THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Sergio Venegas Marin, Lara Schwarz, and Shwetlena Sabarwal © 2024 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank 1818 H Street NW Washington DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org This work is a product of the staff of The World Bank with external contributions. The findings, interpre- tations, and conclusions expressed in this work do not necessarily reflect the views of The World Bank, its Board of Executive Directors, or the governments they represent. The World Bank does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or currency of the data included in this work and does not assume responsibility for any errors, omissions, or discrepancies in the information, or liability with respect to the use of or failure to use the information, methods, processes, or conclusions set forth. The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in this work do not imply any judgment on the part of The World Bank concerning the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Nothing herein shall constitute or be construed or considered to be a limitation upon or waiver of the privileges and immunities of The World Bank, all of which are specifically reserved. Rights and Permissions This work is available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 IGO license (CC BY 3.0 IGO) http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo. Under the Creative Commons Attribution license, you are free to copy, distribute, transmit, and adapt this work, including for commercial purposes, under the following conditions: All queries on rights and licenses should be addressed to World Bank Publications, The World Bank Group, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USA; e-mail: pubrights@worldbank.org. THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT1 Sergio Venegas Marin, Lara Schwarz, and Shwetlena Sabarwal2 APRIL 2024 1 Note: This is the first part of the forthcoming global report on Learning to Propel Climate Action (June 2024). The second part of the report will discuss how the education sector can serve as a powerful catalyst for climate change mitigation and adaptation through mindset and behavior change, green skills, and innovation. 2 This work has been done under the guidance of Luis Benveniste, Harry Patrinos, and Halil Dundar. We would like to thank Diego Ambasz, Marla Spivack, Noam Angrist, Anshuman Kamal Gupta, Surayya Masood, Devika Singh, Natasha Ahuja, and Debi Spindelman for their inputs and comments. The team received helpful feedback from Syud Amer Ahmed, Juan Baron, Pedro Cerdan-Infantes, Gabriel Demom- bynes, James Gresham, Julia Liberman, Craig Meisner, Meskerem Mulatu, Norbert Schady, Monica Yanez Pagans, and Penny Williams. CONTENTS SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 CLIMATE CHANGE IS THREATENING EDUCATION OUTCOMES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Climate change is causing massive school closures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8 Rising temperatures threaten children and their education. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Climate change impacts on health and fragility further erode education outcomes. . 14 The education impacts of climate change are an economic time-bomb.. . . . . . . . . 16 WHAT SHOULD POLICYMAKERS DO? ADAPT EDUCATION SYSTEMS FOR GREATER RESILIENCE THROUGH FOUR STEPS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Education Management for climate resilience . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 School infrastructure for climate resilience.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Ensuring learning continuity in the face of climate shocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Leveraging students and teachers as change agents.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 EDUCATION CAN BE THE KEY TO ENDING POVERTY IN A LIVABLE PLANET, BUT GOVERNMENTS MUST ACT NOW TO PROTECT IT FROM CLIMATE CHANGE. . . . 29 SUMMARY Education can be the key to ending poverty in a livable planet, but governments must act now to protect it. Climate change is increasing the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events such as cyclones, floods, droughts, heatwaves and wildfires. These extreme weather events are in turn disrupting schooling; precipitating learning losses, dropouts, and long-term impacts. Even if the most drastic climate mitigation strategies were implemented, extreme weather events will continue to have detrimental impacts on educa- tion outcomes. Climate change is causing massive school closures. A 10-year-old in 2024 will experience twice as many wildfires and tropical cyclones, three times more river floods, four times more crop failures, and five times more droughts over her lifetime in a 3°C global warming pathway than a 10-year-old in 1970. Over the past 20 years, schools were closed in around 75 percent or more of the extreme weather events that impacted 5 million people or more. These closures were often prolonged due to infrastructure vulnerability and the use of school infrastructure for emergency sheltering. Rigorous evidence from COVID-19 shows that, on aver- age, a day of school closures is a day of learning lost. At the same time, rising temperatures are also inhibiting learning. A school day under extreme heat is a day in which some learning is lost. While the size of the impact remains uncertain and highly context specif- ic, temperatures that are very high or deviate significantly from local trends do precipitate learning losses. Heat-related learning losses may appear unremarkable when looking at changes in average temperatures over time. However, detailed new analysis shows that even the small learning impacts of slowly increas- ing temperatures could amount to significant cumulative losses over time, especially for those in hotter regions.3 Students in the hottest 10 percent of Brazilian municipalities, lost about 1 percent of learning per year due to increasing heat exposure. This would mean that an average student would lose between 0.66- 1.5 years of learning due to rising temperatures. Together these effects will lead to significant learning loss- es which will turn into significant income losses, lower productivity, greater inequality, and possibly greater social unrest. Despite these catastrophic consequences, education remains overlooked in the climate policy agenda. Education made up less than 1.3 percent of climate-related official development assistance in 2020 and mentioned in less than 1 in 3 Nationally Determined Contribution plans. This paper lays out four concrete ways in which governments can protect education systems from climate change so that their positive impacts on economic development, poverty alleviation, and social cohesion can be sustained and boost- ed. These are: (i) education management for resilience; (ii) school infrastructure for resilience; (iii) ensur- ing learning continuity in the face of climate shocks; and (iv) leveraging students and teachers as change agents. The paper presents an actionable agenda for each of these with operational examples in different contexts. 3 Schady et al., forthcoming 5 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT CLIMATE CHANGE IS THREATENING EDUCATION OUTCOMES “[THE 2019 CYCLONE] DEMOLISHED HOUSES—EVEN OUR DISHES WERE BROKEN—AND BOTH OUR HOSPITAL AND SCHOOL WERE DAMAGED. OUR CLASSROOM WAS DESTROYED. AND AT THE SPOT WHERE I USED TO STUDY UNDER THE MANGO TREES, THE BOOKS, PICTURES, AND NOTEBOOKS GOT REALLY WET WHEN IT RAINED.” Candida, 12-year-old student, Mozambique 6 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Education needs to be protected from climate Extreme weather events threaten learning, change. Climate change is increasing the frequen- enrollment, and the future prospects of students cy and intensity of extreme weather events such through both direct and indirect channels.4 Direct as cyclones, floods, droughts, heatwaves and effects of climate shocks harm the quality-of-ser- wildfires as well as the probability of co-occur- vice delivery and classroom environment, increase ring events.1 These extreme weather events are school closures, extend the length of those school increasingly disrupting schooling; precipitating closures through the use of schools as emergen- learning losses, dropouts, and long-term impacts. cy centers, and destroy school infrastructure. Indi- The education of 75 million children is estimat- rect effects can emerge through economic shocks, ed to have been disrupted by conflict and natu- food insecurity, health shocks, and increased ral disasters. These are projected to increase in conflict, migration, and displacement (see Figure frequency and severity with climate change.2 1). These indirect pathways result in reduced Over 99 percent of children around the world are student readiness to learn due to health and nutri- exposed to at least one major climate and environ- tion shocks, diminished demand for schooling due mental hazard, shock.3 These are eroding educa- to household coping mechanisms, and disruption tion outcomes and recent progress in improving to education services due to displacement and school access and learning. conflict. FIGURE 1: CLIMATE CHANGE ERODES EDUCATION OUTCOMES THROUGH BOTH DIRECT AND INDIRECT IMPACTS 7 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT CLIMATE CHANGE IS CAUSING MASSIVE SCHOOL CLOSURES “I have only one thing to say about Cyclone Idai: we were left with nothing. Our houses were all destroyed; the school too. We didn’t have classes because classrooms were full of water and the walls were damaged. Later, when the rains stopped, we continued to teach, but under the trees.” Celeste José Mucaisse, Primary School Teacher, Mozambique —­ A 10-year-old in 2024 will experience three across Malawi faced school closures.7 In the Phil- times more river floods, twice as many tropi- ippines, over 21 percent of schools are flood- cal cyclones and wildfires, four times more crop ed at least once every school year, and this can failures, five times more droughts, and 36 times happen twice a month in some areas.8 During more heat waves over their lifetimes in a 3°C the 2022 flooding in Pakistan, estimates show global warming pathway compared to a 10-year- that 3.5 million children had schooling disrupt- old in 1970.5 Already, the population affected by ed and 1 million children could stop attending climate shocks on an annual basis has more than school.9 Higher impacts were observed for chil- doubled over the past 40 years (See Figure 2). dren of caregivers who had lower levels of educa- tion and income. These closures generate huge Cyclones, floods, wildfires, and storms cause learning losses.10 During COVID-19 (March 2020- widespread school closures which generate huge 2022), each month of school closures translated learning losses. When cyclone Freddy hit Southern to a month of learning losses.11 A day of school Africa in March 2023 nearly 5 percent of students closures is a day of learning lost. FIGURE 2: WORLD POPULATION AFFECTED BY CLIMATE SHOCKS IN 1981-2020, 5-YEAR MOVING AVERAGE6 8 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Cold weather can also disrupt schooling and Most extreme weather events result in school learning. Although cold extremes have been closures. Over the past 20 years, schools were decreasing globally, some regions such as central closed in at least 75 percent of the extreme weath- Asia and areas of Australia and South America er events impacting 5 million people or have observed increases in both extreme heat and more (see Figure 3). In Malawi, 42 percent cold.12 Cold snaps and storms can produce prop- of primary schools were closed due to erty damage and power failures which can have the drought in 2015, forcing over 130,000 boys consequences on infrastructure and educational and girls to drop out of school. In the systems.13 This can also produce school closures.14 Philippines, cyclones in 2009 and 2013 In Mongolia, children of schooling age living in damaged 4,300 and 19,300 schools severely affected districts during winter storms respec-tively, leading to extended school were less likely to have completed basic educa- closures. As the incidence of extreme weather tion ten years after the shock than those children events continues to increase, so does the in less affected districts.15 In January and Febru- likelihood of these school closures. ary 2024, winter storms caused school closures in central and eastern Europe and the midwestern United States.16 FIGURE 3: MOST COUNTRIES EXPERIENCE MORE CLIMATE-RELATED SCHOOL CLOSURES EVERY YEAR. Afghanistan Bangladesh Bolivia China Ethiopia Fiji India Indonesia Jamaica Malawi Malaysia Mexico Nepal Nigeria Pakistan Philippines Somalia South Sudan Sudan Thailand Uganda Vanuatu Venezuela Zimbabwe 2005 2009 2013 2017 2021 Year Cause of school closure Flood Storm Drought Water shortage Wildfire Coldness Heatwave Crosses indicate large disaster, but no evidence found of school closures Shown is an index on school closures that combines the duration of school closures and their geographic spread. The larger the bubble the larger either the length of the school closure or the number of people affected, or both. Source: Angrist et. at (2023). Building resilient edu- cation systems: Evidence from large-scale randomized trials in five countries. No. w31208. National Bureau of Economic Research. Compiled school closure information based on press releases of the United Nation’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) Relief- Web, World Vision, UNICEF, the BBC, and other local outlets. 