system in South- discovered an alternative to dolphin oil East Bangladesh. It is solitary in nature as fish attractant from fish scraps freely unlike other cetaceans. Combining available at the door steps of fishers "The Ganges current knowledge on abundance from (Sinha 2002). Later on, I undertook River dolphin the entire distribution range an educated extension program to popularize this is a flagship guess is that the entire species numbers alternative among the fishers of Bihar species in is about 3700 individuals of all ages. A and Assam where oil fishing was The complexity of managing a all its range total of 197 individuals were counted in rampant. On my initiatives, the Prime countries. It River Brahmaputra in India Minister of India declared the dolphin trans-boundary river can be used as The species has been classified by as National Aquatic Animal on 5th a tool for trans- IUCN as endangered in 1996. The main October, 2009 which was formally boundary river threats are: directed and incidental notified on May10, 2010. Thus India AINUN NISHAT Complications arise when a river flows cooperation." killings as fishery by-catches, habitat became first country in the world to through two or more countries. Like degradation/loss due to indiscriminate have a dolphin as its National Aquatic IT IS very important to remember that we see in the case of the Jamuna. To water abstraction/diversion by Animal. the Brahmaputra-Jamuna not only this end, the Convention on the Law of construction of dams and barrages The Ganges River dolphin as a carry a huge discharge, it also carries a Non-Navigational Uses of International leading to declining and regulated flagship species for trans-boundary river large volume of sediment load. The flow Watercourses, adopted by the United flows in rivers, besides creating physical cooperation. Water scarcity has resulted of water and sediment load influence Nations in 1997, states that there are barriers for dispersal of dolphins, in geopolitical tension and stunted the landscape through which it flows; three parties to trans-boundary river intense river pollution, loss of forests development throughout the world. protects and nourishes the ecosystem management—the riparian countries in catchment areas resulting in heavy There is a need for ‘hydro-diplomacy’ of the surrounding landscape. People's and the river itself. In case of any siltation, river traffic using mechanized – making scarce water a reason for livelihoods are built around the river. need to control the flow of water, we "In case of boats/ vessels, heavy sand mining, lack cooperation, rather than a reason for To manage a river, does not mean have to consider the needs of the river any need to of awareness among common mass, etc. conflict. There is a serious need for only managing the flow. We have to and we need to ensure that ambient control the There has been an age-old practice of greater international cooperation based take into account the sediments, the environment is not disrupted; it is not flow of water, using the dolphin oil as fish attractant on the growing communal urgency aquatic biodiversity, the surrounding harmed. For supporting development, we have to for some commercially important fishes. and need for water around the world ecosystem and communities living along if the flow regime has to be altered, then consider the There was a great passion in me in general and in Indian subcontinent the river. Now we have modern tools how much water can be withdrawn needs of the to learn and save this species since my in particular. Hydro-diplomacy is a like numerical models, GIS and remote from river should be determined by river and school days in 1960s. I have devoted critical tool to ensure that shared water sensing technologies to better understand reserving ecological flow. As population we need to almost four decades learning, studying resources are managed efficiently, the river and how it will behave, more is increasing, it will not be prudent to ensure that and conducting surveys in the entire sustainably and equitably. importantly we have instruments like demand that nature must not be left ambient length of the Ganges and parts of most The Ganges River dolphin is a environmental flows to ensure that the untouched. environment of its tributaries in India and Nepal flagship species in all its range countries. needs of the river and surrounding Management of trans-boundary is not since early 1980s using oar driven It can be used as a tool for trans- ecosystems are taken care of. Armed with rivers is made complex from political disrupted." small boats to assess its status and boundary river cooperation. this knowledge and understanding, it consideration of the riparian countries. should be easier to manage a river, even But the approach has to be scientific as mighty as the Brahmaputra. but political decisions must guide the When a river and its catchment process and, as may be necessary, be able is confined within the borders of to over-ride technical as well so called one country, the task is simpler. legal arguments. 394 395 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES rights make this quite difficult. At Helsinki Rules on the Uses of Waters of the international level the framework International Rivers. These guidelines for cooperation is even weaker and is may not have the force of law but are often locked in a stalemate because of valuable as a starting point for organised sharp differences between upstream cooperation as they reflect a consensus "Today, what and downstream countries on their between legal specialists from upstream we need are respective rights. and downstream states. more complete The way ahead requires a dilution The challenge of international agreements that of the distinction between the rights cooperation in the management of deal with all of upstream and downstream states. international rivers is particularly possible uses of A shared resource is not owned by acute in Asia where a large number of the river and that Managing a shared resource any one party, not even the flows that rivers, many originating in the Tibetan bring together all traverse through its territory. The river plateau, like the Yarlung-Tsangpo- the jurisdictions bed may lie in one jurisdiction; but Siang-Brahmaputra-Jamune River. through which the NITIN DESAI with each other. When waste from human the water travels from one jurisdiction Today, what we need are more complete river passes." settlements and industrial plants pollutes the to another. This emphasis on shared agreements that deal with all possible FRESH WATER, on which all life depends, is a river, its potential as a source of household ownership and shared responsibility is uses of the river and that bring together shared resource, whether it is a village pond, a water may be compromised. When a river is reflected in the available international all the jurisdictions through which the large lake, an underground aquifer or a river. used extensively for navigation or hydro power, guidelines like the Berlin Rules on Water river passes. This book about one such The central issue for water management at all it may interfere so much with fish spawning Resources, adopted by the International shared river, written by many specialists geographical levels from the village or town, grounds that fishery prospects may be adversely Law Association in 2004, which are from the region is a valuable first step in to the regional, national or global level is the affected. When the quantity of water withdrawn more comprehensive than the earlier this direction. adequacy of the governance arrangements to from the river goes beyond a limit it may allow all who share the resource a say in the reduce flows to a point at which river species decisions about its development and use. are threatened with extinction. Population A river poses a truly complex challenge pressures and changing patterns of land use, for governance because of the multiple uses particularly those that encroach on flood it serves. It provides water for household, plains, can increase the threat of floods. Hence agricultural and industrial use. It can be a separating the different uses of the river under major source of hydroelectric power when it different governance arrangements may not be descends from the hills to the plains. It may be appropriate. used for water transport in barges and boats. All of these threats are becoming more acute It can be a source of fish for consumption. It and may become unmanageable if climate change has to be managed to contain flood risks, leads to radical shifts in the quantum and timing The urgent need for regional control pollution and protect biodiversity. of water flows. Hence the need for cooperation All this requires a shared understanding of between the political jurisdictions is now even river-based cooperation the hydrology of the river and relevant data more necessary than in the past when demands exchange between the multiple political for water and other services that a river provides jurisdictions through which river passes, within were lower and less threatened by demographic, QAZI KHOLIQUZZAMAN to organize their lives in conducive or between countries. A further source of economic and ecological changes. When these AHMAD locations. One consideration was surely complexity that is becoming more important jurisdictions are within a country the political proximity to sources of water needed for now is the potential impact of climate change on framework for strengthening cooperation is WHEN, thousands of years ago, farming, in addition to water for life. Up the hydrology of the river. available, though, the experience of countries humans moved out of caves and took to the beginning of the first Industrial These multiple uses of a river interact like India shows that the entrenched views about up agricultural activities, they had Revolution (circa 1870), human 396 397 THE RESTLESS RIVER VOICE: PERSPEC TIVES settlements, by and large, grew alongside it is now generally accepted that a rivers. transboundary river is best managed Currently, road, rail and air by co-riparians together under an transportation along with ground water agreed cooperative framework for larger extraction, water diversion methods, benefits. But politics, diplomacy and, not water purification and transporting of infrequently, bureaucratic tangles often water long distances are so developed prevent cooperation among the that proximity to rivers is not as co-riparians. important as it used to be - generally In the wake of global climate speaking that is. change, which is fast worsening, major But in certain parts of the world, floods are occurring more frequently rivers still define the way of life. The and devastatingly. The changing catchment area of the Yarlung Tsangpo- and shifting pattern of rainfall also Brahmaputra-Jamuna Rivers, running introduces variations in the water flow across China, India and Bangladesh, levels and patterns, thereby disturbing "Given the is one such region. Millions of people crop cycle and other economic activities. fast worsening of the countries through which these Given the fast worsening climate climate change rivers and their tributaries flow through change impacts in the basin, a regional impacts in remain crucially dependent on them for river-based cooperation becomes even the basin, water for life and water for livelihood more urgent also to address climate a regional including irrigation, transportation, change impacts together, while at river-based hydroelectricity, water for industrial and the same time tackling basin-wide cooperation other economic systems and natural river development issues. That is, the becomes even systems. Employment and income cooperation framework has to cover the more urgent." earning opportunities, particularly of basin all the way from the origins of the the rural people, of the basin still largely three rivers, their joining one another evolve around these rivers. at places and eventually flowing down While these rivers are a boon for to the sea. The purpose is to benefit all the people, they also bring sorrow due the peoples of all co-riparians in terms to frequent floods and river erosion. of access to water for various purposes Moreover, downstream countries including irrigation, timely information often suffer from very low flows due to sharing with lower riparian countries as excessive upstream extraction of water flood water rises upstream, cooperative during the dry season. There is therefore generation and equitable sharing of this double jeopardy for the people living hydro-electricity, excavation and river in the downstream regions of this basin. training, addressing climate change But, international rules, Helsinki adaptation, and cleaning up the water Rules for example, provide for equitable of the rivers as required all along the share of transboundary rivers to be course across the countries the river available to all co-riparians. Indeed, runs through. 