9 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT The duration of school closures is prolonged Students in flood-affected areas spend more when school infrastructure is vulnerable or time traveling from home to the university on when schools are used as evacuation centers. flood days (2.54 hours compared to 1.24 hours on For example, between 50 to 90 percent of 6,000 non-flood days).27Attendance is also affected with school buildings across Samoa, Tonga, and Vanu- the percentage of students present for face-to- atu may not withstand a strong cyclone.17 In face classes decreasing from 77 percent on days Zimbabwe, over half of schools (57%) report- without flooding to 27 percent on flood days.28 ed the complete destruction of some infrastruc- Even online participation can be affected- over- ture following Cyclone Idai which hit the country all participation on an online learning platform in 2019.18 In Haiti, physical damage to the educa- for undergraduate and graduate school cours- tion sector from natural disasters has damaged es decreased by 20 percent due to two major four out of five schools across the country19. In typhoon events that affected the Philippines in addition, schools are often used as evacuation 2020.29 In India and Kenya, positive rainfall shocks centers as seen in Haiti,20 Japan,21 Libya,22 Paki- were associated with 0.2 to 0.8 less years of stan,23 and the Philippines24 have shown. In Paki- schooling, respectively.30 stan, 92 percent of households affected by flood- ing in 2022 were still uncertain six months later of Some students do not return to school after when local schools would reopen.25 school closures. In Chile, school closures increased the probability of students dropping out of high Even when schools do not close, extreme weath- school by 49-68 percent.31 Following COVID-19 er events reduce attendance and attainment. In school closures, in Ethiopia and Pakistan, school Brazil there are more absences during the rainy enrollment among children 6-14 dropped by season even when classes are not suspended. This 4 percentage points and 6 percentage points, is due to challenges in transportation, particular- respectively, once schools re-opened.32 Declines ly for poorer and more vulnerable students. The were much larger for students from lower socio- number of days impacted by small-scale floods economic backgrounds. ranges from 7 to more than 12 days every year.26 10 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT RISING TEMPERATURES THREATEN CHILDREN AND THEIR EDUCATION A school day under extreme heat is a day in 22°C–24°C, decreases math scores by 0.066 which some learning is lost, but the size of the standard deviations.36 In Vietnam, each 0.56°C loss remains uncertain and very context specif- increase in temperature on exam day for college ic. Across 58 developed and developing countries entrance exams decreased standard deviation by participating in the Programme for International 0.006. Notably, female students and those resid- Student Assessment (PISA), each additional hot ing in rural areas were most vulnerable to these day (above 26.7 °C) in the three years preceding effects.37 These big impacts could be particular- exams lowered learning by 0.0018 standard devi- ly problematic for high-stake exams which dispro- ations, equivalent to 1.08 days.33 These impacts portionately impact a student’s future employ- were stronger on school days and disproportion- ment and earnings.38 The effect of extreme heat ately affected poorer countries. However, it is diffi- on Korean college entrance exams is equivalent to cult to extrapolate these findings to countries and increasing class sizes by 2-3 students.39 regions of the world where starting temperatures are much higher, and thus, reaching high tempera- Higher average temperatures overall also nega- ture thresholds represents less of a deviation from tively impact learning outcomes. In Brazil, an normal. In countries with higher temperatures, the increase of 1°C during the 2 years prior to the temperature threshold needed to be surpassed basic education national assessment (SAEB) for learning to be inhibited will naturally be high- translates into a learning loss of 0.03 standard er. For instance, in India, each additional hot day deviations in test scores,40 or 10 percent of a typi- lowered learning for reading for primary school cal year of learning.4 In the United States, test students by 0.002 standard deviations, simi- scores decreased by 1 percent for every 0.56°C lar to the previously cited paper, but this impact increase in temperature in the school years lead- was associated with days surpassing a tempera- ing up to the test.41 Similar results were also found ture threshold of 29 °C compared to 26.7 °C.34 A for English/Language Arts and Math test scores novel survey for this note, covering 94 education for students in third grade through eighth grade policymakers across 28 low- and middle-income across the United States. Strong effects were also countries, reveals that 47 percent of policymakers observed when considering days of extreme heat believe that learning is only compromised when above 37.8°C. 42 temperatures are above 37.8 °C. This type of find- ing implies the incidence of days with extreme Crossing specific temperature thresholds caus- heat negatively impacts learning, but the size of es stronger learning losses than an overall rela- the impact will be very much dependent on start- tionship between average temperatures and ing temperatures and the local context. learning may suggest. Therefore, studies that look at increases in the average temperature in Extreme heat on exam day significantly reduc- the year(s) prior to an exam find relatively small es test scores. Even a modest increase of 1°C impacts while studies that look at the impact of in outdoor temperature on exam days can extreme heat on specific school days find larg- result in a substantial decline in test scores.35 In er impacts. In other words, strong learning loss- China, temperatures exceeding 32°C on exam es may emerge only when temperature crosses days, compared to a more moderate range of certain thresholds. 4 This conversion assumes that a typical student learns 0.3 standard deviations per year (See Sabarwal et al., 2023 and Bau et al., 2021 for more information) 11 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Beyond exceeding temperature thresholds, devi- ations from normal also matter for learning, and this goes in both directions. The effects of extreme temperatures on learning will differ regionally due to local climate and adaptive capacity. In regions used to lower temperatures, hot days may have a larger effect as the students may not be used to such temperatures. In the United States, learning was more affected by hot days in schools with lower average temperatures (55° F compared to 85° F).50 Students living in hotter climates may be more resil- ient to the effects of extreme temperatures and the schools may have stronger adaptation measures to combat these effects. While less common under climate change, the opposite is also true. In regions used to higher temperatures, cold days may have an equally negative impact on learning. For exam- ple, in Australia, an additional 10 cold school days with maximum temperature under 15.6°C in the exam year reduced test scores by 1.2% of a standard deviation, or 4% of a typical year of learning.51 While there is some variation in the precise Further, even the small learning impacts of slowly temperature level, it is clear that exceeding increasing temperatures could amount to signif- specific temperature thresholds compromise icant cumulative losses over time. Novel analysis learning outcomes. In several middle- and high-in- from Brazil shows that in the hottest 10 percent come settings, the ideal classroom temperatures of municipalities, maximum daily temperatures lie between 19.5 and 23.3°C.43 In those settings, rose more quickly (at a rate of about 0.6 degrees any temperature above 24°C can compromise Celsius per decade) than in the other 90 percent.52 reaction time, processing speed44, and accura- In these municipalities, which are also the most cy45 through changes in heart rate and respirato- disadvantaged, students lost about 1 percent of ry rates. The heart rates of children can increase learning per year due to rising temperatures. If by approximately 10 beats per minute for every one assumes that learning is entirely cumulative degree Celsius increase in body temperature.46 with each year’s learning building on the prior, and Similarly, respiratory rates can increase by up to that each year only 1 percent of learning is lost, 2 breaths per minute per degree Celsius increase by the time a student completes grade 12, that in body temperature.47 In China, higher classroom student will have lost about 1.5 years of learning. temperatures increased reported health symp- In a more conservative and yet realistic scenar- toms of dry throat, dry skin and headaches, dizzi- io, if one assumes a mix of learning being entire- ness, difficulty in thinking and concentrating clear- ly cumulative in the early years and more inde- ly, fatigue, and decreased well-being and mood.48 pendent in the later years, by the time a student Across 5 experimental studies, high temperature completes grade 12, that student will have lost produced declines in student performance rang- about 0.66 years of learning. In essence, the study ing from 2 to 12 percent for each 1°C increase in finds that a child who enters 1st grade today in a classroom temperature.49 municipality already experiencing high tempera- tures will lose between 0.66 and 1.5 years of learn- ing by the time she graduates from 12th grade. 12 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT FIGURE 4: GLOBAL INCIDENCE OF EXTREME HEAT DAYS (> 30˚C) IN 202053 Extreme heat will disproportionally affect the impact of 209 days under a middle of the road poorest regions. Warmer and lower resource (SSP2-4.5) scenario.54 In contrast, the Nether- settings are facing higher exposures to extreme lands is expected to experience around 2 hot days heat conditions and as a result experiencing the a year even under the most pessimistic climate greatest burden on educational outcomes (See scenario. In addition, within countries, hot days Figure 4). A country like Gambia will experience a will disproportionately affect poorer students median of 280 hot days (above 35 C) a year under who are significantly more likely to attend schools a pessimistic (SSP5-8.5) scenario while a lower without electricity (or air-conditioning). 13 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ON HEALTH AND FRAGILITY FURTHER ERODE EDUCATION OUTCOMES “Because of climate change… now we have a crisis of water, and then a crisis of land… And then we have terrorist groups again… which has devolved into this civil war we are witnessing now in Mali. And then, because of this insecurity there is no education, there is no security, there is no development.” — Houyame Hakmi, Malian PhD student in Morocco Climate change is adversely affecting education The mental health of students is also compro- outcomes indirectly through a range of health mised by climate shocks. Droughts, hurricanes, shocks. A child exposed to high temperature and wildfires can also have negative impacts on in-utero or in early life will attain 1.5 fewer years of student mental health. Following hurricane Ka- schooling in Southeast Asia.55 Exposure to normal trina in the United States, the majority of affected weather conditions in-utero as compared to ninth grade ethnic minority students had mild or extreme weather conditions decreases the prob- severe symptoms of post-traumatic stress disor- der (PTSD).66 College students affected by the ability of dropping out of school by 5 percent in Fort McMurray wildfires had a 11 percent in PTSD Colombia.56 Vector-borne diseases such as malar- following the fires.67 Climate anxiety has also been ia, dengue and Lyme disease are highly sensitive shown to be an increasingly prevalent stressor for to temperature and precipitation and will increase youth.68 Across 50 countries covering 56 percent in many regions under climate change.57 Around of the world’s population, almost 70 percent of 48 million people could be at increased risk of children believe climate change is a global emer- seasonal malaria transmission and 62 million at gency which can produce higher stress and anxi- an increased risk of endemic malaria transmission ety.69 These mental health impacts are likely to ad- in Central, Eastern and Southern Africa by 2030.58 versely affect both student learning and retention. Rising temperatures also amplify the impacts of air pollution, from wildfire smoke and other sourc- Climate change is causing food insecurity and economic fragility which jeopardize school en- es, on children’s health and academic perfor- rollment. It is estimated that up to 170 million ad- mance.59 Exposure to fine particulate matter, a ditional people will be at risk of hunger by 2080 harmful air pollutant, lowers test scores as shown due to climate change.70 This will have adverse with evidence from Brazil, Chile, China, India, effects on student learning and achievement.71 Iran, Italy, and the United States (See Box 1).60 Extreme weather events strain on household re- BOX 1: CLIMATE CHANGE, AIR POLLUTION AND EDUCATION Climate change can increase air pollutants through changes in photochemical reactions, ventilation and dilution, and removal processes such as precipitation.61 Climate change is likely to increase global air pollution and asso- ciated mortality. Projections have shown that 14% of the overall increase in ozone mortality from 2000 to 2100 estimated in a high emissions scenario (RCP8.5) will be attributed to climate change.62 Although particulate matter is expected to decrease overall, the decrease would be approximately 16% greater without the adverse effects of climate change.63 Poor air quality can affect learning and schooling through closures and impacts on cognition and academic achievement. In Brazil, higher particulate matter (PM2.5) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) around schools is associated with 0.05 percent and 1.02 percent lower scores, respectively.64 In China, high air pollution increases school absences, and this was shown to persist for up to 4 days. An air quality that is 10 units higher can produce over 80 thousand student absences student across China every day.65 The effects of climate change and air pol- lution can also co-occur and interact, continuing to produce even more detrimental effects in vulnerable regions. 14 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT sources and can lead to lower expenditure on and rainfall) can increase the risk of intergroup schooling lasting years after a shock.72 In Bangla- conflict by 14 percent and interpersonal violence desh, exposure to cyclones, floods, and droughts by 4 percent.74 Migration and displacement will increased child marriages as families use bride also increase due to changes in water availability, payments as a coping mechanism to financial crop productivity, and wealth which will impact hardship.73 The economic strain of climate shocks educational continuity for children. Conflict, vio- on households will increase learning poverty and lence, and war in turn have severe consequences prevent educational continuity. on children’s educational attainment and achieve- ment. In some settings, temperature shocks also Climate shocks exacerbate conflict, displace- increase recruitment of boy and girl as child sol- ment, and migration, threatening education diers.75 Approximately 222 million children are out outcomes for millions of children. A one stan- of school or at risk of dropping out of school due dard deviation change in climate (temperature to conflict or crises.76 THE EDUCATION IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ARE AN ECONOMIC TIME-BOMB Reduced education attainment will translate into with lower education attainment face econom- lower earnings and productivity. Climate change ic disadvantages and restricted access to stable and weather extremes will have severe costs on employment. These inequalities are transmit- human capital and human development.77 School ted from one generation to the next.80 Parents attainment is linked with higher earnings, with with lower education attainment often struggle estimates suggesting a return of 9-10 percent for to offer adequate support and resources for chil- each additional year of schooling. These returns dren’s education, further perpetuating the cycle of are higher in poorer countries and among girls. lower education levels within families.81 This can As climate shocks reduce education attainment, manifest in various ways, such as limited access future earnings will suffer. As witnessed with the to early childhood education due to cost, fewer COVID-19 pandemic, learning losses and lower opportunities for enrichment activities, and inad- levels of education attainment reduce income and equate academic support at home. Health dispar- productivity, with students in grades 1-12 affect- ities also arise, as lower education correlates with ed by school closures expected to earn 3 percent poorer health outcomes. The combination of less in their lifetime. Studies looking at the impact these factors traps families in cycles of poverty, of wildfires also infer deep impacts on future and further increases their vulnerability to climate earnings, with estimates implying one year of shocks.82 higher wildfire smoke inhalation reduces future earnings of affected populations in the U.S. by The erosion of education outcomes threatens $1.7 billion. This affects primarily disadvantaged the progress on poverty reduction. The indi- groups.78 These impacts are compounded by the vidual returns to education and the acquisition direct economic effects brought about by climate of skills add up to large benefits for economies. shocks, which can directly reduce economic Three-quarters of the variation in growth of GDP growth and levels of output.79 per capita across countries from 1960 to 2000 can be explained by changes in math and science The impacts will be felt across generations, as skills, highlighting the importance of educa- lower education attainment perpetuates cycles tion in economic security and growth.83 But for of poverty and limits social mobility. Individuals many countries, realizing the benefits of educa- 15 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT tion remains a challenge. In 2019, learning poverty the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandem- rate in low- and middle-income countries was 57 ic, further worsens the acquisition of vital skills. percent, or 6 out of 10 children could not read and Without these foundational skills, individuals understand a basic text by age 10. In Sub-Saharan lack the tools needed to secure stable employ- Africa, the rate was even higher, at 86 percent.84 ment and higher incomes, hindering poverty The looming threat of climate shocks, akin to reduction efforts. VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES, WHO HAVE CONTRIBUTED THE LEAST TO CLIMATE CHANGE, WILL BE THE MOST AFFECTED. “Unfortunately, we are the ones who can no longer mitigate. We have to adapt.” — Lashanti Jupp, Education Activist, Bahamas The more severe impacts of climate change to these events.88 Certain groups of people will will occur in low- to-middle-income countries suffer greater climate impacts, including those (LMICs), which are home to 85 percent of the with chronic illness and mobility challenges, world’s children.85 Yet, these countries contrib- people of color and women and girls, and those ute the least to carbon emissions responsible for from low-income populations.89 climate change. For example, the ten highest-risk countries collectively emit only 0.5 percent of Education impacts from climate disasters dispro- global emissions. In addition, consumption-based portionately harm young girls. Climate-related emissions data shows that high income countries events prevent at least 4 million girls in low- and are responsible for 92 percent of excess glob- lower-middle-income countries from completing al CO2 emissions.86 In poor countries, econom- their education.90 In India, girls and children from a ic growth is reduced by 1.3 percent for each 1°C lower socio-economic status are more susceptible increase in temperature each year.87 to flooding and its effect on learning outcomes.91 More broadly, girls and women are particularly Within affected communities, the most vulnera- vulnerable to the social responses triggered by ble children will bear most of the effects. Approx- weather shocks, especially in places where they imately 90 percent of the global burden of disease face restrictive gender norms.92 Coping strategies associated with climate change affects children. to extreme weather events can be particularly According to the Young Lives study which followed harmful to women. Girls are more likely to experi- the lives of 12,000 children in poor communities ence violence and exploitation related to climate across Ethiopia, India, Peru, and Vietnam, children shocks,93 be forced into early marriage,94 and in the poorest households within each country are become pregnant,95 all of which can affect their more affected by extreme weather events. For ability to stay in school. During or after weather example, in Ethiopia, 81 percent of children from shocks, boys can also be taken out of schools to the poorest households had experienced one or be put at work and young men working in agricul- more extreme weather events while 22 percent ture are often forced to migrate to find alternative from the least poor households had been exposed sources of income.96 16 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT WHAT SHOULD POLICYMAKERS DO? ADAPT EDUCATION SYSTEMS FOR GREATER RESILIENCE THROUGH FOUR STEPS. WE ALWAYS SAY CLIMATE CHANGE IS A GLOBAL ISSUE. “ BUT ACTUALLY, IT LOOKS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT IN DIFFERENT CITIES AND COUNTRIES. AND SO, CHILDREN ARE EXPERIENCING IT DIFFERENTLY, AND THE SOLUTIONS ALSO HAVE TO BE LOCAL.” Keya Lamba, Youth Activist, UK 17 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT There is an urgent need to adapt education the difference in the PISA performance between systems for climate change. Even if the most dras- countries like Brazil and South Korea.97 tic climate mitigation strategies were implement- ed, we will continue to observe extreme weather This section presents a broad menu of options events having detrimental impacts on education that can be part of a sound adaptation strategy, outcomes. For the millions of children that need to as well as examples of how countries are apply- attend school over the next 50 years, the results ing these solutions. Ultimately, countries will need of mitigation will simply come too late. Actions to contextualize their strategies according to the can be implemented now to increase the capaci- climate stressors they face, the resources available, ty of education systems to adapt and to cope with and what would work best for their populations. these increasingly prevalent climate stressors. Adapting education systems for greater resil- Education policymakers do not seem to fully ience requires policymakers to act on four fronts appreciate the urgency for climate adapta- (see Figure 5): (i) education management for tion within the education sector. A novel survey resilience; (ii) school infrastructure for resilience; for this note, covering 94 education policymak- (iii) ensuring learning continuity in the face of ers across 28 low- and middle-income coun- climate shocks; and (iv) leveraging students and tries, reveals that only about half (53 percent) teachers as change agents. believe that hotter temperatures inhibit learning and nearly 46 percent also got one of five basic But this adaptation requires policymakers to climate change related questions wrong. Further, allocate sufficient funding for boosting climate nearly 61 percent said the protection of learning resilience within the education sector. Effectively from climate change is among the bottom three implementing adaptation strategies to minimize priorities in their country (out of a set of ten prior- harm and cope with climate shocks will require ities). The corresponding number for World Bank additional funds for the education sector. The case education task team leaders was 72 percent. This for education investment must be strengthened low prioritization of adaptation is troubling given for improved domestic resource mobilization and that increasing heat exposure during the school increased allocation of global adaptation financ- year could come to explain around one-third of ing to education. Each dollar invested in disaster risk reduction to make education systems climate- smart can save up to 15 in post-disaster recov- ery.98 Part of the strategy to mobilize funding may involve the education sector accessing existing, or setting up new, loss and damage funds.99 Inno- vative financing mechanisms, such as the use of parametric insurance in the education sector, may also be useful in ensuring funds are available when coping with shocks.100 Though no global figures exist to summarize the additional financing need- ed for this effort, scattered estimates give a sense of the scale. Looking at just damages due to trop- ical cyclones, global estimates indicate the educa- tion sector experiences financial losses of USD 4 billion annually.101 In the Philippines alone, over 10,000 classrooms per year are damaged due to typhoons and floods.102 18 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT FIGURE 5: APPROACH TO ADAPT EDUCATION SYSTEMS TO CLIMATE CHANGE EDUCATION MANAGEMENT FOR CLIMATE RESILIENCE First, support adaptation and disaster risk plan- to address them.104 Climate change learning strat- ning at the sector and school levels. Education egies led by national institutions have been imple- policies, at the national and subnational levels, mented by various countries such as Benin, Ugan- need to reflect the reality of climate change and da and Indonesia to strengthen linkages between what it means to their sector. Critical aspects to the education and training institutions and the cover include an assessment of climate risks, strat- climate change community.105 egies to minimize impacts to infrastructure and education outcomes, clear coping mechanisms to Such planning should be underpinned by clear manage learning continuity during climate shocks, data and analysis related to climate risks and plans to effectively restore learning process after possible coping strategies. Effectively prepar- natural disasters, and a sensible approach to ing for, coping with, and recovering from climate involve teachers, students, and their families in the shocks requires education policymakers to under- overall adaptation process. Nearly 60 percent of stand the climate risks faced by their sector. Peri- countries in a 2017 survey of 68 high-risk countries odically assembling and discussing data about for disasters include either disaster risk reduction schools that are at risk can help the system mini- or disaster response components in their educa- mize negative impacts. Infrastructure assessments tion sector plan, but these are not always compre- are equally important to identify sub-optimal hensive.103 The Ministry of Education of Liberia school structures that need upgrading for great- has integrated climate mitigation and adaptation er resilience against climate shocks. The process measures into its education sector plan running of assembling these data may involve coordina- through 2027, which identifies medium and long- tion and consultation with non-education minis- term adaptation needs and implements strategies tries and experts. 19 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Second, invest in early warning systems. Invest- Third, supporting good management at the ing in mechanisms to alert schools in real time school level can really pay off. Offering target- and take early action will minimize the damage of ed in-service training to school principals on crisis adverse climate events on students, teachers, and response and overall management practices can schools. Risk reduction measures benefit schools help with risk mitigation and improve the speed and help communities learn of the risk through and recovery following climate shocks. In Haiti, students. Multi-hazard early warning systems are following Hurricane Matthew, better managed being implemented in a growing number of coun- schools recovered faster, with the difference even tries and have been proven to minimize damage more pronounced at higher levels of damage.108 and the number of people impacted by climate School principals scoring higher on a range of shocks.106 In the Philippines and Indonesia, an management practices were able to re-open early warning system for typhoons, floods, and schools faster, bring students and teachers back earthquakes is used for disaster preparedness sooner, significantly minimize learning losses, and and response. In Indonesia, the education sector introduce disaster risk reduction measures in case is provided information through a mobile app to of re-occurrence. Similarly, in Puerto Rico, school improve disaster knowledge for students and staff principals scoring higher on management prac- (see Box 2).107 tices were better able to keep students engaged though remote learning opportunities.109 BOX 2: EXAMPLE EARLY WARNING SYSTEM FOR SCHOOL MOBILE APP FOR DISASTER RESPONSE – INDONESIA InaRISK is a platform that summarizes results of local-level disaster Learn more! risk following hazard assessments conducted by the local government. It has a mobile app that provides information about risks and guidance on how to take anticipatory actions during a disaster. Indonesia’s education system, from primary schools to high schools, are using the app as part of the Disaster Safe Education Unit (SPAB) programme implemented by the Ministry of Education, Culture and Research and Technology to improve the disaster knowledge of students and staff. Schools receive alerts through different channels, and evacuation procedures are often practiced during drills. 