398 399 CONTRIBUTORS Contributors Dilip Chetry Scientist-E, Vice President & Head Primate Research and Conservation Division Golam Rasul Chief Economist, International Centre for Integrated Mountain Ainun Nishat Bibhab Kumar Talukdar Aaranyak, Assam Development (ICIMOD) Professor Emeritus, Centre for Climate Change and Secretary General and CEO, India Nepal Environmental Research, Aaranyak, Assam BRAC University, Dhaka India Eklavya Prasad Gorky Chakraborty Bangladesh Managing Trustee, Associate Professor, Institute of Development Bhoj K Acharya Megh Pyne Abhiyan Studies, Abhishek V. Shukla Associate Professor & Head, Department of India Kolkata Khangchendzonga Landscape Programme, Zoology India WWF- India Sikkim University Farzana Begum Sikkim Sikkim Anthropologist, Directorate of Assam Institute of Halla Maher Qaddumi India India Research for Tribal and Scheduled Castes, Senior Water Economist, Water East Asia & Guwahati, Assam Pacific Region Ahmmed Zulfiqar Rahaman Bishal Thakuri India World Bank Specialist, Climate Change and Disaster Department of Zoology, Vietnam Management Division School of Life Sciences Fazlul Karim Center for Environmental and Geographic Sikkim University Research Scientist (Hydrology), Imtiaz Ahmed Information Services (CEGIS) Sikkim Land and Water Professor of International Relations and Bangladesh India CSIRO Director, Centre for Genocide Studies Australia University of Dhaka Ambuj Thakur Bushra Nishat Bangladesh Assistant Professor, Department of History Environmental Specialist, South Asia Region Ganesh Pangare CKB College Teok, Jorhat ENVIRONMENT unit, Consultant, Senior Water Resources Specialist Indra P. Acharja Assam The World Bank World Bank Chief, Species & Habitat Conservation Division India Bangladesh Thailand Royal Society for Protection of Nature (RSPN) Bhutan Aminul Islam C M Shafi Sami Gautam Bambawale GIS Expert, Disruptive KIDS (Knowledge, Former Foreign Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs Jayanto Bandhopadhya Information & Data Services) Helpdesk, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Government of Government of India Retired Professor, Indian Institute of The World Bank Bangladesh India Management, Kolkota Bangladesh India Anamika Barua Ghongsar Karma Chhopel Professor (Ecological Economics), Humanities and D B Gurung Chief Environment Officer (PHPA-1) Jin Tao Social Sciences, IIT-Guwahati Professor, College of Natural Resources Bhutan Professor, Tibet Academy of Agricultural and Assam Royal University of Bhutan Animal Husbandry Sciences India Bhutan Girish Jathar Tibet Assistant Director, Climate Change & China Arun B Shrestha Dhrupad Choudhury Himalaya Programme Regional Programme Manager - River Basins/ Chief Scaling Operations Bombay Natural History Society Kinlay Tshering Cryosphere and Atmosphere International Centre for Integrated Mountain Maharashtra Director, Department of Agriculture International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) INDIA Ministry of Agriculture & Forests Development (ICIMOD) Nepal Bhutan Nepal 400 401 THE RESTLESS RIVER CONTRIBUTORS Kshirode Roy Marc Foggin Minakshi Bora Nitin Desai Agriculture and Irrigation Engineering Expert Honorary Research Associate Assistant Professor, Department of Retired, Under Secretary General of the UN Gazipur Institute of Asian Research, Environmental Science New-Delhi Bangladesh School of Public Policy and Global Affairs, Gauhati University India University of British Columbia Guwahati, Assam Liu Jiang And International Director of Plateau Perspectives India Paresh Borah Associate Professor, Canada Assistant Professor, Department of Political Institute of International Rivers and Mohammad Hossain Science , Rangapara College Eco-Security, Yunnan University, Md Anisur Rahman Hydrogeologist, Independent Consultant Sonitpur, Assam China Chief Scientific Officer (CSO) Bangladesh India Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute (BFRI) Long Di Bangladesh Mohammed Mainuddin Partha J Das Associate Professor, Department of Hydraulic Principal Research Scientist, Basin Management Head, Water Climate and Hazards Division Engineering, Tsinghua University, Md Ayub Hossain Outcomes Group, Land and Water (WATCH). Aaranyak China Chief Scientific Officer, Farm Machinery and Post CSIRO Assam harvest Process Engineering Division Australia India M Firoz Ahmed Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute Scientist F, Head TRCD and HRCD Bangladesh Mohonto Panging Pao Partha Sarathi Ghose Aaranyak, Assam Group Captain, Retired Air Force Officer Associate Landscape Coordinator, India Md Firoz Alam Social Worker and Author Khangchendzonga Landscape Programme, Associate Specialist, Pasighat WWF-India, Sikkim M Monirul H. Khan Geographic Information System Division India India Professor of Zoology, Jahangirnagar University Center for Environmental and Geographic Bangladesh Information Services (CEGIS) Nan Yi Pooja Kokoty Bangladesh Master Student, Development Consultant Ma Jun Department of Hydraulic Engineering, Assam Director, Institute of Public and Environmental Md Monowar-ul-Haq Tsinghua University, India Affairs Junior Specialist, China China Water Resources Management Division Preetee Sharma Center for Environmental and Geographic Neera Shrestha Pradhan Dept of History, Cotton University Malik Fida A. Khan Information Services (CEGIS) Programme Coordinator Koshi Ad-Interim Guwahati, Assam Executive Director Bangladesh River Basins and Cryosphere India Center for Environmental and Geographic International Centre for Integrated Mountain Information Services (CEGIS) Md Niamul Naser Development (ICIMOD) Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad Bangladesh Professor & Chairman. Department of Zoology Nepal Chairman, Dhaka School of Economics, University of Dhaka University of Dhaka, Dhaka Manjil Hazarika Bangladesh Nisha Wagle Bangladesh Assistant Professor and Head (i/c) Research Associate-Water Resource Department of Archaeology Megha Moktan Management, Water and Air Qu Bin Cotton University, Guwahati Project Officer, Khangchendzonga Landscape International Centre for Integrated Mountain Lecturer, School of Applied Meteorology, Nanjing Assam Programme, WWF- India Development (ICIMOD) University of Information Science & Technology India Sikkim Nepal China India 402 403 THE RESTLESS RIVER CONTRIBUTORS Raju Mandal S S Nandargi Sushmita Mandal Xiawei Liao Assistant Professor, Department of Economics Retired, Scientist E Independent Consultant, Conservation and Water Resource Management Specialist, Water Assam University, Silchar, Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology Livelihoods East Asia & Pacific Region Assam India New Delhi The World Bank India India China Sanchita Boruah Ravindra Kumar Sinha Associate Professor, D.H.S.K.College, Tania Zakir Xu Ran Vice- Chancellor (under Dibrugarh University), Assam Wildlife Researcher and Science Illustrator Department of Hydraulic Engineering, Shri Mata Vaishno Devi University, India Northeast Bangladesh Carnivore Conservation Tsinghua University, Jammu Initiative China India Sanjoy Hazarika Bangladesh International Director, Commonwealth Human Yang Yi Rekha Chetry Rights Initiative, New Delhi Tanvir Ahmed Secretary-General, China Institute of International Scientist-E, India Associate Specialist, Water Resources Studies Aaranyak, Assam Management Division China India Sayam U. Chowdhury Center for Environmental and Geographic Conservation Biologist and Assistant Information Services (CEGIS) Yu Hongyuan RTI International & ELMS Coordinator Spoon-billed Sandpiper Task Force Bangladesh Professor, Shanghai Institute for International North Carolina Dhaka Studies USA Bangladesh Taylor Henshaw Shanghai Consultant, World Bank China Runa Khan Shahnaj Laila Canada Founder & Executive Director Department of History Yulha Lhawa Friendship The Assam Royal Global University Tian Fuqiang Independent Researcher and native speaker of Bangladesh Guwahati, Assam Professor, Department of Hydraulic Khroskaybs Engineering, Tsinghua University, Sichuan Province S P Biswas Shahriar Wahid China China Professor, Department of Life Sciences, Principal Research Consultant, Land and Water Dibrugarh University, Assam CSIRO Utpal Singha Roy Yumiko Yasuda India Australia Assistant Professor (WBES), Department of Senior Network & Transboundary Water Zoology, P. R. Thakur Government College Cooperation Specialist S M A Rashid Shalini Thapa West Bengal Global Water Partnership Centre for Advanced Research in Natural Project Officer, Khangchendzonga Landscape India Sweden Resources and Management (CARINAM) Programme , WWF-India Dhaka Sikkim Uttam Sinha Zhao Fanyu Bangladesh India Fellow, Institute for Defence Studies Master Student, Department of Hydraulic and Analyses (IDSA) Engineering, Tsinghua University S M Sadik Tanveer Sudipta Kumar Hore New Delhi China Senior Assistant Secretary Associate Specialist, River, Delta and Coastal India Ministry of Water Resources, Morphology Division Government of Bangladesh Center for Environmental and Geographic Vasudha Pangare Bangladesh Information Services (CEGIS) Gender, Agriculture and Livelihoods Specialist Bangladesh Bangkok Thailand 404 405 THE RESTLESS RIVER References 2. FLOW-The River's Journey 1. Based on recent remote sensing studies on the origin of the river the length and area have been revised. 2. Jain, S. K., Agarwal, P. K. and V. P. Singh. (2007) Hydrology and Water Resources of India. Springer. Pp 419- 472. 3. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. Saikia. (2014) Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 4. Sharma, J. N. (2004) An Overview of the Brahmaputra river system. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Springer Science & Business Media. Pp 17-23. 5. Immerzeel, W. (2008) Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra basin, International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. DOI: 10.1002/joc.1528 6. An antecedent river is one whose path of flow was established before the mountainous structure was uplifted. 7. A geological epoch (subdivision of the geologic timescale) that lasted from about 56 to 33.9 million years ago. 8. USGS. (2015) The Himalayas: Two continents collide. [online] United States Geological Survey. URL: https:// pubs.usgs.gov/publications/text/himalaya.html 9. Manish, K. and M. K. Pandit. (2018) Geophysical upheavals and evolutionary diversification of plant species in the Himalaya. PeerJ. 2018; 6: e5919. doi: 10.7717/peerj.5919 10. Lang, K. and K. Huntington. (2014) Antecedence of the Yarlung–Siang–Brahmaputra River, eastern Himalaya. Earth and Planetary Science Letters. 397. 145–158. 10.1016/j.epsl.2014.04.026. 11. Rudra, K. (2018) Rivers of the Ganga-Brahmaputra-Meghna Delta: A Fluvial Account of Bengal. Springer. p. 27 12. Goswami, D.C. and Das, P.J. (2003) The Brahmaputra river, India: the eco-hydrological context of water use in one of world’s most unique river systems, Ecologist Asia 11 (1): 9-11 URL: http://nealliance.net/wp- content/uploads/2010/10/NE-Dams.-Ecologist-Vol-11-No1.pdf 13. Purkait, B. (2004) Hydrogeology. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 113-138. 14. Sharma, J. N. (2004) An Overview of the Brahmaputra river system. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 72-87 15. Ibid 16. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. Saikia. (2014) Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh 17. Sharma, J. N. (2004) An Overview of the Brahmaputra river system. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 72-87 18. Ibid 19. Goyal, M. K., Gupta, S., Sarma, A. and D. Singh. (2018). Subansiri: Largest Tributary of Brahmaputra River, Northeast India. In The Indian Rivers. Springer Hydrogeology. pp.523-535. DOI: 10.1007/978-981-10-2984- 4_36 20. NEC (2016), National Integrated Water Resources Management Plan, National Environment Commission, Royal Government of Bhutan 21. Ibid 22. ADB/NEC (2016), Water: Securing Bhutan’s Future, Asian Development Bank/National Environment Commission Royal Government of Bhutan, Thimphu, Bhutan, ISBN: 978-99936-865-3-8 406 407 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 23. The Dooars or Duars are the alluvial floodplains that lie south of the outer foothills of the Himalayas and 48. B. Nishat and S M Rahman. (2009) Water Resources Modeling of the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna north of the Brahmaputra Valley. This region stretches from the Teesta River in West Bengal to the Dhansiri River Basins using Satellite Remote Sensing Data” In Journal of American Water Resources Association in River in Assam. ‘Satellites and Transboundary Water’ Volume 45, Issue 6 December, 2009 24. ADB/NEC (2016), Water: Securing Bhutan’s Future, Asian Development Bank/National Environment 49. Model developed by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) Commission Royal Government of Bhutan, Thimphu, Bhutan, ISBN: 978-99936-865-3-8 50. Map has been developed from model calculations by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information 25. Nishat, B., Chakraborty, S. K., Hasan, E. and A. J. M. Z. Rahman. (2014) Rivers Beyond Borders. India- Services (CEGIS) Bangladesh Transboundary River Atlas. Ecosystems for Life: A Bangladesh-India Initiative. International 51. Based on observed data and model calculations by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Dhaka, Bangladesh Services (CEGIS). 26. Ibid 52. Sharma, J. N. (2004) An Overview of the Brahmaputra river system. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water 27. Ibid Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 72-87 28. Ibid 53. Cumec = cubic meters per second (m3/second) 29. Ibid 54. ​Tian F. , Xu R. , Nan Y. , Li K. , He Z. . (2020) Quantification of runoff components in the Yarlung Tsangpo River 30. Pervez M. S. and M. H. Geoffrey. (2015) Assessing the impacts of climate and land use and land cover change using a distributed hydrological model. Advances in Water Science, 31(3): 324-336. on the freshwater availability in the Brahmaputra River basin. Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies 3:285- 55. Barthakur, M. (2004) Weather and Climate. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., 311. Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 17-23. 31. Immerzeel, W. (2008) Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra 56. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. basin, Int. J. Climatol., 28, 243–254, 2008. Saikia. 2014. Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of 32. Hasson S., Lucarini V. and P. Salvatore. (2013) Hydrological cycle over South and Southeast Asian river Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh. basins as simulated by PCMDI/CMIP3 experiments. Earth System Dynamics 4(2): 199-217. 57. Ibid 33. Kumar, G. A., Immerzeel, W. W., Sperna W. F. C., and M. F. P. Bierkens. (2011) Impact of climate change on 58. Barthakur, M. (2004) Weather and Climate. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., the stream flow of the lower Brahmaputra: trends in high and low flows based on discharge-weighted Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 17-23. ensemble modelling. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 15(5): 1537-1545. 59. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. 34. Immerzeel, W. (2008) Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra Saikia. 2014. Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of basin, International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. DOI: 10.1002/joc.1528 Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh, Pp xii + 74 35. Lupker M., Lavé J., France-Lanord C., Christl M., Bourlès D., Carcaillet J., Maden C., Wieler R., Rahman M., 60. Jain, S. K., Agarwal, P. K. and V. P. Singh. 2007. Hydrology and Water Resources of India. Springer. Pp 419-472. and D. Bezbaruah (2017) Be systematics in the Tsangpo-Brahmaputra catchment: the cosmogenic nuclide 61. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. legacy of the eastern Himalayan syntaxis. Earth Surface Dynamics 5(3): 429-449. Saikia. 2014. Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of 36. Fu C. and J. O. Fletcher Joseph. (1985) The relationship between Tibet-tropical ocean thermal contrast and Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh interannual variability of Indian monsoon rainfall. Journal of climate and applied meteorology. 24(8): 841- 62. Ibid 847. 63. Purkait, B. (2004) Hydrogeology. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and 37. Sharma, J. N. (2004) An Overview of the Brahmaputra river system. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 113-138. Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 72-87 64. NCHM. (2020) Hydrological Extreme Events of Bhutan. National Center for Hydrology and Meteorology 38. BWDB. (2015) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) (Draft Final) Volume I (Main Text) River Bank (NCHM), Royal Government of Bhutan Accessed from https://www.nchm.gov.bt/ on 15 June 2020. Improvement Program (RBIP). Bangladesh Water Development Board. Ministry of Water Resources. 65. Joint River Commission, Bangladesh 39. Brun F., Berthier E., Wagnon P., Kääb A., and D. Treichler. (2017) A spatially resolved estimate of High 66. Ibid Mountain Asia glacier mass balances from 2000 to 2016. Nature geoscience 10(9): 668. 67. NEC (2016), National Integrated Water Resources Management Plan, National Environment Commission, 40. Shrestha A. B., Agrawal N. K., Alfthan B., Bajracharya S. R., Maréchal J. and B. van Oort. (2015) The Himalayan Royal Government of Bhutan. Climate and Water Atlas: impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. 68. Bhutan Water Fact 2018, Ugyen Wangchuck Institute for Conservation and Environmental Research Available online: https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/FullTextPDF/2016/20163337389.pdf (UWICER), Department of Forests and Park Services, Ministry of Agriculture and Forests, Royal Government 41. Shrestha A. B., Agrawal N. K., Alfthan B., Bajracharya S. R., Maréchal J. and Oort B van. (2015) The Himalayan of Bhutan, Bumthang and WWF Bhutan Programme Office, Thimphu Climate and Water Atlas: impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. 69. Chhopel GK, Dulal IR, Chhophel K, Wangchuk C, Rinzin U, Dupchu K, Kunzang, Tse-ring K, Tshethar K, Dorji Available online: https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/FullTextPDF/2016/20163337389.pdf. U, Wangchuk T, Lhamo T, Nidup J (2011) Securing the Natural Freshwater Systems of the Bhutan Himalayas: 42. Mahanta, C., Zaman, A. M., Newaz, S. M. S., Rahman, S. M., Mazumdar, T. K., Choudhury, R., Borah, P. J. and L. climate Change and Adaptation measures on Water Resources in Bhutan. A climate summit for a living Saikia. (2014) Physical Assessment of the Brahmaputra River. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Himalaya. Available from http://sa.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/Water_Paper_Bhutan.pdf Nature, Dhaka, Bangladesh, Pp xii + 74 70. Datta B., Singh V.P. (2004) Hydrology. In: Singh V.P., Sharma N., Ojha C.S.P. (eds) The Brahmaputra Basin 43. Ibid Water Resources. Water Science and Technology Library, vol 47. Springer, Dordrecht 44. Based on data between 1977 and 2006. Data source: National Water Resources Database, Bangladesh. 71. Yasuda, Y., Aich, D., Hill, D., Huntjens, P., Swain, A. (2017), Transboundary Water Cooperation over the Analysis by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) Brahmaputra River: Legal Political Economy Analysis of Current and Future Potential Cooperation. The 45. Liu, X.C. and Xiao, C.D. Preliminary study of the Jiemayangzong Glacier and lake variations in the source Hague Institute for Global Justice. regions of the Yarlung Zangbo River in 1974-2010. (2011) Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology. 2011, 72. Datta B., Singh V.P. (2004) Hydrology. In: Singh V.P., Sharma N., Ojha C.S.P. (eds) The Brahmaputra Basin 33(3), 488-496. Water Resources. Water Science and Technology Library, vol 47. Springer, Dordrecht 46. Ibid 73. BWDB. (2014). Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) of River Bank Improvement Program (RBIP). 47. B. Datta and V. P. Singh. (2004) Hydrology. In The Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. Eds Singh, V. P., Bangladesh Water Development Board. Ministry of Water Resources Sharma, N. and C. S. P. Ojha. Kluwer Acedemic Publishers. pp 72-87 74. Ibid 408 409 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 75. Ibid 96. Dobler, A., Yaoming, M., Sharma, N., Kienberger, S., & Ahrens, B. (2011). Regional climate projections in two 76. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan alpine river basins: Upper Danube and Upper Brahmaputra. Advances in Science and Research, 7, 11-20. Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. doi:10.5194/asr-7-11-2011 ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO 97. Wijngaard, R, R., Lutz, A.F., Nepal, S., Khanal, S., Pradhananga, S., Shrestha, A.B., Immerzeel, W.W. (2017). 77. Ibid Future changes in hydro-climatic extremes in the Upper Indus, Ganges, and Brahmaputra River basins. 78. Immerzeel, W. (2008). Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra PLoS ONE 12(12): basin. International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. doi:10.1002/joc.1528. 98. Lutz, A.F., Maat, H. W.ter., Wijngaard, R.R., Biemans, H., Syed, A., Shrestha, A.B., Wester, P., Immerzeel, W. 79. Flu¨gel, W.-A., Pechstedt, J., Bongartz, K., Bartosch, A., Eriksson, M., & Clark, M. (2008). Analysis of climate (2019). South Asian river basins in a 1.50C warmer world. Regional Environmental Change, 19, 833-847. change trend and possible impacts in the Upper Brahmaputra River Basin – the BRAHMATWINN Project. 13th https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-018-1433-4 IWRA World Water Congress 2008, Montpelier, France. 99. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan 80. Apurv, T., Mehrotra, R., Sharma, A., Goyal, M.K., Dutta, S. (2015). Impact of climate change on floods in Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. the Brahmaputra basin using CMIP5 decadal predictions. Journal of Hydrology, 527, 281-291. http://dx.doi. ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.04.056 100. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent increase in High Asia’s runoff 81. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 10.1038/nclimate2237 Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. 101. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. 82. A Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) is a greenhouse gas concentration (not emissions) trajectory ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO adopted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). The RCPs are consistent with a wide 102. Immerzeel, W. (2008). Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra range of possible changes in future anthropogenic (i.e., human) GHG emissions, and aim to represent their basin. International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. doi:10.1002/joc.1528.; Immerzeel, W. W., van Beek, atmospheric concentrations. L. P. H., & Bierkens, M. F. P. (2010). Climate change will affect the Asian water towers. Science, 328, 1382–1385. 83. A Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) is a greenhouse gas concentration (not emissions) doi:10.1126/science.1183188 trajectory adopted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).. 103. Apurv, T., Mehrotra, R., Sharma, A., Goyal, M.K., Dutta, S. (2015). Impact of climate change on floods in 84. Pervez, M. S., & Henebry, G. M. (2014). Projections of the Ganges–Brahmaputra precipitation— Downscaled the Brahmaputra basin using CMIP5 decadal predictions. Journal of Hydrology, 527, 281-291. http://dx.doi. from GCM predictors. Journal of Hydrology, 517, 120–134. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol. 2014.05.016 org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.04.056 85. Wijngaard, R, R., Lutz, A.F., Nepal, S., Khanal, S., Pradhananga, S., Shrestha, A.B., Immerzeel, W.W. (2017). 104. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan Future changes in hydro-climatic extremes in the Upper Indus, Ganges, and Brahmaputra River basins. Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. PLoS ONE 12(12): e0190224. https://doi. org/10.1371/journal.pone.0190224 ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO 86. Lutz, A.F., Maat, H. W.ter., Wijngaard, R.R., Biemans, H., Syed, A., Shrestha, A.B., Wester, P., Immerzeel, W. 105. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent increase in High Asia’s runoff (2019). South Asian river basins in a 1.50C warmer world. Regional Environmental Change, 19, 833-847. due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 10.1038/nclimate2237 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-018-1433-4 106. Gain, A. K., Immerzeel, W. W., Sperna Weiland, F. C., & Bierkens, M. F. P. (2011). Impact of climate change on 87. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent increase in High Asia’s runoff the stream flow of the lower Brahmaputra: trends in high and low flows based on discharge-weighted due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 10.1038/nclimate2237 ensemble modelling. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 15, 1537–1545. doi:10.5194/hess-15-1537-2011. 88. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan 107. Immerzeel, W. (2008). Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. basin. International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. doi:10.1002/joc.1528. ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO 108. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent increase in High Asia’s runoff 89. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 10.1038/nclimate2237 Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. 109. Lutz, A.F., Maat, H. W.ter., Wijngaard, R.R., Biemans, H., Syed, A., Shrestha, A.B., Wester, P., Immerzeel, W. ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO (2019). South Asian river basins in a 1.50C warmer world. Regional Environmental Change, 19, 833-847. 90. Immerzeel, W. (2008). Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-018-1433-4 basin. International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. doi:10.1002/joc.1528. 110. Ghosh, S., & Dutta, S. (2012). Impact of climate change on flood characteristics in Brahmaputra basin using 91. Flu¨gel, W.-A., Pechstedt, J., Bongartz, K., Bartosch, A., Eriksson, M., & Clark, M. (2008). Analysis of climate a macro-scale distributed hydrological model. Journal of Earth System Science, 121, 637–657. doi:10.1007/ change trend and possible impacts in the Upper Brahmaputra River Basin – the BRAHMATWINN Project. 13th s12040-012-0181-y. IWRA World Water Congress 2008, Montpelier, France. 111. Wijngaard, R, R., Lutz, A.F., Nepal, S., Khanal, S., Pradhananga, S., Shrestha, A.B., Immerzeel, W.W. (2017). 92. Shrestha, AB; Agrawal, NK; Alfthan, B; Bajracharya, SR; Maréchal, J; van Oort, B (eds). (2015). The Himalayan Future changes in hydro-climatic extremes in the Upper Indus, Ganges, and Brahmaputra River basins. Climate and Water Atlas: Impact of climate change on water resources in five of Asia’s major river basins. PLoS ONE 12(12): e0190224. https://doi. org/10.1371/journal.pone.0190224 ICIMOD, GRID-Arendal and CICERO 112. Immerzeel, W. W., van Beek, L. P. H., & Bierkens, M. F. P. (2010). Climate change will affect the Asian water 93. Immerzeel, W. (2008). Historical trends and future predictions of climate variability in the Brahmaputra towers. Science, 328, 1382–1385. doi:10.1126/science.1183188 basin. International Journal of Climatology, 28, 243–254. doi:10.1002/joc.1528. 113. Prasch, M., Marke, T., Strasser, U., & Mauser, W. (2011). Large scale integrated hydrological modelling of the 94. In previous IPCC assessments, the most widely used and referred-to family of emissions scenarios were impact of climate change on the water balance with DANUBIA. Advances in Science and Research, 7, 61–70. the SRES scenarios (Special Report on Emissions Scenarios). These scenarios were based on future doi:10.5194/asr-7-61-2011 global population growth, technological development, globalization, and societal values. RCP scenarios 114. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent increase in High Asia’s runoff supersedes SRES scenarios from 2014). due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 10.1038/nclimate2237.; Lutz, 95. The SRES scenarios (Special Report on Emissions Scenarios) are based on future global population growth, A.F., Maat, H. W.ter., Wijngaard, R.R., Biemans, H., Syed, A., Shrestha, A.B., Wester, P., Immerzeel, W. (2019). technological development, globalization, and societal values. South Asian river basins in a 1.50C warmer world. Regional Environmental Change, 19, 833-847. https://doi. org/10.1007/s10113-018-1433-4 410 411 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 115. Nepal, S., & Shrestha, A. B. (2015). Impact of climate change on the hydrological regime of the Indus, 140. Ibid Ganges and Brahmaputra river basins: a review of the literature. International Journal of Water Resources 141. Sarkar, A., Garg, R. and N. Sharma. (2012) RS-GIS Based Assessment of River Dynamics of Brahmaputra River in Development, 31(2), 201-218. Lutz, A.F., Immerzeel, W.W., Shrestha, A.B., Bierkends, M.F.P. (2014). Consistent India. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, Vol. 4 No. 2, 2012, pp. 63-72. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2012.42008. increase in High Asia’s runoff due to increasing glacier melt and precipitation. Nature climate change. DOI: 142. Bristow, C.S. (1987) Brahmaputra River: Channel migration and deposition. In: Recent Developments in 10.1038/nclimate2237 Fluvial Sedimentology. Ed. by F.G. Ethridge, R.M. Flores and M.D. Harvey. Spec. Publ. Soc. Econ. Paleont. 116. Nandargi, S.S., (2020) An invited article on ‘Floods in Indian Rivers and their Meteorological Aspects’, Volume Miner.,39, 63±74. IV of the ‘Environmental History of India’ of Indian Council of Historical Research (ICH) 143. Lahiri, S. K. and R. Sinha. (2012) Tectonic controls on the morph dynamics of the Brahmaputra River system in 117. http://asdma.gov.in/pdf/asdmp.pdf the upper Assam valley, India. Geomorphology, Volume 169, p. 74-85. DOI: 10.1016/j.geomorph.2012.04.012 118. http://asdma.gov.in/pdf/asdmp.pdf 144. Sarma, J. N. and S. Acharjee. (2018) A Study on Variation in Channel Width and Braiding Intensity of the 119. https://www.villagesquare.in/2017/09/06/riverbank-erosion-no-less-disaster-assam-floods/ Brahmaputra River in Assam, India. Geosciences 2018, 8(9), 343; https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences8090343 120. https://www.villagesquare.in/2017/09/06/riverbank-erosion-no-less-disaster-assam-floods/ 145. Chatterjee, S., Scotese, C. R. and S. Bajpai. (2017) Indian Plate and Its Epic Voyage from Gondwana to Asia: 121. Mukherjee, N., and Khan, M. F. (2009) Factoring Climate Change Considerations in the Design of Padma Its Tectonic, Paleoclimatic, and Paleobiogeographic Evolution. Geological Society of America. p. 120. Multipurpose Bridge. Consultancy Report Prepared by the Centre for Environmental and Geographic 146. Sarkar, A., Garg, R. and N. Sharma. (2012) RS-GIS Based Assessment of River Dynamics of Brahmaputra River in Information Services (CEGIS). Bangladesh Bridge Authority, Dhaka. India. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, Vol. 4 No. 2, 2012, pp. 63-72. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2012.42008. 122. Ibid 147. Gilfellon, G, Sarma, J and K Gohain. (2003). Channel and Bed Morphology of a Part of the Brahmaputra River 123. Analysis by Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS) based on satellite in Assam. Journal of the Geological Society of India. 62. images 148. RTI and Expert Committee. 2018. Framework for Proper Planning & Management of Water Resources 124. Hossain, A.N.H.A. (2006) The Impact of Floods on Bangladesh and Options for Mitigation an Overview, in North East India. Report of the Expert Committee for Suggesting Immediate Measures for Proper In Siddiqui, K. and Hossain, A.N.H. ed. Options for Flood Risk and Damage Reduction in Bangladesh, The Management of Water Resources in North Eastern India University Press Limited, Dhaka, p.60 149. Richardson, W. R. and C. R. Thorne. (2000) Multiple Thread Flow and Flow Channel Bifurcation in a Braided 125. ReliefWeb. (2017) Monsoon Floods in Bangladesh - Situation Report 02 (16 August 2017) River: Brahmaputra -Jamuna River, Bangladesh. Geomorphology 38 (2000): 185- 96. 126. Char is the local name in Bangladesh and India for river island or shoal; a tract of land created by sediment 150. Sarkar, A., Garg, R. and N. Sharma. (2012) RS-GIS Based Assessment of River Dynamics of Brahmaputra River in accretion surrounded by the sea, estuary, or river. India, Journal of Water Resource and Protection, Vol. 4 No. 2, 2012, pp. 63-72. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2012.42008. 127. Nishat, A., Nishat B. and M. F. A. Khan. (2011) A Strategic View of Land Management Planning in Bangladesh. 151. Fischer, S., Pietroń, J., Bring, A. Thorslund, J. and J Jarsjo. (2017) Present to future sediment transport of the In Flood Risk Science and Management. Eds Pender G. and H. Faulkner. Blackwell Publishers Ltd. Brahmaputra River: reducing uncertainty in predictions and management. Reg Environ Change 17, 515–526 128. Concern Worldwide. 2019. Floods in Bangladesh cause devastation. Available at https://www.concernusa. (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-016-1039-7. org/story/floods-bangladesh/ 152. Stewart, R. J., Hallet, B., Zeitler, P.K., Malloy, M.A., Allen, C.M. and D. Trippett. (2008) Brahmaputra sediment 129. Saha, M.K. (2013) Environmental and social impact of flood control, drainage and irrigation projects: is it a flux dominated by highly localized rapid erosion from the easternmost Himalaya. Geology, September development disaster for Bangladesh??? In Planned decentralization: aspired development, pp. 78–85. World 2008; v. 36; no. 9; p. 711–714; doi: 10.1130/G24890A Town Planning Day 2013. (available at http://www.bip.org.bd/SharingFiles/journal_book/20140128163854. 153. Sarker, M. and C. Thorne. (2006) Morphological Response of the Brahmaputra–Padma–Lower Meghna River pdf.) System to the Assam Earthquake of 1950. Braided Rivers: Process, Deposits, Ecology and Management. 130. Neil Noble and Dipok Chandra Roy. (2011) Flood-resistant Housing, Technical Brief. Practical Action. 289-310. 10.1002/9781444304374.ch14. Available at http://practicalaction.org/flood-resistant_housing 154. BWDB. (2015) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) (Draft Final) Volume I (Main Text) River Bank 131. Wahra, G. N. (2011) Bangladesh Disaster Report 2011. Disaster Forum and Disaster Management Bureau, Improvement Program (RBIP). Bangladesh Water Development Board. Ministry of Water Resources. pp.12-32 155. Sarker, M. H., Huque, I. and M. Alam. (2003) Rivers, chars and char dwellers of Bangladesh. International 132. Islam, M. S., Sultana, S, Saifunnar and M. A. Miah. (2014) Adaptation of Char Livelihood in Flood and River Journal of River Basin Management Vol. 1, No. 1 (2003), pp. 61–80 Erosion Areas through Indigenous Practice: A Study on Bhuapur Riverine Area in Tangail. Journal of Environ. 156. BWDB. (2014) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) of River Bank Improvement Program (RBIP). Sci. & Natural Resources, 7(1): 13-19. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3329/jesnr.v7i1.22138 Bangladesh Water Development Board. Ministry of Water Resources 133. Maminul Haque Sarker, M. H., Huque, I. and M. Alam. (2003) Rivers, chars and char dwellers of Bangladesh. 157. Chakrapani, G. J. (2005) Factors controlling variations in river sediment loads. Current Science, Vol. 88, No. International Journal of River Basin Management Vol. 1, No. 1 (2003), pp. 61–80. 4, 25 February 2005 134. The channel planform is the view or outline of a river seen from directly above. Different types of river 158. Rahman, M., Dustegir, M., Karim, R., and Haque, A., Nicholls, R. J., Darby, S. E., Nakagawa, H., Hossain, M., channel planform include meandering, straight, braided and braided meanders. Dunn, F. E. and M. Akter (2018) “Recent sediment flux to the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna delta system,” 135. Avulsion refers to a change in channel alignment was achieved by an abandonment of one course and Science of the Total Environment, 643 (2018) 1054–1064 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.06.147. adoption of a new one some distance away rather than by progressive shifting 159. Sarker, M. H., Huque, I. and M. Alam. (2003) Rivers, chars and char dwellers of Bangladesh. International 136. Major James Rennell, (b. 3 December 1742; d. 29 March 1830) was an English geographer, historian and a Journal of River Basin Management Vol. 1, No. 1 (2003), pp. 61–80. pioneer in oceanography. He is also known as the father of Indian geography. Rennell’s survey of Bengal, 160. Sarker, M. H., Akter, J., and Rahman, M. M.,(2013). “Century-Scale Dynamics of the Bengal Delta and Future which was commenced in 1764, was the first ever prepared and still used as reference for many studies. Development.” 4th International Conference on Water & Flood Management (ICWFM), 2013. 137. Rudra, K. (2018) Rivers of the Ganga-Brahmaputra-Meghna Delta: A Fluvial Account of Bengal. Springer. p. 161. Ibid 27 162. Coleman, J. M. (1969) Brahmaputra river: Channel processes and sedimentation. Sedimentary Geology 138. Alam, J. B., Uddin, M., Ahmed, J. U., Cacovean, H., Rahman, H., Banik, B. K. and N. Yesmin.(2007) Study of Volume 3, Issues 2–3, August 1969, Pages 129-239 morphological change of river old Brahmaputra and its social impacts by remote sensing. GeographiaTechnica, no.2, 2007. URL: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/637c/14b977ae407f0593976b5cc936a2c9f52511.pdf 139. Borgohain, S., Das, J., Saraf, A. K., Singh, G. and S. S. Baral. (2007) Morphodynamic changes of Lohit River, d NE India: GIS-based study. Geographia Technical, no.2, 2007. URL: https://www.currentscience.ac.in/ Volumes/110/09/1810.pdf 412 413 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 23. Rahmani, A.R. and A. Choudhury. 2012. Threatened Birds of India: Their Conservation Requirements. Indian 3. LIFE-Biodiversity of the Region Bird Conservation Network: Bombay Natural History Society, Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and BirdLife International. Oxford University Press. Pp xvi + 864. 24. Ibid; Rahmani, A. R. 2017. Conservation of threatened grassland birds of the Brahmaputra Floodplains. Final 1. Wang, L., Wang, Z., & Liu, X. (2018). Water Resources Carrying Capacity Analysis of YarLung Tsangpo River Report submitted to Bombay Natural History Society. Pp 1-66. Basin (I). Water 10(9), 1131. 25. Choudhury AU. 2015. Conservation of Status of threatened waterbirds in north–east India. In: Gopi GV. & 2. ibid Hussain SA. (Eds.), Waterbirds of India, ENVIS Bulletin: Wildlife and Protected Areas. Vol. 16; Wildlife Institute 3. Smith Andrew T., Foggin Marc J. 1999. The plateau pika (Ochotona curzoniae) is a keystone species for of India, Dehradun–248001, India. biodiversity on the Tibetan plateau. Animal Conservation. ZSL publications.: 235-240. 26. Rahmani AR. Islam MZ. & Kasambe RM. 2016. Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas in India: Priority Sites for 4. Paltridge, N., Jin, T., Unkovich, M., Bonamano, A., Gason, A., Grover, S., Wilkins, J. Tashi, N., & Coventry, D. Conservation (Revised and updated). Bombay Natural History Society, Indian Bird Conservation Network, (2009). Agriculture in central Tibet: an assessment of climate, farming systems, and strategies to boost Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and BirdLife International (U.K.): pp. 1992+xii. production. Crop and Pasture Science 60(7): 627-639 https://doi.org/10.1071/CP08372 27. Choudhury AU. 2015. Conservation of Status of threatened waterbirds in north–east India. In: Gopi GV. & 5. Duan, C., Shi, P., Zong, N., Wang, J., Song, M., & Zhang, X. (2019). Feeding solution: Crop-livestock integration Hussain SA. (Eds.), Waterbirds of India, ENVIS Bulletin: Wildlife and Protected Areas. Vol. 16; Wildlife Institute via crop-forage rotation in the southern Tibetan Plateau. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 284, 106589. of India, Dehradun–248001, India. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2019.106589 28. Alam, F., Alam, Q., Rezac, S., Khurshid-ul-Alamc, S.M., Salequeb, K. and Chowdhury, H. 2017. Sourcing green 6. Li, X., Bleisch, W., Liu, X., & Jiang, X. (2020). Camera-trap surveys reveal high diversity of mammals and power in Bhutan: A review. Energy Procedia, 110:586 – 591. pheasants in Medog, Tibet. Oryx, 1-4. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605319001467 29. Bajrachary, S.R., Maharjan, S.B. and Shrestha, F. 2014. The status and decadal change of glaciers in Bhutan 7. Shen Weishou. 1997. Classification and sorting of the psammophytic vegetation in the middle Yarlung from the 1980s to 2010 based on satellite data. Annals of Glaciology, 55(66):159-166. Zangbo river basin, Tibet. Journal of Desert Research, 17, 269-273. (in Chinese); Huai Huyin. 1997. 30. UWICER. 2018. Relationship between land-use management and hydropower development in Bhutan. Characteristics of Alpine Shrubs on Qinghai-Xizang Plateau. Journal of Gansu Sciences, 9(4): 23-25. Ugyen Wangchuck Institute for Conservation and Environmental Research, Department of Forests and Park 8. Li Hui. 2000. Biological resources and their characteristics in the Yarlung Zangbo river canyon. Tibet science Services - Royal Government of Bhutan. UWICER Press. and technology, (3): 77-78. (in Chinese) 31. NRCR&LF. 2017. Field Guide to Fishes of western Bhutan. National Research Centre for Riverine and Lake 9. He Ping, Guo Ke, Gao Jixi, et al. 2005. Vegetation Types and Their Geographic Distribution in the Source Area Fisheries of the Department of Livestock of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forests of the Yarlung Zangbo. Journal of Mountain Science, 23(3): 267-273. (In Chinese); Chen Bin, Li Haidong, Cao 32. DoFPS. 2015. Protected areas of Bhutan. National Parks, Wildlife Sanctuaries, Strict Nature Reserve, and Xuezhang, et al. 2015. Vegetation pattern and spatial distribution of NDVI in the Yarlung Zangbo River Basin Biological Corridors. Department of Forest and Park Services, Thimphu Bhutan. of China. Journal of desert research, 35(1):120-128. (in Chinese) 33. Tashi, T. 2013. The Brown Trout. Kuensel, January 12, 2013. 10. Zhang Jian, Tan Jiali, Deng Lilan. et al. 2008. Investigation and Assessment of the Terrestrial Vegetation in 34. Everard, M., Pinder, A.C., Raghavan, R. and Kataria, G. 2019. Are well‐intended Buddhist practices an under‐ the Middle Reaches of the Yarlung Zangbo River in Tibet. Forest Resources Management (4):118-123. (In appreciated threat to global aquatic biodiversity? Aquatic Conserv: Mar Freshw Ecosyst, 1–6.   https://doi. Chinese) org/10.1002/aqc.2997 11. Qiong La, Zhaxi Ciren, Zhu Weidong, et al. 2014. Plant species-richness and association with environmental 35. Gurung, D.B., Dorji, S., Tshering, U. and Wangyal, J.T. 2013. An annotated checklist of fishes from Bhutan. factors in the riparian zone of the Yarlung Zangbo River of Tibet, China. Biodiversity Science, 22(3): 337-347. Journal of Threatened Taxa, 5(14): 4880–4886 12. Yang, L., Li, J. and Tsamchu Drolma. 2016. Number and distribution of wintering black-necked crane (Grus 36. Ibid nigricollis) in drainage area of Yarlung-Zangbo River and its two branches from Tibet, China. Journal of 37. Waiba, T.N. 2018. Environment Friendly and Better Farm Roads: An Urgent Necessity in Bhutan. UWICER, Northeast Forestry University 44(5), 70-72, 83. Lamaigonpa, Bhutan. 