20 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE FOR CLIMATE RESILIENCE For infrastructure the key actions are strengthen- elevated foundations, and classrooms are often ing the resilience of existing buildings, protect- constructed on stilts to reduce the risk of inunda- ing classrooms from heat, and adopting inno- tion.112 Infrastructure built for flood risk reduction vative best practices (for both resilience and not only increases resilience to climate stressors cooling) for any new construction. but can have co-benefits on environmental, social and economic systems.113 There are programs like Compliance with local building codes must the World Bank Global Program for Safer Schools, be enforced for all school buildings. Building that aim to improve the safety and resilience of codes are the minimum design and construction schools to natural hazards through large-scale requirements to ensure safe and resilient struc- investments in safer school infrastructure.114 In tures. Though they vary by country, these codes Peru, the program supported policy reform to establish the acceptable levels of risk from an improve resources for disaster risk management, engineering perspective. When school buildings reduce infrastructure vulnerabilities in the educa- operate outside the scope of the building codes, tion and housing sectors including flood protec- they are at risk of severe damage and destruction tion measures and increase governmental capaci- during climate shocks. This is unfortunately far ty for post-disaster recovery and reconstruction.115 too common. In Niger, nearly 47 percent of school infrastructure stock continues to rely on tempo- Risk-informed location for new schools is criti- rary structures (classes paillotes) made of straw, cal. The geographical location of a school deter- which are built based on demand and are disman- mines the climate hazards to which it is exposed. tled annually during rainy season, leaving millions Hazard maps can be particularly useful. For exist- of children and youth without access to school.110 ing infrastructure, an understanding of the expo- Note however that different climate risks add sure of each school facility to natural hazards can different types of stress on school infrastructure, serve as a starting point for managing climate risk. and thus require different solutions. Even for each For new infrastructure, knowledge of the risks of specific risk, there is no one-size-fits-all solution particular locations can guide decision-making as different contexts will have different resources into where to locate schools to minimize risk. If available to respond and mitigate damage. risk cannot be avoided, because of the location of the community that needs to be served by the Structural adjustments can help minimize poten- new school facility, the risk information can inform tial damage to schools from floods and land- the design of the new school building to minimize slides. Measures specifically aimed at preventing damage during the most likely climate shocks. In urban run-off and flooding can be implemented Indonesia, optimal locations for education facili- at the school building level. Options include the ties have been identified using a model for land construction of retaining walls, improved gutters suitability by considering a multi-hazard disaster and drainage systems to guide water away from risk index, with over 25 percent of schools current- the schools, as well as the construction of schools ly located in high vulnerability areas.116 with elevated foundations. Temporary retaining walls can even be made out of sandbags. In Rwan- Classroom temperatures need to be better da, a new project is equipping 1,367 school sites managed, but this doesn’t need to be costly. As with retaining walls to mitigate flood- and rain- discussed above, heat impedes learning. Reduc- storm-related landslides, as well as related risks to ing classroom temperature from 30 °C to 20 °C communities and their assets living downstream could increase performance on learning-related from the school location.111 In Vietnam, schools tasks by 20 percent.117 In Costa Rica, air condi- in flood-prone areas have been designed with tioning units were used to reduce classroom 21 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT temperatures from about 30 to 25°C and speed New classrooms can be designed to keep cool. on cognitive tests increased up to 7.5 percent, and The use of natural ventilation, insulating materi- accuracy increased by 0.6 percent for each degree als, and climate-responsive designs for schools reduction in classroom temperature.118 Interesting- can be alternative strategies to interventions like ly, this effect was stronger for lower performing air conditioning, which may not be feasible in all students. While installing air conditioning units in contexts. School construction integrating natural classrooms is an option that some countries have daylight and cross-ventilation as well as trees and/ implemented, it is certainly not the only approach or shade structures can reduce the energy need- to lowering temperatures. Less costly solutions ed.119 For example, Kenya implemented a Green range from painting rooftops with solar-reflec- Economy Strategy and Implementation Plan that tive white paint, increasing tree coverage in and promotes bioclimatic design for school buildings around the school, leveraging water features to and will increase thermal comfort for students mist the air, to even modifying school schedules during high temperatures.120 to avoid peak heat (See Box 3). BOX 3: SAMPLE STRATEGIES TO COMBAT CLASSROOM EXTREME HEAT Low Tech Low Tech High Tech INDONESIA KENYA TAIWAN Painting rooftops white. Tree planting. Air conditioning in schools. In Indonesia, a project estab- Kenya has set a target to The government of Taiwan lished a facility to produce plant 15 billion trees by 2032. has invested $1.2 billion USD affordable coatings to install Trees will be planted by to install air conditioning cool roofs on over 70 build- students and education work- in every public classroom. ings including schools. Indoor ers and will provide shade Evidence from Costa Rica temperatures were reduced by in school grounds lowering has shown AC to be effective over 10 °C by replacing dark temperatures. This practice at managing temperatures roofs with a white coating. can reduce temperatures in and supporting learning. the school area by 1-5 °C. Learn more Learn more Learn more 22 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT BOX 4: SAMPLE INNOVATIVE DESIGN FOR TEMPERATURE CONTROL GANDO PRIMARY SCHOOL – BURKINA FASO The Gando Primary school was designed by Francis Kéré within the parameters set by cost, climate, resource availability and Learn more construction feasibility. For construction, Clay was used. This material is abundant in the region and can offer thermal protection against hot climate. To avoid overheating due to the commonly used corrugated metal roof, the design pulls the roof of the Gando Primary School away from the learning space of the interior. A dry-stacked brick ceiling is introduced in between, allowing for maximum ventilation: cool air is pulled in from the interior windows, while hot air is released out through perforations in the clay roof. This also significantly reduces the ecological footprint of the school by alleviating the need for air-conditioning. In Burkina Faso (see Box 4), the Gando Prima- provides clean water to students and is expected ry School is a good example of locally-contextu- to reduce carbon emissions by 6 million tons over alized and innovative design that addresses the 10 years.123 issue of extreme heat in classrooms. Ultimately, climate shocks add a level of stress to When the schools are running, make sure water school infrastructure that cannot be fully reme- runs as well. Access to water, beyond a basic died, but enhancing the resilience of school human need, is also a highly effective practice for buildings and ensuring continuity of learning increasing attendance, enrollment, and learning.121 during school closures can significantly reduce Ensuring this provision, especially in water-scarce their impacts.124 environments, requires innovative thinking and local solutions. In Kenya, water tanks and sani- tation infrastructure were installed on rooftops through a water harvesting project. This not only creates storage to harvest water during the rainy season to provide water access during the drier months but can also help minimize local flood- ing of schools.122 In Vietnam, 300,000 water puri- fiers are being distributed to schools and other community institutions to provide access to clean drinking water to 2 million children. This option 23 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT ENSURING LEARNING CONTINUITY IN THE FACE OF CLIMATE SHOCKS Keep schools open (to the extent possible). There classes had approximately 33 percent lower is overwhelming evidence that school closures test scores, but no difference was observed lead to tremendous learning losses, especially when students had access to virtual learning for the disadvantaged. And these losses may be options.127 Remote learning models can be an impossible to recover. Therefore, schools should important adaptation strategy to ensure contin- only be closed when essential and every effort uous learning during school closures. Remote should be made to reopen as soon as possible. instruction proved to be most successful when it ensured fit-for-purpose, enhanced effective- Minimize the time schools are exclusively used ness of teachers, established meaningful inter- as emergency shelters. A key part of minimizing actions, and engaged parents and students as school closures is to minimize their use as evac- partners.128 uation centers and/or emergency shelters. While these centers offer a lifeline to the communi- 2. Conduct re-enrollment campaigns if school ty, they do so at the expense of children’s learn- closures last long. As schools re-open, many ing and their future. At times of crisis, it is normal children do not return on their own.129 Back to for countries to resort to their public infrastruc- school communication campaigns, both gener- ture to meet the needs of their people, and this al and targeted to at-risk students, can help includes schools. However, given the high-cost increase attendance and re-enrollment rates.130 school closures can have on students and their As parental concerns about risk and safety may learning, it is important to minimize the length of be an important factor keeping children from the school disruption regardless of how the school returning, addressing those fears and ensuring buildings are being used. Establishing alternative safety will enhance the effectiveness of those options, keeping dual functions by using class- campaigns. Following COVID-19-related school rooms as shelters only at night and reverting to closures, Ghana conducted a very successful classes during the day, or using alternative tempo- back-to-school campaign resulting in near- rary learning facilities on school sites can lower ly 100 percent re-enrollment.131 This campaign impacts on schooling.125 was successful because it was conducted at the district level, involving government, civil In the event of school closures, four actions can society, and media, and it leveraged different protect or even boost education outcomes. means of communication including radio, TV, and community events. 1. Strengthen remote learning mechanisms to ensure learning continuity during climate-re- 3. Targeted financial support to disadvantaged lated disruptions. COVID-19 disruptions demon- students may be needed to bring them back strated that remote learning needs to be done to school. After climate emergencies, poor more effectively. It’s time to put these lessons households may not send children back to to work to protect learning from climate shocks. school for financial reasons. Removing school Across five countries (India, Kenya, Nepal, Phil- fees, offering subsidies to cover the cost of ippines and Uganda) phone-based targeted textbooks and uniforms, or giving cash trans- instruction significantly improved learning by fers to families have all been shown to increase delivering up to four years of quality instruc- school participation in the aftermath of shocks. tion for every 100 dollars spent.126 On flood days In Sierra Leone, following the school closures in Brazil, students who had only face-to-face associated with the Ebola outbreak in 2014, 24 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT the government removed school fees for two School feeding programs can keep students years, and offered subsidies to cover basic enrolled through climate shocks and offset some inputs like textbooks.132 These efforts to boost of their indirect impacts by improving nutrition re-enrollment increased access to schooling and health. Globally, 418 million children have with an additional 800,000 children enroll- access to school meals142 and many rely on them ing. Broader cash transfer programs that were for their entire caloric intake. This reliance is grow- conditional on schooling in Brazil and Mexico ing as increasing weather and climate extreme have also increased the resilience of house- events are driving millions of people towards holds as well as school participation.133 Easing acute food insecurity. Hence, the provision of transport difficulties after climate shocks can school meals offers a strong incentive for children also be impactful, such as providing bicycles to go to school daily. It can also be an effective to rural girls, which increases access to schools tool to keep children well-nourished, healthier, and (as seen in Zambia and India).134 enrolled. There is also evidence that school meals can support better learning outcomes. In India, 4. Targeted and customized support may be children receiving school meals for prolonged needed for girls. Following shocks, girls are periods of time achieved better test scores in math more likely to fall prey to violence and exploita- and reading.143 In the Philippines, children enrolled tion,135 experience deeper income losses,136 be in early childhood nutrition programs performed forced into early marriage as a coping mech- significantly better in school and every dollar anism,137 become pregnant,138 and drop out of invested in these programs produced a three-dol- school as a result. These vulnerabilities make lar gain in academic achievement.144 them most likely to benefit from communication campaigns as well as financial and nonfinancial incentives, so long as they are targeted appro- priately. Following COVID-19 related school closures, Bangladesh, Benin, Ethiopia, Ghana, Pakistan, and Uganda implemented advoca- cy campaigns for girls’ re-enrollment.139 Other incentives such as scholarships and adaptations for young mothers have also shown success in bringing back girls to school after shocks.140 As students return, catch up and remedial programs may be needed. When schools reopen after climate shocks, not all students will be at the same level as learning losses will likely take place; catch-up programs and extension of the academic calendar can address learning losses for the most impacted students. There are numerous examples of remedial and catch-up programs that proved effective in mitigating learning losses once schools re-open after COVID-19, which can offer valuable insights as countries prepare for increasing climate shocks.141 Common elements of success in those programs include the use of regular classroom assessments to guide instruction and the teaching prioritization of fundamental skills. 25 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Schools may need to provide socio-emotional fornia provided mental health services to address programs to help address students’ anxiety and the psychological impact on students after the distress after climate shocks. Climate change and Camp Fire ravaged through Paradise, California in climate shocks are affecting mental health and 2018.147 In Mozambique, following multiple climate psychological well-being of students. And mental shocks, primary school teachers were trained to health is strongly correlated with academic perfor- provide mental health and psychosocial support mance.145 School-based mental health services for (MHPSS) to students affected by natural disas- elementary school-aged children can be effective ters, conflict, and COVID-19 (See Box 5 for more in decreasing mental health problems and improv- details).148 ing academic performance.146 For example, Cali- BOX 5: POLICY STRATEGIES TO INCREASE RESILIENCE OF EDUCATION SYSTEM TO CLIMATE STRESSORS. Learning continuity Catch-up programs Socio-emotional programs BANGLADESH LIBERIA MOZAMBIQUE Online learning program. Bangla- Second Chance Increasing teacher capacity to desh had one of the longest school provide psychosocial support The Luminos Fund Second Chance closures during the COVID-19 Program is a remedial learning UNICEF and its education part- pandemic which lasted 18 months. A program for Liberian out-of-school ners have established a program in project that helped students contin- children aged 8 to 14. The 10-month Mozambique to ensure access to ue education through distance program helps students devel- mental health and psychological learning helped around 3.26 million op literacy and numeracy skills services in crisis-affected provinc- children, providing training to to transition back into the formal es. This includes mental health and teachers and the development of education system. Children in the psychosocial support interventions digital content. This increases the program increased their reading and manuals for professionals and resilience of students to stress- skills from under 5 correct words school staff to support student ors by ensuring learning conti- per minute to 39. Over 12,000 have well-being before, during and after nuity through school closures. participated and 90% have tran- cyclones and other emergencies. sitioned to formal schooling. Learn more Learn more Learn more 26 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT LEVERAGING STUDENTS AND TEACHERS AS CHANGE AGENTS Students don’t have to be passive victims of well as the role students themselves could play in climate shocks; they can play a key role in risk risk management. Novel data for this paper shows management. Disaster risk reduction involving that across six LMICs151 from three regions, nearly student training and leadership can be a low-cost 81 percent of teachers claimed to include climate strategy to increasing climate resilience. Primary themes in their lessons but over 74 percent got at schools in Cambodia with frequent schooling inter- least one (out of five) basic climate change ques- ruptions from floods, droughts and storms have tion wrong. Several countries are implementing raised disaster risk knowledge among students by this type of training. For instance, in Buenos Aires, integrating disaster risk reduction into the prima- Argentina, teachers in regions highly susceptible ry social studies and science curriculum.149 These to flooding have been trained in flood resilience.152 efforts focus on integrating relevant examples Teachers, government officials, and technical into existing curriculum to ensure students are experts were brought together to design educa- exposed to this critical and relevant information tional content and spaces that encourage children without needing to expand the already-complex and young people to adopt more environmental- curriculum. Activities such as capacity building ly friendly habits. The initiative has given rise to and simulation drills can be implemented with low more than 100 schools having teachers trained in costs and resources and are effective at increasing flood resilience, with many more schools in the student and school resilience to climate hazards. country expected to join. Similarly, the Ministry of Education in Thailand reformed the Basic Education Core Curriculum to To meet the needs of students after school embed disaster education. Lessons are based on closures, teachers will need to be equipped with a prominent community-based risk management the right knowledge and tools. The student that framework and are mainstreamed to learners from leaves the classroom before a climate shock will elementary school to senior high school.150 be very different from the student that returns after. Learning losses, emotional shock, and a like- As the people on the frontline, teachers have a ly less prosperous community will add stress to critical role to play in risk management. Prior to the learning process and limits to how much can extreme weather events, they can ensure students be achieved in the classroom. To meet the needs are aware of the climate risks and how to act in of the students, teachers will need guidance the event of one of them materializing. During and capacity building on key aspects. These are and after climate shocks, teachers are instrumen- well-captured in World Bank’s R.A.P.I.D. framework tal in keeping students engaged in remote learn- which was developed to tackle learning losses ing opportunities if access to school is disrupted. caused by COVID-related school closures and has After climate shocks, they hold the key to ensur- tremendous relevance for climate-change related ing learners have their needs met. school closures. It is based on five evidence-based policy actions for learning recovering after educa- For teachers to play this role successfully, they tion disruptions:153 need to be trained effectively on climate change • Reach all children. risk reduction and resilience building. An educa- • Assess learning. tion climate-adaptation policy will fail to deliver results if the messaging doesn’t reach those at the • Prioritize the fundamentals. frontline: teachers and students. Teachers need to • Increase the efficiency of instruction. be able to communicate fluently with their students • Develop psychosocial health and wellbeing. on what climate change is, the risks affecting their region, what to do in case of an emergency, as 27 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT BOX 6: EXAMPLE OF TEACHER AND STUDENT TRAINING PROGRAM ON DISASTER RESILIENCE DISASTER RISK REDUCTION THROUGH SCHOOL TRAINING – KYRGYZ REPUBLIC The Comprehensive School Safety Framework program in the Kyrgyz Republic is training students and teachers on safe Learn more! behaviors during an emergency including floods, landslides and earthquakes. The program trains educators and students starting at the preschool level on how to understand and manage disaster risk. This also includes a mobile application and online course including interactive games for primary school children to explain safe behaviors during emergency situations. School-based disaster risk reduction training is being expanded to 1,800 schools across the country and is expected to reach 1 million school children. Teachers have needs of their own, offering support nized either monetarily or through other means to them after climate shocks will be important. that may boost motivation. Programs active in Climate shocks will undoubtably impact teachers the school to guarantee access to water and food directly. Their physical and mental health, food and to students can also be extended to teachers. water security and housing can all be impacted by Similarly, while teachers can play a role in offer- weather extremes. In parallel, more of them will ing mental health support to students, it will be be expected in their classrooms as students cope important to offer services to them through either with the direct and indirect impacts of the climate institutional support, peer support groups, or shock. In countries like in the Philippines, teach- other interventions.156 ers are even expected to take additional respon- sibilities to coordinate schools as shelters and provide make-up classes on Saturdays following flooding events, without receiving any addition- al compensation or recognition.154 This combina- tion can easily lead to teacher burnout, absen- teeism and for teachers to eventually leave their jobs.155 To counter these risks, education systems can ensure teachers continue to be paid regular- ly, and that any additional responsibility is recog- 28 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT EDUCATION CAN BE THE KEY TO ENDING POVERTY IN A LIVABLE PLANET, BUT GOVERNMENTS MUST ACT NOW TO PROTECT EDUCATION FROM CLIMATE CHANGE “WE CAN’T BE OBLIVIOUS TO THE FACT THAT WE ARE FACING A GLOBAL CRISIS... AT SOME POINT, WE’RE GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE A BACK STEP AND ACKNOWLEDGE WE’RE IN A CRISIS AND WE NEED TO ADDRESS IT ACCORDINGLY.” Boitumelo Molete, Youth Activist, South Africa 29 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Education generates enormous returns for people ation in growth of GDP per capita across countries and societies. For individuals, education promotes can be explained by differences in international employment, earnings, resilience, and health. For measures of math and science skills.160 societies, it drives economic development, reduc- es poverty, promotes social cohesion, and nurtures Children and their communities are more resil- a more informed and innovative citizenry. Spend- ient to shocks and transitions when they have ing on education is thus not a mere government access to quality education. More educated indi- expenditure, but a powerful investment in the viduals are better able to prepare for, cope with, well-being and progress of societies. Each addi- and recover from shocks, including those related tional year of learning is estimated to generate a 10 to extreme weather events. Studies from Brazil, percent increase in earnings annually.157 These high- Cuba, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Haiti, Mali, er incomes result in significant improvements in Senegal, and Thailand provide robust evidence health outcomes, especially for mothers and their on the positive impact of education on vulnera- kids.158 Combined, these benefits lift people out of bility reduction.161 In these studies, people with poverty in large numbers. If all children got basic higher levels of education exhibit greater disaster reading skills from school, 171 million people could preparedness and response, experience reduced be lifted out of extreme poverty which would be adverse effects, and recover more quickly from a 12 percent decrease in extreme poverty global- disasters. Education attainment directly influences ly.159 For nations, these benefits translate into stron- risk perception, skills, and knowledge, all of which ger and more sustainable economic growth. Over empower individuals to be better prepared against the period 1960–2000, three-quarters of the vari- extreme weather events and thus reduce impacts. FIGURE 6: THE BI-DIRECTIONAL RELATIONSHIP OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND EDUCATION 30 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Improving educational outcomes could reduce the Adaptation within the education sector is urgent- climate risks borne by 275 million children global- ly needed to protect the benefits of education. ly.162 Higher levels of education attainment can also To minimize impacts of climate change on educa- contribute to climate resilience indirectly through tion outcomes, it will be important to promote reduced poverty, improved health, and slow- adaptation and resilience in the education sector. er population growth, all of which are linked with This is particularly urgent because these adverse higher community-level adaptive capacity.163 impacts will continue to become more severe. Even if the most drastic climate mitigation strat- Education attainment also fosters pro-cli- egies were implemented, we will continue to mate behaviors. An additional year of education observe extreme weather events having detri- can increase pro-climate beliefs by 6.3 percent, mental impacts on education outcomes. For the increase pro-climate behavior by 8.5 percent, and millions of children that need to attend school produce a 35 percent increase in green voting over the next 50 years, the results of climate miti- across 16 European countries.164 In China, educa- gation will simply come too late. Actions can be tion attainment is associated with a 2 percent implemented now to increase the capacity of increase in pro-environmental attitudes and educational systems to adapt and cope with these behaviors.165 Similarly, in Thailand, a study found increasingly prevalent climate stressors. that additional years of schooling are associated with knowledge-based environmentally friend- Despite the risks and opportunities, education ly actions such as increasing regular use of cloth remains overlooked in climate discourse. While bags by 5 percent and energy-efficient appliances climate-related official development assistance by 7.7 percent.166 Globally, the level of education (ODA) increased from 21.7 percent in 2013 to 33.4 attained emerges as the most influential factor in percent in 2020, education made up less than 1.3 predicting climate change awareness.167 Educa- percent of this change.169 In terms of action plans, tion also exhibits a robust correlation with envi- less than 1 in 3 Nationally Determined Contribu- ronmental concern and support for policies that tion (NDC) plans mention climate education, and benefit the environment.168 The education sector less than 1 in 4 NDCs mention green skills. More can play a catalytic role in climate change miti- broadly, only half of NDCs have any child-sen- gation and adaptation by reshaping mindsets, sitive education commitments.170 Education is behaviors, skills, and innovation. mentioned 9 times less frequently relative to energy and infrastructure in World Bank Country But climate change is threatening these bene- Climate Development Reports.171 Out of 15 review fits. Extreme weather events – high temperatures, articles on the economic impacts of climate tropical cyclones, droughts, floods, and wildfires change published since 2010, only three mention – harm children and their future through their the impacts of climate change on education.172 Of impacts on education. This is especially true for the research on the impacts of climate on educa- children in the most vulnerable settings, who need tion that does exist, nearly 78 percent comes from education the most. As climate change increases high-income countries.173 the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, climate related learning losses are likely to The education sector must become more active grow. Today’s students could lose not just learn- in climate discourse. This includes focused poli- ing but also a significant share of their future aver- cy action to protect education systems from the age annual earnings. Beyond reducing incomes, impacts of climate change. Without this, both these learning losses will lead to lower productiv- large-scale poverty reduction and climate action ity, greater inequality, and possibly greater social are at risk. unrest for decades to come. But these trends can be reversed if countries act quickly and decisively, guided by evidence on what works. 