13. Yan, R., Shen, W., Zhao, W. and Ouyang, Y. 2018. Dynamics of suitability and conservation of the black-necked 38. Galay, K. 2008. Socio-economic and Environmental Impact Analysis of Khothagpa Gypsum Mine. Journal of crane habitats in the midstream of the Yarlung-Zangbo River. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment. Bhutan Studies, 18:51-81. 34(2), 146-152. 39. Gurung, D.B. and Thoni, R.J. 2015. Fishes of Bhutan, A preliminary checklist. Centre for Rural Development, 14. Hu, G., Du, X., Cheng, L., Ji, F., Mou, Z., Ma, B., Li, L. and Jin, X. 2019. Current situation, major problems and College of Natural Resources, Lobesa, Bhutan. countermeasures of fishery resources in Xizang Autonomous Region. Chinese Journal of Fisheries. 32(3): 40. Marchese, C. 2015. Biodiversity hotspots: A shortcut for a more complicated concept.  Global Ecology and 58-64 (in Chinese). Conservation,  3.: 297-309.; Mittermeier, R. A., Turner, W. R., Larsen, F. W., Brooks, T. M., & Gascon, C. 2011. 15. Boruah, S. Biswas, S.P. 2002. Ecohydrology and fisheries of the Upper Brahmaputra basin. The Environmentalist, Global biodiversity conservation: the critical role of hotspots. In  Biodiversity hotspots. Springer, Berlin, 22(2):119-131 Heidelberg: 3-22. 16. Poff, N.L. & J.V. Ward. 1989. Implications of stream flow variability and predictability for lotic community 41. Acharya, B. K., & Vijayan, L. 2011. The birds of Sikkim: an analysis of elevational distribution, endemism and structure: a regional analysis of stream flow patterns. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, threats. In Biodiversity of Sikkim Exploring and Conserving a Global Hotspot. IPR Department, Government of 46:1805–1818 Sikkim, Gangtok.: 255-282. 17. Tripathi, S.D. 1984. Integrated fish-crop-livestock production in India. Working paper of the 6th-session of 42. Praveen, J., Jayapal, R., & Pittie, A. 2019. Updates to the checklists of birds of India, and the South Asian the IPFC Working Party of Experts on Aquaculture. FAO, Rome. region—2019. Indian BIRDS, 15(1).: 1-9. 18. Saikia, A.K., S. K. Abujam, D.N. Das & S.P. Biswas. 2015. Economics of paddy cum fish culture: A case study in 43. Ali, S. 1962. The Birds of Sikkim. Oxford University Press, New Delhi. Sivsagar, Assam. International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies, 2(5): 198-203 44. IUCN 2020. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2020-1. https://www.iucnredlist.org. 19. Ferdous, M.J, Karim, M.R., Hossain, M. A., Rahman, M. A. & M.M. Iqbal. 2015. Fin fish assemblage and Downloaded on 23 June 2020. biodiversity status of carps on Halda river, Bangladesh. Annals of Veterinary and Animal Science, 2(6):151-161 45. Sharma, P. 2004. Wetlands and their Role in the Geo-Ecological Environment. In N. S. Vijay P. Singh, The 20. Grimmett, R., C. Inskipp and T. Inskipp. 1999. Pocket Guide to the Birds of the Indian Subcontinent. Oxford Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources (pp. 366-375). Springer-Science and Business Media, B.V. and Kluwer University Press, New Delhi. 384pp. Academic Publishers. 21. Stattersfield, A & J., Crosby, M. J., Long, A & Wege, D. C. 1998. Endemic bird areas of the world: priorities for 46. Biswas, D. A. 2011. Bangladesher Nodikosh. Dhaka: Bengal Publications. biodiversity conservation. Cambridge, UK: BirdLife International. 22. Choudhury, A.U. 2000. The Birds of Assam. Gibbon Books and World Wide Fund for Nature-India, Guwahati. 414 415 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 47. Wikipedia. Retrieved from www.wikipedia.org: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalan_Beel. Accessed June Forktail 30, 84-89; Kabir, Tarik., Sayam U. Chowdhury, Tareq Onu, A. B. M. Sarwar Alam., Sakib Ahmed, Omar 20,2020. Shahadat and Md. Foysal. 2016. New breeding record of riverine birds in Bangladesh. BirdingAsia 26: 39-42. 48. Mostafa A. R. Hossain, M. N. 2009. The Chalan beel in Bangladesh: Habitat and biodiversity degradation, and 64. Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A survey for Black- implications for future management. Lakes & Reservoirs: Research and Management 2009, 14: 3–19. bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in Bangladesh. 49. ibid Forktail 30, 84-89. 50. S.M. Galib, M. S. June 2009. Present Status of Fishes in the Chalan Beel- the Largest Beel (Wetland) of 65. Banglapedia. 2020. “Madhupur National Park”. . Accessed in June 2020.; Gain, Bangladesh. nternational Journal of Animal and Fisheries Science 2(3), 214-218. P. 1998. The Last Forests of Bangladesh. Society for Environment and Human Development (SEHD), Dhaka, 51. Mostafa A. R. Hossain, M. N. 2009. The Chalan beel in Bangladesh: Habitat and biodiversity degradation, and Bangladesh.;Green, M.J.B. 1990. IUCN directory: South Asian Protected Areas. Cambridge, UK.; Khan, implications for future management. Lakes & Reservoirs: Research and Management 2009, 14: 3–19. M.M.H. 2008. Protected Areas of Bangladesh: A Guide to Wildlife. Nishorgo Program, Bangladesh Forest 52. Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A survey for Black- Department, Dhaka, Bangladesh.;Nishat, A., Huq, S.M.I., Barua, S.P., Reza, A.H.M.A., Khan, A.S.M. 2002. Bio- bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in Bangladesh. ecological Zones of Bangladesh. IUCN-Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh. Forktail 30, 84-89,; IUCN Bangladesh. 2015. Red List of Bangladesh Volume 3: Birds. IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Nature, Bangladesh Country Office, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 53. Smith, Brian D., AKM Aminul Haque, M. Shakhawat Hossain, and Anisuzzaman Khan. 1998. River dolphins in d Bangladesh: conservation and the effects of water development. Environmental management 22: 323-335.; Ashworth, Philip J., James L. Best, Julie E. Roden, Charles S. Bristow, and Gerrit J. Klaassen. 2000. Morphological evolution and dynamics of a large, sand braid‐bar, Jamuna River, Bangladesh. Sedimentology 47: 533-555. 54. Wegge, Per, Anil K. Shrestha, and Stein R. Moe. 2006. Dry season diets of sympatric ungulates in lowland 4. GROW-Living off the land Nepal: competition and facilitation in alluvial tall grasslands. Ecological Research 21: 698-706. 55. Personal observation by the author 1. Ray, Patrick A., Yi-Chen E Yang, Sungwook Wi, Abedalrazq Khalil, Vansa Chatikavanij and Casey Brown. 2015. 56. BirdLife International. 2019. IUCN Red List for birds. Available online: http:/www.birdlife.org (accessed on “Room for improvement: Hydroclimatic challenges to poverty-reducing development of the Brahmaputra 14 November 2019); Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A River basin”. Environmental Science & Policy 54: 64–80. survey for Black-bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in The study uses FAO CROPWAT for analysis. FAO CROPWAT is a tool for estimating monthly water use for Bangladesh. Forktail 30, 84-89 each crop in each demand sector. CROPWAT takes as input the crop type, latitude and longitude, and 57. Kabir, Tarik., Sayam U. Chowdhury, Tareq Onu, A. B. M. Sarwar Alam., Sakib Ahmed, Omar Shahadat, and planting date, and outputs an estimate for irrigation water need (total crop water consumption minus Md. Foysal. 2016. New breeding record of riverine birds in Bangladesh. BirdingAsia 26: 39-42.; Chowdhury, effective rainfall). Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A survey for Black-bellied Tern 2. FAO. Pastoralism in the new millennium. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021 http://www.fao.org/3/ Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in Bangladesh. Forktail 30, y2647e/y2647e02.htm#P8_3480 84-89; Ahmed, Sakib, Sayam U. Chowdhury, and Robert Sheldon. 2018. Surveys of River Lapwings Vanellus 3. ibid duvaucelii in Bangladesh and observations on their nesting ecology.”  Wader Study 125(2). doi:10.18194/ 4. Nyima Tashi. Pastoral systems, change and the future of the grazing lands in Tibet. FAO. Accessed June 23, ws.00117. 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.fao.org/3/y4856e/y4856e0d.htm 58. BirdLife International. 2019. IUCN Red List for birds. Available online: http:/www.birdlife.org (accessed on 5. For more information, refer section on shifting cultivation 14 November 2019); Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A 6. FarmingIndia.in. Paddy cultivation guide: Different methods of rice cultivation in India. Accessed June 23, survey for Black-bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in 2020; May 3, 2021. https://www.farmingindia.in/paddy-cultivation/ Bangladesh. Forktail 30, 84-89 7. Pangare Ganesh, Vasudha Pangare and Binayak Das. 2006. Springs of Life. New Delhi. Academic Founda- 59. Kabir, S. M. H., M. Ahmad, A. T. A. Ahmed, A. K. A. Rahman, Z. U. Ahmed, Z. N. T. Begum, M. A. Hassan, and M. tion, World Water Institute, Bharathi Integrated Rural Development Society (BIRDS): Khandker. 2009. Encyclopedia of flora and fauna of Bangladesh Volume 25:  Amphibians and Reptiles. Asiatic 8. ibid Society of Bangladesh, Dhaka. 9. Nyima Tashi. Pastoral systems, change and the future of the grazing lands in Tibet. FAO. Accessed June 23, 60. Dudgeon, D. 2002. An inventory of riverine biodiversity in monsoonal Asia: present status and conservation 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.fao.org/3/y4856e/y4856e0d.htm challenges. Water Science and Technology 45: 11-19. 10. Brown, Colin, Lava Prakash Yadav, Jing Zhang and Deqing Zhouma. 2019. Sustainability of Agricultural 61. BirdLife International. 2019. IUCN Red List for birds. Available online: http:/www.birdlife.org (accessed on Diversity in the Farm Households of Southern Tibet. Sustainability 2019, 11, 5756. 14 November 2019); Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A 11. Planning Commission. Government of India. 2017. Final Report of the Working Group on Agro-climatic survey for Black-bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers Zonal Planning including Agriculture Development in North-Eastern India for XI Five Year Plan (2007- in Bangladesh. Forktail 30, 84-89; Kabir, Tarik., Sayam U. Chowdhury, Tareq Onu, A. B. M. Sarwar Alam., 12). Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://niti.gov.in/planningcommission.gov.in/docs/aboutus/ Sakib Ahmed, Omar Shahadat, and Md. Foysal. 2016. New breeding record of riverine birds in Bangladesh. committee/wrkgrp11/wg11_agrclim.pdf BirdingAsia 26: 39-42; Ahmed, Sakib, Sayam U. Chowdhury, and Robert Sheldon. 2018. Surveys of River 12. ibid Lapwings Vanellus duvaucelii in Bangladesh and observations on their nesting ecology.”  Wader Study 13. Department of Agriculture. Government of Assam. Rashtriya Krishi Vikash Yojana (RKVY). Accessed June 23, 125(2). doi:10.18194/ws.00117. 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.rkvyassam.in/?rain 62. Dudgeon, D. 2002. An inventory of riverine biodiversity in monsoonal Asia: present status and conservation 14. Renewable Natural Resources Statistics Division, Directorate Services, Ministry of Agriculture and Forests challenges.  Water Science and Technology  45: 11-19.; Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Bhutan. RNR Statistics 2017. Royal Government of Bhutan: 49. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http:// Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A survey for Black-bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine www.moaf.gov.bt/bhutan-rnr-statistics-2017-2/ birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in Bangladesh. Forktail 30, 84-89 15. Sharma, Ghanashyam and Lalit Kumar Rai. Climate Change and Sustainability of Agrodiversity in 63. Chowdhury, Sayam U., Mohammad Foysal, John Sharpe, and Omar Shahadat. 2014. A survey for Black- Traditional Farming of the Sikkim Himalaya. n.d. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.sikenvis. bellied Tern Sterna acuticauda and other riverine birds on the Jamuna and Padma rivers in Bangladesh. nic.in/writereaddata/12-Chapter_Climate_Change_and_Sustainability_of_Agrodiversity_in_Traditional_ farming.pdf 416 417 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 43. Government of Assam, Department of Agriculture and Horticulture, Directorate of Agriculture. Accessed 16. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics Division, Ministry of Planning. 2019. Yearbook June 23,2020; May 3, 2021. https://diragri.assam.gov.in of Agricultural Statistics-2018. 30th Series. Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. Dhaka. 44. Ibid. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. www.bbs.gov.bd 45. Government of Assam, Department of Agriculture and Horticulture, Directorate of Agriculture. Accessed 17. A species of Daphne plant used in Tibetan and Chinese and medicine. June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://diragri.assam.gov.in/portlets/irrigation 18. Statistical and crop data in this section is accessed from Tibet Statistic Bureau (2018) Tibet Statistic Yearbook. 46. ibid China Statistic Press. Beijing, China. 47. Government of Assam, Department of Agriculture and Horticulture, Directorate of Agriculture. Accessed 19. Zhang, Geli, Jinwei Dong, Caiping Zhou, Xingliang Xu, Min Wang, Hua Ouyang and Xiangming Xiao. 2013. June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://diragri.assam.gov.in Increasing cropping intensity in response to climate warming in Tibetan Plateau, China. Field Crops Research 48. Mandal, R. 2017. “Assam’s Sorrow – Is there a Way Out?”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. LII, No. 36, pp. 142: 36–46 20-22. 20. Li, Y. 2019. Linzhou County in Tibet to grow over 2.91 km2 organic barley. People.cn. Accessed June 23, 49. Government of Assam. 2017. “Flood and Erosion Problem,” Water Resource Department, Government of 2020. http://xz.people.com.cn/n2/2019/0429/c138901-32892660.html Assam. Accessed on 21 August 2017. 21. Yang, S. and Y. Tang. 2016. Price increase of the Gangba Sheep in Tibet. Xinhua Net. Beijing. China. Accessed 50. Goyari, P. 2005. “Flood Damages and Sustainability of Agriculture in Assam”, Economic & Political Weekly, June 23, 2020. http://xz.people.com.cn/n2/2016/0613/c138901-28498078.html 40(26), pp 2723-29. 