31 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT REFERENCES Adelman MB, Baron, J; Lemos, R. Forthcoming. Managing Shocks in Education: Evidence from Hurricane Matthew in Haiti. World Bank. Agnafors S, Barmark M, Sydsjö G. 2021. “Mental health and academic performance: a study on selection and causation effects from childhood to early adulthood.” Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology 56:857-66. Aguilera, R, T Corringham, A Gershunov, and T Benmarhnia. 2021. “Wildfire Smoke Impacts Respiratory Health More than Fine Particles from Other Sources: Observational Evidence from Southern California.” Nature Communications 12:1493. Akhtar S. 2024. Europe grapples with severe cold snap: Schools close and power fails. [accessed February 13 2024]. Akresh R. 2016. “Climate change, conflict, and children.” The Future of Children 26(1) 51-71. Alves A, Patiño Gómez J, Vojinovic Z, Sánchez A, Weesakul S. 2018. “Combining co-benefits and stakehold- ers perceptions into green infrastructure selection for flood risk reduction.” Environments 5(2):29. Amanzadeh N, Vesal M, Ardestani SFF. 2020. “The impact of short-term exposure to ambient air pollution on test scores in Iran.” Population and Environment 41(3):253-85. Angrist N, Winseck K, Patrinos HA, Zivin JSG. 2024. “Human Capital and Climate Change.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 1-28. Angrist N, Ainomugisha M, Bathena SP, Bergman P, Crossley C, Cullen C, et al. 2023. “Building Resilient Education Systems: Evidence from Large-Scale Randomized Trials in Five Countries.” NBER Working Paper No. 31208, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA. Aranda CH, Humeau E. 2022. “Early Warning Systems in the Philippines: Building resilience through mobile and digital technologies.” London, UK. GSMA. Asadullah MN, Islam KMM, and Wahhaj Z. 2021. “Child Marriage, Climate Vulnerability and Natural Disasters in Coastal Bangladesh.” Journal of Biosocial Science 53:948–67. Attanasio OP, Meghir C, Santiago A. 2012. “Education choices in Mexico: using a structural model and a randomized experiment to evaluate Progresa.” The Review of Economic Studies 79(1):37-66. Azevedo JP, Akmal M, Cloutier MH, Rogers H, and Wong YN. 2022. “ Learning Losses During Covid-19.” Poli- cy Research Working Paper No 10218, World Bank, Washington DC. Bakaki Z, Haer R. 2023. “The impact of climate variability on children: The recruitment of boys and girls by rebel groups.” Journal of Peace Research 60(4):634-48. 32 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Balakrishnan U, Tsaneva M. 2021. “Air pollution and academic performance: Evidence from India.” World Development 146:105553. Bangay C. 2022. “Education, anthropogenic environmental change, and sustainable development: A rudi- mentary framework and reflections on proposed causal pathways for positive change in low–and lower– middle income countries.” Development Policy Review. 40(6):e12615. Bas G. 2021. “Relation between student mental health and academic achievement revisited: A meta-analy- sis.” Health and academic achievement-new findings: IntechOpen. Barbic, F., M. Minonzio, B. Cairo, D. Shiffer, L. Cerina, P. Verzeletti, F. Badilini, M. Vaglio, A. Porta, M. Satam- brogio, R. Gatti, S. Rigo, A. Bisoglio, and R Furlan. 2022. “Effects of a Cool Classroom Microclimate on Cardi- ac Autonomic Control and Cognitive Performances in Undergraduate Students.” Science of the Total Envi- ronment 808:152005. Barbic, F., M. Minonzio, B. Cairo, D. Shiffer, A. Dipasquale, L. Cerina, A. Vatteroni, V. Urechie, P. Verzeletti, F. Badilini, M. Vaglio, R. Latrino, A. Porta, M. Santambrogio, R. Gatti, and R Furlan. 2019. “Effects of Differ- ent Classroom Temperatures on Cardiac Autonomic Control and Cognitive Performances in Undergraduate Students.” Physiological Measurement 40:054005. Baron J, Bend M, Roseo EM, Farrakh I, Barone A. 2022. Floods in Pakistan: Human development at risk. Special Note Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. Bashmakov I, Nilsson L, Acquaye A, Bataille C, Cullen J, de la Rue du Can S, Fischedick M, Geng Y, and Tana- ka K. 2022. “Chapter 11.” In Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, edited by N Campbell & R Pichs-Madruga. Lawrence Berkeley National Lab.(LBNL): Berkeley, CA. Bau N, Das J, Yi Chang A. 2021. New evidence on learning trajectories in a low-income setting. International Journal of Economic Development. Volume 84. Bekkar B, Pacheco S, Basu R, DeNicola N. 2020. “Association of air pollution and heat exposure with preterm birth, low birth weight, and stillbirth in the US: a systematic review.” JAMA network open 3(6):e208243-e. Benevolenza MA, DeRigne L. 2019. “The impact of climate change and natural disasters on vulnerable popu- lations: A systematic review of literature.” Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 29(2):266-81. Bernardi F, Keivabu RC. 2023. “Poor air at school and educational inequalities by family socioeconomic status.” MPIDR Working Paper 2023-014. Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, Rostock, Germany. Berry HL, Bowen K, Kjellstrom T. 2010. “Climate change and mental health: a causal pathways framework.” International journal of public health 55:123-32. Blandin A, Herrington C. 2022. Family heterogeneity, human capital investment, and college attainment. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 14(4):438-78. 33 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Bobonis GGN, Marco, Scur, Daniela. 2020. Management Practices and Coordination of Responses to COVID- 19 in Public Schools: Evidence from Puerto Rico. University of Toronto Mimeo. Brink HW, Loomans MG, Mobach MP, Kort HS. 2021. “Classrooms’ indoor environmental conditions affecting the academic achievement of students and teachers in higher education: A systematic literature review.” Indoor air 31(2):405-25. Cadag JRD, Petal M, Luna E, Gaillard J, Pambid L, Santos GV. 2017. “Hidden disasters: Recurrent flooding impacts on educational continuity in the Philippines.” International journal of disaster risk reduction 25:72-81. Caminade C, McIntyre KM, Jones AE. 2019. “Impact of recent and future climate change on vector–borne diseases.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1436(1):157-73. Cano, R. 2020. “School Closures from California Wildfires this Week Have Kept More than a Million Kids Home.” CalMatters, November 15. https://calmatters.org/environment/2018/11/school-closures-calif ornia- wildfires- 1- million- students/. Carneiro J, Cole MA, Strobl E. 2021. “The effects of air pollution on students’ cognitive performance: Evidence from razilian university entrance tests.” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 8(6):1051-77. Caruso G, de Marcos I, Noy I. 2024. “Climate changes affect human capital.” Economics of Disasters and Climate Change 8:157–196. Chakraborty T, Jayaraman R. 2019. “School feeding and learning achievement: evidence from India’s midday meal program.” Journal of Development Economics 139:249-65. Chalupka S, Anderko L. 2019. “Climate change and schools: implications for children’s health and safety.” Creative Nursing 25(3):249-57. Chankrajang T, Muttarak R. 2017. “Green returns to education: Does schooling contribute to pro-environ- mental behaviours? Evidence from Thailand.” Ecological Economics 131:434-48. Chen C, Schwarz L, Rosenthal N, Marlier ME, Benmarhnia T. 2024. “Exploring spatial heterogeneity in syner- gistic effects of compound climate hazards: Extreme heat and wildfire smoke on cardiorespiratory hospi- talizations in California.” Science Advance 10(5):eadj7264. Chen S, Guo C, Huang X. 2018. “Air pollution, student health, and school absences: Evidence from China.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 92:465-497. Chersich MF, Pham MD, Areal A, Haghighi MM, Manyuchi A, Swift CP, et al. 2020. “Associations between high temperatures in pregnancy and risk of preterm birth, low birth weight, and stillbirths: systematic review and meta-analysis.” BMJ 371:m3811. 34 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Chet C, Sok S, Chen TO, Sou V, Chey CO. 2023. “Pupil participation in the comprehensive school safety framework at primary schools in Stung Streng province, Cambodia.” International journal of disaster risk reduction 96:103932. Cho H. 2017. “The effects of summer heat on academic achievement: A cohort analysis.” Journal of Environ- mental Economics and Management 83:185-96. Cianconi P, Betrò S, Janiri L. 2020. “The impact of climate change on mental health: a systematic descriptive review.” Frontiers in psychiatry 11:74. Crandon TJ, Scott JG, Charlson FJ, Thomas HJ. 2022. “A social–ecological perspective on climate anxiety in children and adolescents.” Nature Climate Change 12(2):123-31. David CC, Monterola SLC, Paguirigan Jr A, Legara EFT, Tarun AB, Batac RC, et al. 2018. “School hazard vulnerability and student learning.” International Journal of Educational Research 92:20-9. Davies P, Maconochie I. 2009. “The relationship between body temperature, heart rate and respiratory rate in children.” Emergency Medicine Journal 26(9):641-3. Davis CR, Cannon SR, Fuller SC. 2021. “The storm after the storm: the long-term lingering impacts of hurri- canes on schools.” Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal 30(3):264-78. De Brauw A, Gilligan DO, Hoddinott J, Roy S. 2015. “The impact of Bolsa Família on schooling.” World Devel- opment 70:303-16. Dehingia N, McDougal L, Silverman JG, Reed E, Urada L, McAuley J, et al. 2023. “Climate and gender: associ- ation between droughts and intimate partner violence in India.” American journal of epidemiology kwad222. Dell M, Jones BF, Olken BA. 2012. “Temperature shocks and economic growth: Evidence from the last half century.” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 4(3):66-95. Duque V, Rosales-Rueda M, Sanchez F. 2018. “How Do Early-Life Shocks Interact with Subsequent Human Capital Investments? Evidence from Administrative Data.” Economics Working Paper Series 2019-17. Sydney, Australia. Ebi KL, Hess JJ. 2020. Health Risks Due To Climate Change: Inequity In Causes And Consequences: Study examines health risks due to climate change. Health Affairs 39(12):2056-62. Ebi KL, Vanos J, Baldwin JW, Bell JE, Hondula DM, Errett NA, Hayes K, Reid CE, Saha S, Spector J, and Berry P. 2021. “Extreme Weather and Climate Change: Population Health and Health System Implications.” Annual Review of Public Health 42:293–315. Eder C. 2014. “Displacement and education of the next generation: evidence from Bosnia and Herzegovina.” IZA Journal of Labor & Development 3(1):1-24. 35 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Eide ER, Showalter MH. 2012. “Sleep and student achievement.” Eastern Economic Journal 38:512-24. Evans HI, Handberry MT, Muniz-Rodriguez K, Schwind JS, Liang H, Adhikari BB, et al. 2023. “Winter Storms and Unplanned School Closure Announcements on Twitter: Comparison Between the States of Massachu- setts and Georgia, 2017–2018.” Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness 17:e132. FCDO. 2023. Addressing the climate, environment, and biodiversity crises in and through girls’ education. Fiore AM, Naik V, Leibensperger EM. 2015. Air quality and climate connections. Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association 65:645-685. Fishman R, Carrillo P, Russ J. 2019. “Long-term impacts of exposure to high temperatures on human capital and economic productivity.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 93:221-38. Ford, C. 2022. Education is under threat from climate change - especially for women and girls [press release]. https://www.younglives.org.uk/news/education-under-threat-climate-change-especially-wom- en-andgirls#:~:text=And%20children%20living%20in%20the,in%20the%20least%20poor%20households Fruttero AH, Daniel; Broccolini, Chiara; Coelho, Bernardo; Gninafon, Horace; Muller, Noël. 2023. “Gendered Impacts of Climate Change: Evidence from Weather Shocks.” WBG. Galdo J. 2013. “The long-run labor-market consequences of civil war: Evidence from the Shining Path in Peru.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 61(4):789-823. Garg T, Jagnani M, Taraz V. 2020. “Temperature and human capital in India.” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 7(6):1113-50. Gilraine M. 2023. “Air Filters, Pollution, and Student Achievement.” Journal of Human Resources 54 (4): 421-642 Glewwe P, Jacoby HG, King EM. 2001. “Early childhood nutrition and academic achievement: a longitudinal analysis.” Journal of public economics 81(3):345-68. Glick P, Sahn DE. 2010. “Early academic performance, grade repetition, and school attainment in Senegal: A panel data analysis.” The World Bank Economic Review 24(1):93-120. GPE. 2016. Available from: https://www.globalpartnership.org/blog/5-ways-education-can-help-end-ex- treme-poverty. GPE. 2023. “Toward Climate-Smart Education Systems: A 7-Dimension Framework for Action”.Global Part- nership for Education Working Paper, Washington DC. GPE & Save the Children. 2023. The Need for Climate-Smart Education Financing: A review of the evidence and new costing framework. Groppo V, Kraehnert K. 2017. “The impact of extreme weather events on education.” Journal of Population Economics 30(2):433-72. 36 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Guzmán J, Kessler RC, Squicciarini AM, George M, Baer L, Canenguez KM, et al. 2015. “Evidence for the effectiveness of a national school-based mental health program in Chile.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 54(10):799-807. e1. Halpert M. 2024. U.S. winter storm brings heavy snow and travel chaos to north-east. [accessed Feb 12 2024]. Hanushek, EA, and Woessmann L. 2020. “The Economic Impacts of Learning Losses”. OECD Education Working Papers No 225, Paris, France. Hanushek EA, Woessmann L. 2021. “Education and economic growth.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Economics and Finance Hermann Z, Horn D, Köllő J, Sebők A, Semjén A, Varga J. 2020. “The impact of reading and mathematics test results on future earnings and employment.” The hungarian Labour Market 45-52. Hernandez L. 2019. “Infraestructura y educación, una dupla poderosa frente a las inundaciones.” El País. Hickel J. 2020. “Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundary.” The Lancet Planetary Health 4(9):e399-e404. Hsiang SM, Burke M, Miguel E. 2013. “Quantifying the influence of climate on human conflict.” Science 341(6151):1235367. Hyndman B, Button B. 2023. “The Influences of Extreme Cold and Storms on Schoolchildren.” The Impact of Extreme Weather on School Education: Routledge p. 60-77. IPA. 2020. The Impact of Bicycles on Girls’ Education and Empowerment Outcomes in Zambia. IRC. 2023. Climate Resilient Education Systems Trial (CREST). Jeffries V, Salzer MS. 2022. Mental health symptoms and academic achievement factors. Journal of Ameri- can College Health 70(8):2262-5. Jerrim, J. Lindsey Macmillan, L. 2015. Income Inequality, Intergenerational Mobility, and the Great Gatsby Curve: Is Education the Key?, Social Forces, Volume 94, Issue 2, December 2015, Pages 505–533. Johnston DW, Knott R, Mendolia S, Siminski P. 2021. “Upside-down down-under: Cold temperatures reduce learning in Australia.” Economics of Education Review 85:102172. Joshi K. 2019. “The impact of drought on human capital in rural India.” Environment and Development Economics 24(4):413-36. Juwitasari R. 2022. “Saving Lives Through Education for Disaster Preparedness and Awareness: Lessons from Japan, Indonesia, and Thailand.” Heinrich Boll Stiftung. 