22. Wang, L. 2017. Prevention and control measures of agricultural pests in Tibet. South China Agriculture 11(23): 51. Mandal, R. 2010. “Cropping Patterns and Risk Management in the Flood Plains of Assam”, Economic and 24-25 (in Chinese). Political Weekly, Vol. XLV, No. 33, pp. 78-81. 23. Department of Agriculture and Husbandry. 2017. Grassland resources and ecologic statistics. China 52. Mandal, R. 2014. “Flood, cropping pattern choice and returns in agriculture: A study of Assam plains, India”, Agricultural Statistic Press. Beijing, China. Economic Analysis and Policy, Vol. 44, pp. 333-344. 24. Tibet Statistic Bureau. 2018. Tibet Statistic Yearbook. China Statistic Press. Beijing, China 53. Mandal, R. 2014. “Flood, cropping pattern choice and returns in agriculture: A study of Assam plains, India”, 25. Tibet promotes greenhouse technology. 2011. Accessed June 23, 2020. http://www.agronet.com.cn/ Economic Analysis and Policy, Vol. 44, pp. 333-344. Tech/709038.html 54. Refer to Flow chapter 26. Greenhouse technology contributes to poverty reduction. 2019. Accessed on June 23, 2020. http:// 55. ibid xz.people.com.cn/n2/2019/1014/c138901-33432209.html 56. Information for this section has been extracted from Department of Agriculture, Ministry of Agriculture 27. Badr, A. et al. 2000. On the origin and domestication history of barley (Hordeum vulgare). Mol. Biol. Evol. 17, and Forests, Twelfth Five Year Plan, 2018-2023. Royal Government of Bhutan, Thimpu, March 2019. Ac- 499–510. cessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://www.gnhc.gov.bt/en/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/12FYP-Vol- 28. Zeng, X., Y. Guo, and Q. Xu. et al. 2018. Origin and evolution of qingke barley in Tibet. Nature Communications ume-II-Central-Plans.pdf 9: 5433. 57. ibid. 29. Badr, A. et al. 2000. On the origin and domestication history of barley (Hordeum vulgare). Mol. Biol. Evol. 17, 58. Labour Market Information and Research Division, Department of Employment and Human Resources. 499–510. Labour Force Survey Report 2016. Ministry of Labour and Human Resources. Royal Government of Bhutan. 30. Tibet Statistic Bureau. 2018. Tibet Statistic Yearbook. China Statistic Press. Beijing, China. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://www.molhr.gov.bt/molhr/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/La- 31. Zang, J., Kan, J., Chen, Z. and Zhao, G. 2004. Applications of barley and study on its components. China Food bour-Force-Survey-Report-2016.pdf Additives. 4: 43-46. 59. Forest Resources Development Division, Department of Forests and Park Services. 2017. Land Use and 32. Hou, D. and Shen, Q. 2020. Analysis of nutrition and functional components of 29 kinds of highland barley Land Cover 2016. Ministry of Agriculture and Forests, Thimpu. Bhutan. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, in China. Journal of Chinese Institute of Food Science and Technology 20(2): 289-298. (in Chinese) 2021. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335715768_LAND_USE_AND_LAND_COVER_OF_BHU- 33. Jiang, C., Yan, D., Tan, J., Feng, Z. and Yu, N. 2010. Research and application status of barley. Tibetan TAN_2016_MAPS_AND_STATISTICS Technology. 2: 14-16 (in Chinese). 60. 2017 Population and Housing Census of Bhutan, Monggar Dzongkhag, 2018. National Statistics Bureau, 34. Tibet Statistic Bureau. 2018. Tibet Statistic Yearbook. China Statistic Press. Beijing, China. Royal Government of Bhutan. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://www.nsb.gov.bt/?s=popula- 35. Department of Agriculture. Government of Arunachal Pradesh. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http:// tion+and+housing+census+2017 www.agri.arunachal.gov.in/aboutus.php 61. RGOB (Royal Government of Bhutan). 2009. RNR sector tenth five year plan (2008- 2013): Enabling farm- 36. ibid ing communities to overcome poverty (Vol. I: Main document). Thimphu: Ministry of Agriculture, Royal 37. TERI School of Advanced Studies. 2018. State Specific Action Plan for water Sector- Arunachal Pradesh New Government of Bhutan. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021 https://www.gnhc.gov.bt/en/wp-content/ Delhi: TERI School of Advanced Studies, [Project Report No. 2017QP01] Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, uploads/2017/05/TenthPlan_Vol1_Web.pdf 2021. http://nwm.gov.in/sites/default/files/Report_Draft-SSAP_Arunachal_Pradesh.pdf 62. Twelfth Five Year Plan, 2018-2023, Department of Agriculture, Ministry of Agriculture and Forests, Royal 38. Department of Agriculture. Government of Arunachal Pradesh. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http:// Government of Bhutan, Thimpu, March 2019. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://www.gnhc.gov. www.agri.arunachal.gov.in/aboutus.php bt/en/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/12FYP-Volume-II-Central-Plans.pdf 39. TERI School of Advanced Studies. 2018. State Specific Action Plan for water Sector- Arunachal Pradesh New 63. Sustainable Socio-economic Development through the Commercialisation of Organic Framing, National Delhi: TERI School of Advanced Studies, [Project Report No. 2017QP01] Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, Organic Programme ARDC-Yusipang Department of Agriculture Ministry of Agriculture and Forests Na- 2021. http://nwm.gov.in/sites/default/files/Report_Draft-SSAP_Arunachal_Pradesh.pdf tional Organic Programme ARDC-Yusipang Department of Agriculture Ministry of Agriculture and Forests. 40. Pangare Ganesh, Vasudha Pangare and Binayak Das. 2006. Springs of Life. New Delhi. Academic Foundation, Accessed June 23,2020; May 3, 2021. http://flagship.gnhc.gov.bt/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Organ- World Water Institute, Bharathi Integrated Rural Development Society (BIRDS): 152-155 ic-Flagship-_March-2019.pdf 41. Shifting Cultivation, Livelihood and Food Security: New and Old Challenges for Indigenous People in Asia. 64. Food Security and Agriculture Development Department, Government of Sikkim. Accessed June 23, 2020; 2014. Asia Indigenous Peoples’ Pact (AIPP) and the International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs (IWGIA), May 3, 2021. https://sikkim.gov.in/departments/food-security-and-agriculture-development-department Chiang Mai. http://www.sikkimorganicmission.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Comprehensive-report.pdf 42. Government of Assam. AGRI VISION 2025. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://diragri.assam.gov. 65. ibid in/information-services/agri-vision-2025 418 419 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 66. Ibid. 87. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics 67. Status of Environment and Related Issues. Forest and Environment Department. Government of Sikkim. Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.sikenvis.nic.in/Database/Agriculture_777.aspx www.bbs.gov.bd 68. Food Security & Agriculture Development Department. Annual Progress Report 2013-14. Government 88. Shamsuzzaman, M. M., Mohammad Mahmudul Islam, Nusrat Jahan Tania, Md. Abdullah Al-Mamun, Partho of Sikkim. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http://www.sikkimagrisnet.org/General/UploadedFiles/ Protim Barman, and Xiangmin Xu. 2017. Fisheries Resources of Bangladesh: Present Status and Future Downloads/30024.pdf Direction. Aquaculture and Fisheries. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j. 69. ibid. aaf.2017.03.006 70. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics 89. Hossain, Mostafa Ali Reza. 2014. An Overview of Fisheries Sector of Bangladesh. Research in Agriculture, Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, Livestock and Fisheries 1(1): 109-126 www.bbs.gov.bd 90. Banglapedia. 2015. National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh. Asiatic Society of Bangladesh: Dhaka, Bangladesh. 71. Quddus, M. A. 2009. Crop Production Growth in Different Agro-Ecological Zones of Bangladesh. Journal of 91. Hossain, M. Ayub, Ashoke Kumar Sarker, M. Nurul Amin, M. Mokarrom Hossain, and M. Sumon Miah. 2016. Bangladesh Agricultural University 7(2): 351–360. Development and Performance Evaluation of Sludge Remover for Intensive Aquaculture. Aquacultural 72. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics Engineering 74: 62-69. Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, 92. Hossain, Mostafa Ali Reza. 2014. An Overview of Fisheries Sector of Bangladesh. Research in Agriculture, www.bbs.gov.bd Livestock and Fisheries 1(1): 109-126 73. Social forestry  is the afforestation of barren land, forest management and protection of forest with the 93. Rahman, S., I. A. Begum, and M. J.Alam. 2014. Livestock in Bangladesh: Distribution, Growth, Performance purpose of helping environment, social and rural development. It involves the growing of trees at the farm and Potential. Livestock Research for Rural Development 26(10): No. 173. level to provide firewood, cash crops and the processing of forest products at the household and local 94. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics artisan levels to generate income of the forest dwelling communities. Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, 74. Rahman, M. A., M. M. Rahman, and S. Hossain, 2019. Climate-Resilient Agricultural Practices in Different www.bbs.gov.bd Agro-ecological Zones of Bangladesh. In book: W. Leal Filho (ed.), Handbook of Climate Change Resilience 95. DLS. 2019. Annual Report on Livestock. Division of Livestock Statistics, Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, (pp.1-27); Publisher: Springer, Cham. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3- Farmgate, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 319-71025-9_42-1 96. Hamid, M. A., A. Rahman, M.A. Zaman, and K.M. Hossain. 2017. Cattle Genetic Resources and Their 75. Embankment cropping  is cultivation or growing of crops on the embankment of canal or  haor  (ditch). Conservation in Bangladesh. Asian Journal of Animal Sciences 11: 54-64. DOI: 10.3923/ajas.2017.54.64 Generally, farmers grow vegetables and fruits on embankments for their own consumption and selling. 97. Sarker, N. R., M. A. Habib, M. R., Amin, S. Yeasmin, F. Tabassum, and D. Yeasmin, 2018.  Bangladesh Journal of 76. Shelley Israt, Misuzu Takahashi-Nosaka, Mana Kano-Nakata, Md. Shahidul Haque,,and Yoshiaki Inukai. Animal Science 46(3): 206-214. 2016. Rice Cultivation in Bangladesh: Present Scenario, Problems, and Prospects. Journal of International 98. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics Cooperation for Agricultural Development 14. 20-29 Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, 77. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics www.bbs.gov.bd Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, 99. MOA-GOB. National Agriculture Policy 2018. Ministry of Agriculture, Government of Bangladesh (MOA- www.bbs.gov.bd GOB), 2018 78. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics 100. Peña-Arancibia, Jorge L., Mohammed Mainuddin, Mobin D. Ahmad, Geoff. Hodgson, Khandakar F. Ibn Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, Murad, Catherine Ticehurst, M. Maniruzzaman, M. Golam Mahboob, and John M. Kirby. 2020. “Groundwater www.bbs.gov.bd Use And Rapid Irrigation Expansion In A Changing Climate: Hydrological Drivers In One Of The World’S 79. Islam, A.B.J.; Shahidullah, S.M.; Mostafizur, A. B. M. and Saha, A. 2017. Diversity of Cropping Pattern in Bogra. Food Bowls”. Journal Of Hydrology 581: 124300. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.124300. Bangladesh Rice Journal 21 (2): 73-90. 101. Purdy, Adam J., Cédric H. David, Md. Safat Sikder, John T. Reager, Hrishikesh A. Chandanpurkar, Norman L. 80. Rashid, Mamun-ur. 2016. Maize Growers Eye Bumper Yield in Jamuna Basin Areas. The Daily Star. February Jones, and Mir A. Matin. 2019. “An Open-Source Tool To Facilitate The Processing Of GRACE Observations 17, 2016. And GLDAS Outputs: An Evaluation In Bangladesh”. Frontiers In Environmental Science 7. doi:10.3389/ 81. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics fenvs.2019.00155. Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, 102. Mainuddin, Mohammed, Mac Kirby, Glen Walker, and Jeff Connor. 2014. Sustaining Water Resources For www.bbs.gov.bd Food Security In Bangladesh. Canberra: CSIRO. 82. Qureshi, Asad S. Zia Uddin Ahmad, and Timothy J. Krupnik. 2015. Moving from Resource Development to 103. Twice yearly phenomenon of poverty and hunger in Bangladesh. It happened during September– Resource Management: Problems. Water Resources Management 29(11): DOI: 10.1007/s11269-015-1059-y. November (after the aman crop is planted) and from March–April (after the boro crop is planted) 83. BBS. 2018. Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics-2018. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics and Informatics 104. Dey, Nepal C., Ratnajit Saha, Mahmood Parvez, Sujit K. Bala, AKM Saiful Islam, Joyanta K. Paul, and Mahabub Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, 30thSeries, May 2019, Hossain. 2017. “Sustainability Of Groundwater Use For Irrigation Of Dry-Season Crops In Northwest www.bbs.gov.bd Bangladesh”. Groundwater For Sustainable Development 4: 66-77. doi:10.1016/j.gsd.2017.02.001. 84. Shah T. 2007. The Groundwater Economy of South-Asia: An Assessment of Size, Significance and 105. Mojid, Mohammad A., Mohammad F. Parvez, Mohammed Mainuddin, and Geoff Hodgson. 2019. “Water Socioecological Impacts. In: Giordano M, Villholth KG (eds) The Agricultural Groundwater Revolution: Table Trend—A Sustainability Status Of Groundwater Development In North-West Bangladesh”. Water 11 Opportunities and Threat to Development. CABI, Wallingford, pp 7–36. (6): 1182. doi:10.3390/w11061182. 85. Dey, N. C., S. K. Bala, Saiful Islam A. K. M., Rashid, M. A. 2013. Sustainability of Groundwater Use for Irrigation 106. Peña-Arancibia, Jorge L., Mohammed Mainuddin, Mobin D. Ahmad, Geoff. Hodgson, Khandakar F. Ibn in Northwest Bangladesh. Policy Report prepared under the National Food Policy Capacity Strengthening Murad, Catherine Ticehurst, M. Maniruzzaman, M. Golam Mahboob, and John M. Kirby. 2020. “Groundwater Programme (NFPCSP): Dhaka, Bangladesh. 89 pp. Use And Rapid Irrigation Expansion In A Changing Climate: Hydrological Drivers In One Of The World’S 86. Hossain Md. Ayub. 2019. Solar Pump Irrigation for Sustainable Crop Production in Bangladesh. The Asian Food Bowls”. Journal Of Hydrology 581: 124300. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.124300. Age, 9 January 2020, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 107. Rahman, A.T.M. Sakiur, Takahiro Hosono, Quamrul H. Mazumder, and Chowdhury S. Jahan. 2020. “Sustainable Groundwater Management In Context Of Climate Change In Northwest Bangladesh.” 420 421 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 108. Mojid, Mohammad A., Mohammad F. Parvez, Mohammed Mainuddin, and Geoff Hodgson. 2019. “Water Table Trend—A Sustainability Status Of Groundwater Development In North-West Bangladesh”. Water 11 (6): 1182. doi:10.3390/w11061182. 5. PEOPLE-One river, many cultures 109. Mojid, Mohammad A., Mohammad F. Parvez, Mohammed Mainuddin, and Geoff Hodgson. 2019. “Water 1. Meyer, M.C., M.S. Aldenderfer, Z. Wang, D. Hofman, J. Dahl, D. Degering, et  al. 2017. Permanent human Table Trend—A Sustainability Status Of Groundwater Development In North-West Bangladesh”. Water 11 occupation of the central Tibetan Plateau in the Early Holocene. Science 355: 64-67. (6): 1182. doi:10.3390/w11061182. 2. Miehe, G., S. Miehe, K. Kaiser, C. Reudenbach, L. Behrendes, L. Duo and F. Schultz. 2009. How old is 110. Peña-Arancibia, Jorge L., Mohammed Mainuddin, Mobin D. Ahmad, Geoff. Hodgson, Khandakar F. Ibn pastoralism in Tibet? An ecological approach to the making of a Tibetan landscape. Palaeogeography, Murad, Catherine Ticehurst, M. Maniruzzaman, M. Golam Mahboob, and John M. Kirby. 2020. “Groundwater Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 276: 130-147. Use And Rapid Irrigation Expansion In A Changing Climate: Hydrological Drivers In One Of The World’S 3. Meyer, M.C., C. Hofman, A.M.D. Gemmel, E. Haslinger, H. Hausler and D. Wangda. 2009. Holocene glacier Food Bowls”. Journal Of Hydrology 581: 124300. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.124300. fluctuations and migration of Neolithic yak pastoralists into the high valleys of northwest Bhutan. 111. Purdy, Adam J., Cédric H. David, Md. Safat Sikder, John T. Reager, Hrishikesh A. Chandanpurkar, Norman L. Quaternary Science Review 28: 1217-1237.; Meyer, M.C., M.S. Aldenderfer, Z. Wang, D. Hofman, J. Dahl, D. Jones, and Mir A. Matin. 2019. “An Open-Source Tool To Facilitate The Processing Of GRACE Observations Degering, et al. 2017. Permanent human occupation of the central Tibetan Plateau in the Early Holocene. And GLDAS Outputs: An Evaluation In Bangladesh”. Frontiers In Environmental Science 7. doi:10.3389/ Science 355: 64-67. fenvs.2019.00155. 4. Guo, S., P. Savolainen, J. Su, Q. Zhang, D. Qi, J. Zhou, et al. 2006. Origin of mitochondrial DNA diversity of 112. IWM. Bangladesh Integrated Water Resources Assessment Supplementary report: Surface Water and domestic yaks. BMC Evolutionary Biology 6(1): 73-87. Groundwater Interaction. Institute of Water Modelling, Bangladesh (IWM), 2014. 5. Bailey J.F., B. Healy, J. Han, L. Sherchang, S.L. Pradhan, T. Tsendsuren, J.M. Foggin, C. Gaillard, D. Steane, I. 113. Dey, Nepal C., Ratnajit Saha, Mahmood Parvez, Sujit K. Bala, AKM Saiful Islam, Joyanta K. Paul, and Mahabub Zakharov and D.G. Bradley. 2002. Genetic variation of mitochondrial DNA within domestic yak populations. Hossain. 2017. “Sustainability Of Groundwater Use For Irrigation Of Dry-Season Crops In Northwest In J. Han, C. Richard, O. Hannotte, C. McVeigh & J.E.O. Rege (Eds.), Yak productions in central Asian highlands. Bangladesh”. Groundwater For Sustainable Development 4: 66-77. doi:10.1016/j.gsd.2017.02.001. Proceedings of the third international congress on yak. Nairobi, Kenya: International Livestock Research 114. Purdy, Adam J., Cédric H. David, Md. Safat Sikder, John T. Reager, Hrishikesh A. Chandanpurkar, Norman L. Institute (ILRI). Jones, and Mir A. Matin. 2019. “An Open-Source Tool To Facilitate The Processing Of GRACE Observations 6. d’Alpoim Guedes, J. and M. Aldenderfer. 2019. The archaeology of the early Tibetan plateau: New research And GLDAS Outputs: An Evaluation In Bangladesh”. Frontiers In Environmental Science 7. doi:10.3389/ on the initial peopling through the Early Bronze Age. Journal of Archaeological Research. https://doi. fenvs.2019.00155. org/10.1007/s10814-019-09137-6 115. Kirby, Mac, Mobin Ahmad, Mohammed Mainuddin, Wahid Palash, Mohammed Quadir, Sardar Shah-Newaz, 7. Zeng, X., Guo, Y., Xu, Q.  et al.  2018. Origin and evolution of qingke barley in Tibet.  Nature and Monowar Hossain. 2015. “The Impact of Irrigation Development On Regional Groundwater Resources Communications 9, 5433. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-07920-5 In Bangladesh”. Agricultural Water Management 159: 264-276 8. Shakya, T. (1993) Whither the Tsampa Eaters? Himal Southasian, https://www.himalmag.com/whither-the- 116. “National Agriculture Policy”. 2020. Badc.Portal.Gov.Bd. http://badc.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/ tsampa/ badc.portal.gov.bd/page/c23bdffd_22fd_4f15_8fc4_b1fc7a91a36a/d5a84d165253f9e02–d6190b5d 9. Ekvall, Robert B. 1968. Fields on the hoof: nexus of Tibetan nomadic pastoralism. Holt, Rinehart and 28b1340.pdf. Winston. New York. 117. Zhao, H. and Wang, C. (1990) Tea’s introduction to and cultivation in Tibet. China Tibetology. 3: 006. 10. Miller, D. 2008. Nomads of the Tibetan Plateau and Himalaya. Maptia Stories, https://maptia.com/ 118. Wang, Z. (2016) Current status of tea productions in Tibet. Chinatea. 7. danielmiller/stories/nomads-of-the-tibetan-plateau-and-himalaya 119. Tibet Statistic Bureau (2018) Tibet Statistic Yearbook. China Statistic Press. Beijing, China. 11. Sheehy, D, D. Miller and D.a. Johnson. 2006. Transformation of traditional pastoral livestock systems on the 120. Tea Board, India. Ministry of Commerce & Industry. Government of India. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, Tibetan steppe. Sécheresse 17(1-2): 142-51. 2021 http://www.teaboard.gov.in/TEABOARDCSM/Ng== 12 Nyima, T. 2003. China case study 3: Pastoral systems, change and the future of the grazing lands in Tibet. 121. Government of Assam. Industries and Commerce. Small tea growers. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. In J.M. Suttie & S.G. Reynolds (Eds.), Transhumant Grazing Systems in Temperate Asia. Rome, Italy: Food and https://industries.assam.gov.in/portlet-innerpage/about-tea-industries Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). http://www.fao.org/3/y4856e/y4856e0d.htm 122. ibid 13. Foggin, J.M. 1998. Recent accounts from the source area of the Yangtze River. Xining, China: Plateau 123. http://www.teaboard.gov.in/TEABOARDCSM/Ng== Perspectives. https://stories.plateauperspectives.org/ancient-ways 124. Government of Assam. Transformation and Development. Directorate of Economics and Statistics. State 14. Gruschke, A. 2008. Nomads without Pastures? Globalization, Regionalization, and Livelihood Security of Profile of Assam. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. https://des.assam.gov.in/information-services/ Nomads and Former Nomads in Northern Khams. Journal of the International Association of Tibetan Studies state-profile-of-assam 4: 1-40.; Du, Fachun. 2012. Ecological resettlement of Tibetan herders in the Sanjiangyuan: A case study in 125. Government of Assam. Industries and Commerce. Small tea growers. Accessed June 23, 2020; May 3, 2021. Madoi county of Qinghai. Nomadic Peoples 16(1): 116-133 https://industries.assam.gov.in/portlet-innerpage/about-tea-industries 15. Foggin, J.M. 2011. Rethinking ‘Ecological Migration’ and the value of cultural continuity: A response to 126. Nabajyoti Deka & Kishor Goswami.  2020.  Organic cultivation and farm entrepreneurship: a case of Wang, Song & Hu.  Ambio 40: 100-101. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-010-0105-5 ; Foggin, J.M. and M.E. small tea growers in rural Assam, India,  Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems,  44:4,  446-466, Torrance-Foggin. 2017. Pastoralism, Development, and the Future of Tibetan Rangelands: Experiences DOI: 10.1080/21683565.2019.1646373 in the Development and Provision of Social Services and Environmental Management. In A. Gruschke 127. Prashnani Meghavi, Qadir Abdul, Goswani J, Raju P L N, 2019, Spatio-Temporal Study of Brahmaputra & I. Breuer (Eds.), Tibetan Pastoralists and Development: Negotiating the Future of Grassland Livelihoods. River Islands (Chars) for Agricultural Expansion in Assam, India, The International Archives of the Wiesbaden, Germany: Ludwig Reichert Verlag. Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W6, 2019 ISPRS- 16. Chandler, M.J. and C.E. Lalonde. 1998. Cultural continuity as a hedge against suicide in Canada’s First GEOGLAM-ISRS Joint Int. Workshop on “Earth Observations for Agricultural Monitoring”, 18–20 February Nations. Transcultural Psychiatry 35(2): 193-211. 2019, New Delhi, India. Chandler, M.J. and C.E. Lalonde. 2008. Continuity as a moderator of suicide risk among Canada’s First Nations. In Kirmayer, L. & G. Valaskakis (Eds.), Healing traditions: The mental health of Aboriginal peoples in Canada. Vancouver, Canada: University of British Columbia Press. d 422 423 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 17. Wang, G., J.L. Innes, S.W. Wu, et al. 2012. National Park Development in China: Conservation or 32. https://www.deccanherald.com/national/indo-uk-team-preserve-cultural-684869.html Commercialization? AMBIO 41: 247-261. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-011-0194-9 ; IUCN (2019) 33. Origin, discovery of tea, wild tea and early development of tea in Assam, indigenous tea and tea drinking Developing China’s national park system (IUCN News, dated 26 June 2019). https://www.iucn.org/news/ habit among the tribes in Assam, India. asia/201906/developing-chinas-national-park-system-0 ; 34. http://www.pajhra.org/adivasi-peoples-history/ Katz, B. 2019. China is developing a new national parks system, inspired by Yellowstone and Yosemite. 35. Sharma, Jayeeta. 2011. Empire’s Garden. Duke University Press. Smithsonian Magazine, 14 Nov 2019. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/china-developing- 36. Antrobus, H.A. 1957. A History of the Assam Company 1839-1953. T and A Constable Lts. new-national-parks-system-180973549/ ; Yan, W. 2018. China’s first national park, an experiment in living 37. Baran Barua, K. 2016. Buddhism and Living Atish Dipankar Srijnan-Unsurpassable Luminaries of Asia. with snow leopards. Mongabay News, https://news.mongabay.com/2017/05/chinas-first-national-park- Journal of Religious Studies, Buddhism and Living, North Carolina, USA, Cresco Online Publishing, Article an-experiment-in-living-with-snow-leopards/ Number: JRBL-1002. 1. 18. Foggin, J.M. 2012. Pastoralists and wildlife conservation in western China: collaborative management 38. ibid within protected areas on the Tibetan Plateau.  Pastoralism 2, 17. https://doi.org/10.1186/2041-7136-2-17 39. Ahmad, S. 2013. An imagination of Bikrampur Buddhist Vihara from the foot-print of Atish Dipankar’s travel. ; Foggin, J.M. 2018. Environmental Conservation in the Tibetan Plateau region: Lessons for China’s Belt American Journal of Engineering Research (AJER)e-ISSN:2320-0847 p-ISSN:2320-0936Volume-02, Issue-12, and Road Initiative in the Mountains of Central Asia. Land 7, 52. https://doi.org/10.3390/land7020052 ; pp-276-295. Available at http://www.ajer.org/papers/v2(12)/ZF212276295.pdf. Accessed 1 June 2020 Foggin, J.M. 2018. Snow Leopards at Large: One herding community’s hope for the future in the grasslands 40. Banglapedia. 2015. Dipankar Srijnan, Atish. Available at http://en.banglapedia.org/index.php?title= of Tibet. In J. Xu (Ed.), Mountain Futures: Innovation and Inspiration from the World’s Highlands. Nairobi, Dipankar_Srijnan,_Atish Accessed 1 June 2020 Kenya: World Agroforestry Centre.; Foggin, J.M. 2020. Inclusive Development, An Imperative for the Future: Building broader partnerships for better informed development decisions. Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic: Plateau Perspectives. https://stories.plateauperspectives.org/inclusive-development ;Foggin, J.M. and d L. Cabrera. 2020. Achieving sustainable development with equity in an era of globalisation; Recognizing and respecting local communities and indigenous peoples for creating the future we want. Development Issues, No. 3 (June 2020). Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic: Plateau Perspectives. 19. Hodges, J., J.M. Foggin, R.J. Long and G. Zhaxi. 2014. Globalisation and the sustainability of farmers, livestock- 6. HARNESS-Tapping the river keepers, pastoralists and fragile habitats. Biodiversity 15(2-3):109-118. https://doi.org/10.1080/14888386.2 014.931247 ; Farvar, M.T., G. Borrini-Feyerabend, J. Campese, T. Jaeger, H. Jonas and S. Stevens. 2018. Whose 1. Research Triangle Institute and ‘Inclusive Conservation’? Policy Brief of the ICCA Consortium, No. 5. Tehran, Iran: ICCA Consortium and 2. Water Resource Bulletin of the Yangtze River and rivers in the Southwestern region. Cenesta. 3. IDSA Task Force. 2010. Water security for India: The external dynamics. Institute for Defence Studies and 20. Suttie, J.M. and S.G. Reynolds. 2003. Transhumant Grazing Systems in Temperate Asia. Plant Production and Analyses. Protection Series No. 31 (Rev. 1). Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations 4. FAO. 2011. Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna River basin, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United (FAO). http://www.fao.org/3/y4856e/y4856e00.htm Nations, Rome. http://www.fao.org/nr/water/aquastat/basins/gbm/gbm-CP_eng.pdf 21. Roche, Gerald and Hiroyuki Suzuki. 2018. Tibet’s Minority Languages: Diversity and Endangerment. Modern 5. Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, S., Sillanpää, M. 2019. Water quality in the Tibetan Plateau: Major ions and trace Asian Studies. 52(4): 1227-1278.; Nyima, Tashi, and Hiroyuki Suzuki. 2019. Newly Recognised Languages in elements in rivers of the “Water Tower of Asia”. Science of the Total Environment 649, 571. Chamdo: Geography, Culture, History, and Language. Linguistics of the Tibeto-Burman Area 42(1): 38-81. 