37 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Kemp L, Xu C, Depledge J, Ebi KL, Gibbins G, Kohler TA, Rockström J, Scheffer M, Schellnhuber HJ, Steffen W, and Lenton TM. 2022. “Climate Endgame: Exploring Catastrophic Climate Change Scenar- ios.” Proceed- ings of the National Academy of Sciences 119:e2108146119. Kumer A. 2022. Global status of multi-hazard early warning systems: target G. https://www.undrr.org/publi- cation/global-status-multi-hazard-early-warning-systems: UNDRR & WMO. Lagmay EAD, Rodrigo MMT. 2023. “The impact of extreme weather on student online learning participation. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning. 2022;17(1):26Leal Filho W, Weissenberger S, Luetz JM, Sierra J, Simon Rampasso I, Sharifi A, et al. Towards a greater engagement of universities in addressing climate change challenges.” Scientific Reports 13(1):19030. Lee H, Calvin K, Dasgupta D, Krinner G, Mukherji A, Thorne P, et al. 2023. “Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmen- tal Panel on Climate Change.” Lee TM, Markowitz EM, Howe PD, Ko C-Y, Leiserowitz AA. 2015. Predictors of public climate change aware- ness and risk perception around the world. Nature climate change 5(11):1014-20. Lundeberg S. 2021. Study of destructive California fire finds resilience planning must account for socially vulnerable [press release]. MacEwen LN, Ndabananiye JC, Ortiz D, Séguin T, Tréguier M. 2022. Available from: https://www.globalpart- nership.org/blog/planning-starting-point-climate-resilient-education-systems. GPE. Macks KJ. 1987. “Typhoon resistant school buildings for Viet Nam.” Viet Nam Ministry of Education. UNESCO MBSSE. 2020. Getting all children into school: The Sierra Leone story. McCaul EJ, Donaldson Jr GA, Coladarci T, Davis WE. 1992. “Consequences of dropping out of school: Find- ings from high school and beyond.” The Journal of Educational Research 85(4):198-207. Melo AP, Suzuki M. 2021. “Temperature, effort, and achievement: Evidence from a large-scale standardized exam in Brazil.”. Unpublished work. Miller S, Vela M. 2013. “The effects of air pollution on educational outcomes: evidence from Chile.” IDB Working Paper No. IDB-WP-468, Miller, Sebastian and Vela, Mauricio, The Effects of Air Pollution on Educa- tional Outcomes: Evidence from Chile (December 2013). IDB Working Paper No. IDB-WP-468, available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2370257 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2370257. Misra AK. 2014. “Climate change and challenges of water and food security.” International Journal of Sustain- able Built Environment 3(1):153-65. Mora C, Dousset B, Caldwell IR, Powell FE, Geronimo RC, Bielecki CR, et al. 2017. “Global Risk of Deadly Heat.” Nature Climate Change 7:501–6. 38 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Mordecai EA, Ryan SJ, Caldwell JM, Shah MM, LaBeaud AD. 2020. “Climate change could shift disease burden from malaria to arboviruses in Africa.” The Lancet Planetary Health 4(9):e416-e23. Mugo D. 2023. Nearly half a million children in Malawi unable to attend school due to cyclone Freddy [press release]. https://www.savethechildren.net/news/nearly-half-million-children-malawi-unable-attend- school-due-cyclone-freddy: Save the Children. Munia HA, Guillaume JH, Wada Y, Veldkamp T, Virkki V, Kummu M. 2020. “Future transboundary water stress and its drivers under climate change: a global study.” Earth’s future 8(7):e2019EF001321. Munoz-Najar A, Gilberto A, Hasan A, Cobo C, Azevedo JP, Akmal M. 2021. “Remote Learning during COVID- 19: Lessons from Today, Principles for Tomorrow.” World Bank. Muralidharan K, Prakash N. 2017. “Cycling to school: Increasing secondary school enrollment for girls in India.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 9(3):321-50. Murphy JM, Guzmán J, McCarthy AE, Squicciarini AM, George M, Canenguez KM, et al. 2015. “Mental health predicts better academic outcomes: A longitudinal study of elementary school students in Chile.” Child Psychiatry & Human Development 46:245-56. Muttarak R, Lutz W. 2014. “Is education a key to reducing vulnerability to natural disasters and hence unavoidable climate change?” Ecology and society 19(1). Muttarak R, Pothisiri W. 2013. “The role of education on disaster preparedness: case study of 2012 Indian Ocean earthquakes on Thailand’s Andaman Coast.” Ecology and Society 18(4). Nakitende AJ, Bangirana P, Nakasujja N, Ssenkusu JM, Bond C, Idro R, et al. 2023. “Severe Malaria and Academic Achievement.” Pediatrics 151(4):e2022058310. Neumayer E, Plümper T. 2007. “The gendered nature of natural disasters: The impact of catastrophic events on the gender gap in life expectancy, 1981–2002.” Annals of the association of American Geographers 97(3):551-66. News Citi. 2021. GES trains taskforce to ensure students return to school. https://www.modernghana.com/ news/1054898/ges-trains-taskforce-to-ensure-students-return.html. Modern Ghana. Nübler L, Austrian K, Maluccio JA, Pinchoff J. 2021. Rainfall shocks, cognitive development and educa- tional attainment among adolescents in a drought-prone region in Kenya. Environment and Development Economics 26(5-6):466-87. Obradovich N, Migliorini R, Mednick SC, Fowler JH. 2017. “Nighttime temperature and human sleep loss in a changing climate.” Science advances 3(5):e1601555. Odd D, Evans D, Emond A. 2016. “Preterm birth, age at school entry and long term educational achieve- ment.” PLoS One 11(5):e0155157. 39 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Odera ED. 2020. “Thermal Performance of Learning Spaces in Tvet Institutions in Kisumu.” University of Nairobi. Onyango MA, Resnick K, Davis A, Shah RR. 2019. “Gender-based violence among adolescent girls and young women: a neglected consequence of the West African Ebola outbreak.” Pregnant in the time of Ebola. Global Maternal and Child Health, 121-32. Opoola F, Adebisi SS, Ibegbu AO. 2016. “The study of nutritional status and academic performance of primary school children in Zaria, Kaduna State, Nigeria.” Annals of Bioanthropology 4(2):96. Paciorek M. 2024. Cold snap grips central and eastern europe. [accessed Feb 13 2024]. https://www.barrons. com/news/cold-snap-grips-central-and-eastern-europe-f1237038. AFP News. Park RJ. 2022. Hot temperature and high-stakes performance. Journal of Human Resources 57(2):400-34. Park RJ, Behrer AP, Goodman J. 2021. Learning is inhibited by heat exposure, both internationally and with- in the United States. Nature human behaviour 5(1):19-27. Park RJ, Goodman J, Hurwitz M, Smith J. 2020. “Heat and learning.” American Economic Journal: Econom- ic Policy 12(2):306-39. Pellerone M. 2021. “Self-perceived instructional competence, self-efficacy and burnout during the covid- 19 pandemic: A study of a group of Italian school teachers.” European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education 11(2):496-512. Pichler A, Striessnig E. 2013. “Differential vulnerability to hurricanes in Cuba, Haiti, and the Dominican Republic: the contribution of education.” Ecology and society 18(3). Porras–Salazar JA, Wyon DP, Piderit–Moreno B, Contreras–Espinoza S, Wargocki P. 2018. “Reducing class- room temperature in a tropical climate improved the thermal comfort and the performance of elementary school pupils.” Indoor air 28(6):892-904. Pritchett L, Beatty A. 2015. “Slow down, you’re going too fast: Matching curricula to student skill levels.” International Journal of Educational Development 40:276-88. Psacharopoulos G, Patrinos HA. 2018. “Returns to investment in education: a decennial review of the global literature.” Education Economics 26(5):445-58. Perry FB, Juan D, Dahlin L. 2023. https://blogsworldbankorg/endpovertyinsouthasia/how-are-children-pa- kistans-2022-floods-faring [Internet]. World Bank Blogs. Quigley MA, Poulsen G, Boyle E, Wolke D, Field D, Alfirevic Z, et al. 2012. “Early term and late preterm birth are associated with poorer school performance at age 5 years: a cohort study.” Archives of Disease in Child- hood-Fetal and Neonatal Edition 97(3):F167-F73. Randell H, Gray C. 2019. “Climate change and educational attainment in the global tropics.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116(18):8840-5. 40 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Reid CE, Brauer M, Johnston FH, Jerrett M, Balmes JR, Elliott CT. 2016. “Critical review of health impacts of wildfire smoke exposure.” Environmental health perspectives 124(9):1334-43. Requia WJ, Saenger CC, Cicerelli RE, de Abreu LM, Cruvinel VR. 2022. “Air quality around schools and school-level academic performance in Brazil.” Atmospheric Environment 279:119125. Ridder N, Ukkola A, Pitman A, Perkins-Kirkpatrick S. 2022. “Increased occurrence of high impact compound events under climate change.” Npj Climate and Atmospheric Science 5(1):3. Rifkin DI, Long MW, Perry MJ. 2018. “Climate change and sleep: A systematic review of the literature and conceptual framework.” Sleep medicine reviews 42:3-9. Ritchie A, Sautner B, Omege J, Denga E, Nwaka B, Akinjise I, et al. 2021. “Long-term mental health effects of a devastating wildfire are amplified by sociodemographic and clinical antecedents in college students.” Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness 15(6):707-17. Roach T, Whitney J. 2022. “Heat and learning in elementary and middle school.” Education Economics 30(1):29-46. Ryan SJ, Lippi CA, Zermoglio F. 2020. “Shifting transmission risk for malaria in Africa with climate change: a framework for planning and intervention.” Malaria Journal 19:1-14. Sabarwal S, Venegas Marin S, Spivack M, Ambasz D. 2024. “Learning to Propel climate Action”. World Bank, Washington DC. Sabarwal S, Yi Chang A, Angrist N, D’Souza R. 2023. “Learning Losses and Dropouts: The Heavy Cost Covid- 19 Imposed on School-Age Children.” In: Collapse & Recovery: How COVID-19 Eroded Human Capital and What to Do About It. World Bank, Washington DC. Sakti AD, Rahadianto MAE, Pradhan B, Muhammad HN, Andani IGA, Sarli PW, et al. 2021. “School location analysis by integrating the accessibility, natural and biological hazards to support equal access to educa- tion.” ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information 11(1):12. Sánchez A, Gregory L, Crawford MF, Oviedo Buitrago ME, Herman RS, Ahlgren E. 2023. Learning Recovery to Acceleration : A Global Update on Country Efforts to Improve Learning and Reduce Inequalities. WBG. Sanchez AL, Cornacchio D, Poznanski B, Golik AM, Chou T, Comer JS. 2018. “The effectiveness of school- based mental health services for elementary-aged children: A meta-analysis.” Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 57(3):153-65. Sanson A, Bellemo M. 2021. “Children and youth in the climate crisis.” BJPsych bulletin 45(4):205-9. Santana OA, Silva TP, Oliveira GSd, Silva MMd, Inacio EdSB, Encinas JI. 2013. “Integration of face-to-face and virtual classes improves test scores in Biology undergraduate courses on days with flooding in Brazil.” Acta Scientiarum Education 35(01):117-23. 41 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Schady N, Holla A, Sabarwal S, Silva J. 2023. “Collapse and Recovery: How the COVID-19 Pandemic Eroded Human Capital and What to Do about It” World Bank, Washington DC. Schady N, Sabarwal S, Yi Chang A, Venegas Marin S, D’souza R, Lautharte I, Tzintzun Valladolid I, Schwarz L Forthcoming. Heat and Learning: How Exposure to Extreme Heat Affects Learning in Brazil. Schmidhuber J, Tubiello FN. 2007. “Global food security under climate change.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(50):19703-8. Schiff M, Jha A, Walker D, Gonzalez-Pier E. 2023. “Collectively achieving primary health care and educa- tional goals through school-based platforms: financing solutions for intersectoral collaboration.” Frontiers in Public Health 11:1241594. Shah M, Steinberg BM. 2017. “Drought of opportunities: Contemporaneous and long-term impacts of rainfall shocks on human capital.” Journal of Political Economy 125(2):527-61. Silva RA, West JJ, Lamarque J-F, Shindell DT, Collins WJ, Faluvegi G, et al. 2017. “Future global mortality from changes in air pollution attributable to climate change.” Nature climate change 7:647-651. Simmons SE, Saxby BK, McGlone FP, Jones DA. 2008. “The effect of passive heating and head cooling on perception, cardiovascular function and cognitive performance in the heat.” European journal of applied physiology 104:271-80. Sims K. 2021. “Education, Girls’ Education and Climate Change.” K4D Emerging Issues Report 29. Institute of Development Studies: Brighton, UK. Singh S, Shah J. 2022. “Case Studies on Adaptation and Climate Resilience in Schools and Educational Settings.” Global Center on Adaptation. Stott P. 2016. “How climate change affects extreme weather events.” Science 352(6293):1517-8. Swaine A. 2018. “Conflict-related violence against women: Transforming transition.” Cambridge University Press. Tayne K, Littrell MK, Okochi C, Gold AU, Leckey E. 2021. “Framing action in a youth climate change film- making program: Hope, agency, and action across scales.” Environmental Education Research 27(5):706-26. Thamtanajit K. 2020. “The impacts of natural disaster on student achievement: Evidence from severe floods in Thailand.” The Journal of Developing Areas 54(4). Theirworld. 2018. Safe Schools: The Hidden Crisis. Thiery W, Lange S, Rogelj J, Schleussner C-F, Gudmundsson L, Seneviratne SI, et al. 2021. “Intergenerational inequities in exposure to climate extremes.” Science 374(6564):158-60. Thompson R, Hornigold R, Page L, Waite T. 2018. “Associations between high ambient temperatures and heat waves with mental health outcomes: a systematic review.” Public health 161:171-91. 42 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Thompson T. 2021. “Young people’s climate anxiety revealed in landmark survey.” Nature 597(7878):605-. UN. 2018. Stronger Human Resources and Improved Skills to Tackle Climate Change [Available from: https:// www.uncclearn.org/country-projects/]. UNDP. 2021. Peoples’ Climate Vote. https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/publications/ UNDP-Oxford-Peoples-Climate-Vote-Results.pdf UNFCCC. 2023. Climate Justice: Loss and Damage Finance for Children. https://unfccc.int/sites/default/ files/resource/Child%20Rights-LD%20briefing-11Aug2023.pdf UNICEF. 2016. One week after Hurricane Matthew, at least 300 schools damaged in Haiti, over 100,000 children miss out on learning [press release]. https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/one-week-after-hurri- cane-matthew-least-300-schools-damaged-haiti-over-100000. UNICEF. 