6. Colin, C., Turpin, L., Bertaux, J., Desprairies, A., Kissel, C. 1999. Erosional history of the Himalayan and Burman 22. Roche, Gerald and Hiroyuki Suzuki. 2018. Tibet’s Minority Languages: Diversity and Endangerment. Modern ranges during the last two glacial–interglacial cycles. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 171, 647-660. Asian Studies. 52(4): 1227-1278 7. Singh, S.K., Sarin, M., France-Lanord, C. 2005. Chemical erosion in the eastern Himalaya: major ion 23. Nyima, Tashi, and Hiroyuki Suzuki. 2019. Newly Recognised Languages in Chamdo: Geography, Culture, composition of the Brahmaputra and δ 13 C of dissolved inorganic carbon. Geochimica et Cosmochimica History, and Language. Linguistics of the Tibeto-Burman Area 42(1): 38-81 Acta 69, 3573-3588. 24. Institute of Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. 2013. Introduction of Yaks. http://qzyjy.swun.edu.cn/info/1024/1111. 8. Zheng, M. 1989. Saline lakes on the Qinghai-Xizang (Tibet) plateau. Beijing Scientific and Technical htm Publishing House; Colin, C., Turpin, L., Bertaux, J., Desprairies, A., Kissel, C. 1999. Erosional history of the 25. Miller 1998, cited in Foggin, J.M. 2020. Inclusive Development, An Imperative for the Future: Building Himalayan and Burman ranges during the last two glacial–interglacial cycles. Earth and Planetary Science broader partnerships for better informed development decisions. Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic: Plateau Letters 171, 647-660. Perspectives. https://stories.plateauperspectives.org/inclusive-development 9. ECLCT. 2005. Editorial Committee of Local Chronicle, Tibet Autonomous Region. Local Chronicles of Tibet 26. Majumdar, D. 1980. North East India - A Profile. In T. S. Majumdar (Ed.), Eastern Himalayas. New Delhi: Cosmo Autonomous Region: Climography: 1st edn. Tibetology Publisher: Beijing; 12–29 (in Chinese). Publications. 10. Chaudhuri, S., Clauer, N., Semhi, K. 2007. Plant decay as a major control of river dissolved potassium: a first Dutta, P. 1987. A Sociological Study of Rongker- An Annual Karbi village Festival. (B.N.Bordoloi, Ed.) Bulletin estimate. Chemical Geology 243, 178-190. of the Tribal Research Institute, I (V) Ethno profile of Karbi In Plain Districts of Assam, (n.d.), Pdf file, Assam. 11. Stallard, R., Edmond, J. 1981. Geochemistry of the Amazon: 1. Precipitation chemistry and the marine 27. Deori. S. 2002, Bina Library, Guwahati contribution to the dissolved load at the time of peak discharge. Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans 28. Kotoky, P., D. Bezbaruah, J. Baruah, and J. N. Sarma. 2003. “Erosion activity on Majuli-the largest river island 86, 9844-9858. of the world.” Current science 84, no. 7 (2003): 929-932. 12. Liu, T. 1999. Hydrological Characteristics of Yarlung Zangbo River. Acta Geographica Sinica 54, 157-164. Sarma, J. N., and M. K. Phukan. 2004. “Origin and some geomorphological changes of Majuli Island of the 13. Shi, Y., Yang, Z. 1985. Water resources of glaciers in China. GeoJournal 10, 163-166. Brahmaputra River in Assam, India.” Geomorphology 60, no. 1-2 (2004): 1-19 14. Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, S., Sillanpää, M. 2019. Water quality in the Tibetan Plateau: Major ions and trace 29 ibid elements in rivers of the “Water Tower of Asia”. Science of the Total Environment 649, 571. 30. Roy, Nikhil, Bindhy Wasini Pandey, and Usha Rani. 2020. “Protecting the vanishing geo-cultural heritage of 15. Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, S., Sillanpää, M. 2017. Water chemistry of the southern Tibetan Plateau: an India: Case study of Majuli Island in Assam.” International Journal of Geoheritage and Parks. assessment of the Yarlung Tsangpo river basin. Environmental earth sciences 76, 74.; Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, 31. Roy, Nikhil, Bindhy Wasini Pandey, and Usha Rani. 2020. “Protecting the vanishing geo-cultural heritage of S., Sillanpää, M. 2019. Water quality in the Tibetan Plateau: Major ions and trace elements in rivers of the India: Case study of Majuli Island in Assam.” International Journal of Geoheritage and Parks. “Water Tower of Asia”. Science of the Total Environment 649, 571. 424 425 THE RESTLESS RIVER REFERENCES 16. WHO Drinking-water Quality 4th edition. 2011. 45. Rahaman, M. M., & Varis, O. (2009). Integrated water management of the Brahmaputra basin: Perspectives 17. e. (MOH&SAC, 2006) and hope for regional development. Paper presented at the Natural Resources Forum. 18. c. Huang et al. (2019) 46. Chellaney, B., & Tellis, A. J. (2011). A Crisis to Come? China, India and Water Rivalry. Carnegie Endowment 19. Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, S., Sillanpää, M. 2019. Water quality in the Tibetan Plateau: Major ions and trace Report, September13. elements in rivers of the “Water Tower of Asia”. Science of the Total Environment 649, 571. 47. Brammer, H. (1990). Floods in Bangladesh: II. Flood mitigation and environmental aspects. Geograph- 20. Huang, X., Sillanpää, M., Gjessing, E., Peräniemi, S., Vogt, R. (2011) Water quality in the southern Tibetan ical Journal, 158-165. Plateau: chemical evaluation of the Yarlung Tsangpo (Brahmaputra). River Research and Applications 27, 48. Jiang and He (2011) A new era for Tibet’s rivers. https://www.chinadialogue.net/article/show/single/ 113-121. en/4055 21. Qu, B., Zhang, Y., Kang, S., Sillanpää, M. (2017) Water chemistry of the southern Tibetan Plateau: an assess- 49. Handique, K. and Dutta, A. (2012) Power and North East: The Hydro Power Scenario of North East. ment of the Yarlung Tsangpo river basin. Environmental earth sciences 76, 74. International Journal of Science and Research 602-609. 22. Li, C., Kang, S., Chen, P., Zhang, Q., Mi, J., Gao, S., Sillanpää, M. (2014) Geothermal spring causes arsenic 50. Ministry of Power, Government of India contamination in river waters of the southern Tibetan Plateau, China. Environmental earth sciences 71, 51. https://www.mfa.gov.bt/rbedelhi/?page_id=28 4143-4148. 23. Goswami, D. C. (1985) Brahmaputra River, Assam, India: Physiography, basin denudation and channel d aggradation. Water Resources Research. 21(7), 959-978. 24. Trivedy, R. K., & Goel, P. K. (1986) Chemical and biological methods for water pollution studies. India: Envi- 7. GOVERN-Framework for co-operation ronmental Publication. 25. APHA (2005) Standard methods for examination of water and wastewater, 21stedn. American Public Health Association, Washington. 26. Sivasankar, T., Borah, S. B., Das, R., & Raju, P. L. N. (2020). An Investigation on Sudden Change in Water Qual- 1. DISCLAIMER: The transboundary agreements discussed pertain to the South Asia Water Initiative ity of Brahmaputra River Using Remote Sensing and GIS. National Academy Science Letters, 1-5. basins only. Ministry and agency names often change with new governments and institutional 27. Bora, M., & Goswami, D. C. (2017) Water quality assessment in terms of water quality index (WQI): case study restructuring—best efforts were made to ensure names are current. of the Kolong River, Assam, India. Applied Water Science. 7(6), 3125-3135. 2. Xie, L., Zhang, Y. and Panda, J.P. (2018) Mismatched Diplomacy: China-India water relations over the 28. Abbasi, S.A. (2002) Water quality indices. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna River Basin. Journal of Contemporary China 27(109): 32-46. 29. Brown R. M., McClelland N. I., Deininger R. A., & O’Connor M. F. (1972) A Water Quality Index-Crashing the 3. Feng, Y. & He, D.M. (2009) Transboundary water vulnerability and its drivers in China. Journal of Physiological Barrier. Indicators of Environmental Quality. 1, 173-182. Geographical Sciences, 19, 189–199. 30. Jamwal, N. (2020), “Neither sewage, nor sewage treatment plant, the Bharalu river is a sewage channel”, 4. Feng, Y., Wang, W. and Liu, J. (2019) Dilemmas in and pathways to transboundary water cooperation Gaon Connection, at . 5. ibid 31. Handique, B. (2012), “Waste floats on ‘clean’ rivulet”, The Telegraph, at between China and India on the Yaluzangbu-Brahmaputra River. Water 11, 2096. 32. Goswami, P. (2012), The History of Assam: From Yandabo to Partition, 1826-1947, Orient Blackswan. 7. National Environment Commission. 2007. Bhutan Water Policy. Royal Government of Bhutan. Available 33. Saikia, A. (2011), Forests and Ecological History of Assam: 1826-2000, New Delhi: OUP. at http://extwprlegs1.fao.org/docs/pdf/bhu167545.pdf. Accessed on 12 June 2020. 34. Borthakur, A., and Singh, P. (2016), “India’s lost rivers and rivulets”, Energy, Ecology and Environment, 1, 310– 8. Ministry of Water Resources. 1999. National Water Policy 1999. Available at https://mowr.gov.bd/sites/ 314, at < https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40974-016-0039-2#citeas>. default/files/files/mowr.portal.gov.bd/files/32e67290_f24e_4407_9381_166357695653/National%20 35. Pollution Control Board, Assam (2013), “Conservation of River Bharalu, Guwahati”, Detailed Project Report Water%20Policy%20(English).pdf Accessed on 12 June 2020. Draft, at . 9. Joint Rivers Commission. 2019. History. Available at http://www.jrcb.gov.bd/site/page/1032c710-feb2- 36. Guwahati Development Department, Government of Assam (undated), “Bharalu River”, Guwahati Smart 48cc-979e-1d7d47590cad/- Accessed on 28 June 2020. City Limited, at < https://gscl.assam.gov.in/projects/detail/bharalu-river>. 10. Ministry of Shipping. First ever movement of container cargo on Brahmaputra (National Waterway -2). 37. Liu, D. (1986) Urgent needs to develop inland navigation in the middle reach of the Yarlung Tsangpo River. Press Release. Ministry of Shipping, Government of India. Port & Waterway Engineering. 2, 3-7. 11. Saran, S. 2016. South Asia’s Mounting Ecological Challenge. In Thirty Years of SAARC: Society, Culture 38. Bhattacharya (2004) The Brahmaputra in Assam’s economy. Singh, V.P., Sharma, N. and Ojha, C.S.P. [ed] The and Development. Eds, R. Kumar and O. Goyal. SAGE Publications India. Brahmaputra Basin Water Resources. 12. Baru, S., Rais, R., & Baral, L. (2010). Role of SAARC Observers: Members’ Perspectives. In S. Muni (Ed.), The 39. The 20-foot container, referred to as a Twenty-foot Equivalent Unit (TEU) became the industry standard Emerging Dimensions of SAARC (pp. 229-276). Foundation Books. doi:10.1017/UPO9788175968615.011 reference so now cargo volume and vessel capacity are commonly measured in TEU. www.worldshipping. 13. Dash, K. C. 2008. Regionalism in South Asia. Negotiating Cooperation, Institutional Structures. Rutledge. org London Pp 96. 40. World Bank. (2007). Revival of Inland Water Transport: Options and Strategies, Bangladesh Development 14. Chatterjee, B and A. Ganguly. 2020. Time to Implement the BBIN Motor Vehicles Agreement. The Series, Paper No. 20. The World Bank Office, Dhaka. Economic Times. Available at https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-commentary/time-to- 41. Consultancy services for development of IWT system in Bangladesh, by Parvez Ali Anwar Khan implement-the-bbin-motor-vehicles-agreement/ Accessed on 28 June 2020 42. Mishra D. K. & Hussain S. M. (2012). Situation Analysis on Inland Navigation, Ecosystems for Life: A Bangla- 15. Ibid desh-India Initiative, International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources. 16. BIMSTEC. 2020. About BIMSTEC. Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic 43. Mishra D. K. & Hussain S. M. (2012). Situation Analysis on Inland Navigation, Ecosystems for Life: A Bangla- Cooperation (BIMSTEC). Available at https://bimstec.org/?page_id=189 desh-India Initiative, International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources. 17. Bhattacharjee, J. 2018. SAARC vs BIMSTEC: The Search for the Ideal Platform for Regional Cooperation. 44. Bangabandhu Jamuna Multipurpose Bridge http://en.banglapedia.org/index.php?title=Bangabandhu_ Observer Research Foundation. ORF Issue Brief, Issue No. 226. Jamuna_Multipurpose_Bridge 426 427 THE RESTLESS RIVER 18. Roy Chaudhury, D. (2019), “Kunming Meet Revives BCIM Link Plan”, Accessed 25 June, 2020 URL: https:// economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/kunming-meet-revives-bcim-link-plan/ articleshow/69921135.cms. 19. Thakur, Ambuj (2014), Sub-Regional Initiatives of China in South and Southeast Asia, 1999-2012, Ph.D Thesis, New Delhi: Jawaharlal Nehru University. 20. Pangare Ganesh, Editor. 2014. Hydro-Diplomacy: Sharing Water Across Borders. IUCN. Academic Foundation, New Delhi. 21. ibid. 22. Arupjyoti Saikia, The Unquiet River: A Biography of the Brahmaputra, Oxford University Press, New Delhi (2019). 23. For further details of the issues and proposals set out in this article, see ‘Why Eastern Himalayan countries should cooperate in transboundary water resource management’, Golam Rasul, Water Policy 16 (2014) 19- 38, IWA Publishing. 24. Bandyopadhyay, Jayanta, Nilanjan Ghosh and Chandan Mahanta. 2016. IRBM for Brahmaputra Sub- basin: Water Governance, Environmental Security, and Human Well-Being. New Delhi. Observer Research Foundation. (https://www.orfonline.org/research/irbm-for-brahmaputra-sub-basin/); Barua, Anamika. 2018. Water diplomacy as an approach to regional cooperation in South Asia: A case from the Brahmaputra basin. Journal of Hydrology 567:60-70. 25. Kattelmann Richard. 1987. Uncertainty in Assessing Himalayan Water Resources. Mountain Research and Development 7(3):289-286. 26. SAWI. 2018. China and India’s Animosity About Tibetan Rivers’ Fate. South Asia Water Initiative 08 August. 27. Hazarika, Obja Borah. 2015. Riparian Relations between India and China: Exploring Interactions in Trans- boundary Rivers. International Journal of China Studies 6(1) April:63-83. 28. Ho, Selina. 2017. Power Asymmetry in the China-India Brahmaputra River Dispute. Asia Pacific Bulletin 371 February 16. 29. Vellore, Ramesh K et al. 2014. On the anomalous precipitation enhancement over the Himalayan foothills during monsoon breaks. Climate Dynamics 43 January 04:2009-31. 30. Guoying, Li. 2005. Maintaining the healthy life of the Yellow River. Yellow River Conservancy Press. Zhengzhou. 31. Ahmed, Imtiaz. 2012. Teesta, Tipaimukh and River Linking Danger to Bangladesh India Relation. Economic and Political Weekly XLVII (16) April 21:51-53. THE RESTLESS RIVER Supported by: 428