2018. Drinking water, sanitation and hygiene in schools: Global baseline report. UNICEF. 2020. Responding to the Mental Health and Psychosocial Impact of COVID-19 on Children and Families. https://www.unicef.org/media/83951/file/MHPSS-UNICEF-Learning-brief.pdf UNICEF. 2021a. The climate crisis is a child rights crisis. https://www.unicef.org/media/105376/file/UNICEF- climate-crisis-child-rights-crisis.pdf UNICEF. Making Climate and Environment Policies for & with Children and Young People. UNICEF. 2021b. Mental Health and Psychosocial Support Case Study Mozambique. https://www.unicef. org/media/113516/file/Responding%20to%20multiple%20emergencies%20%E2%80%93%20building%20 teachers%E2%80%99%20capacity%20to%20provide%20mental%20health%20and%20psychosocial%20 support%20before,%20during,%20and%20after%20crises%20(Mozambique).pdf UNICEF. 2022a. A call to action on climate and children. https://www.unicef.org/media/126601/file/ Protect,%20Prepare,%20Prioritize.pdf UNICEF. 2022b. Child-sensitive climate policies for every child. https://www.unicef.org/media/130081/file/ Child-Sensitive%20Climate%20Policies%20For%20Every%20Child.pdf UNICEF. 2022c. Haiti: Six months after the earthquakes, more than 4 out of 5 schools destroyed or damaged are yet to be rebuilt [press release]. https://www.unicef.org/lac/en/press-releases/haiti-six-months-after- earthquake-more-4-out-5-schools-destroyed-or-damaged-are-yet-to-be-rebuilt. UNICEF. 2023. Weather-related disasters led to 43.1 million displacements of children over six years [press release]. https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/weather-related-disasters-led-431-million-displacements- children-over-six-years. Van der Land V, Hummel D. 2013. Vulnerability and the role of education in environmentally induced migra- tion in Mali and Senegal. Ecology and Society 18(4). 43 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT van Houdt CA, Oosterlaan J, van Wassenaer–Leemhuis AG, van Kaam AH, Aarnoudse–Moens CS. 2019. Executive function deficits in children born preterm or at low birthweight: a meta–analysis. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 61(9):1015-24. Varchetta A. 2019. Evaluating Comprehensive School Safety through a Global Baseline Survey of Disaster Risk Reduction Policies in the Education Sector. Western Washington University Graduate School Collec- tion. Venegas Marin S, Schwarz L, Sabarwal S. 2024. “Impacts of extreme weather events on education outcomes: a review of evidence.” World Bank Research Observer. Vu TM. 2022. “Effects of heat on mathematics test performance in Vietnam.” Asian Economic Journal 36(1):72-94. Wamsler C, Brink E, Rentala O. 2012. “Climate change, adaptation, and formal education: the role of school- ing for increasing societies’ adaptive capacities in El Salvador and Brazil.” Ecology and Society 17(2). Wang Q, Niu G, Gan X, Cai Q. 2022. “Green returns to education: Does education affect pro-environmental attitudes and behaviors in China?” PloS One 17(2):e0263383. Wargocki P, Porras-Salazar JA, Contreras-Espinoza S. 2019. “The relationship between classroom tempera- ture and children’s performance in school.” Building and Environment 157:197-204. World Bank. 2015. “The Socio-Economic Impacts of Ebola in Sierra Leone.” https://www.worldbank.org/en/ topic/poverty/publication/socio-economic-impacts-ebola-sierra-leone. World Bank. World Bank. 2017. “Economic Impacts of Child Marriage: Global Synthesis Report.” World Bank. World Bank. 2022a. “Securing a Future with Safer Schools: Building Resilience in Pacific Schools.” Available from: https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2022/05/30/securing-a-future-with-safer-schools- building-resilience-in-pacific-schools. World Bank. World Bank. 2022b. “Guide for Learning Recovery and Acceleration.” https://thedocs.worldbank. org/en/doc/523b6ac03f2c643f93b9c043d48eddc1-0200022022/related/English-Exec-Summa- ry-Guide-for-Learning-Recovery-and-Acceleration-Final.pdf. World Bank. World Bank. 2022c. “Education in Niger: Proposed Support to Government Priorities for FY 23.” World Bank. World Bank. 2022d. “Project Paper on Proposed additional credit and grant to Republic of Rwanda.” Inter- national Development Association. World Bank. World Bank. 2023a. “How to Protect, Build, and Use Human Capital to Address Climate Change.” https:// thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/cc99b238fa9a0f266579d49dc591b2d4-0140062023/original/HCP-Cli- mate-Policy-Brief.pdf . World Bank. 44 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT World Bank. 2023b. Private Capital Brings Clean Drinking Water to Schools and Communities in Vietnam [press release]. https://www.worldbank.org/en/results/2023/12/20/private-capital-brings-clean-drinking- water-to-schools-and-communities-in-vietnam. World Bank. 2023. “Nigeria: A financial incentive scheme is bringing girls back to school” [Available from: https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2023/09/12/nigeria-a-financial-incentive-scheme-is-bring- ing-girls-back-to-school] World Bank. 2024a. Global Program for Safer Schools (GPSS). [https://gpss.worldbank.org/index.php/en/ about-us]. World Bank. World Bank Group, Climate Change Knowledge Portal. 2024b. URL: https://climateknowledgeportal.world- bank.org/. Date Accessed:  2/11/2024.  CMIP6 0.25degree, Number of Hot Days (TMAX > 30 C), Annual Aggregation, Timeseries 2015-2100, 50thPercentile of Multi-Model Ensemble, SSP2-4.5 Scenario (Middle- of-the-Road Scenario) Weems CF, Taylor LK, Costa NM, Marks AB, Romano DM, Verrett SL, et al. 2009. “Effect of a school-based test anxiety intervention in ethnic minority youth exposed to Hurricane Katrina.” Journal of Applied Devel- opmental Psychology 30(3):218-26. Wei T, Yang S, Moore JC, Shi P, Cui X, Duan Q, et al. 2012. “Developed and developing world responsibil- ities for historical climate change and CO2 mitigation.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(32):12911-5. Wen J, Burke M. 2022. “Lower test scores from wildfire smoke exposure.” Nature Sustainability 5(11):947-55. WFP. 2023. “The State of School Feeding Worldwide 2022.” https://www.wfp.org/publications/state- school-feeding-worldwide-2022. Williams PC, Bartlett AW, Howard–Jones A, McMullan B, Khatami A, Britton PN, et al. 2021. “Impact of climate change and biodiversity collapse on the global emergence and spread of infectious diseases.” Journal of paediatrics and child health 57(11):1811-8. Williamson K, Satre-Meloy A, Velasco K, Green K. 2018. “Climate change needs behavior change: Making the case for behavioral solutions to reduce global warming.” Rare Center for Behavior & the Environment, Arlington, VA, USA. WMO. 2021. “Weather-related disasters increase over past 50 years, causing more damage but fewer deaths.” https://public-old.wmo.int/en/media/press-release/weather-related-disasters-increase-over-past- 50-years-causing-more-damage-fewer. Yeganeh AJ, Reichard G, McCoy AP, Bulbul T, Jazizadeh F. 2018. “Correlation of ambient air temperature and cognitive performance: A systematic review and meta-analysis.” Building and Environment 143:701-16. Zhang X, Chen X, Zhang X. 2024. “Temperature and low-stakes cognitive performance.” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 11(1):75-96. 45 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT Zhang X, Chen X, Zhang X. 2018. “The impact of exposure to air pollution on cognitive performance.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115(37):9193-7. Zhang Y, Li Q, Ge Y, Du X, Wang H. 2022. “Growing prevalence of heat over cold extremes with overall mild- er extremes and multiple successive events.” Communications Earth & Environment 3(1):73. Zimbabwe Education Cluster. 2019. Rapid Joint Education Needs Assessment. Zivin JG, Shrader J. 2016. “Temperature extremes, health, and human capital.” The Future of Children 31-50. Zivin JG, Song Y, Tang Q, Zhang P. 2020. “Temperature and high-stakes cognitive performance: Evidence from the national college entrance examination in China.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Manage- ment 104:102365. Zuilkowski SS, Jukes MC, Dubeck MM. 2016. “I failed, no matter how hard I tried: A mixed-methods study of the role of achievement in primary school dropout in rural Kenya.” International Journal of Educational Development 50:100-7. 46 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT 47 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT NOTES 1 Ebi et al., 2021; Stott, 2016 2 Theirworld, 2018 3 UNICEF, 2021a 4 Venegas Marin et al., 2024 5 Thiery et al., 2021 6 Data extracted from Climate Change Knowledge Portal. For the purpose of this graph, only Landslide, Flood, Storm, Wildfire, and Drought events are included 7 Mugo, 2023 8 David et al., 2018 9 Baron et al., 2022 10 Azevedo et al., 2022; Schady et al., 2023 11 Shady et al., 2023 12 Zhang et al., 2022 13 Akhtar, 2024 14 Hyndman & Button, 2023; Evans et al., 2022; Gruppo & Krahnert, 2016 15 Groppo & Krahnert, 2016 16 Akhtar, 2024; Halpert, 2024 17 World Bank, 2022a 18 Zimbabwe Education Cluster, 2019 19 UNICEF, 2022c 20 UNICEF, 2016 21 Kawasaki et al., 2021 22 UNICEF, 2023 23 Perry, 2023 24 Cadag et al., 2017 25 Perry, 2023 26 Cadag et al., 2017 27 Santana et al., 2013 28 Santana et al., 2013 29 Lagmay & Rodrigo, 2022 30 Nübler et al., 2021; Shah & Steinberg, 2017 31 Grau et al., 2018 32 Schady et al., 2023 33 Park et al., 2021. Methodology to translate standard deviation into learning losses assumes students learn on average 0.3 stan- dard deviations per year and that a typical academic year has 180 days (See Sabarwal et al., 2023 and Bau et al., 2021 for more information). The formula is thus: 34 Garg et al., 2020 35 Park, 2022; Zivin et al., 2020; Vu, 2022; Melo & Suzuki, 2021; Zhang et al., 2024 36 Zhang et al., 2024 37 Vu, 2022 38 Hermann et al., 2020 39 Cho, 2017 40 Schady, et al., forthcoming 41 Park et al., 2020 42 Roach & Whitney, 2022 43 Brink et al., 2020 44 Dupont et al., 2023 45 Simmons et al., 2008 46 Davis, Cannon, & Fuller, 2021 48 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT 47 Davies & Maconochie, 2009 48 Yeganeh et al., 2018 49 Franca Barbic et al., 2022; F Barbic et al., 2019; Brink et al., 2021; Porras–Salazar et al., 2018; Wargocki et al., 2019; Stud- ies ranging from elementary to college/university level students. Assumes effect of temperature on achievement is linear. Two studies observed no effect of temperature. 50 Roach & Whitney, 2022 51 Johnston et al., 2021 52 Schady et al., 2024 53 Climate Change Knowledge Portal, 2024b 54 Climate Change Knowledge Portal, 2024b 55 Randell & Gray, 2018 56 Duque et al., 2019 57 Caminade et al., 2019 58 Ryan et al., 2020 59 Aguilera et al. 2021; Reid et al. 2016; Chen et al., 2024 60 Bernardi and Keivabu 2023 ; Gilraine and Zheng 2022; Amanzadeh et al. 2020; Carneiro et al. 2021; Miller and Vela 2013; Zhang et al. 2018; Balakrishnan and Tsaneva 2021 61 Fiore et al., 2015 62 Silva et al., 2017 63 Silva et al., 2017 64 Requia et al., 2022 65 Chen et al., 2018 66 Weems et al., 2009 67 Ritchie et al., 2021 68 Crandon et al., 2022 69 UNDP, 2022 70 Schmidhuber & Tubiello, 2007 71 Opoola et al., 2016 72 Nübler et al., 2021 73 Asadullah, Islam, & Wahhaj, 2021 74 Hsiang et al., 2013 75 Bakaki et al., 2023 76 FCDO report, 2023 77 Caruso et al., 2024; WBG, 2023a 78 Wen & Burke, 2021 79 Dell, Jones, and Olken 2012 80 Jerrim and Macmillan 2015 81 Duncan and Murnane 2011 82 Leichenko et al., 2014 83 Hanushek & Maximilian, 2021 84 World Bank, 2022b 85 UNICEF, 2014 86 Hickel, 2020 87 Dell et al., 2012 88 Ford, 2022 89 Benevolenza et al., 2019 90 GPE, 2023 91 Joshi, 2019 92 Fruttero et al., 2023 93 Swaine, 2018 94 Asadullah et al., 2021 95 Onyango et al., 2019 96 Fruttero et al., 2023 97 Park et al., 2021 98 GPE & Save the Children, 2023 99 UNFCCC, 2023 49 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT 100 IRC, 2023 101 World Bank, 2024a 102 David et al., 2018 103 GPE, 2023 104 MacEwen et al., 2022 105 UN, 2018 106 Kumer, 2022 107 Aranda, 2022 108 Adelman et al., (forthcoming) 109 Bobonis et al., 2020 110 World Bank, 2022c 111 World Bank, 2022d 112 Macks, 1987 113 Alves et al., 2018 114 World Bank, 2024a 115 World Bank, 2024a 116 Sakti et al., 2021 117 Wargocki et aal, 2019 118 Porras–Salazar et al., 2018 119 Chalupka et al., 2019 120 Odera et al., 2020 121 UNICEF, 2018 122 Singh & Shah, 2022 123 W orld Bank, 2023b 124 World Bank, 2024a 125 Cadag et al., 2017 126 Angrist et al., 2023 127 Santana et al., 2013 128 Munoz-Najar et al., 2021 129 World Bank, 2015 130 World Bank, 2022b 131 Citi news, 2021 132 MBSSE, 2020 133 Attanasio et al., 2012; De Brauw et al., 2015 134 Muralidharan & Prakash, 2017; IPA, 2020 135 Swaine, 2018 136 Sims, 2021 137 Asadullah et al., 2021 138 Onyango et al., 2019 139 World Bank, 2022b 140 World Bank, 2023c 141 Schady et al., 2023; WBG, 2022b 142 WFP, 2023 143 Chakraborty & Jayaraman, 2019 144 Glewwe et al., 2001 145 Murphy et al. 2015; Agnafors et al. 2021; Bas 2021 146 Sanchez et al., 2018 ; Guzmán et al., 2015 147 Lundeberg, 2021 148 UNICEF, 2021b 149 Chet et al., 2023 150 Juwitasari, 2022 151 Bangladesh, Chad, Gabon, Jordan, Pakistan, Uganda 152 Hernandez, 2019 153 Sanchez, 2023 154 Cadag et al., 2017 155 Pellerone, 2021 50 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT 156 UNICEF, 2020 157 Psacharopoulos and Patrinos, 2018 158 World Bank, 2017 159 GPE, 2016 160 Hanushek & Woessmann, 2021 161 Muttarak & Pothisiri, 2013; Pichler & Striessnig, 2013; Van der Land & Hummel, 2013; Wamsler et al., 2012 162 UNICEF, 2022a 163 Muttarak & Lutz, 2014 164 Angrist et al., 2024 165 Wang et al., 2022 166 Chankrajang & Muttarak, 2017 167 T. M. Lee et al., 2015 168 Chankrajang & Muttarak, 2017 169 GPE, 2023 170 UNICEF, 2022b 171 Authors own analysis based on a review of the CCDRs made publicly available as of April 2024 172 First three pages of google scholar search of search terms climate AND impact AND economic including only articles published 2010 and onwards that are review articles on the broad impacts on economy/social and excluding articles on a specif- ic sector or with a methods focus or that have a specific regional focus. 173 A Web of Science search on the topic “climate and impact” with the search terms, health resulted in 24,980, economic produced 31,243 and education produced 5,732. From these results, we can conclude that there is four times more research on the economic impacts of climate and five times more research on health impacts of climate than there is research considering the educational impacts of climate. Out of the 5,732 results from Web of Science of climate impacts on education, 1903 (33%) are based in the United States and 4,467 (78%) are from high-income economies (based on WBG classifications). This is based on web of science classifications and may not describe where the research for the manuscript it based. 51 | THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON EDUCATION AND WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT